Is 'Once Upon A Broken Heart' A Sequel To 'Caraval'?

2025-05-29 21:58:22 154

4 answers

Uma
Uma
2025-05-30 11:59:15
'Once Upon a Broken Heart' isn't a direct sequel to 'Caraval', but it dances in the same enchanting universe. Stephanie Garber crafted it as a spin-off, focusing on Evangeline Fox—a fresh protagonist—while weaving subtle threads from the 'Caraval' trilogy. You’ll spot familiar faces like Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, whose charm and chaos bridge both stories. The tone shifts too: 'Caraval' revels in magical games, while 'Broken Heart' leans into fairy-tale whimsy and darker romance. It’s a standalone adventure, but reading 'Caraval' first unlocks richer layers, like understanding Jacks’ tragic allure or the rules of this world’s magic.

That said, newcomers won’t feel lost. Garber’s prose sparkles with new mysteries—curses, wish-bringing vampires, and clocks that tick toward fate. The stakes feel more personal here, less about spectacle, more about heartbreak and hope. If 'Caraval' was a circus of illusions, 'Broken Heart' is a midnight ballad—same composer, different melody.
Mila
Mila
2025-05-30 06:39:10
As someone who binge-read both, I’d call 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' a spiritual successor rather than a sequel. It’s set after 'Caraval', with nods to its events, but Evangeline’s quest for love and truth stands on its own. Jacks steals the spotlight again, his backstory deepening like vintage wine. The magic system expands too—think cursed apples and blood vows instead of ticket-based games. Garber’s style feels more polished here, blending Gothic romance with her signature whimsy. Fans of 'Caraval' will geek out over Easter eggs, but the emotional core is new: less sisterly bonds, more star-crossed yearning. It’s like comparing a masquerade ball to a moonlit hunt—same world, different thrills.
David
David
2025-06-02 08:41:25
Technically no, but emotionally yes? 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' orbits the 'Caraval' universe like a glittering satellite. It’s a fresh story with new leads, yet Jacks—the morally gray fan favorite—ties both together. Imagine stepping into a sequel’s vibe without the baggage: Evangeline’s journey mirrors Scarlett’s growth but with more knives-and-lace drama. The magic feels grander, too—bartering with Fate, kissing statues to life. Garber’s knack for sensory overload (peach-scented curses, anyone?) hits harder here. Read 'Caraval' for the games; read this for the ache.
Sawyer
Sawyer
2025-05-30 09:48:35
'Once Upon a Broken Heart' is its own tale, though Jacks from 'Caraval' plays a key role. The setting’s similar—whimsical, perilous—but the plot’s independent. Evangeline’s story dives into prophecies and desperate bargains, distinct from Scarlett’s game-centric arc. Garber’s worldbuilding expands with new lore, like vampire-like immortals and enchanted artifacts. Familiarity with 'Caraval' adds depth, but it’s optional. Think of it as a parallel door in the same fantastical hotel.

Related Books

Broken Heart
Broken Heart
Tak banyak hal yang dapat aku ceritakan. Tentang hidupku masih saja sama, sama-sama berantakan dan tak terkendali. Kumatikan diriku, hatiku bahkan hidupku setelah semua hal buruk menimpaku. Ku tutup diriku, menjadi lelaki tak berguna dan tak bermaya.
10
5 Chapters
BROKEN HEART
BROKEN HEART
Saat amarah menguasai diri seseorang apapun akan dilakukannya untuk melampiaskan kemarahanya seperti Hilman Junanta yang membunuh Karina dengan tangannya sendiri. Kejadian itu berdampak buruk pada psikologis Lilian Junanta anak kedua dan putri kesayangan pasangan Hilman Junanta dan Karina. Menyaksikan papa dan mama bertengkar setiap hari sudah membuat Lili, nama panggilannya. Muak! Dan lebih memilih mengurung diri dikamar sepulang sekolah. Apalagi melihat papa membunuh mama dengan kedua tangannya. Setelah insiden pembunuhan itu berdampak buruk terhadap lingkungan dan kehidupan yang dijalani Lili. Disekolahpun. Kini. Lili diasingkan dianggap sebagai anak seorang pembunuh. Teman-temannya serentak mundur dari list pertemanan. Lili yang sifatnya ceria secara perlahan menjadi pribadi yang tertutup. Begitu juga dengan cinta pertamanya Aliando Jacob. Memilih menjauh darinya. Dengan alasan yang sama yaitu karena dirinya anak seorang pembunuh. Lagi-lagi ia ditinggalkan dengan alasan anak seorang pembunuh Aliando Jocob adalah orang pertama dan terakhir yang ia harapkan tinggal disisinya namun ia juga kehilangan harapannya tersebut. Karena Alinado Jacob mundur teratur dari hidupnya. Tidak ada lagi alasan untuk hidup bukan?
Belum ada penilaian
6 Chapters
Broken
Broken
Yandi anak kedua dari tiga bersaudara, dari keluarga yang cukup berada. Ia adalah anak yang selalu berlangganan masuk ke ruang kepala sekolah. Meskipun kedua orang tuanya mengetahui hal itu, namun mereka lebih mementingkan pekerjaan mereka. Yandi juga menjadi siswa yang kurang di sukai, karena sikapnya yang selalu saja membuat teman-temannya kesal. Namun semua sikapnya itu hanyalah pelampiasan atas luka yang ia rasakan. Luka yang terus bersamanya tanpa diobati sekalipun. Luka yang dialaminya sama seperti kerusakan yang sulit diperbaiki, karena ia tak pernah mendapat pengobatan hingga parah. Jika sudah parah pasti sulit untuk sembuh. Begitu pun sesuatu yang sudah rusak memang dapat di perbaiki. Namun, kerusakan itu tetap ada. Kerusakan itu tak akan menghilang. Lalu bagaimana cara memperbaiki kerusakan itu agar dapat kembali sempurna?
10
152 Chapters
Once Again
Once Again
Berawal dari perjanjian keluarga di masa lalu, mengharuskan Kyle Al Jerome Willian dan Clarissa Bella Buczer untuk menjalin sebuah hubungan yang tidak pernah didasari oleh cinta. Al yang harus meninggalkan kekasihnya, sedangkan Cla yang harus kehilangan impiannya. Kehidupan pernikahan yang tidak pernah didasari oleh cinta, keromantisan yang ia lihat pada kedua orangtuanya tidak pernah Cla temui dalam pernikahannya bersama Al, pun sebaliknya. Justru yang mereka temui hanyalah masalah dan masalah.
Belum ada penilaian
22 Chapters
BROKEN
BROKEN
Erhan adalah sebuah keluarga yang telah rusak oleh sebuah pengkhianatan. Nick Erhan terpaksa harus menjalani waktu panjangnya di rumah sakit jiwa yang menyedihkan. Padahal, ia tidak gila seperti asumsi para polisi. Ia meninggalkan Jessyca Amora untuk mengurus sendiri dua buah hati mereka dengan cara yang aneh. Jess menderita gangguan jiwa yang tidak diketahui oleh siapa pun. Didikan yang aneh membuat Dev Sasaka dan Elfara selaku anak-anaknya hidup dalam kesalahpahaman hingga keduanya memiliki jalan hidup yang tragis. Apa yang sebenarnya terjadi kepada keluarga Erhan sehingga pasutri itu hidup dalam tempat yang seolah tertukar dan seperti apakah hidup Dev dan Elfara?
10
89 Chapters
Delta yang Terpilih (She-wolf Sequel)
Delta yang Terpilih (She-wolf Sequel)
Lanjutan she-wolf. Davian hidup terkucilkan, bersama sang paman yang mengaku sebagai ayahnya. Tanpa seorang ibu, dan keterbatasan fisik membuatnya terkucilkan di pack. Hingga sang paman memilih untuk pergi, meninggalkan pack yang menjadi tempat Davian tumbuh dan berlindung. Tak diduga, di perjalanan sang paman menemukan pasangannya, membuat Davian terlupakan. Kemudian, Davian memilih pergi. Namun, tanpa disangka dia malah bertemu dengan seorang gadis vampir yang cantik. Dari gadis itu, Davian mengetahui banyak hal. Daei alasan mengapa dirinya tak pernah bertemu dengan ibunya, hingga mengapa dia haeus bersembunyi. Dan ternyata, tak lama kemudian semua hal terkuak. Perang tak dapat dihindari, begitulah jalan takdir. Mampukah Davian bertahan, dan apa yang telah menantinya di ujung jalan?
10
156 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is The Curse In 'Once Upon A Broken Heart'?

4 answers2025-05-29 19:39:35
In 'Once Upon a Broken Heart', the curse is a hauntingly poetic twist of fate wrapped in love and despair. The protagonist, Evangeline, unknowingly binds herself to the bewitching Prince of Hearts, whose kisses are both a blessing and a curse. Each one steals a piece of her destiny, leaving her future frayed and uncertain. The deeper she falls for him, the more her life unravels—memories blur, choices vanish, and time itself becomes a tangled web. The curse isn’t just supernatural; it’s emotional. It mirrors the fragility of trust and the danger of giving your heart to someone who might shatter it. The Prince’s magic is seductive, laced with roses and riddles, but its price is steep. Evangeline’s journey becomes a race against time to reclaim what’s lost before the last kiss erases her entirely. The novel weaves this curse into themes of agency and sacrifice, making it as poignant as it is perilous.

How Does 'Once Upon A Broken Heart' End?

4 answers2025-05-29 15:24:05
The finale of 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' is a whirlwind of bittersweet revelations and poetic justice. Evangeline Fox, after enduring heartbreak and magical bargains with the Prince of Hearts, finally uncovers the truth about his cursed existence. Their love story crescendos with a sacrifice—her tear-stained kiss breaks his centuries-old curse, freeing him but at a cost. The ending teeters between triumph and melancholy, as Evangeline gains independence yet mourns what could’ve been. The epilogue hints at new beginnings, with Evangeline opening her own curiosity shop, surrounded by enchanted artifacts and whispered rumors of the Prince’s occasional visits. The last pages linger on themes of self-discovery and the price of wishes, leaving readers torn between closure and longing for a sequel.

Is Once Upon A Broken Heart Spicy

1 answers2024-12-31 13:39:58
Once Upon a Broken Heart “Spicy" if you say this means an unexpected plot twist or a touch of mystery then indeed 's you are right. And the novel is indeed deliciously spicy. The novel is packed with fascinating characters. There are many who make their home in the City of the Dead although they are far from simple– their stories weave together like threads, making you turn page after page. This love story has none of the standard fairy-tale romance flavor to. Rather, it flickers into life in slow motion, gaining intensity with every turn of the plot. From yearning glances to playfully mocking words, it offers readers several passages that will set their hearts aflutter 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' is wrapped in beautiful and extravagant descriptions of mystical places, including a storyline filled with miserable experiences, hope and an ever enduring love. It really serves up the spice However, if by 'spicy' you mean racy or graphic scenes, then this novel is closer to tender and sweet--for it sketches a delicate picture of agonized, complicated love So, it is spicy in the unique way how storytelling develops. But likewise, it is sweeter-through its gentle and soft exploration of love.

Who Does Evangeline End Up With In 'Once Upon A Broken Heart'?

4 answers2025-05-29 14:16:09
Evangeline’s journey in 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' is a rollercoaster of emotions and betrayals, but by the end, she finds herself tangled in the enigmatic arms of Jacks, the Prince of Hearts. Their relationship is anything but simple—Jacks is a paradox, charming yet dangerous, with a history of breaking hearts. Yet, there’s an undeniable chemistry between them, a push-and-pull dynamic that keeps readers hooked. What makes their pairing fascinating is how Evangeline’s innocence clashes with Jacks’ cynicism. She believes in love’s power, while he’s cursed to destroy it. The book hints at a deeper connection, suggesting Jacks might be her destined match despite his flaws. Their ending isn’t neatly wrapped; it’s bittersweet, leaving room for hope and heartbreak in equal measure. It’s a classic case of ‘right person, wrong time,’ with a fantasy twist that leaves fans desperate for the next installment.

Will There Be A Movie Adaptation Of 'Once Upon A Broken Heart'?

4 answers2025-05-29 00:29:42
Rumors about a 'Once Upon a Broken Heart' movie adaptation have been swirling since the book's popularity exploded. The author dropped vague hints during a livestream, saying discussions were 'ongoing' but nothing concrete. Hollywood’s current obsession with fantasy romances—think 'Twilight' meets 'A Curse So Dark and Lonely'—makes it a prime candidate. The book’s lush visuals, from enchanted roses to cursed ballrooms, practically beg for a cinematic treatment. However, adaptations take years. The rights might’ve been optioned already, but scripts, casting, and production delays could push a release to 2026 or later. Fans should temper expectations; even 'Shadow and Bone' took a decade to hit screens. If it happens, I hope they capture the story’s whimsical cruelty—the way love and betrayal twist together like thorned vines.

How Does Jacks Manipulate Evangeline In 'Once Upon A Broken Heart'?

4 answers2025-05-29 14:50:48
In 'Once Upon a Broken Heart', Jacks is a master of emotional manipulation, weaving a complex web around Evangeline. He exploits her longing for love and her belief in fairy tales, subtly positioning himself as both savior and tempter. His words are laced with just enough truth to feel genuine, yet they always serve his hidden agenda. He plays on her vulnerability, offering glimpses of affection before withdrawing, keeping her emotionally off-balance. Jacks also uses Evangeline’s curiosity against her, dangling mysteries like bait. He knows she can’t resist uncovering secrets, so he crafts scenarios where she’s compelled to seek him out. His manipulations aren’t just about control—they’re a twisted game, one where he revels in her growing dependence. The tragedy lies in how Evangeline, despite her intelligence, becomes entangled in his schemes, blurring the line between choice and coercion.

How To Mend A Broken Heart

2 answers2025-02-14 19:27:03
Healing a broken heart is like working through a difficult quest in an RPG. It's tough, and you'll encounter numerous challenges, but there's always hope at the end. In 'The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt', Geralt learns that sometimes letting go is the bravest thing you can do. Similarly, it's important to allow yourself to grieve, understand it’s okay to hurt, and give yourself some time. Surround yourself with people who support you like in 'Final Fantasy XV', where Noctis leans on his friends when he’s feeling down. And lastly, find a healthy outlet for your feelings—whether that’s channeling your energy into a powerful 'Super Smash Bros. Ultimate' match or diving into an immersive novel like 'The Heart's Invisible Furies'. Have your own adventure, just like in 'RPG', to tear yourself away from the pain.

When Your Child'S Heart Is Broken Quotes

4 answers2025-03-20 20:58:59
Dealing with a child's heartbreak is tough. I really like the quote, 'Sometimes it’s the smallest things that take up the most room in your heart.' It's a gentle reminder that feelings, even painful ones, are valid and important. Sharing this with my little one gives them space to heal. Another great one is, 'Your heart is free, have the courage to follow it.' It encourages them to embrace vulnerability. These can be wonderful for encouraging resilience and love again, despite the hurt.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status