What Is The Earliest Source Of The Quote From Aristotle?

2025-08-28 13:21:32 103

4 Answers

Theo
Theo
2025-09-01 04:20:19
I still get a little thrill digging through old texts, and this one’s a classic: when people ask for the "earliest source" of a quote attributed to Aristotle, the first thing I do is try to pin down the exact wording. A lot of familiar lines are paraphrases or later compressions of something he actually argued. For example, the crisp modern line ‘Man is by nature a political animal’ comes directly from Aristotle’s 'Politics' (Book I) — that’s one of the cleaner cases where the phrasing is close to the original idea.

Other famous phrases aren’t so straightforward. The phrase people shorten to ‘the whole is greater than the sum of its parts’ is a modern paraphrase of discussions he has about wholes and parts in 'Metaphysics' (he interrogates how composite substances differ from mere aggregates). And the oft-quoted ‘We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit’ is actually a 20th-century paraphrase (famously by Will Durant) of material in 'Nicomachean Ethics' (Book II) about virtue arising from habituation.

So my quick rule: find the precise words you saw, then check Aristotle’s core works — 'Nicomachean Ethics', 'Politics', 'Metaphysics', 'Rhetoric' — using Bekker numbers or a reliable translation (Loeb, Oxford, or Perseus) to see whether it’s verbatim, a paraphrase, or a later summary. If you give me the exact phrasing, I’ll chase the earliest citation for that line specifically.
Quinn
Quinn
2025-09-01 09:21:53
I’ve chased odd quotations for fun more times than I’ll admit at 2 a.m., and there’s a sweet pattern: a modern-sounding aphorism gets attached to Aristotle, and then you either find the same sense in an Arisotle text or you don’t. When you want the earliest source, start with a small triage in your head: is it ethical, political, or metaphysical? If ethical, my nose points to 'Nicomachean Ethics' (Book II has the classic stuff on habit and virtue). If political/social, try 'Politics' (that’s where he famously calls humans political animals). If it’s about unity, parts, or substance, 'Metaphysics' is the place.

A pet peeve: a lot of internet quotes like ‘We are what we repeatedly do’ are not him verbatim — that one is Will Durant’s neat compression of Aristotle’s sense. So you often need to get to a scholarly edition (I like Loeb for facing Greek/English, or Oxford for commentary) and look up Bekker numbers to be precise. Another fun route is searching the Perseus Project for Greek keywords; it often reveals the original sentence and context. If you drop the exact quote here, I’ll dig through and tell you the earliest textual source I can find — or show you why it’s a later paraphrase.
Sophia
Sophia
2025-09-01 22:56:53
I often tell friends that hunting the earliest source feels a bit like detective work. If you don’t have the exact wording, check the usual suspects: 'Nicomachean Ethics' for moral maxims, 'Politics' for social claims (like humans being political animals), and 'Metaphysics' for anything about whole vs part. Many popular one-liners are paraphrases — for example, the memorable ‘we are what we repeatedly do’ is a twentieth-century summary of Aristotle’s point about habit in 'Nicomachean Ethics', not his literal sentence.

If you need a precise citation, give me the quote and I’ll look it up in a critical edition or a reliable translation (I use Bekker pagination to be precise). Otherwise, a quick check in 'Politics' or 'Metaphysics' usually reveals whether Aristotle actually wrote the line or if it’s a later simplification.
Ronald
Ronald
2025-09-03 07:00:54
I like to keep things practical: if you’ve seen a short, catchy quote credited to Aristotle, chances are it’s one of three things — a direct line from one of his works, a paraphrase of a passage, or a later invention that got slapped onto his name.

For direct lines, check 'Politics' for political/ethical phrasing (for instance, the idea that humans are social/political animals is from there), and 'Nicomachean Ethics' for anything about virtue, habit, and character. For metaphysical-sounding maxims about parts and wholes, look in 'Metaphysics' where he analyzes substance and composition. If you want the absolute earliest manuscript witness, it gets trickier: Aristotle’s Greek texts survive in medieval manuscripts (many copied in Byzantium), and the Latin and Arabic translations used by medieval scholars brought his ideas into Western Europe earlier. My usual workflow is to search a reliable edition (Bekker pagination or Loeb) or use the Perseus Digital Library and then trace any later paraphrase (like Will Durant’s popularized lines) back to the original chapter in Aristotle.

If you tell me the exact wording you saw, I’ll try to locate the earliest primary reference for that specific phrasing.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Taming Architect Aristotle (English  Version)
Taming Architect Aristotle (English Version)
Robin Serrano Mercader is a kind, caring and gorgeous scholar from Marinduque. Her life is going nowhere until she meets Aristotle Lecaroz, an exchange architect student from Harvard, a man with a passion. Robin fall in love with Aristotle the moment her eyes darted to his almond eyes. However, she's destined to marry Ricci Reyes. Robin takes an instant liking to Aristotle not until she learnt his a Lecaroz. However, when everything went well between Aristotle and Robin, the fued between Lecaroz and Mercader family arise. Robin begins to notices that Aristotle is actually rather generous at heart. But, the pressures of Aristotle's family as a heir leave him blind to Robin's affections and Ricci Reyes, her fiancee surface, it creates a chaos in their fresh bond. Finally, when the three rivalry family, Mercader, Lecaroz and Reyes threatens to come between them, Robin has to act fast. But will they ever find the deep love that they deserve? "Our love was more chaotic than war, yet the most calming thing." What path would you choose? The upright journey where your heart is safe or dangerous path ahead where your heart is at risk. Choose you fighter! Aristotle or Ricci?
10
10 Chapters
Alpha Killian
Alpha Killian
Seen by few living, Alpha Killian Desmond is whispered about throughout the world, his cruel reputation proven countless times. The ferocity of this man and his pack have been the source of many legends and nightmares. Most who have met him, have died at his hands. Claire Miller has lived a simple life as the daughter of the Beta in her pack. As the Moon Ball approaches, and every pack in the United States gather to meet, the sense of dread building inside of her grows.What will happen when Claire is thrown into the arms of the most ferocious and cruel Alpha known to man? Will she prove to be the exception to his malicious ways? Or will she suffer the same fate as countless others.
9.8
44 Chapters
Trapped Between Two Alphas
Trapped Between Two Alphas
"What's that?" I whispered to myself as I felt something moved very fast behind me. It was very dark at night and a dim-lighted lamp was the only source of light I had to see my way home! "Oh my God!! What could that be?" I whispered to myself again as it moved again, this time, I felt it getting closer to me. Suddenly, I heard a soft whisper close to my left ear "she's back and will spare no one". I became more terrified and decided to run. As I was running, I felt that something was running after me, something I couldn't see. Suddenly, my foot hit a stone on the ground and I fell down with a loud thud, shattering the only source of light I had to pieces! And as I was trying slowly to get back to my feet, I was startled by what I perceived in my nostrils. It was as if what was chasing me was right before my face but yet, I couldn't see it, I could only perceive the smell of warm human blood!
7.5
762 Chapters
Mated To The Beastly Alpha
Mated To The Beastly Alpha
WARNING: WARNING: This book contains violence, explicit words, and sex. Some words that might not be liked by others. Reader's discretion is advised. Liam Hallows was a beast that everyone feared, ruthless, and filled with anger. He was born to torment his oppressors and hates the word mate or love. His ideal type is a one-night stand, fvcks and never to be heard of again. What happens when Liam had a one-night stand with a girl who he accidentally imprinted on, a mistake he dreads his entire life? Nicole Mallory, the perfect luna who was loved and adored by all except her mate. She was forced to watch her mate have s3x with different omegas as a punishment for being given to him as a source to pay her parent's debts. Too much pain and agony had her drinking in the bar and ending up in bed with a total stranger who wanted her but he was the same, exactly like his mate. Would Liam be able to win the heart of the girl he imprinted on or would she be able to tame the beast that is ready to devour her?
9
360 Chapters
His Warm-Blooded Mate
His Warm-Blooded Mate
Julian Alnwick had his life stripped away from him at a young age. Emotions? He had none of those. At least not until he met his mentors, Dimitri and Ambrosia (The King and Queen of his kind). Due to certain unfortunate events and the little fact that he was reborn with the mark of the next King to take the throne, he now has more responsibilities than he had before — albeit controlling his thirst. A Queen to stand by him? That was something he thought of but never pictured himself having. his intellect might have surpassed many but his boyish looks would not be appealing enough to attract someone. So, what happens when he receives a little help from an unlikely source? A little help known as a mate bond, tying him to a werewolf. A Vampire and Werewolf pairing, what could possibly go wrong? (FOUTH BOOK OF THE MATE SERIES! _________________________________ Book will not make sense if you don't read BOOK ONE: P.S. You're my mate, BOOK TWO: She's my mate, BOOK THREE: I'm his mate.
9.8
43 Chapters
Mafia Lord's Innocent Bride
Mafia Lord's Innocent Bride
Nathan Williams is dangerous. He can be your worst nightmare if you get on his bad list. He is a vicious, cruel, ruthless, merciless, and heartless killer. He is New York most dangerous mafia lord in the disguise of the most successful CEO.He is known as Scorpio in the underworld because of his obsession with the deadly animal.Sophia James was leading a simple vanilla life when all of sudden her world turns upside down. She is an innocent, sweet and pure soul but that’s what attracts the darkness the most. She is the source of light to brighten up his dark world and he has no intention of letting her go if it means to blackmail her to last extents.....
9.2
26 Chapters

Related Questions

How Does The Quote From Aristotle Explain Friendship?

4 Answers2025-08-28 15:57:34
Whenever I think about Aristotle’s line that friendship can be seen as ‘a single soul dwelling in two bodies,’ I get this warm, slightly dramatic image of two people who reflect each other’s best self. For Aristotle, though, that poetic phrasing wasn’t just fluff — it points to a deeper idea: the highest form of friendship is built around virtue. Two people who genuinely wish the good for one another help each other become better, and their relationship becomes an extension of their characters. In practical terms he divides friendships into three kinds: those of utility (you benefit each other), those of pleasure (you enjoy each other’s company), and those of the good (you love the other for who they are). The ‘single soul’ bit belongs to the last group — rare, mutual, and lasting. I’ve seen this in my own life: a few friendships that survive messy years because both people care about the other’s moral growth, not just hangouts or favors. It feels less transactional and more like two people walking the same path, nudging each other forward. That’s Aristotle’s friendship in a nutshell — aspirational, demanding, and deeply rewarding.

What Does The Quote From Aristotle On Happiness Mean?

4 Answers2025-08-28 00:18:59
There’s a famous line from Aristotle that goes something like, 'Happiness is the meaning and the purpose of life, the whole aim and end of human existence.' To me that doesn’t mean he’s promising constant joy or a life of nonstop pleasure. I read this over coffee one rainy afternoon and it clicked: Aristotle’s 'happiness' — eudaimonia — is closer to flourishing, doing well as a human, living in accordance with your best capacities over a lifetime. When I break it down, I think of three parts: function, excellence, and action. Aristotle asks, what is the function of a human? He decides it’s rational activity. So happiness is performing that function well — exercising reason, cultivating virtues like courage and temperance, and making them habits. It’s not a single moment but an active way of living, shaped by choices and practice. Practically, I take it as an invitation to build character through everyday acts: be honest when it’s hard, practice patience, invest in friendships. Those habits compound. It’s comforting and challenging at once, and it makes life feel purposeful rather than just a series of chasing feelings.

Why Is The Quote From Aristotle On Education Famous?

4 Answers2025-08-28 16:52:42
There’s a line from Aristotle that gets quoted a lot: 'Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all.' For me, its fame comes from that neat little tension it captures — it’s short, memorable, and refuses to let education be only about test scores or rote facts. I use it as a mental bookmark when I think about classrooms, online communities, or the way adults shape younger people: it reminds me that ethics, empathy, and character are part of learning, not extras. I’ve seen this idea pop up everywhere from commencement speeches to teacher-training handbooks. It fits modern conversations about emotional intelligence, social responsibility, and civic formation, so people across centuries and cultures keep finding it useful. On a personal level, I watch students who learn the mechanics of something but miss the empathy piece—and that quote keeps pushing me to balance both sides every time I teach a workshop or cheer on a kid who finally understands why their work matters to others.

Can You Summarize The Quote From Aristotle About Rhetoric?

4 Answers2025-08-28 15:43:33
Whenever Aristotle's line about rhetoric pops into my head, I picture someone leaning over a crowded agora, noticing what will move a crowd and why. To me, his core claim is simple and brilliant: rhetoric is the practical skill of spotting the available means of persuasion in any situation. That means not just arguing with logic, but tuning into character and feeling—what he later framed as ethos, pathos, and logos. I often think about how this plays out in everyday life. Ethos is about credibility—how your voice, reputation, or demeanor makes people trust you. Pathos is the emotional hook that makes an idea land, and logos is the structure and evidence that hold it together. Aristotle also nudges us toward responsibility: rhetoric can be used well or badly depending on the speaker’s aims. So his quote isn't just a textbook line; it's a reminder that persuasion is a craft you can practice, and that practicing it wisely matters. Next time I scroll through a viral post or listen to a debate, I try to spot which of those 'available means' the speaker is using, and whether they're serving something genuine or just the moment.

How Do Modern Philosophers Interpret The Quote From Aristotle?

4 Answers2025-08-28 20:21:46
I've always loved how a single line from Aristotle can turn into a dozen modern conversations. When people quote him—whether it's 'the whole is more than the sum of its parts', 'man is by nature a political animal', or bits from 'Nicomachean Ethics' about virtue and happiness—contemporary philosophers split into camps depending on what they care about. Analytic metaphysicians tend to read the metaphysical lines as proto-claims about emergence: they treat Aristotle as gesturing toward systems in which novel properties arise that can't be reduced straightforwardly to microphysics. That idea shows up in philosophy of mind and in debates about consciousness. Virtue ethicists, led by voices like Alasdair MacIntyre, Philippa Foot, and Martha Nussbaum, treat Aristotle's ethical sayings as a living resource. They reinterpret 'eudaimonia' not as a mystical soul-bliss but as human flourishing—embedded in institutions, relationships, and practical wisdom (phronesis). Political philosophers, meanwhile, argue over the political-animal claim: is Aristotle describing an inescapable human sociality or prescribing a particular polis-shaped life? Feminist and postcolonial thinkers read his texts critically, pointing out exclusions and then salvaging useful tools for thinking about care, community, and virtue. All of this means modern readings are plural and pragmatic: Aristotle is a touchstone, not a rulebook. I love sitting down with a dog-eared translation and imagining how a line written centuries ago gets reframed in neuroscience labs, community ethics workshops, or debates about institutions today.

Where Can I Find The Original Quote From Aristotle Online?

4 Answers2025-08-28 07:35:44
I get a little giddy whenever someone asks where to find an original Aristotle quote online — it’s like treasure-hunting in old books. First thing I do is pin down which quote and whether it’s even Aristotle’s. Lots of pithy lines floating around social media are paraphrases or misattributions. If you have some words in Greek, that’s gold: search the Greek phrase on the Perseus Digital Library to find the passage in the original language and a facing English translation. Perseus will also give you the Bekker number (the standard reference system for Aristotle), which is essential for tracking the exact place in works like 'Nicomachean Ethics' or 'Metaphysics'. Once I have a Bekker citation (it looks like 1103a1, for example), I cross-check with a parallel Loeb edition if I can — those small green/grey volumes are brilliant because they put Greek and English side-by-side. If I don’t have library access, I’ll hunt on Wikisource, Internet Classics Archive (for some works), Google Books, or Archive.org for older translations. For rigorous verification I’ll look up the critical editions (Oxford Classical Texts) or consult JSTOR articles that quote the passage. The final step is noting the translator and edition when you cite it, because translations vary wildly and context matters — sometimes a famous line is simply an over-friendly paraphrase of a longer argument. Happy digging; the way a passage reads in Greek versus a modern translation can actually change how you feel about Aristotle’s point, and I love that little revelation.

Which Quote From Aristotle Defines Tragedy In Drama?

4 Answers2025-08-28 12:34:33
Whenever I circle back to classical drama, one line from Aristotle keeps replaying in my head: 'Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude; in language embellished with each kind of artistic ornament; in the form of action, not of narrative; through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation (katharsis) of these emotions.' Reading that in 'Poetics' felt like unlocking a cheat code for why some plays make you ache. Aristotle isn’t giving a checklist so much as he’s sketching an experience: a whole, weighty story told through deeds that moves us to pity and terror, and—crucially—leaves us cleansed somehow. That word ‘purgation’ (often translated as catharsis) has fueled centuries of debate, but in everyday terms I take it as the emotional release after being fully immersed. If I think of 'Oedipus Rex' or 'Hamlet', they match Aristotle’s blueprint: grand stakes, moral complexity, action-driven plots, and that mix of dread and sympathy that feels oddly therapeutic. It’s one of those quotes that makes me want to rewatch the classics and notice how modern tragedies echo that same structure.

Which Quote From Aristotle Influenced Political Theory Most?

4 Answers2025-08-28 15:10:10
Whenever I get pulled into a late-night debate about where politics comes from, the line that I pull out most often is Aristotle's famous claim: "Man is by nature a political animal." It's from 'Politics' (Book I), and to me it reads like a thesis statement for everything that follows in Western political thought. Aristotle wasn't just noting people gather in cities—he argued our very flourishing depends on political life and civic relationships. That idea changed the game because it framed the state as natural and teleological: communities exist not merely for survival or transaction but to aim at the good life. From there, thinkers argued about rights, duties, civic virtue, and how much the state should shape character. It also left a shadow—Aristotle used the same framework to justify problematic positions like natural slavery, so his influence is double-edged. I find it both inspiring and irritating: inspiring because it elevates civic life, irritating in how easy it becomes to naturalize hierarchies. Whenever I read modern debates about community versus individual liberty, I spot Aristotle's fingerprints, and that keeps me flipping pages and arguing with friends late into the night.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status