Home / Romance / Stealing His Brother's Girl / What Will You Do, Novalyn?

Share

What Will You Do, Novalyn?

Author: Scarl James
last update Last Updated: 2025-12-16 22:05:27

My heart stops.

Did I hear him correctly?

“You’re joking,” I blurt out, and I can already feel the heat flooding up my neck. “I—I can’t do that. Sebastian, seriously. I’ve never done anything like that.”

"But you know what it is, don't you?" His voice is sinful, and it does something dangerous to my insides.

Of course I know what a lap dance is. I'm not completely sheltered. It’s the thing girls in music videos do. Rolling their hips and flipping their hair and grinding like their lives depend on it while some guy sits there looking like he’s about to ascend into heaven.

But me?

Doing that to him?

"Come on, sweetheart," he murmurs, and the endearment sends a shiver down my spine. "No need to be shy."

Sweetheart?

“You don’t understand,” I rush out, shaking my head so hard a strand of hair hits my lip. I reach up to brush it away with trembling fingers. "I don’t… I don’t do stuff like this. I’ve never even been to a club before.”

Which is pathetic, really. I'm twenty-six years old and this is my first time in a nightclub.

He leans back, stretching those stupid long legs in front of him and I desperately pray he'll drop the topic, let it go and move on to something else.

Because I can't grind on the twin brother of the man I love.

I won't.

It would be shameless and cheap. Wrong on about seventeen different levels.

I came here to forget Rowan for a little while, not to... slut around on Sebastian freaking Oberon.

You know the rules,” he leans into his chair. “Every dare you skip costs you two glasses."

"What?" My eyes widen and I lean forward without meaning to. "Two what? I thought you didn't want me getting drunk. You literally said—"

"Relax." He chuckles darkly. "I'm not actually going to make you do it. The look on your face was entertaining enough."

"You're cruel," I breathe out, but there's no real bite to it.

"So I've been told." He picks up his glass, swirling the dark liquid. "Aren't you curious about something, Novalyn?"

"About what?"

"Why I bothered to spend my Saturday night with you." He pauses deliberately. "A girl I've never cared about."

He's... He's right. That is a good question. Actually, it's an excellent question, and I feel monumentally stupid for not asking it sooner. For not wondering about it the second he gave me the card. I was so desperate to escape my heartbreak, so eager to get away from watching Rowan and Jane be perfect together that I didn't stop to think about the logistics. About why Sebastian of all people, Sebastian who has never shown the slightest interest in me would offer to help me. Why he would waste his time on someone he barely knows.

"I..." My voice cracks. I clear my throat, forcing myself to meet his gaze. "I don't know, so tell me. Why did you?"

Sebastian leans forward, eliminating the space between us. His elbow finds the table, and suddenly he's close enough that I can smell his cologne.

"What if I told you..." He pauses, letting the silence stretch taut between us. "I could help you get Rowan?"

The world stops.

I can feel my pulse pounding in my ears.

"You..." I can barely form the words. "What did you just say?"

Did I hear that right? Did he really just say he could help me get Rowan? As in, make Rowan fall for me? Make Rowan see me as something other than his little sister figure?

That's not possible. That's not... People can't just make someone fall in love. That's not how it works.

"But in return," Sebastian says, his dark eyes never leaving mine, "you help me with something."

The offer is so unexpected that I can't quite wrap my mind around it. It feels like something out of a movie. A bad teen romcom where the protagonist makes a deal with the devil and learns a valuable lesson about being careful what you wish for.

I should stand up and walk away.

But my legs remain frozen.

"He has..." I finally manage to say, and my voice is shaky. "I mean, Rowan has a girlfriend now. How can you possibly help me with something I couldn't help myself with? If I couldn't make him see me that way after all these years, what makes you think you can?"

"Because unlike you," Sebastian says sharply, "I'm not a coward."

My eyebrows shoot up.

Did he just call me a coward?

"You loved him for so long but couldn't tell him."

"I was waiting for the right moment," I protest weakly, my chest tightening like someone just stuck a needle directly into my heart.

"Was there ever going to be a right moment, Novalyn?" His gaze pins me in place. "Or were you always going to find another excuse?"

I can't answer. I can't defend myself. Because he's right, and we both know it.

Anyone looking at my situation from the outside would see exactly what he's seeing. Would call me exactly what he's calling me. A coward. Someone who let the perfect moment slip through her fingers again and again and again because she was too scared to take the risk.

I can't blame him for seeing what's obvious.

I drag in a long breath through my nose and let it out slowly through my mouth, feeling some of the fight drain out of me.

"I was going to tell him," I admit quietly. "The night he introduced me to Jane. That was supposed to be the night."

For the first time this evening, Sebastian looks genuinely surprised. His eyebrows lift slightly.

"That's twisted," he says, but there's something almost impressed in his tone. "The universe really said fuck you, didn't it?"

A bitter laugh escapes me. "Yeah. It did."

"I'm saying now, Novalyn," Sebastian continues, and his voice takes on a more serious tone. "I can make Rowan fall for you. I can make him finally notice you. The way you want him to."

I stare at him, trying to figure out if he's messing with me. If this is some elaborate joke at my expense.

"How?" I ask, and I can hear the skepticism in my voice. "Not long ago you were daring me to give you a lap dance. Now you're saying you can make him love me?"

"I have a plan," Sebastian says, and that dangerous smile returns. "A very specific plan. But you have to help me first."

I take a moment to let his words sink in. To really consider what he's saying.

"You don't understand," I respond, shaking my head. "Rowan still sees me as a sister. As family. What kind of crazy scheme could you even have that's giving you the confidence to think you can change years of history between us?"

"Let me worry about that," he replies smoothly.

Frustration bubbles up inside me.

"Fine. Then what do you need my help for?" I ask, deciding to approach this from a different angle. "What could I possibly do for you?"

"You're the only person who's close to Rowan," Sebastian explains. "I need a concrete piece of information from him. And only you can get it for me."

My stomach drops.

"What information?" The question comes out cautious.

"I'm not letting it out now," he says firmly, his jaw setting. "Not until you agree to the deal. That's how this works."

He pauses.

"And before you agree blindly, before you shake my hand and seal this thing, know this. What I’m asking isn’t small. You’d be betraying Rowan’s trust. If he ever finds out… he’ll never forgive you.”

B‑betray Rowan? My pulse hammers in my ears. I can’t… I can’t think straight. I can’t even form words. I just stare.

"So… Novalyn, what will it be?" He tilts his head, his dark eyes piercing mine. "Are you going to do it… or are you going to watch him slip away forever?"

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    The Girl Who Cried Wolf

    Rowan just stares at me. He blinks once. Then twice. His face goes completely blank, like his brain is trying to process information in a language it doesn't understand."What?" he finally manages to say. "What did you just say, Nova?""James Sterling," I repeat, and my voice is shaking but I press forward anyway because I've started this and I have to see it through, I have to make him understand. "Her ex-fiancé from LA. She's been seeing him. Today, right now, she's with him at the Grandview Hotel. I followed her there. I saw them together—""You followed her?" Rowan's voice shifts, going hard in a way I've rarely heard directed at me. "Nova, what the hell are you talking about?""I had to. I found evidence, Rowan. A robe in her things with his initials embroidered on it. J.S. James Sterling. And then I found out he's been staying at the Grandview for days, and today when Jane said she was going to see her sick mother she actually went straight to him. She lied to your face about wh

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    Love Makes Fools of Us

    The door swings shut across the hall.That's when it hits me, I'm not alone in this room. I'm here with Sebastian Oberon, having just spectacularly failed at the one thing we came here to do.I stumble back from the peephole, my legs suddenly weak. One hand reaches out blindly for the wall to steady myself while the other still clutches my phone. The screen is dark now, silent and innocent-looking, as if it didn't just detonate our entire operation like a bomb.When I finally manage to turn around, I find Sebastian already watching me.He looks calm, his expression sitting somewhere between disappointed and grimly amused."Well," he says slowly, and I can hear the dry amusement threading through his voice, "that was impressively terrible timing.""I know," I mumble, still gripping my phone like somehow if I hold it tight enough, I can rewind time. Undo Rowan's call. Get the photo I was supposed to get. Make this disaster un-happen. "I didn't... I didn't know he would call right then.

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    Sweetheart, Don’t Blush

    We watch the car keep moving toward the place we already suspect. Or maybe know for sure it's heading to. And with every second that passes, my heart trembles even more. My fists are balled tight on my laps."Stop fidgeting," Sebastian says without taking his eyes off Jane's car, three vehicles ahead of us. "You're making me nervous.""I'm making you nervous?" I raise a brow. "You're the one who apparently does this for fun.""I prefer to think of it as a hobby." He says, sliding through another lane, always keeping the right distance. "Besides, I don't do it for fun. I do it because I'm good at it.""That's not the reassurance you think it is, Sebastian.""Wasn't trying to reassure you, sweetheart." He glances at me briefly, one eyebrow raised. "I was stating a fact."Sweetheart? My cheeks flush at the endearment, heat creeping up my neck. The way he says it sends me hot. It's just a word. Just a casual endearment people throw around all the time. But the way Sebastian says it sends

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    The Alibi

    The three days between Wednesday and Saturday crawl by.Thursday morning, I show up to work at the café already exhausted. My shift starts at six, and I immediately start messing up orders. I give a customer oat milk instead of almond. I forget to add the extra shot of espresso someone specifically requested. I nearly burn myself twice on the steam wand because I'm not paying attention.Because my mind keeps circling back to Sebastian and our Saturday 'mission.' Every time I try to focus on something else, my brain yanks me right back to it. Friday, I have the day off. I should be grateful for the rest, should use it to catch up on sleep or do literally anything productive. But instead, I spend the entire day pacing my room like a caged animal, nervous.At dinner, Jane makes this incredible chicken parmesan. I sit across from her, watching her twirl pasta onto her fork. I really, really look at her. How can someone look so innocent while harboring such a foul secret?I take a breath.

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    One Last Time

    Sebastian's eyes are fixed on me. He's waiting for me to speak, to explain why I dragged him away from his friends and made him sit here with me in this smoke-filled carI need to tell him what Rita said. I need to make him understand that this is real, that Jane really is doing what we suspected. But now that I'm actually sitting here, now that the moment has arrived, my throat feels tight. The words are stuck, refusing to come out in any coherent order.So, I just blurt it out."Jane is cheating on Rowan."Sebastian's eyebrows rise slowly. He doesn't look shocked, exactly. More like... interested. Like I've finally said something worth his full attention."What?" His voice is calm. Too calm for what I just told him."My boss, Rita," I continue. "She told me something today at the café. She saw Jane a few days ago coming out of a hotel with a man.""What hotel?" He asks calmly."The Grand Regency." I watch his face for a reaction. "The same hotel where James Sterling is staying. And

  • Stealing His Brother's Girl    A Risky Meeting

    I can't just waltz out of the apartment. I explicitly told them I was exhausted, that I was going straight to bed to rest. If I suddenly say I'm leaving, they'll definitely ask questions. I pace around my room, thinking hard, running through possibilities and discarding them just as quickly.I could say I'm meeting a friend. But which friend? Rowan knows I don't have many friends in the city. He'll ask who. He'll ask where we're going, and I'm not good enough at lying under pressure to come up with convincing details on the spot.I need something concrete. Something believable. Something that gives me a good reason to leave right now and be gone for at least an hour, probably longer.I pace faster, biting my thumbnail.And then it hits me.My wallet.I could say I left my wallet at work. That I just realized it's still in my locker at the café and I need to go get it.It's perfect. It's the kind of thing I would actually do. I'm always forgetting things, always leaving my jacket some

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status