What Mystery Fiction Awards Recognize Short Stories And Novellas?

Question

Award listings for mystery novelettes never seem as clear as the ones for full novels. Which prizes specifically champion those shorter detective tales?

KyleHicks · Answer

The 'Best American Mystery Stories' annual anthology, edited by a guest editor each year, is essentially an award in book form. Getting included is a massive honor. While it's not a trophy, for writers and serious readers, being in that table of contents is a huge mark of quality.

I often use the past years' editions as a reading syllabus to catch up on standout short mystery fiction.

JazzBird · Answer

The translation gap is a real issue. There are incredible mystery short stories written in Spanish, French, Swedish, Japanese… but unless they get translated for a specific award-eligible publication in English, they're invisible to the Edgar, Anthony, etc. Some international awards, like the German Deutscher Krimi Preis, have short story categories, but finding translations of those winning works is another hurdle.

Occasionally, a major anthology like 'The Best American Mystery Stories' will include a translated story, and that's a huge boost. But generally, the award ecosystem for short mysteries is very Anglophone. As a reader, it's worth seeking out translated collections from big names in international crime writing—they often include shorter pieces that were award-winners in their home countries.

NicoEllis · Answer

The Agatha Awards are for 'traditional' mysteries—think cozy or historical, without explicit sex or violence. They have an Agatha for Best Short Story, and the winning stories often appear in anthologies like 'Malice Domestic' or similar collections.

It’s a great list to mine if you prefer your mysteries more about the puzzle and characters than gritty procedurals. The community around Malice Domestic is really passionate, so the nominated stories tend to be beloved by fans of the subgenre.

VeraMills · Answer

The archival value is something to consider. A story that wins a major award is preserved. It will be in databases, studied in writing classes, and included in historical overviews of the genre. It becomes part of the permanent record.

So, when we talk about awards recognizing short stories, we're also talking about canon-building. Which stories from our era will people read fifty years from now? The award winners have a leg up. They're the ones likely to be republished in 'century's best' collections. There's a weight to that. As a reader today, you're witnessing and participating in the selection of what future generations will consider the classic short mysteries of our time. That's pretty cool.

LukePrice · Answer

I get overwhelmed by awards lists. My method is simpler: I follow a few mystery critics and reviewers who specialize in short fiction. When they consistently rave about a story, I track it down. Often, those stories end up on award shortlists months later, so it feels like getting a sneak preview.

People like Sarah Weinman (who edits anthologies) or Paul D. Marks (a short story writer himself) often highlight amazing work on blogs or social media long before the award committees make their picks. It's a more personal, less institutional way to find great reads. The awards are a validation, but the initial buzz from trusted readers is what usually gets me to actually read something.

BeauBlack · Answer

I feel like novellas get the short end of the stick in mystery awards, which is a shame. They're such a perfect length for a gripping, single-sitting mystery. The novel categories often want 70k+ words, and the short story categories cap at 15-20k. That 20k to 50k zone is an award no-man's-land for a lot of organizations.

Some smaller presses and independent awards are starting to fill that gap. Things like the 'Novella Award' (though not mystery-specific) sometimes get mystery entries. Self-published mystery novellas on platforms like Amazon can also win genre-specific 'Best eBook' awards that have novella categories. It's not the traditional prestige path, but it's recognition.

TessCole · Answer

Do any awards specifically focus on the first paragraph or opening of a mystery short story? That would be cool. The hook is so crucial in short fiction. I'm not aware of one, but some writing contests for mysteries might judge on the opening page. That's more of a craft award than one for a published story, though.

Maybe someone should start one. Call it the 'Grabber Award' or something.

EmeryOwl · Answer

The 'Thriller' genre awards, like the ITW Thriller Awards, have Best Short Story categories too. While 'thriller' implies more action or suspense, the line between a mystery and a thriller short story is often paper-thin. A tightly-plotted psychological suspense piece could easily be nominated in both mystery and thriller awards.

So expanding your search to thriller awards nets you even more potential reads.

KyleBee · Answer

Let's not overlook awards that include translated work. The CWA also has the International Dagger for translated novels, but for short stories, you sometimes see translated pieces pop up in the anthology-focused awards.

For instance, if a stellar Japanese or Scandinavian crime short is translated in an anthology like 'The Best Mystery Stories of the Year,' it could be nominated for an Edgar or Anthony. It's rarer, but it happens.

DeclanFan · Answer

The reprint market is important. A story might win an award years after its initial publication if it gets reprinted in a major anthology. So, when you look at an award's eligibility period, it's not always for first publication. A story could have been in a small literary journal five years ago, then get picked up for 'The Best American Mystery Stories,' and then be eligible for awards the year the anthology comes out.

This means award lists can be a way to discover older stories that have stood the test of time. You're not just getting the hot new thing; you're getting a story that had a second life and impressed people all over again. That's a strong endorsement of its lasting power.

RheaYoung · Answer

What about awards for audio performances of short stories? The Audies have a 'Short Stories/Collections' category. A narrator bringing a mystery short to life can add a whole new layer of tension and character. An award for that performance recognizes a different art form—the performance of the mystery, not just the writing.

Some short stories are even written specifically for audio, with sound design and multiple narrators. Those might be eligible for podcasting or audio drama awards. The 'Best Mystery & Thriller Audio' at the Audies is usually for novels, but the short story collection category is where you'll find stellar performances of compact, punchy mysteries. It's a different way to experience the same award-winning writing.

JesseCook · Answer

Okay, but has anyone actually read all the stories nominated for a single award in one year? I tried it with the Derringers one time. It was fascinating to see the range of what 'counts' as a great mystery short story. You get everything from hardboiled PI tales to historicals to almost-literary character studies with a crime at the center.

It changed how I read short stories. I started paying less attention to 'whodunit' and more to how the author managed tone, pace, and revelation within the constraint of the word count. An award shortlist isn't just a reading list; it's a snapshot of the genre's current capabilities. I recommend doing it at least once if you're a serious fan of the form.

MateoFox · Answer

The economic reality is that writing mystery short stories is rarely profitable. Awards, even without big cash prizes, provide legitimacy that can help an author secure teaching positions, speaking engagements, or grants. For an emerging writer, a nomination can be the line on their bio that gets an agent to request their novel manuscript.

So when we, as readers, seek out award-winning short fiction, we're indirectly supporting the ecosystem that allows writers to practice and hone their craft in a shorter form. Buying an anthology that features award nominees tells publishers there's a market. It's a way to vote with your wallet for the kind of writing you want to see more of in the world.

What Mystery Fiction Awards Recognize Short Stories And Novellas?

13 Answers

Kaugnay na Mga Aklat

Wet Dreams: The Ultimate Steamy Short Stories Collection

Midnight Pleasure: 30 Shades Of Short Steamy Stories

WILD PLEASURE {short stories}

Burning Passion {steamiest short stories}

Sinful Desires(steamiest Short stories)

Shifter Short Stories

Kaugnay na Mga Tanong

What mystery writing awards focus on crime short stories?

What major mystery fiction awards should new readers know about?

What major mystery writing awards recognize debut novels?

Which mystery novel awards focus specifically on debut authors?

Are there awards for best novella length fiction?

Which mystery fiction awards focus on debut detective novels?

Mga Kaugnay na Paghahanap

Award-winning Mystery Novels

Murder Mysteries Short Stories

Best-selling Mystery Novels

Best Literary Mysteries

Best Mystery Novels

Best Fiction Mystery Novels

Genre Mystery Books

Top Mystery Fiction Books

Mystery Best Novels

Best Mystery/thriller Novels