Home / Romance / The Stranger I Choose / Chapter 2 - Just One Conversation

Share

Chapter 2 - Just One Conversation

Author: Cilo
last update publish date: 2026-07-22 01:58:33

Emma spent exactly three minutes staring at the app icon before locking her phone.

Ridiculous.

She had assignments to finish, laundry to fold, and two salt breads waiting on the kitchen counter.

A dating app shouldn't be the most interesting thing about her evening.

She reached for her pencil instead.

The public library floor plan lay unfinished across her tiny table. Erasing a line, she redrew the entrance, adjusted the reading area, and added a skylight over the central atrium.

Better.

She leaned back, satisfied.

Her phone buzzed again.

Lily: Downloaded it yet?

Emma smiled despite herself.

Emma: No.

Three dots appeared almost instantly.

Lily: Coward.

Emma: I'm busy.

Lily: You're eating bread and drawing rectangles.

Emma laughed out loud.

Emma: They're not rectangles.

Lily: Sorry. Fancy rectangles.

Emma shook her head.

Lily had an extraordinary talent for making architecture sound painfully unimpressive.

Another message arrived.

Lily: Promise me one thing.

Emma: What?

Lily: Just make an account.

Emma: And then?

Lily: Nothing.

Emma: Nothing?

Lily: You don't have to meet anyone.

You don't have to fall in love.

Just prove to yourself that talking to someone new doesn't have to be scary.

Emma's smile slowly faded.

Talking.

That sounded much less frightening than dating.

Maybe Lily was right.

Maybe she'd built walls so high that even ordinary conversations felt impossible.

She placed the pencil down.

"...Fine."

She opened the app.

A cheerful screen appeared.

Welcome to HeartMatch.

The registration process was surprisingly simple.

Name.

Emma.

Occupation.

Student.

Interests.

Architecture.

Baking.

Books.

Coffee.

The next question stopped her.

Age

She typed 21.

The app immediately displayed a message.

"Most of your matches will be between 20 and 25."

Emma frowned.

She wasn't looking for boys her own age.

Not intentionally.

But every time one smiled at her on campus, they reminded her how different her life had been.

While they worried about first dates...

She had once worried about making someone angry because dinner wasn't warm enough.

Her thumb hovered over the keyboard.

Twenty-one.

Delete.

Twenty-four.

The message disappeared.

Instead, the app expanded her recommended age range.

Emma exhaled quietly.

"I'm sorry."

It wasn't a lie she was proud of.

It was simply easier than explaining the truth.

She uploaded a photo Lily had secretly taken a month earlier.

Emma was standing outside the bakery, holding a tray of freshly baked salt bread.

She remembered complaining about the picture.

"My hair looks messy."

Lily had rolled her eyes.

"Your smile looks happy."

Emma hadn't argued after that.

She tapped Complete Profile.

Within seconds, faces began filling her screen.

Swipe left.

A shirtless man posing in front of a mirror.

Left.

Someone whose bio only said, "Future millionaire."

Left.

A man holding an enormous fish.

Emma blinked.

"...Why?"

Left.

Another profile featured six different gym selfies.

Left.

One simply read:

"Looking for someone to spoil me."

Left.

She couldn't help laughing.

Maybe she wasn't cut out for this after all.

Just as she was about to close the app, a new profile appeared.

Daniel.

Age: 35.

Occupation: Office Worker.

His profile picture wasn't professionally taken.

He stood in front of a bookshelf, wearing a navy sweater with the sleeves rolled to his forearms. No expensive watch. No sunglasses. No luxury car in the background.

Just books.

Emma tapped his profile.

Favorite weekend?

Finding a quiet café and pretending I don't have work waiting for me.

She smiled.

A habit I'm trying to quit:

Buying books I don't have time to read.

Another smile.

Biggest green flag:

Remembering how people take their coffee.

Emma found herself reading every answer twice.

There was something... calm about him.

Nothing felt rehearsed.

Nothing screamed for attention.

She almost swiped left anyway.

Thirty-five.

That was a fourteen-year difference.

He was probably looking for someone older.

Someone with a career.

Someone who had life figured out.

Certainly not a college student who spent half her paycheck on tracing paper and butter.

She locked the phone.

"No."

Five seconds later...

She unlocked it again.

"...Maybe."

A knock sounded at the door.

Mrs. Hernandez, her elderly neighbor, stood outside carrying a small potted plant.

"I bought too many herbs," she said. "Would you like some basil?"

Emma's face brightened.

"I'd love some."

"It's good for pasta."

"I mostly use it for bread."

Mrs. Hernandez chuckled.

"I know."

She glanced inside the apartment.

"It always smells like a bakery in here."

Emma accepted the little pot with both hands.

"Thank you."

"You young people don't decorate with plants anymore."

"I've been meaning to."

"Now you have no excuse."

After the older woman returned to her apartment, Emma placed the basil on the windowsill above the sink.

The tiny kitchen suddenly looked a little brighter.

She watered it carefully.

Maybe she'd buy another plant next month.

When she had enough money.

Her phone vibrated again.

Lily.

Well?

Emma looked from the basil to the phone.

Back to the basil.

Then to Daniel's profile.

He still smiled gently from the screen.

No flashy promises.

No dramatic declarations.

Just...

ordinary.

Maybe ordinary wasn't so bad.

Maybe ordinary was exactly what she'd been searching for all these years.

Her thumb hesitated above the screen.

Then, before she could overthink it...

She swiped right.

For a heartbeat, nothing happened.

Emma laughed softly.

"I knew it."

She was about to close the app when the screen flashed.

It's a Match.

She stared at the words.

Her heart skipped once.

Then again.

A chat window opened.

Neither of them typed.

Emma bit her lower lip.

Should she say hello first?

Or wait?

The blinking cursor seemed to tease her.

Seconds stretched into a full minute.

Then her phone buzzed.

A new message appeared.

Daniel: Good evening, Emma.

I hope you had a good day.

She read the message twice.

Simple.

Polite.

No pickup line.

No flirting.

Just five ordinary words from a complete stranger.

For reasons she couldn't explain...

They made her smile.

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 38 – Slip

    Daniel’s hand stayed on her breast, thumb still moving in slow, absent circles. His mouth drifted lower, pressing warm, open kisses along the line of her collarbone and the soft skin just above it. He spoke against her skin, voice still rough with sleep.“Did I say anything bad last night?”Emma’s fingers, which had been resting in his hair, stilled.“No,” she said quietly.He made a low, thoughtful sound and sucked gently at the base of her throat. “I don’t remember most of it. Just… pieces.” His hand squeezed her breast more firmly. “I remember you on top. How good you felt. And your mouth.” Another slow pull of his lips against her skin. “You were very patient with me.”Heat rose in Emma’s face. Part of her wanted to push the conversation back to what he had actually said. The larger part of her—the part currently arching slightly under his mouth—hesitated.She could still feel the weight of those words. *I don’t want to be divorced again.* They sat between them even now, unspoken

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 37 – What He Said

    Emma’s eyes opened to pale morning light and the immediate, heavy knowledge that she had barely slept.For a long second she only stared at the ceiling of her own bedroom. Then the memory returned in a single, sharp line—I don’t want to be divorced again…She turned her head.Daniel was still asleep beside her, one arm stretched across the mattress toward where she had been. His face was completely relaxed. No tension in his brow. No careful composure. Just the quiet, even breathing of someone who had fallen into deep sleep without carrying a single thought with him.It wasn’t fair.Emma sat up slowly. The dark circles under her eyes felt obvious even without a mirror. She had lain awake for hours after those words, turning them over until they lost their shape and became something heavier. Daniel, meanwhile, had mumbled a few more half-finished sentences and then slept like a child who had never known a complicated thing in his life.She slipped out of bed carefully, gathered a chan

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 36 – One More Drink

    Daniel and Emma had spent the evening date at a quiet restaurant a few blocks from Emma’s neighborhood—low lighting, shared plates, conversation that never quite touched the heavier things between them. By the time they stepped outside, the night had settled into something cooler and softer. Streetlights pooled yellow across the pavement as they walked without any real destination.They turned a corner and passed a small bar with warm light spilling through its windows. Soft music drifted out every time the door opened. A few people stood outside finishing cigarettes. Emma’s steps slowed without her meaning them to.Daniel noticed immediately.“Something wrong?”She hesitated. The old instinct rose first—the one that told her to keep walking, to stay careful, to not ask for more than what was already given. Then she pushed it down.“Do you… want to get a drink?” she asked, voice quieter than she intended. “Just one. Or two. If you’re not too tired.”Daniel looked at the bar, then back

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 35 – Unspoken Things

    Daniel drove home with the paper bags of cinnamon rolls sitting untouched on the passenger seat.The bakery visit had gone better than he expected. Lily had been protective, sharp-eyed, and fair. Nathan had been Nathan—useful, slightly chaotic, and far too entertained by the whole exchange. Emma had laughed easily, cheeks warm every time their eyes met for longer than a second. When he left, she had stood near the counter in her flour-dusted apron and smiled at him like the rest of the afternoon had simply faded around them.He should have felt settled.Instead, the quiet of the car made room for every thought he had been carefully setting aside.He parked in the underground garage of his building and took the elevator up without checking his phone. The penthouse was still and cool when he stepped inside. Afternoon light stretched across the piano lid. He set the paper bags on the kitchen counter and loosened the collar of his shirt, then walked to the windows and looked out at the ci

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 34 – Meet the Best Friend

    For one long second, Emma simply stared."...Daniel?"A smile spread across his face."Hi.""What are you doing here?""I was in the neighborhood."Nathan coughed into his fist.Emma looked at him.Nathan smiled innocently."I told him the bakery was worth another visit.""You told me the salt bread was already sold out by noon.""Exactly."Daniel looked at the display shelves."I wanted to test that theory."Emma couldn't help laughing."You came all the way across town... for bread?"Daniel met her eyes."And to see you."Her cheeks immediately warmed.Nathan looked toward the ceiling."I suddenly feel invisible."Emma laughed even harder."Good afternoon, Nathan.""Good afternoon, Emma.""You came back.""I was promised excellent bread."Mrs. Alvarez peeked out from the kitchen."Oh!"She wiped her hands on a towel."Daniel!"Daniel smiled politely."Mrs. Alvarez.""You're back.""I am."Mrs. Alvarez looked between Daniel and Emma before a knowing smile crossed her face."I'll pret

  • The Stranger I Choose   Chapter 33 – Weekend Bread

    Saturday mornings at Mrs. Alvarez's Bakery were always the busiest.By eight o'clock, the first trays of croissants had already disappeared. Fresh loaves lined the wooden shelves, the display case gleamed beneath warm lights, and the familiar scent of butter and yeast drifted through the little shop every time the door opened.Emma stood behind the counter tying another ribbon around a paper bag."Have a wonderful day.""You too, dear."The elderly customer smiled before disappearing through the door.The little brass bell chimed.Another customer stepped inside.Another order.Another smile.Normally, the steady rhythm of the bakery helped clear her mind.Today...Not so much.Because every few minutes, her thoughts wandered somewhere else.To a penthouse overlooking the city.To a black grand piano sitting beside floor-to-ceiling windows.To Daniel.She still couldn't believe it.Daniel Brooks.CEO of Veridian Group.She'd spent weeks talking to him without knowing.Weeks explaining

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status