CHAPTER 5: THE OTHER MAN

Sebastian Hale hadn’t just found me. He’d been watching my company grow for over a year, making sure I would come back, and I walked right into his trap like it was the best business decision I’d ever made.

I checked it the next morning.

It took forty minutes, one old contact at a corporate filing service, and the kind of cold patience I’d learned after sixteen years of hiding. The paperwork was right there in his internal files, standing instructions set up fourteen months earlier under some boring “events” heading.

My company name had been flagged for the first big contract that came along. He hadn’t stumbled across me, he had been waiting and planning. Making it look completely normal.

I sat at my kitchen table at seven in the morning, staring at the screen until my coffee went cold. Anger would’ve been easy and clean, but what I felt was colder and sharper, like a block of ice settling deep in my stomach and twisting everything I thought I knew.

A man who was surprised to see me would’ve been one kind of problem. A man who had spent fourteen months quietly setting this up was something much worse. It meant he had a plan, and I still didn’t know what it was.

My chest felt tight, like I couldn’t quite catch my breath. I closed the file, got dressed, and went to the meeting anyway. My hands shook a little as I buttoned my coat.

------

The third meeting was a site visit at the venue, a big converted space in Midtown with good bones but tricky sound. Patricia showed up with two junior staff. I got there early on purpose.

Sebastian arrived four minutes later. He was adjusting his schedule around mine. I noticed, and I filed it away.

I smiled at Patricia and asked about the ceiling height. The visit lasted ninety minutes. I walked every inch of the place with my notebook, asking questions I already knew the answers to. It was the quickest way to see how people really thought.

Patricia was careful, a little nervous. The juniors kept looking at Sebastian on anything about the building. He stayed two steps behind me most of the time, not crowding me, just there. Quiet and steady, the way he used to be.

But today I watched him differently. Not with old feelings. With cold strategy.

I watched how he moved through the room, sure of himself without showing off. I watched how his staff looked at him, respectful, but not scared.

I watched his hands when he pointed out the speaker problem on the east wall. The same hands that once left a little Post-it note on the kitchen counter that said “for the folder.”

The memory tried to sneak in, warm and painful. I shut it down hard, but it still left a sting in my chest. I turned to Patricia and asked about the catering doors instead.

------

“You’re looking at me differently today,” Sebastian said quietly.

We were standing near the north entrance while Patricia talked to the venue manager across the room.

I turned to him. “Looking at you, how?”

“Like you’re studying me. Assessing every move.” His eyes didn’t leave mine. “On Tuesday it felt different. Today it feels… colder.”

I kept my face blank even though my chest tightened. “You’re a client, Mr. Hale. Assessment is part of the job.”

“Naomi.” His voice dropped, rough around the edges, almost pleading. “You don’t have to freeze me out like this. Talk to me.”

“Mr. Hale,” I said, keeping my tone pleasant but sharp, “the east wall speaker issue you mentioned on Tuesday, I’d like to walk it again before we leave.”

He paused, jaw tight. Something raw flashed in his eyes, not quite pain, more like a man swallowing a consequence he’d known was coming. “Of course,” he said finally, voice low. “Whatever you need.”

We walked over together. He explained the acoustic problem with clear, focused words. He’d done his homework. I took notes, my pen digging into the paper harder than it needed to. Inside, my stomach churned with anger, confusion, and something I couldn’t name.

------

I was gathering my things to leave when Patricia finished with the venue manager. Sebastian was talking to one of the juniors near the main entrance.

I headed down the corridor toward the exit alone. I think better when I’m moving, and right now I had too much spinning in my head.

“Ms. Reed.”

The voice came from behind me. Not Sebastian’s. Lighter. Easier. Like a man who was comfortable everywhere and had chosen to be comfortable here.

I turned.

He looked about Sebastian’s age, maybe a little older. Thirty-two or so. Relaxed shoulders, warm brown eyes that noticed everything even though his smile tried to hide it. He held out his hand.

“Ethan Cross,” he said. “I work with Sebastian. Loosely.”

I shook his hand. “Naomi Reed.”

“I know.” He held the handshake a second longer than normal, not aggressive, just making sure I paid attention. His voice lowered. “I’ve been wanting to do that for sixteen long years.”

My whole body went still. My heart slammed against my ribs so hard it hurt. He saw it and gave a small nod, like I had just proved something to him.

“There are things about the wedding you don’t know,” he said quietly, his tone even but urgent, like he’d practiced these words many times. “Things that would change everything you think happened back then. The whole damn story. When you’re ready to hear the truth, I’m not hard to find.”

He let go of my hand and stepped back, giving me space. Then he walked away toward the entrance with his hands in his pockets, slow and calm, like he had finally done something he’d waited sixteen years to do.

I stood frozen in the corridor, staring at the empty space where he had been. My mind spun wildly. My chest felt squeezed until I could barely breathe.

Sixteen years of pain. Sixteen years of building walls. Sixteen years of raising Isla alone while I told myself the story that kept me strong.

And now that ground suddenly felt shaky, like the floor under my feet had cracked open.

“Things that would change the shape of what you think happened.”

I had built my whole life around the story I thought was true– my company, my rules, my plan to come back here and make Sebastian pay. The nights I comforted a little girl who asked why she didn’t have a dad. The rage that kept me going when I wanted to fall apart.

That story had been my foundation. Now someone had just told me the foundation might be fake.

I walked out into the afternoon air, heart pounding so hard I felt sick. Tears burned behind my eyes, hot and angry, but I refused to let them fall. My hands clenched into fists at my sides until my nails dug into my palms.

Who the hell was Ethan Cross?

What did he know that I didn’t?

What if everything I believed about Sebastian, about the wedding, about why he left, about why I had to run… was a lie?

What if I had spent sixteen years hating the wrong man?

What if my revenge had been aimed at the wrong heart?

And what if the truth was even worse than the lie I’d been living with all this time?