What Are The Best Old Man Logan Marvel Collected Editions?

I'm a sucker for a good Wolverine saga, and when people ask me which collected editions of 'Old Man Logan' to chase, I break it down by what you want out of the story. If you want the classic gut-punch that started the craze, start with the original Mark Millar/Steve McNiven story collected as the 'Old Man Logan' trade/hardcover (the storyline originally ran in 'Wolverine' #66–72). That one is grim, cinematic, and has McNiven's jaw-dropping visuals — perfect if you like a tight, high-impact read that inspired the Logan we see in other media.

If you care about atmosphere and modern character work, I love the 2015 'Old Man Logan' run by Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino, which is collected into several trades and deluxe hardcover volumes. Sorrentino's layouts and Lemire's slower, haunted take on Logan are a completely different vibe from Millar's apocalypse-on-rails — more melancholy, more mystery. For collectors, look for the hardcover collections or the omnibus editions that gather these runs in one big, shelf-friendly package; they often include extras like covers, sketches, and variant art that make them worth the price if you enjoy flipping through process work.

Practical tip: if you’re on a budget, digital collections on services like Marvel’s storefront or secondhand TPBs at your local shop are great. For a single-session binge, read the Millar/McNiven original first — it’s the foundational beat — then move into Lemire/Sorrentino to see how the concept was expanded and reworked. Happy reading, and may your coffee stay hot while you get emotionally wrecked by a man who refuses to be anything but Logan.

I tend to recommend editions based on mood and shelf-space, so here's a compact guide from someone who buys more collected volumes than I'll admit to friends.

Best for newcomers: grab the Mark Millar and Steve McNiven 'Old Man Logan' trade. It's the punchy, iconic origin of the 'Old Man' idea, and McNiven's art is the kind of thing you want on a coffee table. Best for atmosphere: the Jeff Lemire/Andrea Sorrentino trades — they're serialized in multiple volumes and reward the slower, creepier tone with gorgeous, cinematic page work. There's also an omnibus/hardcover route if you like everything in one tidy, weighty book; these editions are pricier but they look great and usually include extras.

If you enjoy continuity, check reading order notes in the back of trades—some collections include short tie-ins or follow-up material. I buy most of these in hardcover for longevity, but if you want to save money, the trades are perfectly readable and easier to carry around. Also, Marvel's digital shop often runs sales, so I keep an eye out and snag things when they drop. Might even pick up a signed copy someday if my LCS has one.

I still get a little giddy whenever I flip through a collected 'Old Man Logan' volume, so here are my top picks in short: first, the original Mark Millar/Steve McNiven 'Old Man Logan' trade (the one from the 'Wolverine' issues) — brutal and iconic; second, the Jeff Lemire/Andrea Sorrentino 'Old Man Logan' trades or hardcover volumes for a moodier, emotional ride; and third, if you want everything together, hunt down a hardcover omnibus or deluxe collection that compiles the runs and extras.

Why these three? Millar/McNiven is the raw concept with blockbuster art, Lemire/Sorrentino expands the character in interesting ways, and omnibus editions are for people who like to own a complete, handsome set. I usually buy one trade to read and then decide if the hardcover is worth the shelf space. If you're undecided, read the original story first — it’s fast and will tell you whether you’re hooked.