What Awards Did 'That'S Not What Happened' Win?

I remember picking up 'That's Not What Happened' on a whim, and boy, did it leave a mark. The book’s raw honesty and gripping narrative didn’t just resonate with readers—it caught the attention of some big awards too. While it didn’t sweep every podium, it snagged a few honors that cemented its place in contemporary literature. The most notable was the Young Adult Library Services Association’s Best Fiction for Young Adults selection. That list is no joke; it’s basically a gold stamp for books that tackle tough themes with nuance, and this one fit right in. The way it handled trauma and misinformation felt so timely, like it was written for this era of hot takes and half-truths.

Then there’s the Cybils Award nomination in the Young Adult Fiction category. Cybils is special because it’s bloggers and book lovers who decide the winners, not just critics. That tells you something about how deeply it connected with everyday readers. I wasn’t surprised to see it there—the protagonist’s voice is so sharp and real, you forget you’re reading fiction. Some lesser-known but equally meaningful nods include making the Rainbow Book List, which highlights LGBTQ+ inclusive stories, and being featured on the Texas Library Association’s Tayshas Reading List. Neither are traditional 'awards,' but they’re huge in the book community for spotlighting titles that deserve attention. Honestly, the lack of a shiny medal on every cover doesn’t matter. The real win is how often you still see it in 'must-read' discussions years later.