What Smeagol Hobbit Fanworks Best Capture His Psychological Turmoil And Loneliness?

2025-11-21 04:17:41 185

5 Answers

Violet
Violet
2025-11-22 07:56:52
I've read a ton of fanfics digging into Smeagol's twisted psyche, and some really nail the tragic duality of his character. The best ones don't just rehash 'The Lord of the Rings' events but invent scenarios that peel back layers—like exploring his years alone in the Misty Mountains. There's this haunting AO3 fic called 'The Water's Whispers' where Smeagol talks to fish hallucinations, mirroring Gollum's later conversations with himself. The writer uses broken, repetitive language that feels ripped from his mind.

Another gem is 'Ash and Bone', which frames his corruption through flashbacks of Deagol's death. The visceral guilt and the Ring's whispers are woven together so tightly you almost sympathize before recoiling at his violence. What elevates these works is how they balance his monstrous side with glimpses of the hobbit he was—like when he sobs over stolen memories of sunlight. Lesser fics make him either a pure victim or a caricature, but the great ones sit in that awful in-between.
Liam
Liam
2025-11-24 19:36:00
I gravitate toward fics that treat Smeagol's loneliness as a slow poison. 'Fathomless' stands out—it’s a series of vignettes where he counts cracks in caves to stay sane, and the prose gets progressively more fragmented. The author doesn’t romanticize his suffering but shows how isolation warps time itself for him. Another underrated piece is 'Mouthful of Shadows', where he accidentally bonds with a wounded orc before betraying it, echoing his later relationship with Frodo. The way the orc calls him 'Stinker' as a joke, only for Smeagol to weep when killing it? Chilling. These stories work because they understand his loneliness isn’t passive; it’s active decay.
Quinn
Quinn
2025-11-25 02:14:11
Short but brutal rec: 'The Stone Song'. It’s a 5k fic where Smeagol carves Deagol’s face into rocks for 500 years. Each chapter jumps decades, and his sculptures go from detailed to grotesque. By the end, he’s just scratching lines—can’t remember the eyes. The author uses run-on sentences that mimic his unraveling thoughts. No other fic made me feel his eternity under the Ring’s weight so viscerally.
Vesper
Vesper
2025-11-26 18:46:58
I adore fics that explore Smeagol’s pre-Ring life to contextualize his later fragility. 'River’s Child' imagines his youth as a bullied hobbit who talked to frogs, making his attachment to Deagol (and subsequent guilt) even more tragic. The writing’s folksy at first, then warps alongside him. It’s not epic-length, but every sentence serves that arc—like how he stops naming animals after the murder, just calls them 'creatures.'
Wyatt
Wyatt
2025-11-27 15:48:49
For raw emotional impact, 'Hollow as a Bone' destroys me every time. It’s an AU where Smeagol resists the Ring longer, so his madness manifests as obsessive-compulsive rituals—washing hands until they bleed, rearranging pebbles in patterns only he understands. The tragedy isn’t just his fall; it’s watching him know he’s losing himself. The prose is clinical when describing his actions but lyrical in his internal monologue, creating this dissonance that mirrors his split identity. Bonus points for including hobbit folklore; his hallucinations reference children’s rhymes, making it creepier.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

To Capture His Heart
To Capture His Heart
“So, tell me about yourself Mr. Davenport?” she asks. I don’t look up from my computer, as I log in. “What do you want to know, Miss Harvey?” I ask her. "Are you perhaps dating anyone right now?" she asks. I look up at her surprised by her question. I shake my head. "No..." it’s true I’m not dating anyone right now. Her smile brightens. “That’s good.” She tells me. I frown, “Why would that be good exactly?” I ask, I look back at the screen and see Kendell hasn’t arrived at the sight yet, I’m about to tell her when she speaks again. “So Mr. Davenport, do you find little old me attractive?” she asks me. I look at her… “What are you getting at Miss Harvey?” I ask her. “Come humor me…” she tilts her head. I sigh. “I’d be a fool not to find you attractive, though I don’t know how that’s of any pertinence to right now." I tell her. She smiles. “So what do you say Mr. Davenport, or can I call you Blake?” I ask her. I have no idea what she’s up to. I choose to ignore her. She moves closer to me. “Come on now, don’t ignore me.” she says. I look at her, a little dress that leaves little to the imagination. She’s leaning onto the desk giving me a full view of her breasts. Is she hitting on me? She is hitting on me right? “So how sturdy is this desk exactly?” she asks. I take her in, it’s been four years since I’ve so much as touched a woman sexually. Hell I can’t even tell if she’s flirting with me.
10
130 Chapters
To Capture a Ring
To Capture a Ring
A young woman falls for the young billionaire he works for as a maid. After being saved from a deadly car crash, a billionaire offers a young poor woman to work in his house as his maid but fate has other plans for them.
10
14 Chapters
To Capture A Heart
To Capture A Heart
In a world where humans are classified into three types: Alpha, Omega, and Beta. Alphas can dominate Omegas through pheromones, Omegas can fool Alphas through pheromones and beauty, and betas can't detect pheromones at all. Beatrice Prieur, the omega who has outstanding beauty, but a simple girl who just wants a simple life with a man she loves. Sixinere De Beville, an Alpha who’s known as the dominant one and for his playful attitude. If a serious like Omega met her playful Alpha, can it be called love?
Not enough ratings
3 Chapters
His Best Man's Boyfriend
His Best Man's Boyfriend
"Work Hard, Play Hard" Archie is never without a beautiful woman or a glass of good scotch in his hand, which drives his ultra-wealthy, conservative parents to distraction. To force him to take life more seriously, his father threatens to name his cousin the CEO of the company Archie helped build from the ground up if he doesn't marry a girl of their choosing. To appease his parents, Archie proposes to Leticia and gives her the family heirloom ring. Archie's best friend Josh thinks he's making a big mistake and invites him for a week's holiday in Ibiza, telling him it's a stag party. With his boyfriend Charlie, Josh aims to convince Archie to face his true self and his long-buried truth. Archie initially clashes with the outgoing, gregarious Charlie, but soon finds himself drawn to him as Charlie returns the attraction, pushing Archie to explore this connection even at the risk of losing Josh's friendship. But Archie's return to the real world makes him realize that his love for Charlie could cost him the CEO position and the love of his parents. Forced to choose between a chance at true love and familial loyalty, Archie makes the ultimate decision, but either one will destroy lives and hearts.
10
13 Chapters
What?
What?
What? is a mystery story that will leave the readers question what exactly is going on with our main character. The setting is based on the islands of the Philippines. Vladimir is an established business man but is very spontaneous and outgoing. One morning, he woke up in an unfamiliar place with people whom he apparently met the night before with no recollection of who he is and how he got there. He was in an island resort owned by Noah, I hot entrepreneur who is willing to take care of him and give him shelter until he regains his memory. Meanwhile, back in the mainland, Vladimir is allegedly reported missing by his family and led by his husband, Andrew and his friend Davin and Victor. Vladimir's loved ones are on a mission to find him in anyway possible. Will Vlad regain his memory while on Noah's Island? Will Andrew find any leads on how to find Vladimir?
10
5 Chapters
What It Means to be His
What It Means to be His
Lia lives a quiet life in a small two-bedroom home on the outskirts of a major city. Between playing piano at a piano gallery, waitressing at a high-end restaurant, and her never ending love for books, she never thought there would be anything more to life. She was content. At least she thought so. It wasn't until she went out with her best friend and had a hot encounter with a large and sexy stranger. One moment they are flirting in a booth, the next she's rushing out of an expensive hotel room after waking up naked beside the handsome stranger. After living through her first one-night stand, she decided to leave it at that. But what she wasn't expecting was to be hunted down by the most dangerous man in the country. Turns out, the man from her one-night stand held more mystery than she thought. Now she must determine whether to find some way to be comfortable with his lifestyle and embrace the kind of love she only seen in her romance novels or to stick with her morals and let this relationship go. That is, if he lets her...
10
60 Chapters

Related Questions

What Would A Smeagol Harry Potter Patronus Represent?

4 Answers2025-08-23 21:24:50
I've been scribbling marginalia in my copy of 'The Lord of the Rings' for years, and the idea of a Smeagol-shaped Patronus made me smile and wince at once. Imagine the Patronus as a flicker of someone's truest, most defended memory—if Smeagol were your Patronus, it would scream of survival, shame, and a clinging, battered tenderness. That tiny, furtive figure would represent the part of you that has been cornered by obsession and hurt, yet still refuses to disappear. On the bright side, a Smeagol Patronus could also be a strange badge of resilience. It would remind you that even damaged things can protect you; the Patronus doesn't judge the origin of its form, it only reacts to the light within. So this Patronus would carry complicated signals—warning to stay vigilant against your darker compulsions, but also a whisper that the soft, human part can still save you if you feed it with kinder memories. I think about this when I reread scenes where Smeagol dims into Gollum, and I picture someone confronting their own shadows with a trembling, honest charm. It wouldn't be pretty, but it would be truthful—and sometimes truth is exactly the kind of shield you need.

Are There Official Smeagol Harry Potter Mashups Or Only Fan Art?

4 Answers2025-08-23 17:54:19
I've dug through a lot of corners online and the short, candid truth is: there aren't any official crossovers that mash up Sméagol (or Gollum) with 'Harry Potter' from the rights holders. Both universes are tightly controlled—'The Lord of the Rings' material is handled separately from 'Harry Potter'—so an authorized, canonical blend of those characters just hasn't happened. What you will find everywhere, though, is fan creativity: art, comics, cosplay mashups, memes, and fanfiction where someone gleefully imagines Sméagol in a Hogwarts robe or casting weird little spells. I love hunting through DeviantArt, Tumblr, and Instagram for those quirky takes; sometimes creators even make clever commissions or prints on Etsy and Redbubble. Just be careful: commercial sellers sometimes get notices, and platforms will remove infringing or infringing-appearing items. If you want something durable, support an artist directly and check whether they’re open to commissions instead of buying mass-produced bootlegs. Bottom line—official? No. Delightful, inventive fan stuff? Absolutely yes, and it’s my go-to for a laugh or a new aesthetic. If you like, I can point you toward subreddits or tags where the best mashups bubble up.

What Role Do Woodland Elves Play In The Hobbit Movie Adaptations?

5 Answers2025-09-26 11:19:01
In the 'Hobbit' movie adaptations, woodland elves, particularly represented by Thranduil's realm in Mirkwood, have a visually stunning and significant role. These elves are portrayed with a kind of ethereal beauty and an air of mystery, which really adds to the film's overall fantasy aesthetic. I absolutely love how director Peter Jackson made them feel both regal and somewhat aloof, capturing that classic elf demeanor. Thranduil, with his flowing hair and majestic presence, really stands out as both a protector and a proud leader, but there's also depth in his character that showcases his struggles and motivations. Their interactions with the dwarves, particularly in scenes showcasing their capture of Thorin and his companions, illustrate the theme of mistrust and misunderstanding that runs through Tolkien's work. Watching the elves navigate these tense dynamics was fascinating! It's like they’re caught between their own ancient practices and the chaos brewing across Middle-earth. I also appreciate how the elves show that ancient wisdom and beauty don’t necessarily imply passivity; they engage actively in the unfolding conflicts, especially when it comes to the Battle of the Five Armies. Plenty of epic action moments feature them, like their combat skills and agility, which just feel so perfectly elven! All in all, the woodland elves in these adaptations do more than just add pretty visuals; they enrich the narrative and bring a bit of that high fantasy elf charm that we're always excited to see!

What Unique Traits Do Woodland Elves From The Hobbit Possess?

5 Answers2025-09-26 07:07:01
Woodland elves in 'The Hobbit' have this enchanting aura that really sets them apart from other races in Middle-earth. Their grace and agility seem almost supernatural, allowing them to move silently through the trees, blending into the environment like shadows. That connection to nature gives them a certain ethereal beauty, don’t you think? Just look at Legolas! But it's not just their physical traits; they also possess an innate wisdom, having lived for centuries, which makes their perspective on life quite unique. Their culture thrives in the beauty of their surroundings, adoring music, art, and festivities that honor nature. They have a knack for crafting amazing bows and arrows, reflecting their deep understanding of woodland realms. You see that beautifully illustrated in the elven architecture of Mirkwood, where their homes appear to grow from the trees rather than disrupt nature—it's really poetic! I sometimes wish I could just stroll through those enchanting woods, soaking in the vibrant atmosphere and hidden secrets. And let’s not forget their elusiveness; they can be quite mysterious, often appearing suddenly or vanishing without a trace. There’s something intriguing about that, creating an air of magic and wonder around them. Isn't it wild how these traits, from their movement to their musical talents, weave together a tapestry of character that captures the imagination?

How Long Is 'The Hobbit' Compared To 'Lord Of The Rings'?

4 Answers2025-09-07 12:01:51
Oh man, comparing 'The Hobbit' to 'Lord of the Rings' is like comparing a cozy campfire story to an epic symphony! 'The Hobbit' is way shorter—around 300 pages depending on the edition, while the full 'LOTR' trilogy spans over 1,000 pages. Tolkien originally wrote 'The Hobbit' as a children's book, so it's snappier and more whimsical, with fewer digressions. But 'LOTR'? That thing sprawls with lore, multiple plotlines, and dense world-building. It's a commitment, whereas 'The Hobbit' feels like a weekend adventure. That said, I love how 'The Hobbit' eases you into Middle-earth. It’s like a gateway drug—once you finish it, you’re itching for the heavier stuff. The pacing is totally different too; 'LOTR' takes its time, especially in 'The Fellowship,' where the Shire chapters alone could be a novella. Meanwhile, 'The Hobbit' jumps right into Bilbo’s unexpected journey. Both are masterpieces, but one’s a sprint and the other’s a marathon.

What Races Appear In Both 'The Hobbit' And 'Lord Of The Rings'?

5 Answers2025-09-07 21:07:32
Man, I could talk about Middle-earth all day! Both 'The Hobbit' and 'Lord of the Rings' feature some iconic races that make Tolkien's world feel so rich. Obviously, you've got humans—though they're more prominent in LOTR with characters like Aragorn and Boromir. Then there are dwarves, with Thorin's Company taking center stage in 'The Hobbit' and Gimli bringing the axe-swinging charm in LOTR. Elves are everywhere too, from Legolas’s sharpshooting to Thranduil’s drama in Mirkwood. Hobbits are the heart of both stories, though Bilbo’s more of a reluctant adventurer compared to Frodo’s burdened heroism. And let’s not forget the villains! Orcs and goblins (which are pretty much the same thing in Tolkien’s lore) pop up in both, whether it’s the Battle of Five Armies or the mines of Moria. Oh, and trolls—those dimwitted brutes appear in both, though they’re way scarier in LOTR. Honestly, revisiting these races makes me wanna rewatch the movies tonight!

What Inspired Tolkien To Write The Hobbit?

2 Answers2025-09-01 13:15:51
Just thinking about the origins of 'The Hobbit' gets me excited! Tolkien’s journey into the world of Middle-earth was fueled by his love for mythology and linguistics. Imagine a professor, surrounded by books, scribbling away in his spare time, contemplating the intricacies of language. Tolkien, with his deep affection for ancient lore, wanted to create something unique. His inspiration struck when he began to put together a tale for his children, capturing their imaginations and his own. You can almost picture him telling bedtime stories, shaping a whole universe filled with hobbits, dragons, and adventures. The creation of 'The Hobbit' blossomed from his interest in nature and the landscapes that brought him joy. He took inspiration from the rolling hills of the English countryside, where he often wandered, bursting with ideas for adventures waiting to unfold beneath the sunlit skies. The beauty of simple things—a meal shared, a friendship kindled, and the courage found within—definitely influenced his writing. Plus, let’s not forget his experiences in World War I. Those challenging times made him yearn for escape and wonder, something to uplift the spirit, which translated beautifully into the charm of the Shire and the thrill of quests. Every page brims with echoes of both his personal life and broader human themes, making it such a relatable tale. I'm really drawn to how it combines fantasy with a sense of home, a journey that reflects our own lives. What strikes me the most is how he wasn't just telling a story for children. Beneath the surface, there are themes of loss, friendship, and the quest for identity. It resonates with many of us, doesn't it? Exploring terrains unknown, battling inner fears—what a ride! It’s amazing that a simple bedtime story led to an epic saga that influences countless works even today, reminding us just how powerful storytelling can be.

Why Did J.R.R. Tolkien Write The Hobbit Novel?

4 Answers2025-08-30 18:53:17
There’s something very cozy about how 'The Hobbit' began — for me it always feels like a bedtime story that grew legs. I like to imagine J.R.R. Tolkien sitting down to amuse a small group, because, in a way, that’s exactly what happened: he wrote the tale largely to entertain children (his own and others) and because he loved telling stories. He was a language nerd through and through, and his fascination with words and old myths naturally bubbled into a charming little narrative about a reluctant hero, treasure, and dragons. Beyond the immediate spark, though, he had broader intentions. Tolkien’s work on ancient languages and northern mythologies meant he wanted to create a world that felt rooted and real. 'The Hobbit' started as something light but tapped into deeper veins of folklore, philology, and his desire to craft stories that felt like genuine myth. Publishers and a bit of luck helped it reach readers, and the book’s success convinced him to dive further into his legendarium — which eventually led him to expand into 'The Lord of the Rings'. For me, the book’s origin is a lovely mix of private amusement and a scholar’s restless creativity — it’s like finding a small sketch that becomes a sprawling painting, and I still love rereading it when I need to feel small and adventurous at the same time.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status