Is Dumbledore Bad

2025-01-16 18:31:25 509

2 Answers

Chloe
Chloe
2025-01-18 03:49:31
Ah, the question of Albus Dumbledore's morality – it's been hotly debated among Potterheads ever since the series wrapped. Well, let me indulge you with my thoughts. From a child’s perspective, Albus Dumbledore in initial books of 'Harry Potter' series appears as the embodiment of supreme good. He's the wizarding world's example of ultimate power combined with ultimate humility—a clear force of good.

However, as the series evolves, so does his character - not all for the good. For one, his hand in the underage wizard Harry’s dangerous exploits would definitely not pass as sound judgement in the muggle world.

Furthermore, his secret-keeping habit - especially key information about horcruxes from Harry fuels his detractors. His past history with Grindelwald and his family were far from stellar too. What's intriguing in JK Rowling's portrayal of Dumbledore though, is his acknowledgement of his own flaws - his quest for power in youth, his indirect approach and so on.

Yeah, it's safe to say he's no poster child for sainthood; but terming him as 'bad', that seems a tad too harsh. He’s much more of a morally grey character, more nuanced than just 'good' or 'bad'. Quite like real people, eh?
Cassidy
Cassidy
2025-01-20 16:00:01
Albus Dumbledore first appears on the scene as an interesting old man with a hat. In the 'Harry Potter' series by J.K. Rowling, however, he is often seen as a figure who seeks to guide and help make things come right--representation of wisdom and goodness. And, inevitably, he is not perfect: there have been questionable moments in his conduct — what he decided about Harry's upbringing, what he has kept secret in the name of helping make the greater good. You might call them all sticking points.

Yet to view him as 'bad' represents a punishment too severe. He has all the complexity of character, showing us that even heroes can have flaws. Is Albus Dumbledore a good or a bad person? This questions has got a lot of play. Well, for what it's worth, my opinion differs from those who now consider the thing settled.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Bad Meets Bad
Bad Meets Bad
Amelia Black is known as the "rebellious girl" , she was the kinda girl your parents told you not to hang out with. Also known as "Black Rose" the undefeated street fighter. Amelia's life revolves around pain and tragedy but she refuses to let it break her, instead it makes her stronger. It's time for a fresh start in a new town with new people. With her past catching up to her can Amelia keep her past all a secret or, will a certain Mafia boss unleash every secret Amelia has hidden? Vincenzo De Luca is the Don of the Italian mafia, his name is feared by many due to him being heartless, cruel, ruthless and not sparing a soul from his wrath. He has the looks, the money and has every girl panting and dropping for him but what happens when a certain Amelia black piques his interest?
8.1
71 Chapters
Bad Liar
Bad Liar
"Because I should be the only one who looks at you like that," he murmured, his voice dropping low as he steps closer. Miles Carter is notorious around town for being a player. Miles and his best friend, Finn, have always been well-known for their wit, good looks and charming personality. Neither of them ever let a girl get under their skin, until Miles and Finn's twin sister, start seeing each other. After one fateful night of lies, leading to someone's death... Things have never been the same. Finn and Isobel are still recovering from what happened, a year and a half ago. Everything changes, when Miles arrives back in town, with one thing on his mind.
10
48 Chapters
Bad Nanny
Bad Nanny
I had taken leave from the sealed research institute where I'd been confined for six years, just so I could attend my daughter's kindergarten graduation. The moment I stepped through the gates, I froze. A woman holding a little boy by the hand was shoving my daughter, Amy, straight into the gutter. She slapped Amy across the face, then sneered for everyone to hear, spitting venom as she called my little girl a filthy wretch. Drenched in filthy water, Amy dropped to her knees before the woman, trembling in humiliation. Rage burned through me. I stormed forward and slapped the woman across the face. But instead of shame, she jabbed a finger at my nose and shouted, "Do you even know who I am? To offend me is to offend the entire Grant family!" Tears welled in Amy's eyes as she tugged at my sleeve, pleading in a choked voice, "Please leave… she's my dad's nanny. My dad will punish you if you hurt her." The woman planted herself in front of me, her arrogance towering. "The Grant family rules this city. You think you can run from us?" For a brief moment, I stood stunned, then calmly pulled out my phone and dialed my husband. "Your nanny says you run Bexley City. Well, I think that's about to change."
8 Chapters
BAD Boy
BAD Boy
One night of unbridled passion changed his life forever. Now years later he's back to claim his woman and take back everything that's his.BAD Boy is created by Jordan Silver, an eGlobal Creative Publishing Signed Author.
10
33 Chapters
Bedding Bad
Bedding Bad
Meghan Summers; Mean lean captain of the basketball team. She'll slam your ass in the lockers and tell you the painful truth without batting a lash Zayn Rodriguez; The badboy with presumed skeletons and the leather jacket, of course. These two were cliques apart until a stupid dare brought them together. When an arranged marriage threatens to make things more than they are, Meg and Zayn must see to it that things don't change.
10
40 Chapters
BAD MOON
BAD MOON
"Get your foot, out of my door!" I yelped as I tried heavily to shut the door on him. "Pet... No need to be shy, it's only me, besides it's not the first time I've seen you naked?" He grinned like he was enjoying toying with me. My temporary guardian easily pushed himself inside my bathroom making my heart pound. Who was I kidding, I was no use for his incredible power, nor was my I any match for his crazy fast speed. However, if I was out in the woods, I'd still have a chance to escape him, thanks to my powers. He locked the bathroom door once he was in. "I apologise Kavyaa, but I no longer can not let you go back with Mark." "What?! Are you insane? He's a cop! You can't legally do this!" He smirked sending a chill down my spine, and slowly started to make his way over to me. "I can do, whatever I want with you." -- Kavyaa is taken in by her cop cousin Ethan. Ethan is a werewolf, and he has been strictly told to keep his true identity a secret from her, since she's just going to be staying with him for a short while. However things start to get heated up with murders into town, and Kavyaa finds out about her guardian's canine secret. Will she be able to escape from him? Or will she end up being his next prey?
Not enough ratings
28 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Killed Dumbledore

4 Answers2025-02-06 04:54:11
Well, 'Harry Potter' has been my go-to series since I was a kid, and one thing I'll never forget is how shocked I was when I first read that it was Severus Snape who killed Dumbledore. J.K. Rowling had a way of playing with our perceptions, right? I remember feeling betrayed, thinking "How could Snape do that?" Yet later on, it's revealed how everything was part of Dumbledore's plan - a revelation that truly blew me away.

What Did Dumbledore Teach

4 Answers2025-01-16 00:42:41
A multi-talented teacher was Professor Dumbledore. He doesn't teach solely sorcery and wizardry however, he also imparts many useful life-lessons about courage love, etcetera in "Harry Potter. "Before he obtained his supreme position at Hogwarts in the J.K. Rowling novel Harry Potter City And The Incredible Hallows Maid to Philanthropists Everywhere, naturally enough it was characterized by transfiguration. However, it was also a matter of the will to win (against daunting odds). is his insistence on social justice feeling "closing ranks" or what, then? Moreover people love him because he makes this clear: love in wordless tenderness will accomplish more for you and return greater benefits than any amount of spells and ritual used upon oneself or projected outwards. It's safe to conclude that his teachings made an indelible impression on Harry and his friends.

When Did Dumbledore Die

3 Answers2025-01-31 16:26:32
In 'Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince', the shocking event occurs. Albus Dumbledore, the beloved headmaster of Hogwarts, meets his untimely end. It's a tragic moment that shakes the entire wizarding world.

What House Was Dumbledore In

5 Answers2025-02-05 20:25:49
Spotting a 'Harry Potter' fan, eh? Just pulling your leg. The answer to your query is, Albus Dumbledore; the wizard who makes white beards and half-moon spectacles seem so cool, was a member of the noble house of Gryffindor during his Hogwarts years!

What Happened To Ariana Dumbledore

3 Answers2025-01-15 06:21:25
As a matter of fact, Ariana Dumbledore was a key character in the backstory of Harry Potter despite only ever appearing occasionally within pages As a young witch, she was unable to control her magic and following a traumatic incident with some Muggle (non-magical) boys This inadvertently led her to cause an accident that killed her own mother. Such a tragic mischance left Ariana with guilt and fragmented feelings, unable to break free from her haunted past Her life closed only too soon. In a tragic three-way duel between Albus and Aberforth -her brother's, and one of the most powerful dark wizards out there, Gellert Grindelwald (whom we do not even know he was named by J.K Rowling) Ariana was slain.

When Did Grindelwald And Dumbledore Have Their Duel?

3 Answers2025-08-25 07:19:23
I still get a little thrill thinking about how the whole thing ties to real history — Dumbledore finally stopping Grindelwald in 1945. The basic fact, which you can trace back to 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows', is that their legendary duel took place in 1945, after years of Grindelwald’s rise to power and terror across the wizarding world. Grindelwald was captured and locked away in Nurmengard, and Dumbledore left that clash with the Elder Wand in his possession. It’s tidy, cinematic, and sort of mirrors the end-of-war atmosphere in the Muggle world at the same time, which always gives me goosebumps when I reread the books. I like to think about the human side: two brilliant, stubborn people who were once nearly inseparable ended up on opposite sides and faced each other like that. Their friendship back in 1899, the tragedy of Ariana’s death, and Grindelwald’s subsequent quest for domination all build to that single, devastating confrontation. If you’ve watched the 'Fantastic Beasts' films, the timeline fills in lots of earlier steps, but the definitive KO is that 1945 moment — Dumbledore’s victory and Grindelwald’s fall to Nurmengard. It’s one of those scenes that feels both mythic and heartbreakingly personal to me.

Where Were Grindelwald And Dumbledore During The 1940s?

3 Answers2025-08-25 11:44:14
It's one of those wizarding history tidbits I like to pull out when conversations drift toward messy alliances and regretful genius. In the 1940s the big, undeniable fact is that Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald came head-to-head in 1945 — the famous duel everyone points to. Grindelwald had already made a dramatic rise through the 1920s and 1930s, gathering followers and spreading his dangerous ideas across Europe; by the time the mid-'40s rolled around he was a jailed figure in the fortress-prison he’d built for himself, Nurmengard, and Dumbledore stopped him for good there. My mental picture of that decade always mixes the wizarding duel with real-world echoes: 1945 is also the end of the Muggle Second World War, and J.K. Rowling uses that overlap to underline how epic and consequential the clash was. After Dumbledore beat Grindelwald, Grindelwald remained locked in Nurmengard until Voldemort showed up decades later. As for Dumbledore’s day-to-day whereabouts in the 1940s, he was still very much tied to Hogwarts — teaching, guiding students, and quietly carrying the weight of past friendships and broken plans. Some sources suggest he wasn't yet headmaster during Tom Riddle’s school years, but he was certainly a major presence at Hogwarts long before Harry's time. If you like digging, check references in 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows' and interviews Rowling gave afterwards; and pair that with the backstory hinted at in the 'Fantastic Beasts' era to see how the pieces fit. Personally, every time I reread those sections I picture an exhausted old castle librarian watching two very different ideologies collide — and feeling oddly glad to be on the side of the books.

How Did Ariana Dumbledore Die

4 Answers2025-01-15 05:32:37
The death of Ariana Dumbledore was tragic enough, to make people wonder the reason it happened. Unfortunately, the poor girl Ariana, daughter of Albus Dumbledore and sister to his present successor Aberforth was mortally wounded after being caught in the crossfire between Albus, Gellert and Aberforth Grindelwald. Ariana was suspected to have had this curse laid upon her by one of them but there is still no real clue as to which man actually did serve up her quick departure into that unknown whether it was Albus' themo mage flame or someone else's could never be said with any certainty.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status