Chapter Four- The Stranger in the Corner Booth

By the fourth night, Jamie knew better than to pretend the corner booth was empty. Even when it was. Bar Della Luna remembered people. Not in the sentimental way; no nostalgia, no warmth but like a ledger. Inked entries. Names written once and never crossed out. The booth carried that same memory now, a presence that lingered even when Adrian wasn’t there, like the shape a body left behind on a bed.

Jamie hated that he noticed. Hated that his eyes drifted there between orders, that his shoulders relaxed a fraction when he saw it occupied, that his chest tightened when it wasn’t. He told himself it was routine. Pattern recognition. Nothing more. “Stop staring holes in the furniture,” Mara murmured as she slid past him with a tray. “You’ll scare it.”

Jamie startled. “I wasn’t.” She gave him a look. The kind that said she’d been doing this long enough to recognize lies even when they were gentle. “Uh-huh.”

The bar was full early tonight. A corporate crowd, pressed shirts, loosened ties, voices pitched too loud like confidence was something you could fake by volume. Jamie moved through them smoothly, smile in place, hands steady. He took pride in that. In competence. In the small, private satisfaction of doing something well even when no one noticed. Still, the booth pulled at him. He wiped the counter again. Checked the clock. 9:42.

Too early, he told himself. Adrian came late. After midnight. When the city thinned and the masks slipped. Jamie felt ridiculous waiting. The door opened.

Not Adrian. A man stepped in alone, tall and broad-shouldered, coat still buttoned despite the warmth inside. He paused just long enough to scan the room, eyes sharp and assessing, before moving with purpose toward the corner booth. Jamie stiffened. People didn’t choose that seat. They were directed to it, invited or they didn’t sit there at all. The man slid into the booth like he belonged. Something in Jamie’s chest went cold.

“Who’s that?” Evan asked, appearing at the bar with his usual lack of subtlety, eyes bright with curiosity. “He looks like trouble.” Jamie forced his gaze away. “Everyone here looks like trouble.”

“That’s not what I mean.” Jamie didn’t answer. He watched from the corner of his eye as Mara hesitated near the booth, then approached. The man said something low, Mara nodded quickly and retreated, expression tight. She came straight to Jamie. “Take that table,” she said quietly.

Jamie blinked. “Me?”

“Yes. And don’t argue.” His stomach dropped. “Mara….”

“Jamie,” she cut in, eyes flicking toward the booth. “Please.” That did it. He grabbed a glass, wiped it though it didn’t need it, and walked. Up close, the man looked older than Adrian. Late thirties, maybe. Hair dark, cut short. His eyes were a pale, unsettling gray, like fog over steel. He didn’t smile when Jamie approached. Didn’t frown either. Just watched. “Whiskey,” the man said. His accent was Italian, thicker than Adrian’s. Less polished. “Neat.” Jamie nodded. His hands felt clumsy as he poured, awareness prickling along his spine. He returned and set the glass down carefully.

“Anything else?” Jamie asked. The man’s gaze flicked to Jamie’s name tag. “Jamie Reed.” Jamie’s breath caught. “Yes?”

The man’s mouth curved, just barely. “You work hard.” Jamie bristled. “Do I know you?”

“No.”

“Then….”

“You know someone who does.” The air felt thinner. Jamie straightened. “I’m busy.”

“So I see.” The man lifted his glass but didn’t drink. “Tell Adrian DeLuca I stopped by.” Jamie stared. “Who?” The man’s eyes sharpened. “You heard me.”

“I… I don’t….” The man leaned back, assessing him openly now. “Interesting.” Jamie felt suddenly exposed, like a wire pulled too tight. “If that’s all….”

“It is,” the man said. “For now.” Jamie turned away on unsteady legs, heart pounding too loud in his ears. He didn’t look back. He didn’t need to. He could feel the man’s gaze linger, cool and deliberate, like a blade resting against skin without pressing. At the bar, Evan leaned in. “You look like you’ve seen a ghost.” Jamie swallowed. “That guy knows my name.” Evan’s smile faded. “What?”

“And Adrian’s.” That wiped the humor clean off Evan’s face. “Jamie.”

“I know,” Jamie said. “I know.” The stranger left ten minutes later without finishing his drink. The booth felt colder after. Adrian arrived just before midnight. The shift was immediate, subtle, but real. The room adjusted around him, like it always did; voices lowering, bodies shifting unconsciously out of his path. Jamie felt it in his bones, a familiar tension that settled somewhere between anticipation and dread. Their eyes met across the bar. Adrian frowned.

He crossed the room without sitting, stopping in front of the bar instead. Close enough that Jamie could see the muscle jump in his jaw. “You spoke to someone,” Adrian said quietly. Jamie blinked. “Hello to you too.”

Adrian didn’t smile. “Jamie.” The way he said his name; firm, edged, sent a shiver through him. “Yeah. I did.”

“Who.” Jamie hesitated. He didn’t know why. Loyalty, maybe or instinct. “A man, he sat in your booth.” Adrian’s eyes flicked toward it, then back. Something dark moved behind them. “Did he touch you?”

“No.”

“Threaten you?”

“I don’t know,” Jamie said honestly. “He knew my name.” That did it. Adrian’s control cracked, just a hairline fracture, but Jamie saw it. His hand tightened on the edge of the bar.

“What did he say?” Adrian asked. “That I work hard,” Jamie said, then huffed a humorless laugh. “And that I should tell you he stopped by.” Adrian closed his eyes briefly, like he was counting. When he opened them, his gaze was sharp and focused. “You’re done for the night,” he said.

Jamie stiffened. “I still have….”

“You’re done,” Adrian repeated. Softer now, but no less certain. “I’ll handle Mara.”

“I don’t need you to….”

“Yes,” Adrian said. “You do.” Jamie’s chest tightened. “You can’t just decide things for me.” Adrian leaned closer, lowering his voice. “Someone from my world noticed you, that changes things.” Jamie stared at him. “Your world?” Adrian held his gaze, expression unreadable. “The man’s name is Marco Bellini.” Jamie’s stomach dropped. “Should I know who that is?”

“No,” Adrian said. “And I intend to keep it that way.” Jamie laughed, sharp and disbelieving. “That’s not reassuring.”

“It’s honest.” Mara appeared, eyes flicking between them. “Everything okay?”

“Yes,” Adrian said smoothly. “Jamie’s leaving early.” Jamie shot him a look. Mara raised an eyebrow but nodded. “Go,” she said. “I’ll cover.” Jamie untied his apron with stiff fingers, anger buzzing under his skin. He grabbed his jacket and turned back to Adrian. “You don’t get to control my life.” Adrian’s gaze softened, just enough to be dangerous. “I’m trying to keep it intact.”

Outside, the night pressed close, the street quieter than it should have been. Adrian stood beside him, presence steady, grounding in a way Jamie resented. “Who was he really?” Jamie asked. Adrian didn’t answer right away. They started walking. “Someone who wants to know what I care about,” Adrian said finally. Jamie scoffed. “You barely know me.” Adrian stopped. Jamie took another step before realizing, then turned. Adrian’s eyes were dark, intent. “I know enough.”

Jamie’s breath hitched. “That’s what you said the first night.”

“And it’s truer now.” Silence stretched between them. A car passed at the end of the street, headlights sweeping briefly over their faces, illuminating the tension etched there. “You should stay away from me,” Jamie said quietly. Adrian shook his head. “It’s too late for that.”

“For what?” Adrian stepped closer, just inside Jamie’s space, not touching. “For pretending you’re not already involved.” Jamie swallowed. His heart pounded, loud and traitorous. “I didn’t choose this.”

“No,” Adrian agreed. “But you can choose what comes next.” Jamie laughed softly, bitter. “Those aren’t the same thing.” Adrian didn’t argue.

From somewhere unseen, Marco Bellini watched the city lights and smiled, already certain he’d found Adrian DeLuca’s weakness. And in Bar Della Luna, the corner booth waited, patient and knowing, for the next stranger brave or foolish enough to claim it.