How Do I Design Red Herrings That Feel Fair In A Detective Mystery?
2026-07-23 14:59:42
52
關注5
分享
ReeseNash
Detail Finder
Translator
ABO人格測試
快速測測看!你的真實屬性是 Alpha、Beta 還是 Omega?
費洛蒙
屬性
理想的戀愛
潛藏慾望
隱藏黑化屬性
馬上測測看
6 答案
DanaBurns
Book Guide
Journalist
I think of them as emotional traps, not just logical ones. A red herring can be a person the reader wants to be guilty because they’re unlikable, or someone they desperately don’t want to be guilty because they’re a sweet old lady. Playing on those biases feels fair because it exposes the reader's own assumptions, not the author's trickery.
2026-07-25 06:57:40
5
TomRyan
Plot Detective
Office Worker
Series regulars can be perpetual red herrings. The detective’s rival in the police department, the nosy reporter, the ex-lover—they have established motives to be involved. Using them as occasional genuine culprits and other times as red herrings keeps readers on their toes, as long as their role is justified by the specific plot each time.
2026-07-27 06:34:29
3
TobyAllen
Book Scout
Assistant
Forensic science is great for this. A partial fingerprint matches a suspect, but it’s from a recent, innocent visit. A DNA trace is found, but it’s transferred via a handshake. The science is accurate, but the interpretation is misleading. That feels fair because it mirrors real investigative challenges.
2026-07-27 09:33:33
3
RealPages
Longtime Reader
Editor
Has anyone tried writing one? I’m outlining something and I’m worried my fake clue is too obvious. Or maybe it’s too obscure. How do you even beta-test a red herring?
2026-07-27 20:09:31
1
VedaReid
Frequent Answerer
Office Worker
Avoid red herrings that rely on characters acting stupidly. An innocent person finding the murder weapon and deciding to hide it ‘just because’ is infuriating. Their actions need a psychologically believable motive, even if it’s panic, pride, or a misguided sense of protection.
2026-07-29 14:02:00
2
查看全部答案
掃碼下載 APP
相關作品
Who's the Real Detective Here?
Perfect Timing
10
3.2K
I quit and dipped. City threw a parade.
Only Jenna Blake—my oh-so-gifted junior who claimed she could "see through killers' eyes"—lost it.
At her celebration banquet, she went full drama queen:
"I owe everything to Kate Mercer. Please, bring her back!"
I laughed. Cold. Not happening.
Last time around, I was the hotshot detective. But every clue I found? She dropped it first like she read my mind.
People started saying I was washed.
So I went all in—three months, no sleep, cracked a massive trafficking ring. Led the raid myself.
She beat me there. Again. Place was cleaned out.
Boom. She's the city's golden girl.
I'm the clown with no game.
Pressure got ugly. My head snapped. I died chasing the last scumbag.
Then—bam. I woke up. Same day. Raid morning. Round two.
There are three things Samara Culkin loves: her father, wearing high heels, and being a detective. But in a world where being a female officer is considered weak, she struggles to find a place where she feels truly belong. Determined to prove The Detective Tag firm that she is worth it, she sets out to solve one of the biggest cases the city of Los Angeles has ever seen.
There are three things Clayton Jones likes: his car, detective skills, and the female detective who happens to catch his eye—Samara. As an expert and well-known crime officer, he is given the chance to work with her; a one-time possibility that rarely happens. The only problem is that she hates him. And he does not know why.
The Detective Tag is a crime fiction with a twist of romance. Join Samara and Clayton—all the bitterness, dislikes, and romance in between—as they dive into the world of crime cases and murder investigations.
Well, maybe a bit of finding love, too.
With the sudden death of his sister, detective Dawson Wills was going to give everything to find her killer, he wanted to do it alone. To find and make the killer pay for causing him so much pain, but unfortunately, life doesn’t always give you what you desire. Dawson was giving a partner, one of the things he disliked as a detective.
Jane Johnson was Dawson's dream woman, how would Dawson maneuver his way from falling in love with this beautiful woman who was now his partner and finding his sister’s killer?
He dislikes having partners, but detective Jane was too beautiful to be disliked….
"He's gone, Elizabeth," her captain Charles Johnston tells her. Elizabeth blinks back her tears. Her face full of shock and disbelief. Her frozen stare interrupted by his words. "He left his badge." "There's no way," she thought. He wouldn't leave her like this. No warning, no phone call, no letter. She was more to him than that or at least so she thought. That conversation has plagued her for 3 years. For 3 long years, Detective Elizabeth Ryan tried to shut out him, to finally be able to move on. But just as she does, he abruptly returns seeking more than what either of them anticipated. Will Elizabeth be able to forgive him, or will the past be too much to swallow? What happens when life throws her too many twists to handle?
The bread knife stuck in Jon doe’s chest had an unusual pattern, I grabbed a camera from the nearest person and clicked a few pictures of the design “Email them to me.” I said as I was handing the camera back to them. It looked ancient and rare, not the usual bread knifes you’d find at our local stores here in Seattle.
I looked up to find a detective watching my every move, it seemed that his one side of the face looked sunken in, similarly you only see this in people who don’t have teeth, which prompted me to look into his mouth, to find that all of his teeth had been pulled out. I sighed loudly and said “well, here goes our identification route of checking dental records, this body was left in the hopes that no identification will be made!”
Craning my neck to have a look at the coroner who had just arrived on scene, I recalled working with her once before on another case when I first started as a rookie, Dr Leslie Adams is an expert in her field and one of the most professional and efficient woman.
She looked down at me, and stated “Detective Rush you do know that the body you are looking at has been dead for more than 3 days, and also looks as if it was stored in a body freezer before being planted at this scene” I shook my head and realised that this is getting more intense by the second, “I hadn’t realised so Doc, that’s the reason we have you here, to help me solve the mystery “- I said whilst walking up to her, I held out my hand and gave her hand a firm handshake.
When Emma's sister vanishes, she's thrust into a deadly game of cat and mouse. A mysterious figure, hidden behind a mask, demands Emma play a twisted game of puzzles and clues to rescue her sister. With time running out, Emma must use her wits to unravel the mysteries and face the sinister forces behind the game. But as the stakes grow higher, Emma realizes the game is designed to test her limits, and the truth about her sister's disappearance may be more terrifying than she ever imagined. Will Emma solve the puzzles and save her sister, or will she become the game's next victim?
I'm leaning back in my chair thinking about all the times I've been brilliantly fooled. The feeling of being tricked fairly is a rare joy. It's not about being smarter than the reader; it's about being a good host, guiding them through a fun, challenging maze where the walls are transparent if you look at them from the right angle. The red herrings are the ornate decorations on the walls that distract you. The clues are the slight gaps in the panels that let you see through to the other side. A writer who respects you decorates the walls beautifully but never seals those gaps.
My pet peeve is the red herring that's just a random stranger who acts suspiciously for no reason and then vanishes from the plot. That's lazy. A good red herring character should have a full reason for their behavior, even if it's unrelated. They should feel like a real person with their own story, not a cardboard cutout placed to fool me.
Beware of the 'chekhov's gun' principle turning against you. If you mention a strange noise, a missing letter opener, and a strained relationship in Act One, the reader will expect them all to connect. A clever red herring uses one of those elements as a legitimate clue and another as the herring. The strange noise was the real murder; the missing letter opener was just misplaced by the maid. You fulfill the narrative promise but in an unexpected way, making the reader feel both surprised and satisfied that the element was addressed.
Physical objects are classic for a reason. A misplaced earring, a specific brand of cigarette ash, a unique ink smudge. The trick is introducing them casually, as set dressing. The reader's eye should glide over them the first time. The red herring is often a more dramatic, emotional object—a bloody knife, a torn letter, a shouted threat. The real clue is the quiet, almost boring one. Its importance only becomes clear when it's connected to a person or a place.
For instance, everyone focuses on the murder weapon (the red herring), which turns out to be from the house and has everyone's prints. The real clue is the type of soil on the victim's shoes, which matches only one greenhouse in town. The soil was mentioned in a throwaway line describing the body. That's the planting. Later, when we learn a suspect frequents that greenhouse, the connection clicks. The drama points one way, the evidence points another.
They also master the 're-contextualization' moment. A red herring isn't just disproven; the facts that supported it are shown to mean something entirely different. That bloody knife wasn't the murder weapon; it was used to cut the fishing line that set up an accidental death. The midnight argument wasn't about the murder; it was about a pregnancy scare.
The original clue isn't erased or labeled a lie; its meaning is transformed. This is so much more satisfying than just finding out a witness was mistaken or a clue was planted. The world of the story remains consistent and solid; only your understanding of it shifts. It rewards close attention and makes the fictional world feel airtight and real.