Cassandra fell silent.
She didn't like Phoebe, but she had never intended to harm her baby. This outcome was far heavier than anything she could have anticipated.
"I'm sorry," she said, her voice dry and rasped. "I'm willing to make it right."
"Make it right? Why should you?"
Even tied up, Juliana strained her neck to curse aloud. "Theodore! Because of you, Cass lost the chance to ever become a mother seven years ago! When did you ever try to make it up to her? And now you're out here blaming her over some irrelevant woman?"
Theodore frowned. Just as he opened his mouth to speak, Phoebe suddenly snapped to life in her wheelchair. She fixed Cassandra with a glare drenched in bone-deep hatred.
"A life for a life! Cassandra York, you took my baby, so you're going to taste that exact same pain!"
Cassandra kept her lips pressed tight, but Juliana let out a cold laugh. "Then you're out of luck! Thanks to certain people, she couldn't have kids in the first place!"
Phoebe's gaze snapped instantly to Juliana. "Since you and Cassandra are thick as thieves, you can take her punishment for her!"
"No!" Cassandra shouted sharply to stop her.
Yet Theodore spoke with chilling indifference, "Do it."
Those two light, effortless words fell like a thunderbolt striking right beside Cassandra's ear.
She stared at him in sheer disbelief—the very same Theodore who had once sworn to protect her and everyone by her side with his life.
At his command, several thugs rushed Juliana and pummeled her with punches and kicks, targeting her abdomen in particular.
"No! Stop!" Cassandra's vision blurred with rage as she tried to charge forward, only to be held back by a wall of stronger hands.
She couldn't fight off a mob alone. All she could do was watch helplessly as Juliana curled into a ball on the ground. Her white shirt was rapidly soaked through with blood.
By the time Theodore raised a hand to call them off, Juliana was barely clinging to consciousness.
"Cassandra, when you do wrong, there has to be a price to pay."
With that, Theodore turned and pushed Phoebe away from the dock.
Cassandra finally broke free and rushed to Juliana's side. Terrified to touch her anywhere for fear of worsening the damage, all she could do was desperately press her hands against the bleeding wounds.
If Theodore had accompanied her for 16 years of her life, Juliana was a presence stretching even further back. She was the very first person Cassandra met after getting lost and one of the rare sources of genuine warmth in her entire world.
Yet now, that warmth had been cruelly trampled into the dirt. A metallic taste rushed up her throat.
Her body gave out entirely. A mouthful of fresh blood burst from her lips, staining her world red before she plunged into absolute darkness.
…
When consciousness finally clawed its way back, the sensation of weightlessness snapped Cassandra completely awake.
She found herself suspended over a cliff edge by frayed hemp ropes. The roaring, violent sea was churning below her feet.
Not far away, Phoebe was hanging from a similar line.
"Branden." Cassandra instantly grasped the situation.
Branden, whose leg had been crippled by Theodore, had come back for revenge.
On the flat ground above the cliff, Branden and his remaining loyalists stood locked in a standoff against Theodore. To Cassandra's utter shock, Ethan and Megan were standing there as well.
"Theodore Hale!" Branden grinned hideously. "The more I thought about what happened before, the angrier I got. So today, I'm inviting you all to play a little game. Pick one.
"You and Professor Lawson will call out the name of the person you want saved at the same time. If your choices match, I'll let her go. If they don't match, no worries, there's always a second chance."
Hearing that rule stirred a faint, pathetic flicker of hope in Cassandra.
She had long since stopped expecting anything from Theodore. Yet she still held a little hope for the Lawsons, who had shown her kindness when she was sick.
Branden grinned like a demon as he began to count down. "Three, two, one!"
Almost in unison, three distinct voices rang out across the edge.
"Phoebe."
Theodore's voice, alongside Ethan's and Megan's voices, overlapped completely, without a single second of hesitation.
Cassandra closed her eyes.
How wonderful.
They had all given up on her.
16 years of sharing life and death couldn't outweigh three months of naive sweetness.
The blood ties she had only just discovered couldn't stand against 24 years of invested habit.
The scarred, battered wasteland inside her chest was finally crushed into fine powder, turning entirely to ash.
Cassandra barely felt the pain anymore. All that remained was a hollow sense of closure.
Was this what Theodore meant when he said she had everything?
"Well, looks like we have total agreement." Branden cackled and gave a sharp wave of his hand.
Cassandra felt the rope binding her snap loose in an instant.