CHAPTER 6- BETWEEN THEM

Maya

I woke up aching.

Not just between my legs — everywhere. My hips, my thighs, the places their hands had gripped me. Even after sleeping, my body still felt marked. I lay still in the dark and tried to ignore the way heat already pooled low in my stomach at the memory.

My phone lit up on the nightstand.

Noah: Come over.

Theo: Don’t make us wait.

No location. No time. Just the order.

I stared at the screen for a long time. Part of me wanted to ignore it. To roll over, go back to sleep, and pretend I still had control. The bigger part of me was already pushing the covers off.

I got dressed quietly so I wouldn’t wake Lila. Skirt. Loose sweater. No underwear, because I already knew what they preferred. My hands were unsteady as I locked the dorm door behind me.

They were waiting for me in the private lot behind the old student center. Noah leaned against his black car, arms crossed. Theo sat on the hood, legs spread, watching me walk toward them with that lazy half-smile that never quite reached his eyes.

“You came,” Noah said.

“You told me to.”

Theo’s smile widened. “Good answer.”

Noah opened the back door of the car. “Get in.”

I slid into the back seat. The second the doors closed, the air felt heavier. Noah drove. Theo turned in the front passenger seat so he could look at me.

“You’ve been thinking about us,” Theo said. It wasn’t a question.

I swallowed. “Yes.”

“How much?”

I hesitated. Honesty felt dangerous, but lying felt worse. “Too much.”

Noah’s eyes met mine in the rearview mirror. “Good.”

They took me to an off-campus apartment I hadn’t seen before — clean, expensive, clearly one of theirs. The second the door locked behind us, the dynamic shifted.

Noah turned to me first. “Clothes off.”

I pulled the sweater over my head, then pushed the skirt down. Cool air hit my skin. Both of them watched me without speaking, eyes dark, assessing.

Theo walked in a slow circle around me. “She’s still marked from the other night.” His fingers brushed the faint bruises on my hips. “Looks good.”

Noah stepped closer, gripped my chin, and forced me to look at him. “We’re not rushing you into everything at once. But we are going to start getting your body used to more.” His voice dropped. “You’re going to take both of us eventually. Properly. Until then, we train you.”

My pulse hammered.

They led me to the wide couch. Noah sat down and pulled me onto his lap so I was straddling him, naked while he was still fully dressed. His hands settled on my waist.

“Ride me,” he said quietly. “Slow.”

I reached between us, freed his cock, and sank down onto him inch by inch. The stretch made me gasp. Even after everything, he still felt thick enough to force my body to adjust. When I was fully seated, he held my hips still.

“Don’t move yet.”

Theo moved behind me. I felt him kneel on the couch, then the slick press of his fingers between my cheeks, rubbing lube against my back entrance. I tensed automatically.

“Relax,” Theo murmured against my ear. “I’m not fucking you there today. Just getting you used to the feeling.”

He pushed one finger into me slowly while Noah stayed buried deep in my pussy. The dual sensation made my breath stutter. It felt strange, intense, too full even with just a finger.

Noah’s eyes stayed locked on mine. “How does it feel?”

“Full,” I whispered.

“You’ll get fuller.”

Theo worked his finger slowly, then added a second, stretching me carefully while I sat impaled on Noah’s cock. The pressure made my thighs shake. Noah finally let me move, guiding my hips so I was riding him in short, deep strokes while Theo’s fingers stayed inside me.

The combination was overwhelming. Every time I sank down on Noah, I felt Theo’s fingers deeper. My clit rubbed against Noah’s stomach. Pleasure built fast and sharp.

“You’re clenching,” Noah observed. His voice was rough. “You like being filled by both of us.”

I couldn’t deny it. My body was already chasing the feeling, moving faster despite the stretch.

Theo’s free hand reached around and rubbed my clit. “Come whenever you need to. This time we won’t stop you.”

I broke with a choked moan, walls fluttering around Noah’s cock and Theo’s fingers. They worked me through it until I was shaking and oversensitive.

Only then did Noah lift me off him. Cum was already starting to leak out of me. He turned me around so I was on my hands and knees on the couch, then pushed back into my pussy from behind. Theo moved in front of me, cock hard and waiting.

“Open.”

I took him into my mouth. They fucked me like that — Noah deep and steady from behind, Theo using my mouth with controlled thrusts. The wet sounds of both ends being used filled the apartment. I gagged and drooled and still pushed back for more.

Noah came first, gripping my hips hard as he flooded my pussy. Theo followed soon after, spilling across my tongue with a low curse.

They didn’t let me collapse right away. Noah pulled out and watched his cum drip down my thighs. Theo wiped my mouth with his thumb and made me look up at both of them.

“This is how it’s going to be,” Noah said quietly. “We take. You give. And every time you think you’ve had enough, we’ll push you a little further.”

Theo’s eyes were still dark. “You’re not ready for both of us at the same time yet. But you will be.”

I was still trying to catch my breath when Noah’s phone buzzed. He glanced at the screen, and something cold passed through his expression.

He showed the phone to Theo. Theo’s jaw tightened.

Noah looked back at me.

“Get dressed. We’re leaving.”

My stomach dropped. “What happened?”

Noah’s voice was calm, but his eyes were sharp.

“Someone sent us a photo. Of you. From the other night on the roof.”

He turned the phone so I could see it.

It was a clear image of me bent over the wall, Noah behind me, Theo’s hand in my hair.

And it had been sent from an anonymous number.