Why did I let it go on that long?

Clara’s POV

The moment the words left my mouth, I couldn’t stand there another second. My skin felt too tight, my chest too heavy—the weight of Nolan’s smirk pressing down on me like a curse I couldn't shake off. I turned on my heel, the echo of my hurried footsteps betraying the conflict raging inside me, each sound reverberating with the tension of what I had just witnessed.

The floorboards creaked beneath my hurried steps, each sound a reminder of the line I had just crossed, one I never should have approached. The further I got from his room, the easier it was to breathe, but the echo of his laughter trailed after me, dark and taunting, as if it clung to the walls themselves, wrapping around my senses like a suffocating fog.

Once in the kitchen, I leaned against the counter, gripping the edge until my knuckles turned white. My hands trembled, and a wave of nausea twisted in my stomach, knotting tighter with each passing second. The cold surface felt like a lifeline, a distraction from the chaos storming through my mind.

I forced air into my lungs, steadying myself against the pressure rising within. My stomach was no longer hungry. It was a knot, twisted and tight, as if it knew I had crossed some invisible line—by looking, by listening, by staying there longer than I ever should have.

Disgust flooded me, hot and suffocating. Not just for him—for myself. Why did I let it go on that long?

Nolan was my tormentor, my stepbrother—the devil who made my life a living hell. I should feel nothing but loathing for him. Yet, I could still see him there, the way his hands had moved, the rawness of the moment lurking like a ghost in my mind. That devastating image flickered in my thoughts—stark and unapologetic—refusing to fade.

“Stop it, Clara,” I muttered to myself, pressing my palms against my face. You’re better than this. You don’t want this. I didn’t want him; I didn't want that part of me that had reveled in the moment, that had watched him like a moth drawn to a flame.

Yet, how could I reconcile that part of myself with the seething disgust I felt? The truth was, I could still hear his voice—smooth, taunting, and oh-so-confident. “Enjoying the show, stepsis?”

I couldn’t take it. The knot in my stomach twisted tighter, a painful reminder of how vulnerable he had made me feel—how exposed. I shuddered, crawling beneath the covers as if I could bury the memory with the weight of my blankets.

Lying there in the darkness, I felt utterly alone, the silence swallowing me whole. And yet, in that silence, his voice echoed again, low and smug, wrapping around me like a serpent.

What was it about him that unsettled me so deeply? He infuriated me, twisted my stomach with rage and embarrassment, and yet… there was something else brewing beneath the surface, something that scared me even more.

Just then, my phone buzzed on the nightstand, jarring me from my thoughts. I grabbed it, my heart leaping in my chest as I flicked the screen on. It was a text from Jenna.

Jenna: You okay? Heard some rumors about Nolan being an ass again. You can’t let him get to you, Clara!

I hesitated, thinking of how to respond. She cared; she always did.

Me: He’s just being himself, as usual.

Jenna: Don’t let him bother you. You’re stronger than he thinks. Just ignore him!

I sighed, running my fingers through my hair. Ignoring Nolan was easier said than done, especially with the fresh memories burning beneath the surface.

Me: It’s hard… He just makes it so impossible to act like everything’s normal.

Jenna: Let me know if you want to talk. I’m here, okay?

Her message struck a chord. I knew she was right, that I needed to share what I was feeling, but part of me felt protective over my thoughts—too ashamed to lay bare the embarrassment and shame that gnawed at me.

I typed a response, then deleted it, staring blankly at the screen. I couldn’t tell her. It was too complicated. There was no way Jenna would understand how deeply Nolan’s actions affected me, how conflicted I felt just standing there, paralyzed.

I tossed the phone aside, burying my face in my pillows, where the soft fabric held no judgment. I felt like I was suffocating, drowning in the weight of my own thoughts. Why had I let myself get so close to the flame?

I closed my eyes, trying to drown out the memories threatening to seep in—the way he’d smirked, the confident tilt of his head, the raw vulnerability he had displayed, as if daring me to join him in his darkness.

Hours blurred together, the shadows in the room deepening and wrapping around me like a familiar shroud, until the weight of sleep began to pull me under. Just as I thought I’d escaped the turmoil, the darkness morphed into fragmented visions of Nolan, stifling and potent, making my heart race against the swell of anxiety.

What was it about him that captivated me? I hated him. I wanted to hate him. But with every biting word and every taunting glance, there was a tension lurking just beneath the surface—a challenge I didn’t fully understand but could feel echoing through the fibers of my being.

Just as the last tendrils of conscious thought began to slip away, I heard a soft knock at my door, stirring me from the depths of my restless thoughts.

“Clara?” It was my mom’s voice, soft and comforting. “Are you okay in there?”

I took a deep breath, pushing back the turmoil inside me. My mom thought I was tired, moody, perhaps a little withdrawn after my first day. She had no idea what I had seen, what I had felt.

“Yeah, Mom. Just… a little tired,” I called back, willing my voice to sound steady, to project an air of calm.

“Alright, sweetheart. Just checking in. If you need anything, I’m right downstairs,” she replied.

“Thanks!” I said, forcing a smile I knew she couldn’t see.

I heard her footsteps retreat down the hall, leaving me alone once more with my chaotic thoughts. What if she knew? What if anyone found out what had really happened? My stomach twisted at the prospect, and I buried my face in the pillow again—suffocated by my secrets.

At that moment, I could have screamed. I could have torn the blankets away and fled—fled from Nolan, from this house, from the torment of my own feelings. But instead, I lay there, heart pounding, wrestling with myself in the dark.

Maybe being around him had triggered something too deep within me; maybe it was some sort of betrayal I couldn’t put into words. There was a part of me that wanted to resist, to fight against the raw desire clawing at the edges of my consciousness, but the other part—that traitorous part—thrived on the pull toward the chaos he represented.

I could feel the stark divide within myself, the war waging—a battle of morality, of self-preservation against the allure of danger, of the unknown. Would I let him win? Would I let him twist my emotions until I didn’t recognize myself anymore?

A fresh wave of shame flooded through me, mingling with the anxiety I already felt. I didn’t want to be the girl caught in this web of confusion, trapped between hatred and something dangerously close to needing him—to wanting him.

I wanted to scream, to cry, to slam my fists against the walls until all of it shattered into pieces and left me free from this torment. But instead, I lay there silent, where the darkness embraced me so wholly I almost forgot the storm brewing just outside my door.