Is American Hippo Worth Reading?

Sarah Gailey's 'American Hippo' is one of those wild rides that sticks with you long after you’ve turned the last page. It’s a blend of alternate history and heist adventure, set in a version of America where hippos were imported to solve a meat shortage—and then, of course, things went gloriously off the rails. The novella combines two previously released works, 'River of Teeth' and 'Taste of Marrow,' into a single volume, and it’s packed with sharp wit, chaotic energy, and a cast of characters that feel like they’d leap off the page if given half a chance. If you’re into stories that refuse to play by the rules, this one’s a gem.

What really hooked me was the sheer audacity of the premise. Hippos as invasive species turned into weapons? A found family of outlaws riding them through the bayou? It’s bizarre in the best way, and Gailey’s writing leans into the absurdity without ever losing sight of the characters’ humanity. Winslow Houndstooth, the charismatic leader of the gang, is a particular standout, but even the side characters have layers that make them unforgettable. The pacing is brisk, the dialogue crackles, and there’s just enough emotional weight to keep the stakes feeling real. It’s not a deep philosophical tome, but it doesn’t need to be—sometimes, you just want a story that’s unapologetically fun, and 'American Hippo' delivers in spades.

That said, if you prefer slower, more contemplative narratives, this might not be your cup of tea. The world-building is intentionally loose, leaving a lot to the imagination, and the humor can be hit-or-miss depending on your taste. But for me, the sheer joy of watching a heist unfold on the backs of murderous hippos was worth every page. I’d recommend it to anyone who loves genre-bending stories with a side of chaos and heart. It’s the kind of book that makes you grin while reading—and really, what more could you ask for?