MasukShe entered the interview room the next morning.I waited outside, my palms damp with sweat.Half an hour later, she emerged with a light in her face that I had not seen in far too long.“Mom, I finished.”“Were you nervous?”“Very.”She smiled.“But I didn’t hide.”The final result was posted soon afterward.Nina Frost: recommended for direct admission to the master’s program at Westbridge Institute of Mathematics.The moment I read it, I leaned against the corridor wall because my legs would no longer hold me.The road stolen from her in my first life had finally returned beneath her feet.Spring came quickly.Northgate University adopted new rules governing student housing and graduate recommendations.All dorm transfers had to be approved in writing.Students could no longer be made privately responsible for another student’s housing or personal crisis.Any report involving bullying, defamation, or a mental-health emergency required evidence to be gathered from both sides.A studen
Two months later, the forensic analysis of the recordings was completed.They were unedited, unaltered, and chronologically intact.Trevor could no longer claim they were fake.In her police statement, Chloe confessed to everything.She said that at first, she had simply been jealous of Nina.Nina had exceptional grades, a stable home, the faculty’s approval, and a secure lead in the graduate recommendation process.Chloe had transferred in with nothing.When Trevor approached her, she was frightened at first.But he told her, “As long as you play the victim, no one will dare hold you accountable.“Everyone hates bullies. Once that label sticks to Nina, she’ll never be able to explain it away.”He also promised her money.Seven thousand dollars.To Chloe, it was an enormous sum.She thought she was only putting on a performance.“I never meant to make her drop out,” she said.When I heard that, I could only laugh at the absurdity.In my first life, Nina had dropped out.She had locked
Chloe’s public apology was scheduled for a department-wide assembly.She had lost a great deal of weight by the time she stepped onto the stage.The paper in her hands was crushed and wrinkled.“Because I was jealous of Nina Frost’s academic record and her recommendation for direct admission to Westbridge’s master’s program, I conspired with Trevor Hale to fabricate a story that she had bullied me.“I posted false statements on social media, the anonymous campus forum, and the mathematics department’s group chat. Those statements misled students and faculty.“I caused Nina serious harm.“I’m sorry.”By the final words, her voice had broken.No one applauded.No one spoke up for her.In my first life, she had stood in a similar place and received everyone’s sympathy.University officials called her brave. Students brought her flowers.Trevor helped her off the stage while cameras captured the righteous concern on his face.And Nina sat at home, too frightened even to turn on her phone.
Northgate University issued its formal apology on the third day.It happened faster than I had expected, because the state higher-education board had intervened and the recordings were too complete to explain away.In its statement, the university admitted that it had acted improperly by proposing to suspend Nina’s graduate recommendation before verifying the crucial evidence.Mr. Bennett was removed from all work related to the graduate recommendation process.Ms. Vance submitted a written account of her conduct and apologized to Nina in person.Nina sat beside me while her advisor stood in front of her with red-rimmed eyes.“Nina, I’m sorry.“My first thought that day was to contain the public reaction and make sure Chloe didn’t hurt herself.“I forgot that you were frightened too.”Nina was silent for a long time.At last, she said only, “I heard your apology.”She did not say it was all right.She did not say she forgave her.Ms. Vance went pale, but nodded.I did not speak for my
A crowd of students was still gathered in the corridor when Trevor and Chloe were escorted away to give statements.The same people who had waited to watch Nina be punished now looked as though someone had closed a hand around their throats.Whispers moved through the crowd.“The recordings were real?”“How could Trevor do that?”“Chloe deserves an award for acting.”I stopped and looked at them.“You were all much louder when you were calling my daughter a bully.”The corridor fell silent.No one would meet my eyes.Nina stood beside me, still pale.I knew she had not recovered from what had happened.In my first life, looks like these had crushed her.At least this time, she did not have to stand beneath them alone.My mother was waiting at our front door when we got home.The moment she saw Nina, she pulled her into her arms.“It’s all right, sweetheart. Grandma is here.”Nina had held herself together until then. At those words, her tears spilled over.“Grandma, I never bullied her
The recorder was connected to the conference-room speakers.Chloe shot to her feet.“I don’t want to hear it!” Her voice was shrill enough to hurt.One of the officers looked at her.“Sit down.”Chloe’s entire body trembled.Trevor struggled to maintain his composure.“If these files were edited, we will pursue it.”I did not bother looking at him.“Please do.”The first recording began.It was the evening of September seventh, the night Chloe moved in.Suitcase wheels scraped across the floor.Then Nina’s voice came through the speakers.“The shared walkway has to stay clear. You can take your time unpacking. If you need help, we can call Ms. Moore.”Chloe answered sweetly, “Are you annoyed with me?”“No. I won’t touch your personal belongings. I don’t want there to be any misunderstandings.”The recording moved ahead to late that night.After the sound of a bed curtain closing, Chloe’s hushed voice could be heard on the phone.“What if she had refused to let me move in from the begin







