Nine months later.
“I want to hold another party, in celebration of you getting into Crestfield!” Elara shrieked through the phone, her voice bright and obnoxiously chipper. “Elara, no. Absolutely not,” I groaned, balancing my phone between my shoulder and ear as I tossed my keys onto the kitchen counter. “Come on, Evie,” she whined, dragging my name out like a kid begging for candy. “You’re officially a college student now. You’re supposed to be wild and crazy. Live a little!” “First of all,” I said, rolling my eyes as I opened the fridge, only to find it depressingly empty. “I got into Crestfield because I had no other choice. It’s not Ravencrest, and it’s not what I wanted.” “Boo-hoo,” Elara mocked, her dramatic tone practically dripping through the phone. “So what if Crestfield isn’t Ravencrest? At least you’re going to college and studying engineering, which is, like, the most Evie thing ever.” I sighed, shutting the fridge door and leaning against the counter. “Elara, do you even know what engineering is?” “It’s like… robots and stuff, right?” she said, and I could practically hear her smirking on the other end. “Jesus Christ,” I muttered, rubbing my temples. “Anyway,” she continued, undeterred, “I’m throwing this party, and you’re going to come, and you’re going to have fun. And maybe—just maybe—you’ll get laid again.” “Elara!” I snapped, heat rushing to my cheeks. “What?” she replied, feigning innocence. “You can’t tell me you’re still not thinking about him. It’s been nine months, Evie. Nine. Months.” “I’m not thinking about him,” I said firmly, though the lie was obvious even to myself. “Oh, please,” Elara said with a scoff. “You’re probably still dreaming about that hot stranger who gave you the best night of your life, and then you—” “I know what I did, Elara,” I interrupted, groaning. “I took a shower and washed off his number. Can we move on?” “Nope,” she said cheerfully. “I’m never letting you live that down. Do you know how rare it is to find someone who looks like a Greek god and actually knows what to do in bed? And you just let him disappear.” I sighed, leaning against the counter and pinching the bridge of my nose. “I didn’t let him disappear. It was a one-night stand. That’s literally how they work.” “Not when they’re that good,” she quipped. “Honestly, I’m just disappointed in you. I expected more from my best friend.” “Well, sorry to disappoint,” I said dryly. “Now, can we please talk about something else? Like how you’re going to pay for this party you’re so determined to throw?” “Oh, don’t worry about that,” she said breezily. “I’ve got it all figured out. You just have to show up and look hot. It’s not that hard, Evie.” I rolled my eyes, already regretting this conversation. “Elara, I really don’t think—” “Nope,” she interrupted. “You’re coming. End of discussion.” I opened my mouth to argue, but the sight of my mom sitting on the living room sofa stopped me in my tracks. “Elara, I’ll call you back,” I said quickly, cutting her off mid-rant. “What? Why—” “Mom’s here,” I said, already lowering the phone. “Fine,” she huffed. “But we’re not done talking about this party, Evie!” I hung up before she could say anything else, stuffing my phone into my pocket as I walked into the living room. “What are you doing here?” I asked, frowning as I took in the sight of my mom sitting stiffly on the edge of the couch, her hands folded tightly in her lap. “That's not how you talk to your mum.” “Well, that's how I talk to my mum, who left me for over a year and didn’t even bother showing up to her daughter’s graduation,” I snapped, arms crossed tightly over my chest. “I was the best in my class, by the way. Not that you care.” “Oh, come on, Evie,” my mother said, waving me off as if I were being dramatic. “You’re a big girl now. Besides, I was… busy. Trying to get you a proper life.” “Yeah, by stripping your life away,” I shot back, my tone sharp. “Great way to be a mother.” Her face twitched, just for a second, before she composed herself and smoothed her dress, a glittery, way-too-tight number that clung to her figure like desperation. Her hair, a bright platinum blonde with dark roots peeking through, fell in loose curls around her shoulders. Her makeup was flawless, but heavy, the kind that didn’t just try to hide age but bury it completely. “My little pessimist,” she said with a sigh, brushing imaginary dust off her skirt. “I heard you got into Crestfield.” I raised an eyebrow. “Yeah. A low-class school. Exactly what you’re about to call it, right?” She pressed a hand to her chest, feigning shock. “I wasn’t going to say low-class.” “No?” I challenged, glaring at her. “Fine,” she admitted, waving her hand dismissively. “It’s not Ravencrest, is it? But it’s… something, I suppose.” “Wow, thanks for the glowing review,” I said, the sarcasm dripping from my voice. “Now, can you go back to wherever you were before? I don’t need your commentary.” She ignored me, standing up from the couch and smoothing her dress again. “What if you got into Ravencrest?” I laughed, but there was no humor in it. “They don’t give scholarships, Mom. That’s the whole point. It’s for rich kids and trust fund babies. Not for people like us.” “People like us,” she repeated, her tone almost mocking. “There you go again, being so pessimistic.” “And there you go again, being delusional,” I shot back, a grin tugging at my lips. “I know, Mother. I know. Now leave.” She didn’t move. Instead, she tilted her head, her gaze distant for a moment before her eyes lit up with an unnerving enthusiasm. “You’re going to love it, Evie. Just imagine: a big university, a gorgeous campus, parties on yachts—” “Yachts?” I interrupted, my brows shooting up. “Really? Dad left you for another woman, Mom. And not just any woman, his wife. You weren’t even the first pick. You were the ‘other woman’ chasing after a rich husband. And now you’re back here, being—” “Unreasonable?” she cut in, her voice unusually calm as she reached into her purse. I stopped mid-sentence as she pulled out her hand and held it up. There, sitting on her ring finger, was a massive diamond ring. My jaw tightened. “Who did you steal that from?” I asked coldly.I looked at him. Really looked at him. And for the first time in a long time, I didn’t know what to feel.I felt empty.Like every version of him I’d built in my head was slowly peeling away, and underneath… I didn’t know what was left.Ryder didn’t look away. “Liliana dyed her hair,” he said quietly. “That’s when I lost interest.”My throat tightened. “You say that like it’s normal.”“I didn’t mean it like that.” He rubbed his hand down his face. “I wasn’t possessive with her. I wasn’t even… invested. Not the way I should’ve been.”“So why did you date her?”He shrugged, like the answer didn’t sit well even with him. “She reminded me of you. That was all it took.”I shook my head, disgust twisting in my chest.“I didn’t treat her badly,” he added quickly. “I wasn’t cruel. Just… distracted.”“Great,” I muttered. “That makes it all better.”He kept going anyway. “Sienna hated it. Thought I liked Liliana more than I did. Got jealous. Started following her around, trying to dig into what
“What's that supposed to fucking mean?”I didn’t realize I’d said it until the echo bounced off the walls.The door was already closed, but I wasn’t done. Not even close. My fists were clenched, and my jaw ached from how hard I was grinding my teeth.Don’t break her?That’s what Nate said to me?I paced the living room, every step sharp. My chest was tight. Too tight.He kissed her.He held her, touched her—talked to her like he knew her better than I ever could. Like he hadn’t just walked into her life with his soft words and his easy charm and taken what I didn’t know how to hold onto.He fucking kissed her.I picked up a glass off the table and almost threw it. Almost. Instead, I set it down, harder than necessary, and leaned forward, bracing my hands on the edge of the counter.The silence crawled up my spine.I closed my eyes.“If you really cared about her, you’d stop thinking about what hurts you and start thinking about what’s best for her.”He’d said that like it was so damn
Did she know?That was the question sitting on my tongue, heavy and bitter.Maya turned the last page again, eyes scanning the edge of the journal like she might’ve missed something. I took the book from her carefully, holding it like it might fall apart in my hands. The spine was cracked. The paper smelled like smoke and dust. Her handwriting shifted halfway through—neat, then frantic. The ink smudged in places, like she’d written while crying.“She was scared,” I said again, but quieter this time.“She knew they were watching her,” Maya murmured. “Maybe even following her.”Nate knelt beside me, took the USB from where it rested on the floor. “We’ll check what’s on this. Could be nothing. Could be everything.”“There has to be more,” I whispered, flipping back through the pages.And then I saw it.One page had a taped fold in the back cover. Like she’d tried to seal it in. My fingers worked carefully along the seam, peeling it open until a thin, crumpled piece of paper slipped out a
I blinked, about to turn.“Don’t look now,” he murmured.Then he leaned in and kissed my forehead.It wasn’t long, or dramatic. Just soft. Like it belonged there.My chest fluttered.I smiled. Then grinned.He smirked. “Now look.”I turned, casually, like it was nothing.Sienna was walking away, fast, heels clacking against the stone path. Her shoulders were stiff. Her head didn’t turn once.“She saw?” I asked.“She saw,” Nate said. “Let her think what she wants.”He stood and slipped his hands into his pockets.“But be careful, Evie. You dig too far, and you won’t just make enemies.”I looked up at him, the smile fading slowly from my face.“I don’t want to find out what happened to Liliana,” he said quietly. “By having it happen to you.”That stopped me.I blinked, caught off guard by the weight in his voice. It wasn’t a warning. It felt closer to a plea.“Thanks,” I murmured, unsure what else to say. Then I turned and walked away before he could see the confusion on my face.Later
Sienna removed her contact lenses, blinking at the mirror as her eyes adjusted to the harsh bathroom light. Her heels were already kicked off, the gala dress hanging half-zipped around her waist. She looked tired. Not in the cute, effortless way either—just drained.Her phone vibrated where it sat on the marble counter.Cohen.She picked it up and answered without much enthusiasm. “Yeah?”“You sure it was smart to invite her?”Sienna rolled her eyes, twisting her hair into a loose bun. “I didn’t invite her, Cohen. Riley did. And even if I had, it’s not like she was snooping.”“She’s been asking questions. Someone’s been poking around Liliana’s name.”“And you think it’s her?”There was silence on the other end.Sienna sighed. “Evie’s too busy playing Romeo and Juliet with Ryder. I doubt she has time to actually dig deep.”“You sound pretty confident. Isn't Ryder her Stepbrother?”“Soon to be. I mean Ryder is hot, I doubt if it would stop her. One day I would catch them in the act. Wou
His lips were warm against mine. He tasted faintly like peppermint and something sweeter I couldn’t place. His hand found the curve of my waist, holding me gently, like I might pull away any second. I didn’t. Not right away.The kiss was good. Soft. Controlled. The kind that didn’t rush. It felt like it should’ve meant something.But it didn’t feel like Ryder.Nate kissed me like he was trying not to break anything. Ryder kissed like he didn’t care if we both shattered.I eased back just a little, enough to see his face. His eyes searched mine, waiting for some kind of answer.“You okay?” he asked.I nodded, then shook my head. “I don’t know.”His brow furrowed. “Too much?”“No,” I said quickly. “You didn’t do anything wrong.”He looked like he wanted to ask more but stopped himself. He stepped back a little, giving me space.I ran a hand through my hair, trying to breathe past the tangle in my chest.“I just…” I looked down. “It felt different.”“Different how?” he asked, not unkindl