Is 'City Of Thieves' Based On A True Story?

2025-06-17 20:34:47 315

3 answers

Chloe
Chloe
2025-06-21 04:30:15
I've done some digging into 'City of Thieves' by David Benioff, and while it's not a direct true story, it's heavily inspired by real historical events. The novel is set during the Siege of Leningrad in World War II, which was an actual horrific event where millions starved. The characters are fictional, but the backdrop is painfully real—the desperation, the cannibalism, the freezing temperatures. Benioff based it on stories his grandfather told him, blending family lore with historical research. It feels authentic because the details are spot-on, from the blocked supply routes to the Nazi encirclement. If you want something based completely on fact, try 'The 900 Days' by Harrison Salisbury, but 'City of Thieves' captures the spirit of survival against impossible odds.
Benjamin
Benjamin
2025-06-21 23:28:22
As someone who reads a ton of historical fiction, I can confirm 'City of Thieves' walks a fine line between fact and imagination. The novel's core premise—two men sent on a suicidal mission to find eggs during the Leningrad blockade—is fictional, but every brick in that world is real. The starvation rations (125 grams of bread per day), the frozen corpses stacked like firewood, the artists boiling glue from wallpaper to make soup—all documented horrors.

Benioff's brilliance is how he uses fiction to amplify truth. Lev and Kolya aren't real people, but their struggles mirror countless survivors' diaries. The dialogue crackles with dark humor that feels true to wartime coping mechanisms. Even the surreal moments (like the cannibal colonel) reflect documented cases of extreme desperation.

For a deeper dive into the siege, check out 'Leningrad: State of Siege' by Michael Jones. But don't dismiss 'City of Thieves' as 'just' fiction—it's a love letter to oral history, where personal stories become legends.
Samuel
Samuel
2025-06-23 13:00:12
Reading 'City of Thieves' felt like uncovering a lost wartime anecdote. Benioff never claims it's nonfiction, but he buries truths in the fiction so skillfully that it blurs the line. Take the setting: Leningrad's siege lasted 872 days, and the novel nails the psychological toll—how hunger warps morals, how humor becomes survival. The characters’ quest for eggs mirrors real accounts of people trading heirlooms for food. Even minor details, like the NKVD's brutality or the makeshift radio broadcasts, are historically accurate.

What makes it feel 'true' is the emotional honesty. Lev's naivety crumbling under trauma mirrors real teen diaries from the siege. Kolya's bravado hides the same fragile masculinity seen in Soviet veterans' memoirs. The book's power comes from stitching these real fragments into a new tapestry. For a raw documentary approach, try 'The Siege' by Helen Dunmore, but Benioff's novel makes history visceral in ways textbooks can't.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Тимбилдинг на выживание
Тимбилдинг на выживание
Моя работа - предел мечтаний. Отличный коллектив, понимающий шеф и бесплатный кофе. За исключением одного: вместе со мной работает исчадие ада, мой личный демон и безумно раздражающий фактор! И все бы ничего, если бы не совместная командировка с ним на месяц. И если я думала, что работа бок о бок только усилит нашу войну, то, судьба, видимо, решила пошутить над нами, влюбив нас друг в друга.
10
36 Chapters
Мой личный монстр
Мой личный монстр
Жизнь – интересная штука! Еще недавно, я думала, что живу очень интересно и правильно: хорошая работа, хороший город, друзья. Верхом безумия в моей жизни была ночь напролет в клубе. А потом мне наскучила работа. А еще пришло сообщение. А еще ночью пришли неожиданные гости. И все как закрутилось-завертелось! И стала жизнь похожа на сплошную лотерею, ну или фильм ужасов, ну или любовный роман – в общем, решайте сами!
10
33 Chapters
Жена дракона
Жена дракона
На ночной дороге водитель сбивает красивую девушку в странном платье. Она чудом выживает и вскоре выясняется, что ничего не помнит о своем прошлом. Спустя время она обживается , выходит замуж за состоятельного и влиятельного мужчину и живет с ним долгие годы. Но вот внезапно, на выставке старинного оружия ее похищают странные незнакомцы, которые утверждают, что она родом совсем из другого мира, где была мятежной и непокорной супругой правителя. Они забирают девушку с собой и день за днем она узнает причудливый мир по новой, а затем и вспоминает все причины, что привели ее к бегству.
Недостаточно отзывов
35 Chapters
Криминальный рыцарь
Криминальный рыцарь
Когда в жизни ты привыкла полагаться только на себя, тебя тяжело сломать. Но иногда наступает такой момент, когда помощь очень необходима, а поблизости нет ни одного человека, готового за тебя заступиться. И вот тут, словно в сказке, появляется рыцарь. Правда не в доспехах и с конем, а с кастетом и на тонированной тачке. Да и криминалом от рыцаря попахивает неслабо. Но, как говорится, что есть, то есть. Да и все девочки любят плохих мальчиков!
10
40 Chapters
Попытка номер 2
Попытка номер 2
Когда я развелась, все мои знакомые сочли своим долгом устроить мою личную жизнь. Но только мне не хотелось пока ни с кем связывать свою судьбу, слишком сложно я отходила от разрыва прошлых отношений. Но судьба не нуждается в свахах, она сама решает, когда и где столкнуть тебя с героем твоего романа, даже если этот герой совсем не в твоем вкусе.
10
21 Chapters
Крылья мглы
Крылья мглы
Летти Войт - жестокая социопатка, серийная убийца или девушка с обостренным чувством справедливости и комплексом защитницы слабых духом и телом? Та, что всегда выбирает драться, а не смиряться. Потомки драконов - образцы добродетели, спасители погибающего человечества или эгоистичные создания, играющие только на своей стороне? Жуткие твари из Зараженных земель - вероломные захватчики, нарочно вторгшиеся из чужого измерения, или же создания, обитающие там в силу непреодолимых обстоятельств, притесняемые всеми и вынужденные сражаться за право жить в своих домах и быть собой? Магия- это коварный дар, который одни получают от рождения, а другие - нет, или просто инструмент, мощь и субстанция, пригодная для любых манипуляций и трансформаций, и важно лишь в чьих руках окажется ее источник? Все это можно узнать, лишь дойдя до завершения этой истории.
10
59 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is The Setting Of 'City Of Thieves'?

3 answers2025-06-17 07:18:09
The setting of 'City of Thieves' is brutal yet mesmerizing—a frozen Leningrad during WWII’s siege, where hunger and fear gnaw at everyone. Streets are littered with rubble, buildings stand like skeletons, and the cold is a character itself, biting through coats and souls. The city feels claustrophobic, a cage where survival depends on trading morals for bread. But amid the despair, there’s a weird beauty. Moonlight glints off icicles hanging from bombed-out rooftops, and abandoned theaters echo with ghostly elegance. The black market thrives in basements, and NKVD officers lurk like wolves. It’s a place where jokes are as sharp as knives, and trust is rarer than meat.

Who Wrote 'City Of Thieves' And Why?

3 answers2025-06-17 13:18:58
I’ve always been fascinated by how 'City of Thieves' came to be. David Benioff, the guy behind 'Game of Thrones', wrote it as a novel before diving into TV. He based it on his grandfather’s wartime stories—those gritty, surreal moments during the Siege of Leningrad. Benioff wanted to capture that bizarre mix of horror and humor war creates. The book’s not just about survival; it’s about two mismatched guys on a wild goose chase for eggs during a famine. The absurdity makes the tragedy hit harder. If you liked the book, try 'The Siege' by Helen Dunmore for another take on Leningrad’s resilience.

How Does 'City Of Thieves' End?

3 answers2025-06-17 16:05:53
I just finished 'City of Thieves' last night, and that ending hit me like a freight train. Lev and Kolya finally make it to their destination after all that madness—only to face the brutal reality of war. Their mission succeeds, but at a cost. Kolya, the charismatic rogue, gets his moment of heroism, but it’s bittersweet. Lev’s transformation from a scared kid to someone who understands the weight of survival is heartbreaking. The last scene with the colonel is chilling—it strips away any illusions about glory in war. The book doesn’t tie things up neatly; it leaves you staring at the page, thinking about how war twists people.

Who Are The Main Antagonists In 'City Of Thieves'?

3 answers2025-06-17 20:54:16
In 'City of Thrones,' the main antagonists aren’t just one-dimensional villains—they’re a brutal mix of political schemers and physical threats. The Red Fang syndicate runs the underworld with a grip tighter than a noose, led by the ruthless Dain, a former gladiator who turned crime lord. Then there’s Lady Vesper, a noble who plays the long game, using her wealth and influence to manipulate the city’s factions like chess pieces. The Church of Eternal Dawn adds a creepy religious angle, with High Priest Solon preaching purity while ordering assassinations. What makes them compelling is how their goals clash—Dain wants chaos, Vesper wants control, and Solon wants purification, creating a three-way war that keeps the protagonist scrambling.

Does 'City Of Thieves' Have A Sequel Or Spin-Off?

3 answers2025-06-17 00:26:25
I've scoured through David Benioff's works and can confirm 'City of Thieves' stands alone—no direct sequel or spin-off exists. It's a shame because Lev and Kolya's gritty WWII journey through Leningrad had such rich chemistry. The novel wraps up neatly, but their dynamic could've fueled more stories. Fans craving similar vibes should check out 'The Book Thief' or 'All the Light We Cannot See' for that blend of historical peril and poignant friendship. Benioff moved on to screenwriting for 'Game of Thrones', so I doubt he'll revisit this universe, but the book’s cult following keeps hope alive for adaptations.

How Does 'Vow Of Thieves' Compare To 'Dance Of Thieves'?

3 answers2025-06-27 03:07:14
I tore through both books back-to-back, and while 'Dance of Thieves' hooked me with its heist dynamics and slow-burn romance, 'Vow of Thieves' cranks everything up to eleven. The sequel dives deeper into the political chaos of the Ballenger empire, with Kazi and Jase facing way higher stakes—think war councils and betrayals that hit harder than in the first book. The action scenes are more brutal, too; Kazi’s street-smart tactics clash with Jase’s strategic mind in life-or-death scenarios. What surprised me was the emotional weight. Their relationship isn’t just about sparks now—it’s tested by loyalty and sacrifice. The world-building expands beyond the desert into eerie forests and crumbling cities, making the sequel feel grander.

What Is The Setting Of 'Den Of Thieves'?

3 answers2025-06-18 18:13:17
The setting of 'Den of Thieves' is a gritty, modern-day Los Angeles that feels alive with danger and deception. The city's underworld thrives in shadowy backrooms of upscale clubs and the neon-lit streets where armored trucks become targets. It's not just about locations—it's the tension between two worlds. The elite bank robbers operate with military precision, treating heists like art forms, while the cops are equally ruthless, bending rules to catch them. The film captures LA's duality: glamorous skyline views contrasted with grimy alleyways where deals go down. The setting becomes a character itself, shaping every betrayal and bullet fired.

Is There A Sequel To 'Vow Of Thieves'?

3 answers2025-06-27 11:28:53
I just finished 'Vow of Thieves' and immediately went searching for a sequel. The ending left so many possibilities open—especially with Kazi and the political fallout in Torwerth. Right now, there isn't an official announcement for a direct sequel, but the author Mary E. Pearson has mentioned expanding the 'Dance of Thieves' universe in interviews. Fans are speculating about spin-offs focusing on side characters like Synové or Jase’s siblings. If you loved the world-building, try Pearson’s 'Remnant Chronicles' trilogy—it’s set in the same universe and has that same mix of romance and high-stakes politics. Until a sequel drops, fan theories are keeping the hype alive.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status