Home / Romance / SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS / CHAPTER 5: The Decision

Share

CHAPTER 5: The Decision

Author: ASHVA
last update publish date: 2026-02-16 06:09:59

 CHAPTER 5: The Decision

ARIA'S POV

I drove to Jordan's house on autopilot. Didn't remember getting on the highway. Didn't remember taking the exit. Just suddenly I was there, parked crooked in her driveway, and the sobs were coming so hard I couldn't catch my breath.

The porch light came on. Jordan appeared in the doorway in pajamas. Took one look at me and ran.

She opened my car door. "Come on. Come inside."

I couldn't move. Couldn't make my legs work.

"Aria. Look at me." She crouched down. Put her hands on my face. "Breathe. Just breathe."

"He has a baby," I managed. "She's seven months pregnant."

"Okay. Okay." Jordan unbuckled my seatbelt. Helped me stand. Kept an arm around me as we walked to the house. "We've got you."

Her spouse, Ryan, was in the living room. Saw my face and immediately grabbed car keys. "I'll take the twins to the park tomorrow. Give you space."

The twins. Maya and Zoe. Three years old. I'd held them when they were hours old. Had watched Jordan build the life I'd thought I was building with Flynn.

Jordan guided me to the couch. Disappeared and came back with a blanket and a box of tissues. Sat next to me and just waited.

The story came out in pieces. The bank statements. Flynn's refusal to explain. Rebecca's call. Driving to Sellwood. Seeing Sienna with her pregnant belly and my husband's vase on her counter.

"Seven months," I kept saying. "Seven months."

Jordan's jaw was tight. Her hands kept clenching into fists. "I will help you bury his body. Just say the word."

I almost laughed. Almost. "I need a lawyer, not an accomplice."

"Sarah. I'll text her right now."

"It's almost midnight."

"She'll answer." Jordan pulled out her phone. "What are you going to do tonight?"

"I can't go home."

"You're staying here. That's not a question." She typed fast. "Ryan already made up the guest room. We were expecting this."

"You were?"

"Babe, I've known something was wrong since Monday. I just didn't know how wrong."

Her phone buzzed. She read the message and showed me. *Tell Aria I'm sorry. I can see her first thing tomorrow morning. 8 AM. My office.*

Tomorrow was Friday. I was supposed to be installing the new exhibit. Meeting with artists. Living my normal life.

But nothing was normal anymore.

I didn't sleep. Jordan stayed up with me. We sat on her couch eating ice cream we couldn't taste and watching terrible reality TV. At some point, Ryan brought down pillows. Made sure we had water. Didn't ask questions.

Around three, Jordan fell asleep. I covered her with a blanket and sat there in the dark. My phone kept buzzing. Flynn calling. Texting. I didn't read any of it. Just watched the screen light up and go dark. Light up and go dark.

At dawn, Ryan came downstairs. Found me still awake, still staring.

"Coffee?" He asked.

I nodded.

He made a whole pot. Scrambled eggs that I couldn't eat. Toast that sat on the plate getting cold.

Jordan woke up at seven. Looked at me. "Did you sleep at all?"

"No."

"Okay. Let's get you ready."

She found clothes that fit me. I showered in their bathroom. Watched water circle the drain and wished I could disappear down it too. When I looked in the mirror, I didn't recognize myself. Eyes swollen. Face pale. Hair wet and tangled.

I looked exactly how I felt.

We made it to Sarah's office by eight. She had coffee waiting. Her office smelled like leather and old books. There were photos on her desk. Her kids, maybe. A dog.

"Aria." She shook my hand. Firm grip. Direct eyes. "I'm so sorry you're going through this."

"I need to file for divorce."

"Let's talk through your options first."

"No." My voice came out harder than I meant. "I don't want options. I want out."

Sarah studied me. Nodded. "Okay. Let's do this."

She asked questions. I answered them. How long married. Assets. Bank accounts. Property. Did I want to try counseling first.

"No," I said to that one. "He's having a baby with someone else. There's nothing to counsel."

"Oregon has a ninety-day waiting period," Sarah explained. "I can file today. Process servers will deliver the papers within forty-eight hours."

"Good."

"Where will you be staying?"

I looked at Jordan. She nodded without me having to ask. "With me," she said. "As long as she needs."

"But I need to get my things," I said. "Some of them."

"Want me to come with you?" Jordan asked.

"Please."

We left Sarah's office at nine-thirty. I had a folder full of papers I hadn't really read. Jordan drove us to the house.

Flynn's car was in the driveway.

"He took the day off," I said. "He never takes days off."

"Want me to come in?"

"No. Wait here. This won't take long."

He must have heard my car because he opened the door before I reached it. He looked terrible. Same clothes from yesterday. Hair a mess. Eyes red and desperate.

"Aria. Thank god. I've been calling—"

"I'm here for my things."

"Yout things? Honey Please. Let me explain. I love you. This isn't—"

"Don't." I pushed past him. "Don't say you love me. Love doesn't look like this."

"It's not what you think. Sienna isn't–"

"I met her, Flynn. I saw the apartment. I saw the baby things. I saw the vase I bought you on her kitchen counter."

He went pale. "You went there?"

"What did you expect me to do? You wouldn't tell me the truth."

"I was trying to protect‐"

"I don't care." I headed for the stairs. He followed.

"Where are you going?"

"To pack."

"Pack? Aria, wait. We can work this out."

"There's nothing to work out." I grabbed a suitcase from the closet. Started pulling clothes off hangers. Underwear from drawers. My art supplies from the desk I never used.

"Where will you go?"

"Anywhere you're not."

He stood in the doorway. Watching me pack up pieces of our life. "I can explain everything in due time. I just need you to trust me."

I stopped. Looked at him. "You had three years to earn my trust. You spent Seven months destroying it. We're done."

"Aria-"

"I filed for divorce this morning."

The words hit him like a punch. He actually stepped back. Grabbed the doorframe. "No. You can't. We.. We can fix this." he whispered. 

"There's nothing to fix." I zipped the suitcase. "You made your choice. Now I'm making mine."

I walked past him to the bathroom. Grabbed my toothbrush. Face wash. The jasmine lotion I loved. In the mirror, I caught sight of my left hand. The ring caught the light.

I twisted it off. It stuck a little. I'd worn it every day for three years. My finger felt naked without it.

I walked to the dresser. Set it down carefully. Three years of promises reduced to a circle of gold I couldn't bear to touch.

"Aria, please."

I picked up my suitcase. My bag of art supplies. Walked past him without looking back.

Jordan had the car running. I put my things in the back and got in. Through the window, I could see Flynn in the doorway. Still in yesterday's clothes. Still looking destroyed.

Jordan put the car in reverse. "Ready?"

I didn't look back when I closed the door. That was the first time I didn't look back. If he was going to build with a mistress, he should be free to do so but not with me in it the picture. 

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App
Comments (8)
goodnovel comment avatar
Bluepearl
Flynn is being to slow with his explanation
goodnovel comment avatar
Feigh
I think aria should slow down love the pacing btw
goodnovel comment avatar
I.O PIETRO
I think Aria is daft for this...
VIEW ALL COMMENTS

Latest chapter

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 188: Grateful, on One Knee

    ARIA'S POV The smoke alarm went off before the turkey even finished resting. I found Flynn standing on a kitchen chair, waving a dish towel at the ceiling like he could argue the beeping into silence, our daughter propped on his hip and shrieking with delight at the noise instead of being scared of it the way any sensible baby would be. "It's the rolls," he said, not looking at me. "I think. Or the thing in the oven. One of the things." "Which thing, Flynn." "The bread thing." "That was supposed to be dinner rolls." "They still might be edible." I climbed up next to him, silenced the alarm, and opened the oven to a tray of what could generously be called charcoal. He had the decency to look only mildly ashamed. "I'm sorry?” He said, leaning his head to one side. Then he brought Hazel up to his face and mimicked her. “Daddy said he is sorry. You should forgive him?” I let out a small laugh at his silliness “Daddy insisted on helping.” “Well… He really did try” He said in t

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 187: I'm ready to build something small

    ISABELLA'S POVMy whole body forgot how to work the second his name left my mouth. What the heck was he doing here?!!Three months of imagining this exact moment, rehearsing what I'd say if he ever stood in a room with me again, and all I managed was one syllable. “Hi” The dish towel slipped off my shoulder. My heart was too busy trying to climb up into my throat to worry about laundry.He looked the same and not the same at all. Same jaw, same steady eyes that used to make me feel like the only person in any room. But something had changed in the way he held himself, careful now, guarded, like he had learned the hard way to protect a bruise before anyone got close enough to hit it again.I did that. I put that carefulness on his shoulders.The sadness hit me first, sharp enough to steal my breath, my mind dragging me straight back to the bakery counter and the sound of my own voice calling the best thing that ever happened to me: *nothing*. Then the guilt came right behind it, very f

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 186: My own side of three months

    ETHAN'S POV "Come on, Ethan, at least look like you're having fun. You're supposed to be the face of this whole expansion." My business partner Luke said it low, leaning toward me over his glass, nodding at the room like it was mine to enjoy. Rooftop bar, the whole city glittering out past the railing, a crowd of investors and their guests mixing brand of expensive perfume with expensive liquor. I'd been standing in the same spot for twenty minutes holding a drink I hadn't touched. "I'm having plenty of fun," I said, which was a lie neither of us believed. It's been three months of this. Three months of rooms exactly like it, cities blurring into one long string of good lighting and better small talk, my face apparently now familiar enough that some magazine had slotted me into a list of the city's most eligible bachelors a few weeks back. Luke had framed the page and hung it in his office, which he thought was hilarious. I hadn't found much of anything funny lately. A woman,

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 185: Starting Over Again

    *Three months later*ISABELLA'S POVThe kitchen smelled like cinnamon and burnt sugar, and for a second I could not remember which one I wanted to actually make.Thanksgiving was two days away and my mother had the whole house running on holiday time, sweet potatoes lined up on the counter, a turkey thawing slowly in the fridge that had swallowed up half the shelf space. I had offered to handle the desserts as it gave my hands something to do, and because saying no to my mother during the holidays has never once worked in the history of our family.Three months. That was how long it had been since the bell over my bakery door rang behind Ethan for the last time and I stood there waiting for it to ring again but it never did. Three months since he left with no calls or texts from him. I used to think this would be different from Dominic, because at least Ethan had been mine to lose for one real night at the lake but I was wrong about that matter. If anything the last three months felt

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 184: Leaving Leavenworth

    Song Recommendation: Train wreck by James Author ETHAN'S POV I almost turned around twice before I made it to her door. Five days of silence will do that to a man. Make him rehearse a hundred versions of a conversation in his car, then abandon every single one of them the second his hand actually lands on the door handle. I told myself I wasn't going to push. I told myself that the whole drive over. Somewhere between her my house and this bakery, I stopped believing it. The bell rang before I'd even finished deciding what to say. "We're closed," she called out but didn't turn. Then she did turn, and I watched every ounce of color drain sideways out of her face. "Oh. Hi, Ethan." Bright and brittle, a voice built to hold a door shut. "What.. what are you doing here?" I asked her straight out if she was avoiding me. But I already knew the answer. Some part of me had known it since her mother stood in that doorway, sighing like she'd been carrying a lie too heavy to hold anymore.

  • SHE WAS NEVER HIS MISTRESS    Chapter 183: It's not that serious Ethan! 

    Song Recommendation: Before you go by Lewis CapaldiISABELLA'S POVThe bell over the door was the last sound I wanted to hear that evening.I had the sign already flipped to closed, the last tray wiped down, flour dust catching gold in the low light coming through the front window. My feet ached in that good, worn out way they always did after a full day, and for one small stretch of silence before that bell rang, my head had been empty of everything except tomorrow's prep list."We're closed," I called out without turning, rag still in my hand.Then I turned anyway, out of habit more than anything, and every muscle in my body locked at once."Oh. Hi, Ethan." My voice came out too bright, too fast, like i was hoping nobody notices i was bracing for something. "What.. what are you doing here?""Izzy, are you avoiding me?" I walked past him toward the far table, I moved my rag over a surface that was already clean. "No. Never. Why would I avoid you hmm?""Isabella, I was at your house

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status