How Does 'When We Believed In Mermaids' Explore Family Secrets?

2025-06-26 12:07:05 57

3 answers

Noah
Noah
2025-06-28 20:29:51
The novel 'When We Believed in Mermaids' digs deep into the emotional wreckage left by family secrets. It follows two sisters, Josie and Kit, torn apart by lies and tragedy. Josie fakes her death, leaving Kit to grapple with grief until she spots her sister on TV years later. The story unravels through alternating timelines, showing how childhood trauma shaped their bond. Their parents' hidden affairs and neglect festered into generational wounds, forcing Josie to reinvent herself entirely. The ocean becomes a metaphor for those buried truths—endless, unpredictable, and capable of both nurturing and destruction. What hits hardest is how Kit's search for answers forces Josie to confront the past she fled, proving some secrets can't stay submerged forever.
Leah
Leah
2025-06-27 04:43:19
'When We Believed in Mermaids' handles family secrets like a surgeon peeling back layers of scar tissue. The Bianci sisters' childhood seems idyllic—beachfront home, free-spirited parents—until you notice the cracks. Their mother's alcoholism and father's infidelity are downplayed as 'eccentricities,' but the girls absorb the damage. Josie develops self-destructive tendencies, while Kit becomes hypervigilant. The novel's brilliance lies in juxtaposing their adult lives against flashbacks of pivotal moments—like when Josie took the blame for Kit's mistake, foreshadowing her later sacrifice.

The secrecy isn't just about hiding ugliness; it's performative. Their parents curate a bohemian facade, making the girls complicit in pretending everything's fine. This shapes Josie's decision to stage her death; she's replicating the family habit of erasing problems rather than facing them. The Auckland earthquake serves as a literal and metaphorical rupture, exposing buried truths. When Kit tracks Josie down, their reunion isn't warm—it's messy, raw, and steeped in decades of unspoken accusations. The book argues that some secrets are prisons, and the only escape is tearing down the walls.

What sets this apart from other family dramas is its refusal to tidy up the aftermath. Josie's new identity as Mari isn't a clean slate; it's a desperate attempt to outswim her past. The mermaid mythos woven throughout symbolizes how family legends distort over time—what was once a childhood game becomes a lifeline for Josie, then a haunting reminder of what she lost. The ocean, ever-present, mirrors the secrets: vast, shifting, and impossible to fully navigate.
Zachary
Zachary
2025-06-30 14:07:26
This book wrecked me in the best way. It's not just about a sister who faked her death—it's about how families collectively rewrite history to survive. Kit and Josie grew up believing their parents' chaotic love was normal, only to realize later how much it cost them. The secrets here aren't dramatic reveals; they're quiet erosions. Like when Josie covers for their mom's drunkenness by calling her 'sleepy,' or how their dad's 'business trips' always coincided with new 'aunts' visiting. The sisters develop their own secret language, mermaid lore, to cope, which makes Josie's disappearance even crueler—she took their shared mythology with her.

Barbara O'Neal doesn't romanticize reconciliation. When Kit finds Josie living as Mari in New Zealand, their confrontation isn't cathartic—it's brutal. Josie's new life was built on lies too, proving the cycle never broke. The most poignant detail? Josie keeps a hidden box of childhood treasures, clinging to fragments of the sister she abandoned. The mermaid motif resurfaces here; just as sailors mistook manatees for sirens, the sisters misremember each other. Their childhood wasn't as golden as Kit recalls, nor as wretched as Josie pretends. The truth, like the ocean, is too vast for simple narratives.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Family secrets
Family secrets
A jong girl named Violet Hope Rossi was taken away from her parents and older brothers at a young age she doesn't remember them but they remember her and missed her. What happens when she meets her family?? Will they find out how she is?? Will she find out what their secrets are or will she reveal her truth and open up to them?? Will she ever get to meet her mother or is her mother really gone?? Find out in Family secrets Started~ 30 September 2021 Ended~ 06 December 2021
Not enough ratings
72 Chapters
Family Secrets (Book 2 The Silver Dragon Series
Family Secrets (Book 2 The Silver Dragon Series
****PLEASE Read Book 1 The Silver Dragon to understand the background of this story. You won't find this interesting or understand what's going on if you don't******** Here you will find books 2 and 3 of the Silver Dragon Series. Book 2 Family Secrets Book 3 Revenge Our story continues following the journey of Davina Ortiz, now Brooks, and Derek Brooks. Malayah has been kidnapped. Enzo is controlling her with the help of the rogues and the necklace. Malayah struggles to fight back as he continues to use her to kill everyone he captures. It’s a race against time as Derek and Davina are recruiting as many allies as possible to save their daughter, including a sister she didn’t know she had. Davina learns deeper secrets regarding her family as she prepares to go head to head with the master mind behind it all to get her daughter back. Can Malayah be saved before it’s too late? Will Davina be to handle the revealed secrets of how her parents died and who killed them? Keep an eye out for books 4-6 of the Silver Dragon Series!
10
176 Chapters
The Nordic Wolves - A Mermaids Tail
The Nordic Wolves - A Mermaids Tail
Chloe is a scientist with a secret, she is a mermaid...without a mermaid, or so she thinks. She is a hybrid, half human and half mermaid whose father is disgusted and left her mother when he found out she was pregnant. With the help of her best friend Kari, who finds out she is Royalty in the Werewolf Kingdom, she finds herself fitting in with the Werewolves when the King of the Sea finds her. He is disgusted with her father for abandoning her and pulls her into their world along with her werewolf mate but she finds out that she is special and she is hunted for her mermaids scales
2
13 Chapters
SECRETS
SECRETS
Being chased out of Ohio, Kahlan is forced to start a new life in Florida. She meets a diverse group of friends who thrust her into a world of romance, drama and secrets. Little do they know, she has a few dark secrets of her own.
8.7
210 Chapters
Secrets
Secrets
“You've been there for me through the best and the worst, shared my happiness and my sadness, you're the person I want to argue with and wake up next to every day of my life. I can go on for hours about how much you mean to me and how much I love you, but I always believed that actions speak louder than words, so I'll knee before you and ask; Will you marry me, will you give me a lifetime to show you how much I love you?” Aria's body was covered in goosebumps, her whole body felt like it had frozen over. She heard every word he uttered like a siren in the night, but her brain wouldn't function. This wasn't supposed to happen. “I can't..." She didn't realise that the words were out of her mouth till she saw his face fall and the crowd gasped. “What do you mean you can't?” Deagan stood up and took a step towards her, but she stepped back before he could touch her. “I- I just can't, I'm sorry.” Tears welled in her eyes and her heart burned with pain, she knew she was hurting him and that made her heart break even more. ### Aria and Deagan face the test of time as two people from opposing social standings trying to navigate a relationship, standing strong when their families try to tear them apart until the secrets they keep from each other are revealed. Will Deagan win back his girl or is his past too heavy a burden to face? There's a fine line between secrets and lies, until keeping a secret means having to tell a lie...
9.9
78 Chapters
Family Ties
Family Ties
With a history like ours, the meaning of the word family tended to tangle into something unrecognizable. DNA and bloodlines didn’t tie us together, and neither did our last names. Various shades of grey blurred the branches of our twisted family tree. I wasn’t her brother. They weren’t my parents. Not that it mattered… She was off limits. Portia was my friend. Then my foster sister. And she’d always be the love of my life. Family Ties is created by Stephie Walls, an eGlobal Creative Publishing Signed Author.
Not enough ratings
58 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Are The Sisters In 'When We Believed In Mermaids'?

2 answers2025-06-26 15:58:05
I recently finished 'When We Believed in Mermaids', and the sisters' dynamic is one of the most compelling parts of the story. Kit and Josie Bianci are sisters who grew up in a chaotic, bohemian household in California, but their lives take drastically different paths after a tragedy. Kit, the younger sister, becomes an ER doctor in New Zealand, living a structured life that contrasts sharply with her wild childhood. Josie, the older sister, is presumed dead after a terrorist attack in Europe—until Kit spots her on TV years later. This discovery sends Kit on a journey to uncover the truth about her sister's disappearance and the secrets that fractured their family. What makes their relationship so fascinating is how differently they cope with trauma. Kit buries herself in work and logic, while Josie reinvents herself entirely, slipping into a new identity. The novel explores how memory can be unreliable, especially when shaped by loss. Josie’s transformation into someone else isn’t just about survival; it’s a rebellion against the past. The contrast between Kit’s steadfastness and Josie’s fluid identity creates this tension that drives the narrative. The sisters’ bond is messy, painful, and deeply real, showing how family ties can both haunt and heal.

Where Is 'When We Believed In Mermaids' Set?

3 answers2025-06-26 22:59:17
The novel 'When We Believed in Mermaids' is primarily set in two stunning coastal locations that contrast beautifully. Most of the present-day action unfolds in Auckland, New Zealand, where the protagonist Kit lives as an ER doctor. The author paints vivid pictures of the city's harbor and black sand beaches, making the setting almost a character itself. The story also flashes back to their childhood in California, specifically the fictional seaside town of Echo Bay. These coastal settings mirror the sisters' turbulent relationship with water - both as a source of joy during their childhood and as the site of their greatest tragedy. The New Zealand sections particularly shine with descriptions of volcanic landscapes and Maori cultural elements woven into the narrative.

What Is The Twist In 'When We Believed In Mermaids'?

3 answers2025-06-26 12:02:42
The twist in 'When We Believed in Mermaids' completely flips your understanding of the story. Josie, presumed dead for years, is actually alive and living under a new identity in New Zealand. Her sister Kit spots her in a news clip from a disaster, sparking a journey to uncover the truth. The real shocker is why Josie faked her death—escaping a traumatic past filled with abuse and a life she couldn’t bear anymore. The revelation that she chose to abandon her family to protect them from her own demons adds layers to her character. It’s not just about survival; it’s about the painful choices people make to find peace. The twist forces you to rethink every interaction and memory shared between the sisters, making the emotional payoff intense.

Does 'When We Believed In Mermaids' Have A Happy Ending?

2 answers2025-06-26 16:13:41
Reading 'When We Believed in Mermaids' was an emotional rollercoaster, and the ending left me with mixed feelings—but in the best way possible. The story follows Kit as she discovers her sister Josie, long believed dead, is actually alive. The reunion is bittersweet, packed with raw emotions, secrets, and the heavy weight of their shared past. While it’s not a fairy-tale ending where everything magically fixes itself, it’s satisfying in its realism. The sisters rebuild their fractured relationship, and there’s hope for healing, even if scars remain. The author doesn’t shy away from the messy parts of forgiveness, making the resolution feel earned rather than forced. The happiness in the ending comes from the characters’ growth. Kit learns to let go of her anger and grief, while Josie confronts the trauma that made her disappear. Their bond isn’t perfect, but it’s stronger because it’s honest. The supporting characters, like Kit’s love interest, add warmth without overshadowing the central theme of sisterhood. The book closes with a sense of quiet optimism—not a loud celebration, but a soft acknowledgment that some wounds can mend. If you define a happy ending as characters finding peace, then yes, it delivers. But if you expect uncomplicated joy, you might find it more nuanced than that.

Is 'When We Believed In Mermaids' Based On A True Story?

2 answers2025-06-26 17:12:57
I recently finished reading 'When We Believed in Mermaids', and the question of whether it's based on a true story really stuck with me. While the novel isn't a direct retelling of real events, the emotional core feels incredibly authentic. Barbara O'Neal crafts a story about two sisters separated by tragedy and reunited years later under extraordinary circumstances. The setting, especially the New Zealand coastal town, is described with such vivid detail that it feels like a real place you could visit. The author mentions drawing inspiration from her own experiences with family dynamics and loss, which adds layers of realism to the fictional narrative. The themes of identity, trauma, and redemption are handled with such raw honesty that they blur the line between fiction and reality. The sisterly bond between Kit and Josie resonates deeply, making their struggles feel genuine. O'Neal's background in psychology shines through in how she portrays memory and perception, making the characters' journeys psychologically believable. While no specific true story matches the plot exactly, the novel captures universal truths about family that make it feel real in an emotional sense. The exploration of how people reinvent themselves after trauma mirrors many real-life experiences, giving the story a grounded quality despite its dramatic twists.

How Do Mermaids Mate

3 answers2025-03-10 02:38:52
Mermaids, like many mythical beings, have all sorts of intriguing ideas surrounding their mating habits. They’re often depicted in stories as being very romantic and enchanting. Some narratives suggest that they might share a special bond that involves singing to each other or performing a dance in the moonlight to attract a mate. The deep ocean setting definitely adds a layer of mystery and magic to the whole process. It's fascinating to think about how these beautiful creatures would express emotions and connect in their underwater world.

What Powers Do Mermaids Have In 'Mermaid Tears'?

2 answers2025-06-14 19:21:29
The mermaids in 'Mermaid Tears' are far from the typical gentle creatures of folklore. Their abilities are deeply tied to the ocean's raw power and their own emotional states. At their core, they possess hydrokinesis—manipulating water with terrifying precision. The protagonist, Luna, can summon tidal waves strong enough to capsize ships or create delicate water sculptures that shimmer like glass. Their voices aren’t just enchanting; they’re weapons. A mermaid’s song can shatter eardrums or lull humans into a trance so deep they drown without resistance. Some older mermaids even develop cryokinesis, freezing entire sections of the sea into jagged battlefields. What fascinates me most is their symbiotic bond with marine life. They don’t just communicate with creatures; they command them. Luna once summoned a swarm of bioluminescent jellyfish to illuminate an underwater cavern, and later directed a pod of orcas to hunt down a poacher’s fleet. Their tears are literal magic—crystallizing into pearls that heal wounds or, in rare cases, grant temporary aquatic breathing to humans. The darker side? Mermaids in grief or rage trigger maelstroms. The book’s climax shows Luna’s despair manifesting as a hurricane, making it clear their powers are as volatile as the sea itself.

How Does 'Into The Drowning Deep' Portray Mermaids Differently?

3 answers2025-07-01 09:32:39
The mermaids in 'Into the Drowning Deep' are nothing like the sweet, singing creatures from fairy tales. These are apex predators, designed with terrifying precision. Their razor-sharp teeth and muscular tails make them perfect hunters, capable of tearing through steel and flesh alike. What's chilling is their intelligence—they don't just attack; they strategize, using mimicry to lure humans into traps. Their vocalizations aren't melodies but sonic weapons that can rupture eardrums or induce paralyzing fear. The book strips away any romanticism, presenting mermaids as cold, calculating killers who view humans as prey. It's a fresh take that makes the ocean feel like a horror show.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status