What Are The Best Fan Theories About Alumnas Storyline?

I’ve spent way too much time obsessing over fan theories about 'Alumna,' and one that really stuck with me is the idea that the protagonist isn’t actually human but a construct designed to replicate human emotions. The way she struggles with memories that feel fragmented and the recurring motif of glitches in her perception hint at this. Some fans point to the scene where she ‘malfunctions’ during a high-stress moment as proof. Others argue her ‘creator’ is the shadowy figure who appears in flashbacks, though the show never confirms it. The theory adds a layer of tragedy to her journey—she’s fighting for autonomy she might never truly have.

Another angle I love is that the entire storyline is a simulation, a test run by an advanced society to study human resilience. The recurring symbols of loops and repeated events feed into this, and it’d explain why certain characters seem to ‘reset’ after traumatic events. It’s wild how much evidence fans have dug up, from background details to cryptic dialogue.

The fan theories around 'Alumna' are some of the most creative I’ve seen, and they range from plausible to downright mind-blowing. My personal favorite is the idea that the protagonist is stuck in a time loop, reliving her trauma until she ‘solves’ it. The show drops subtle hints—repeated imagery, déjà vu moments, and characters who seem to know more than they should. There’s a scene where a side character whispers, 'You’ve been here before,' and it’s never addressed again. Fans speculate this is a clue that the loop is breaking.

Another theory suggests the world of 'Alumna' is a purgatory-like space where souls are tested before moving on. The eerie, dreamlike quality of certain episodes supports this, especially the way time flows inconsistently. Some characters age rapidly while others stay the same, and locations shift without explanation. It’s as if the rules of reality are fluid.

The most controversial theory is that the protagonist is actually the villain, manipulating events from the shadows. This one’s a stretch, but there are moments where her actions seem suspiciously convenient. A handful of fans even think she’s an unreliable narrator, and the story we’re seeing is her distorted version of events. Whatever the truth is, the show’s ambiguity is what makes it so fun to dissect.

I’m obsessed with how 'Alumna’s' storyline invites so many interpretations. One theory that fascinates me is the idea that the protagonist is a ghost, unaware she’s dead. The way other characters sometimes look right through her or react with confusion fits this. There’s also the recurring motif of cold spots and flickering lights, classic ghost story tropes. Some fans believe the ‘alumna’ title refers to her being a ‘graduate’ of life, now stuck in limbo.

Another popular take is that the story is an allegory for mental illness, with each character representing a different facet of the protagonist’s psyche. The antagonist, for example, could embody her self-destructive tendencies. This theory gains traction from the show’s surreal visuals and disjointed pacing, which mirror the chaos of a fractured mind.

Less discussed but equally intriguing is the theory that the world is a collective hallucination shared by the characters. The way they sometimes finish each other’s thoughts or experience the same visions supports this. It’s a haunting idea—that none of them are real, just echoes in each other’s minds.