Why Do Awards Struggle To Judge All Book Genre Fairly?

2025-09-05 15:03:44 42

5 Answers

Derek
Derek
2025-09-06 08:15:42
Okay, this frustrates me sometimes but in a good way — it means books matter enough to argue about. Awards struggle because they try to measure apples, oranges, and durians with the same ruler. Judges often come from particular reading backgrounds and tastes, and even the most earnest panel has blind spots: some love experimental prose, others prize tight plotting or worldbuilding. Add marketing buzz and established names that already carry cultural capital, and smaller genre works get overshadowed, no matter how daring.

Then there's the problem of criteria. Literary awards frequently value certain formal qualities — voice, thematic depth, innovation — while genre fans often care about pace, stakes, and emotional payoff. Hybrid books that sit between categories confuse juries: is that space opera with a feminist critique science fiction, literary, or both? I find it helpful when awards are transparent about what they’re judging, or when separate genre-specific prizes exist, so the unique strengths of each tradition get honored instead of flattened into one vague ‘best book’ category. That would make my bookshelf feel a little less cheated and a lot more celebrated.
Yara
Yara
2025-09-06 17:44:00
I sometimes approach this like a detective: start with the evidence (the shortlist), then examine motive (what the prize values), and finally look for bias (who’s on the panel, what publishers pushed). The structural issues are the kicker: many major awards were created in eras that separated ‘literary’ from ‘popular’ fiction, so the judging language and expectations still reflect that split. That leaves genre writers having to either write against their genre or risk being dismissed.

Practical fixes would include separate criteria sets tailored to different genres, anonymized submissions for early rounds so fame doesn’t sway readers, and outreach to underrepresented presses. But cultural change matters too — readers, critics, and award organizers need to broaden what they celebrate. I love when a surprising genre novel breaks through because it reminds everyone that quality comes in many flavors, not just one.
David
David
2025-09-07 08:26:38
It bugs me how awards act like one-size-fits-all. Genres are like different games with different win conditions; you can't judge a mystery by the standards of poetry any more than you can judge a sitcom by the standards of opera. Panels are human and time-poor, often leaning toward the familiar canon, so bold or niche works slip through.

Also, small presses and translated books struggle for visibility. I try to follow smaller, genre-specific prizes and reader polls because they spotlight voices mainstream awards miss — it’s where I find my next favorite read.
Bennett
Bennett
2025-09-07 18:30:14
I’m the kind of reader who mixes thrillers, slice-of-life novels, and weird fantasy on my commute, so I see the mismatch clearly: awards often have narrow vocabularies for praise. That makes them favor books that fit recognizable molds. Also timing matters — if a genre hot right now, a lot of similar titles flood the market and judges get overwhelmed, making it harder for quieter, inventive works to shine.

Translation, cultural context, and readership expectations complicate it further: a book revered in one country might seem unfamiliar to judges elsewhere. Personally, I look beyond big prizes to find recommendations and enjoy when niche awards or reader communities highlight gems that mainstream prizes overlook; they remind me that diversity in taste is what keeps reading exciting.
Jolene
Jolene
2025-09-09 17:30:36
I get annoyed and amused by this at the same time. In my book club we argue for hours because different genres aim for different things: thrillers want tension and twists, romance focuses on relationship payoff, fantasy builds entire cultures. A panel applying the same yardstick to all of those is going to miss the point of a lot of books. Judges also have limited time — they usually can’t read every submission deeply, so reputation, blurbs, and publicity influence who actually gets a careful read.

Another thing I notice is industry inertia: prestige prizes grew up valuing a certain style and keep reinforcing that taste. That creates a feedback loop where publishers push certain titles harder to fit the prize mold. If I could nudge the system, I’d love to see rotating judges with diverse reading habits, clearer rubrics for different genres, and more weight given to independent and translated works. It won’t be perfect, but it would help level the playing field a bit and bring books I adore into the conversation.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Cosmic Struggle
Cosmic Struggle
Red didn't mean to find out. She was the assistant to a private detective and she needed money. It was a regular night and she went to work, only to find out that her boss wasn't there. He wasn't just gone but truly gone. Now, who was going to pay for her bills? Desperate for money, Red looks for her boss only to find something else. Now, will Red be able to deal with her new problems and most importantly, will she be able to pay for her bills?
Not enough ratings
2 Chapters
Desiree mixed genre collection
Desiree mixed genre collection
"Do you believe desire can be holy ,or is it always a sin" ? " Depends. Sometimes it saves you . Sometimes it ruins you." "And if you knew the ending was tragic , could you still want it" ? "Every time " Twenty different tales of obsession, betrayer,and temptation-where love is never simple or safe. From rejection mates and cursed vampire to priest breaking vows ,ex-wives hunting revenge ,and human traped between werewolves and mermaid-These stories test the limit of what we dare to want . Some lovers burn the word for each other. Some are destroyed by their own hunger . But all of them prove one truth; Desire always costs .
Not enough ratings
14 Chapters
A Sorceress Struggle
A Sorceress Struggle
They say if you work hard, you will be able to achieve what you want. Born in a modest family, orphan at a young age, struggling in a capitalistique world to find her place; that's what her daily life seemed to be. But who would have thought she would die a meaningless death when hit by a truck after leaving from the office?! And say what !? She died a virgin without even having a boyfreind once! Luckly the universe is righteous! She get's a new chance for life and become the daughter of the all powerful Duke Evanson! Lady Satiana Von Evanson! Living a life of pleasure she enjoys beeing rich and live a carefree life... But that all will change when she realize that the world she's reincarnated in is that of a Role play game called "Saga of Regulus". A fantazy world where magic and monsters exist... and what ? she is the main stories Female Villainess ! The Solis Family that rules over the Regulus empire, she is engaged to the heir to the throne ! The blonde Crown Prince Lukretus La Solis! Her nemesis! To escape a fate of ruin and destruction, she struggle day and night under the cover of the Sorceress Satania. With schemes and devious toughts she takes on the role of the Villainess with the sole purpose of survival! And during her journey... her fated encounter with the Red haired boy will change everything... "Who is this man? Why is he so familiar !? And why the hell am i falling for him! i don't have time for this! i need to continue with my plan!" With such toughts will she achieve her happiness? Will her hard work pay at last? Folow the story of the Sorceress and her journey against the fate of the Villainess!
10
29 Chapters
Heaven's Love Struggle
Heaven's Love Struggle
Diki Reandi is a member of the Indonesian Air Force International, has a cold demeanor and is talkative. He is 28 years old and at this time, he is involved in solving problems in the past which all started from the disappointment experienced by a man named Kenzo Albert. In the middle of a wedding with his wife. He had a deep loss. The woman who had only been his wife for 1 minute died in front of him. His family and friends died where what was supposed to be happy news turned into sad news. "Nokkkk!" Kenzo shouted when he saw his wife's incomplete body in front of him. In the luxury mension with a classic style, a beautiful woman is seen sitting on a chair equipped with a hand and an arm. "You're mean!" shouted Dissa leaking Kenzo Albert's handsome face. "I don't care, how you judge myself, the most important thing is that you are born again. I have the right to have you. I will avenge everything they did to us first. Wait for my play!" said Kenzo by leaking sharp like an eagle in front of Dissa Richard. "Stop! Don't try my sister or I will break your hands," threatened Diki Reandi running towards them. Will Diki save Dissa from Kenzo's clutches? or Dissa must choose Kenzo to save innocent people?
10
100 Chapters
Struggle for a Chance
Struggle for a Chance
She was infertile. Her husband said he would love her no matter what. For three years, he had always been gentle to her, She was happy that she found someone who truly loved her and didn't mind that she couldn't give him a child. Until one day, She learned the fact that he's been cheating on her a long time ago, living a double life and having a baby with someone else. And that woman was someone she know. she was mad and slapped her, but didn't expect it would kill the baby. His husband was furious and sent his lawyer to force her to sign the divorce agreement. She was told not to take any jewelry he bought for her, and no property would belong to her, all she could do was just pack and leave. Three years later, She came back with another man...
8.9
247 Chapters
Death Judge Noble Park (English Version)
Death Judge Noble Park (English Version)
The world was glorious, shining like gold in the middle of the universe as people raised their toasts, celebrating the victory they had. However, the victory they achieved turned out to be a nightmare. The victors swung their blades as the blood of their own kin spread on the floor. The victors did everything, no matter how cruel it is, just to achieve victory. In the end, the world was like a paradise—a deceptive paradise everyone thought was glorious . . . but it isn't. It was fiendish. Maximaze was a child from the lowest level of civilization, a slave of the superiors. Maze just wanted a peaceful life with her mother, Sybil, while desiring to find her father who was separated from them since the day she was born. Until one day, an old friend of her parents entered her life and gave her an opportunity to study. However, there was a condition. Maze needed to be one of the candidates to become a Death Judge and travel the world. Her desire for peace made her continue the ruthless road of becoming the Death Judge. Her quiet yet terrific life with her mother before became more chaotic—worse than slavery. As she wandered the world, she found out the truth. Maze's dreams shattered into pieces—nightmares kept visiting her, day and night. Since that day, she received a horrific reminder.
10
36 Chapters

Related Questions

What Genre Is A Book

5 Answers2025-08-01 12:50:29
As someone who's spent countless hours buried in books, I've come to appreciate how genres can shape the entire reading experience. A book's genre is like its DNA—it defines the themes, tone, and even the pacing. For instance, 'The Hobbit' by J.R.R. Tolkien is a classic fantasy adventure with dragons and quests, while 'Gone Girl' by Gillian Flynn falls into the psychological thriller category, packed with twists and suspense. Genres aren't just labels; they help readers find stories that resonate with their moods. Romance novels like 'Pride and Prejudice' focus on relationships and emotional depth, whereas sci-fi works like 'Dune' explore futuristic concepts and technology. Sometimes, books blend genres, like 'The Night Circus,' which mixes romance with magical realism. Understanding a book's genre sets the right expectations and enhances the journey.

What Is The Genre Of Book Before We Were Yours?

5 Answers2025-08-14 19:37:10
I find 'Before We Were Yours' by Lisa Wingate to be a fascinating blend of historical fiction and family drama. The story is deeply rooted in real-life events, specifically the infamous Tennessee Children’s Home Society scandal, which adds a layer of historical gravitas. The narrative alternates between the past and present, following the lives of children stolen from their families and sold to wealthy clients, and a modern-day woman uncovering her family’s dark secrets. What makes this book stand out is its emotional depth and meticulous research. The historical elements are seamlessly woven into a gripping family saga, making it a compelling read for those who enjoy stories with a strong sense of time and place. The genre is primarily historical fiction, but it also touches on themes of identity, loss, and resilience, which resonate with readers of contemporary drama. If you’re into books that combine heart-wrenching history with personal journeys, this one’s a must-read.

What Is The Genre Of The Book 'Pestilence'?

5 Answers2025-06-23 14:30:57
'Pestilence' is a gripping blend of dark fantasy and apocalyptic horror, with a strong romantic subplot that adds depth to its grim narrative. The story unfolds in a world ravaged by supernatural plagues, where humanity’s survival hinges on confronting the Horseman of Pestilence himself. The genre defies simple categorization—it’s a visceral mix of body horror and emotional stakes, where the line between villain and love interest blurs. The apocalyptic setting amplifies the tension, while the romantic elements humanize the chaos. Fans of morally gray characters and high-stakes world-building will find it addictive. What sets 'Pestilence' apart is its refusal to sanitize the macabre. The Horseman’s powers are grotesquely vivid, from spreading blight with a touch to manipulating decay. Yet, amid the devastation, the novel explores themes of redemption and unlikely connections. The romance isn’t just tacked on; it’s woven into the survival narrative, creating a bittersweet contrast between destruction and tenderness. This genre hybridity makes it stand out in crowded shelves.

What Genre Is A Sports Book

3 Answers2025-06-10 17:14:31
I've always been drawn to sports books because they blend action, drama, and personal growth in such a dynamic way. The genre is a mix of nonfiction and fiction, depending on whether it’s a biography, memoir, or a novel. Nonfiction sports books like 'Open' by Andre Agassi or 'The Boys in the Boat' by Daniel James Brown dive deep into real-life struggles and triumphs, while fiction ones like 'The Art of Fielding' by Chad Harbach or 'Beartown' by Fredrik Backman use sports as a backdrop to explore human relationships. The best part is how they capture the adrenaline of competition and the emotional highs and lows that come with it. Whether you're into baseball, basketball, or soccer, there's a sports book out there that’ll make you feel like you're right in the middle of the game.

What Genre Does This Book Is Not For You Belong To?

3 Answers2025-07-06 14:26:39
I absolutely adore most genres, but I have to admit that hardcore horror is just not my cup of tea. Books like 'The Shining' by Stephen King or 'House of Leaves' by Mark Z. Danielewski give me sleepless nights. I prefer stories that leave me feeling warm or inspired, not ones that make me check under my bed. Psychological horror, especially, messes with my head in ways I can't handle. Give me a cozy romance or a thrilling adventure any day over something that'll haunt my dreams for weeks. I respect the craft, but my heart can't take the dread.

What Is The Genre Of The Important Book?

5 Answers2025-07-07 03:58:41
As an avid reader who thrives on dissecting literary genres, I find 'One Hundred Years of Solitude' by Gabriel García Márquez to be a masterpiece of magical realism. This genre blends fantastical elements with everyday reality, creating a surreal yet deeply human narrative. The book's vivid imagery and intertwining family sagas make it unforgettable. Another pivotal work is '1984' by George Orwell, a cornerstone of dystopian fiction. It explores themes of totalitarianism and surveillance with chilling precision. The genre's bleak, cautionary tone resonates even today, making it a must-read for anyone interested in political and social commentary. Lastly, 'Pride and Prejudice' by Jane Austen epitomizes classic romance, weaving wit and societal critique into a timeless love story.

What Is The Genre Of The Book Naruto?

4 Answers2025-07-16 18:56:26
As someone who has spent countless hours immersed in the world of 'Naruto', I can confidently say that it blends multiple genres seamlessly. At its core, it's a shounen manga and anime, which means it targets young male audiences with themes of friendship, perseverance, and growth. The action-packed battles and ninja techniques make it a thrilling adventure series, while the deep character backstories and emotional arcs add layers of drama and even tragedy. The series also incorporates elements of fantasy with its chakra system, jutsu, and mythical creatures like the Tailed Beasts. There's a strong undercurrent of coming-of-age as Naruto evolves from a mischievous outcast to a respected hero. The political intrigue and war narratives in later arcs introduce shades of military fiction and political drama. What makes 'Naruto' stand out is how it balances intense action with heartfelt moments, making it a multi-genre masterpiece.

What Genre Is Being The Other Woman Book?

3 Answers2025-07-31 04:24:22
I’ve always been drawn to books that explore complex relationships, and 'Being the Other Woman' fits right into that niche. This book falls under the drama and contemporary romance genres, but it’s not your typical love story. It delves into the messy, emotional side of affairs, focusing on the perspective of the 'other woman.' The narrative is raw and unflinching, tackling themes like guilt, desire, and societal judgment. While it’s romantic in some ways, the emotional weight and moral dilemmas make it more of a psychological drama. It’s the kind of book that lingers in your mind long after you’ve finished it, making you question the boundaries of love and loyalty.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status