All Chapters of A Love That Shouldn't Be: Chapter 71 - Chapter 80

Mike gently pulled out slightly and desperately tried to hide his actions under the blankets they were sharing. His cock popped out her pussy briefly, and he quickly pushed it back inside, pulling Emma's hips towards him and causing more movement than he'd intended. Her eyes were closed but she was shifting her hips back and forth, urging his cock back inside and gasped as he replaced it. With that, she began to feel an orgasm stirring, and buried her face in Danni's side, unintentionally pressing into her right breast with her face.Danni stifled a giggle as Emma's hand shifted around to her stomach, tickling her accidentally. Her younger sister's hand was squeezing her tightly as an orgasm worked its way through her, the younger girls hips moving back and forth of their own volition. Lost in the passion of the moment, Emma began to gently squeeze her sister's breast, working upwards to gently pinch her nipple.Danni wasn't in any position to move her sister's hand and certainly didn

But he gently tugged the slightest bit at the towel wrapped around her. It had been just barely hanging there so it fell away easily. She seemed not to notice and soon he felt her breasts pushing into his chest as he ran the same hand along her back, gently squeezing her naked ass and back up again.He stopped for a second, and the spell was broken. She hurriedly reached for the towel. Dropping to her knees, she pulled it up around her as she knelt. She looked up at him and was afforded a perfect view of the large bulge at his crotch.She stared wide-eyed at it as she rose, glancing back up at him."Is that because of me?" she asked.He blushed quickly, embarrassed that she'd noticed for some odd reason, but eventually shrugged and nodded."I told you. You're beautiful." he said. "Why is it so hard to believe that you turn me on, too."She shrugged and bit her bottom lip nervously, and a long silence passed between them."So, can uh..." she started.He peered at her curiously, wonderi

Back downstairs, the girls decided to invite a few friends each, and began making plans as to games and such. Mike wondered what surprises the night might hold for him, and decided to head outside to make the back yard presentable, just in case the girls ended up back there."What about my 'free day?' I can't very well use it to make you do anything while you are doing chores and shit."'Well, no. But don't you see the opportunities that tonight might present? Who knows what will happen. Girls can get awful freaky at slumber parties.'"Freaky?"'Yup.'"Well, alright. You get a reprieve for one day on our bet. But, you've got to start listening to my suggestions more. You saw what happened with Beth. We were right there."Mike smiled, but didn't answer. He dressed and went downstairs to clean the yard, pool, and hot tub.******The girls all began to make phone calls, and texting friends. Emma had three friends that were coming over, Becca, Ashley, and Tina. Danni asked Megan to come,

"Just one night? She can't be serious. This is a joke right. They've got some kind of scheme cooked up, and are going to surprise us, right? RIGHT?""What do you think ya'll will do tonight?" Mike asked with a smile.Danni shrugged. "Just the regular slumber party girly stuff, I'd imagine. We'll try on lingerie, model it for each other, play with each other's boobs, beg each other to lick each other's pussies, talk about how much we love dick, and talk you into just watching us do it all. Stuff like that.""Wait, is she serious?""Smartass," Mike laughed and shook his head, and went back to clipping the hedge.Danni laughed. "Movies, talking, maybe some swimming." she said."Sounds like a real hoot," Mike said."Hoot, my ass.""Yeah," added Danni, "I'm sure you're going to just hate having to watch out for a bunch of nineteen to twenty-five year old girls running around in their underwear, bikinis or maybe even skinny dipping.""Underwear, bikinis, AND skinning dipping? And no pussy?

In the other room, Ashley had begun gushing over Mike as soon as he'd disappeared. "Oh my god he is soooo cute!"She had always been taken with Mike, and had a serious crush on him. She was a cute little redhead, small framed and almost no breasts, skinny, but still, very cute.Emma rolled her eyes as she had been expected to, keeping up the appearances of the disgusted sister. "It's just Mike," she said, glancing over at Danni who was biting her lip and trying not to laugh."Come on Emma, he's so hot." Tina said. Tina was a dark-haired Asian girl, but had dyed parts of her hair purple.Emma made a face and glanced over. "He's my brother for crying out loud. I don't think anything about that."Becca laughed. "He really is cute," she agreed, "but even you have to admit, he's got a great butt." she giggled, and the rest of the girls started laughing along with her.Becca had raven black hair and was thin, though not as thin as Ashley.Danni stopped laughing finally and turned to Becca.