Is 'Antigone' Justified In Her Actions?

2025-06-15 16:54:00 319

5 Jawaban

Ruby
Ruby
2025-06-16 07:43:47
Antigone’s justification is layered. Philosophically, she aligns with natural law theorists who argue morality transcends man-made rules. Practically, her actions force Thebes to reckon with the consequences of blind authoritarianism. Creon’s punishment of her seems disproportionate, revealing his fragility. Antigone isn’t just right—she’s necessary. Her death isn’t defeat; it’s proof that some truths can’t be buried, even by kings. The play’s endurance confirms her stance as universally resonant.
Ivy
Ivy
2025-06-16 08:53:10
Absolutely. Antigone’s decision stems from raw humanity. Polynices was her brother, and leaving him unburied would’ve been a visceral betrayal. Creon’s law was cold and impersonal; her act was hot with love and grief. The play suggests some laws are too unjust to obey. Her justification isn’t logical—it’s emotional, and that’s why it’s powerful. Sometimes, the heart’s verdict outweighs the court’s.
Felix
Felix
2025-06-17 16:20:20
Antigone's actions in Sophocles' play are deeply justified when viewed through the lens of moral duty. She defies King Creon's decree to bury her brother Polynices, not out of rebellion but from unwavering loyalty to divine law and familial love. The Greeks believed proper burial was essential for the soul's peace, and Antigone prioritizes this sacred obligation over human authority. Her defiance isn’t reckless—it’s a calculated stand against tyranny, highlighting the conflict between state power and personal conscience.

Creon’s edict violates religious norms, making Antigone’s resistance a defense of cultural values. Her tragic fate underscores the cost of integrity in an unjust system. While some argue she escalates conflict, her actions expose Creon’s hubris, ultimately leading to his downfall. Her justification lies in the play’s core question: when laws contradict ethics, which should prevail? Antigone chooses the timeless over the temporal.
Reid
Reid
2025-06-19 06:27:44
Antigone’s justification hinges on her role as a woman in ancient Thebes. In a society where women had limited agency, her act of burying Polynices becomes radical. She weaponizes her marginalized status, forcing Creon to confront his hypocrisy. Her actions aren’t just about burial rites—they’re a critique of power structures. The play frames her as a martyr, but modern readers might see her as an early feminist icon. Her defiance resonates because it’s both personal and political, a quiet revolution against oppression.
Sadie
Sadie
2025-06-19 07:10:01
From a dramatic standpoint, Antigone’s actions are the spark that ignites the tragedy. Without her defiance, Creon’s arrogance would go unchecked. She’s justified because her role demands it—the story needs her to challenge the status quo. Her resolve contrasts with Ismene’s compliance, emphasizing courage over fear. The audience roots for her because she embodies the rebel archetype, turning personal loss into a public reckoning. Her actions aren’t just right; they’re narratively essential.
Lihat Semua Jawaban
Pindai kode untuk mengunduh Aplikasi

Buku Terkait

Actions Have Consequences
Actions Have Consequences
The mother of Mr. Burr, the hospital director, was critically ill and needed emergency surgery. My wife, wanting to help her beloved crush, Cedric Grey, take the spotlight, deliberately kept the surgery time from me. By the time I finally arrived—late, Mr. Burr stopped me from entering the operating room and scolded me harshly for being unprofessional and unethical. Once I realized what my wife was doing, I handed the lead surgeon position over to her beloved crush. “Well, since you're so eager to shine,” I said coldly, “you’d better not screw it up.” The nurses tried to talk me out of it. They said I was being impulsive, that this was a rare chance to prove myself. However, none of them knew that I was the only doctor in the entire country capable of performing this rare and complex heart valve surgery. Even if Cedric managed to buy time with some miracle drug and made it look like the patient was improving, without my diagnosis and surgical skills, the operation was doomed to fail. And when that happens, he’d be held responsible. As for my wife, her blind favoritism would come back to haunt her.
8 Bab
In Her Shadow
In Her Shadow
My twin sister, wanting to be with her thug boyfriend, secretly planned to apply for a junior college. When I could not talk her out of it, I told our parents and managed to stop her. However, just a month into the new semester, her thug boyfriend cheated on her. She left a suicide note, blaming it all on the long distance between them. She wrote that if she had gone to that junior college, her boyfriend would never have cheated. Grief‑stricken, my parents turned all their rage on me. "You wretched girl, this is all your fault for meddling! What business was it of yours which school your sister went to? Even if she didn't go to college, we could still support her. We didn't need your big mouth!" "If it weren't for your spiteful tongue, your sister wouldn't be dead!" "We were cursed to have a vicious, unfilial daughter like you!" They locked me in her room, ordering me to repent. Then they took her ashes on a trip, saying they wanted her to see the beautiful mountains and rivers she never got to visit in life. A month later, they returned from their travels to find me long dead, starved to a withered husk in front of my sister's photo. Their eyes held no grief, no guilt, only a faint, scornful curl of the lips. In their eyes, my death was nothing more than justice served. My broken soul saw their icy expressions, and despairing tears burned my eyes. Then my sister's familiar voice rang out again: "What business is it of yours which school I go to? You're just jealous that I have a boyfriend, aren't you?"
8 Bab
IN HER EYES
IN HER EYES
When Cali Olwen, the only werewolf with a gift gets sent out of her pack, life becomes a living hell without control over her powers. But what happens when she meets the cold hybrid that everyone talks about. The one people feared because he was half demon. What happens when she finds out he was given to her by the moon goddess and his sister is the key to unlocking her hidden powers and how to control them. Will she be able to run from the devil or succumb to his touch of ecstasy. Read IN HER EYES to find out.
10
10 Bab
In Her Head
In Her Head
It's Kleo's 17th birth and her closest friends have all decided to treat her for the day. While at a lounge, her mom(a nurse) surprises her with a single phone call telling her to come home early which was a shock due to how busy the nurse schedule is but when mother calls you just have to listen. Never been behind the wheel before and getting praised for her driving skills it was unanimously decided as a joke that kleo should drive which as it turns out was a bad idea to begin with. A truck hits her car and puts her into a coma and is rushed to the hospital. On the other hand there's Avan and Avan's mom has cancer. She has a year to live but as fate would have it her room is just right beside Kleo's room. Avan always used to see kleo's room full of visitors but never the girl they were there to see, however, he notices that it's empty today, the day the doctors announce his mother's remaining life span... Dejected, sad and angry he storms out of the room and happens to be around when Kleo's room was left opened, sneaking a peak to notice the beautiful girl that is unconscious.
10
3 Bab
In Her Shoes
In Her Shoes
Lara Smith is a 30-year-old woman who has been living a dull and lonely life. She doesn't have a family of her own, she doesn't have her own savings, and she is working hard like a dog, just to make ends meet. She wished to be like Amanda Montserrat, a beautiful, rich and a powerful woman who owns Etoile Cosmetics company. The world is her oyster, and she lives a perfect live. She's a trillionaire, she's a genius woman running a cosmetic empire on her own and she is engaged to be married to Emmett Albreicht, who is an extremely famous hotel magnate. While on a company field trip, Lara was involved in a tragic accident, and she was in a comatose state for a year. As she wakes up from her slumber, she realized in horror that she is she's been trapped into a different body! She is now living the life of Amanda Montserrat and she doesn't have any choice but to live a different life while thinking on how to get back to her original body!
Belum ada penilaian
123 Bab
Drowning in Her Darkness
Drowning in Her Darkness
She's always been alone. Without a name. With out light. Without any idea that this is not what life should be. Until the day she hears her in her mind. A strong, sweet voice that tells her this is not what life is. This is not living, just drowning slowly in darkness, but she can help. What happens when a girl with no name and no memories of a life before the dark, escapes and discovers there is so much more then she thought in this world? What will she do when the life she built, after emerging from the darkness, comes crashing down around her? Can she stand and fight for the light she’s now apart of, or will she find her self Drowning in Her Darkness forever.
10
64 Bab

Pertanyaan Terkait

Why Does 'Antigone' Defy Creon'S Law?

5 Jawaban2025-06-15 18:46:49
Antigone's defiance in 'Antigone' is driven by deeply personal and moral convictions that clash with Creon's authoritarian rule. She prioritizes divine law over human law, believing her brother Polynices deserves a proper burial despite being labeled a traitor. To her, familial duty and religious obligation outweigh political decrees. Her actions aren’t just rebellion; they’re a statement about the limits of power and the supremacy of ethics over blind obedience. Creon represents rigid state control, while Antigone embodies individual conscience. Her resistance highlights the tension between loyalty to family and loyalty to the state. The play forces us to question whether laws that violate fundamental human decency deserve respect. Antigone’s tragic fate underscores the cost of integrity in a world where power often dismisses morality.

How Does 'Antigone' End Tragically?

5 Jawaban2025-06-15 17:10:57
The tragedy of 'Antigone' reaches its devastating climax with a chain of irreversible choices and consequences. Antigone, defying King Creon’s decree, buries her brother Polynices and is sentenced to death. Creon’s stubbornness blinds him to the warnings of the prophet Tiresias, who predicts divine wrath. Only after Antigone hangs herself does Creon realize his folly. His son Haemon, Antigone’s fiancé, kills himself in grief, followed by Creon’s wife Eurydice, who curses him before taking her own life. The play ends with Creon broken, carrying the weight of his hubris as the chorus reflects on the futility of pride. The tragedy isn’t just in the deaths but in the relentless irony—Creon’s laws, meant to stabilize Thebes, unravel his family. Antigone’s moral defiance, though righteous, leads to her destruction. The gods’ will, ignored by Creon, manifests in ruin. The final image of Creon alone, begging for death, underscores Sophocles’ theme: human arrogance invites catastrophe. It’s a raw, unflinching look at how rigid authority and uncompromising ideals collide with tragic inevitability.

How Does 'Antigone' Reflect Greek Values?

5 Jawaban2025-06-15 08:38:41
'Antigone' is a brilliant reflection of Greek values, especially the tension between divine law and human authority. The play centers on Antigone’s defiance of King Creon’s edict to leave her brother unburied, showcasing the Greek reverence for familial duty and religious rites. Burial rites were sacred in Greek culture, believed to ensure the dead’s passage to the afterlife. Antigone’s insistence on honoring her brother underscores the Greek prioritization of piety over political obedience. Creon represents the state’s authority, embodying the Greek ideal of civic order. However, his rigid stance leads to tragedy, highlighting the Greek belief in hubris—excessive pride leading to downfall. The chorus, a staple in Greek drama, voices communal wisdom, reflecting the collective mindset. The play’s climax, where both Antigone and Creon suffer, illustrates the Greek concept of balance—dike (justice)—where extremes are punished. 'Antigone' isn’t just a story; it’s a moral compass of Greek society.

What Books Are Similar To The Three Theban Plays: Antigone; Oedipus The King; Oedipus At Colonus?

3 Jawaban2026-01-08 04:06:26
Sophocles' 'The Three Theban Plays' are timeless tragedies that dive deep into fate, family, and moral dilemmas. If you loved the raw emotional power and complex characters, you might enjoy Aeschylus' 'Oresteia' trilogy—especially 'Agamemnon.' It’s another Greek classic that wrestles with vengeance and justice, but with a more epic, sweeping feel. Euripides' 'Medea' is another must-read; it’s shorter but packs a brutal punch with its exploration of betrayal and revenge. For something more modern but equally intense, try Jean Anouilh’s reimagining of 'Antigone.' It keeps the Greek spirit but adds a wartime resistance vibe that feels eerily relevant. If you’re into the philosophical side of these plays, Camus’ 'The Myth of Sisyphus' ties existential themes back to Greek mythology in a way that’ll make you rethink Oedipus’ struggles.

Who Are The Main Characters In The Three Theban Plays: Antigone; Oedipus The King; Oedipus At Colonus?

3 Jawaban2026-01-08 13:37:02
The Theban Plays are a trio of Greek tragedies that have haunted me for years—not just because of their themes, but because of how vividly the characters stick in your mind. In 'Oedipus the King,' Oedipus himself is the tragic heart of it all, a man whose relentless pursuit of truth leads to his own ruin. His wife (and mother, yikes) Jocasta is another key figure, trapped in the horror of fate. Then there’s Creon, Jocasta’s brother, who starts off as a voice of reason but later becomes a rigid authority figure in 'Antigone.' Speaking of 'Antigone,' she’s the defiant heroine who buries her brother Polynices against Creon’s orders, embodying raw moral courage. And let’s not forget Tiresias, the blind prophet who sees everything coming but can’t stop the train wreck. 'Oedipus at Colonus' gives Oedipus a quieter, almost mystical end, with his daughters Antigone and Ismene by his side. These characters feel less like ancient myths and more like people you’d argue with at 3 a.m. about life’s cruel jokes. What fascinates me is how their flaws and virtues intertwine. Oedipus’ pride, Antigone’s stubborn love, Creon’s brittle authority—they’re all so human. Even the chorus, though not 'characters' in the usual sense, feels like a collective conscience, murmuring warnings no one heeds. I’ve reread these plays during different life phases, and each time, someone new resonates—lately, it’s Ismene, the 'quiet' sister who’s often overlooked but carries her own grief with dignity. Sophocles knew how to carve souls into words.

What Is The Conflict Between 'Antigone' And Creon?

5 Jawaban2025-06-15 14:39:28
The conflict between 'Antigone' and Creon is a timeless clash of values—personal duty versus state authority. Antigone, driven by familial love and religious obligation, defies Creon’s decree to leave her brother Polynices unburied. She sees burial as sacred, a moral imperative beyond human laws. Creon, as ruler, prioritizes order and loyalty to the state, viewing defiance as treason. His rigidity amplifies the tragedy; he misinterprets her actions as rebellion rather than devotion. Their conflict exposes deeper tensions: youth versus age, divine law versus human law. Antigone’s resolve highlights the limits of political power—Creon’s edict can’t suppress her conscience. His eventual downfall stems from pride, refusing to heed warnings until it’s too late. The play forces us to question whether justice lies in obedience or in challenging unjust authority. Their confrontation isn’t just personal—it’s a battle for the soul of societal values.

How Does Home Fire A Novel Compare To The Original Antigone?

4 Jawaban2025-08-14 08:11:13
'Home Fire' by Kamila Shamsie and 'Antigone' by Sophocles offer fascinating contrasts. 'Antigone' is a Greek tragedy centered on moral duty versus state law, where Antigone defies King Creon to bury her brother. 'Home Fire' transposes this into a contemporary political thriller, exploring the struggles of a British Muslim family torn between loyalty and extremism. While 'Antigone' is stark and mythological, 'Home Fire' delves into nuanced, real-world issues like terrorism, identity, and media scrutiny. Shamsie’s Isma, Aneeka, and Parvaiz mirror Antigone, Ismene, and Polynices, but their conflicts are deeply personal and globally resonant. The modern twist on Creon’s character—a politician playing to public fear—adds layers of commentary on Islamophobia and power. Both works ask: What do we owe our family versus our society? But 'Home Fire' makes it painfully current.

What Is The Ending Of The Three Theban Plays: Antigone; Oedipus The King; Oedipus At Colonus Explained?

3 Jawaban2026-01-08 18:39:33
The Three Theban Plays weave this tragic tapestry where fate and defiance collide. 'Oedipus the King' starts it all—Oedipus, the dude who unknowingly kills his dad and marries his mom, realizes the horror and gouges his eyes out. Jocasta, his mom-wife, hangs herself. Fast-forward to 'Oedipus at Colonus,' and he’s a broken, wandering old man, but he finds a weird sort of peace. Theseus grants him sanctuary in Athens, and he dies mysteriously, almost like the gods finally cut him some slack. Then comes 'Antigone,' his daughter, who’s got her own drama. She defies King Creon to bury her brother Polynices, gets sentenced to death, and offs herself in a tomb. Creon’s son (her fiancé) and wife also kill themselves from grief. It’s a family curse that just won’t quit—everyone’s stubbornness and pride lead to ruin, but there’s this eerie beauty in how Antigone chooses honor over survival. What sticks with me is how Sophocles makes you question free will. Oedipus tries to outrun prophecy and trips right into it; Antigone knows she’ll die but does what’s right anyway. The endings aren’t just sad—they’re like a punch to the gut, but you can’t look away. The plays leave you wondering if the characters ever had a chance, or if they were just puppets of the gods. And that last scene in 'Antigone,' with Creon holding his dead wife? Chills.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status