Why Was 'A Child Called "It"' Banned In Some Schools?

2025-06-14 17:21:34 321

3 Answers

Anna
Anna
2025-06-16 02:01:11
From a literary perspective, the banning of 'A Child Called "It"' reflects society's discomfort with uncomfortable truths. The book doesn't just describe abuse - it forces readers to visualize a mother systematically dehumanizing her child, referring to him as 'It.' That psychological aspect might be why some schools pull it from shelves. They aren't just protecting kids from gore; they're shielding them from contemplating how easily humanity can be stripped away.

The educational counterargument is powerful though. This memoir gives students vocabulary to describe abuse patterns they might otherwise normalize. When Dave's mother makes him vomit so she can force-feed him the vomit, or when she invents 'games' to torture him, these aren't just shock value - they're textbook examples of abusive tactics.

Interestingly, the bans rarely hold because teachers keep fighting for it. Many argue that sanitizing literature does students a disservice, especially when real children endure similar horrors daily. The book's lasting presence in many curricula proves its value outweighs the discomfort.
Ivan
Ivan
2025-06-19 06:50:22
I understand why some schools banned it. The book's graphic depiction of child abuse is extremely intense, showing physical torture, psychological manipulation, and severe neglect in brutal detail. Some educators worry younger readers might find the scenes too disturbing, like when the mother forces the boy to eat feces or burns his arm on a stove. While the story ultimately celebrates survival, the relentless cruelty could potentially traumatize sensitive students. Schools that banned it often cite concerns about triggering abuse victims or normalizing violence. But personally, I think hiding such stories does more harm than good - awareness prevents abuse.
Samuel
Samuel
2025-06-20 18:58:12
Having followed numerous book debates, 'A Child Called "It"' gets banned primarily for its explicit content, but the reasons run deeper. The autobiographical account of Dave Pelzer's abuse presents ethical dilemmas for educators. On one hand, it exposes horrific realities of child abuse that society often ignores. The scenes where Dave starves while his family eats, or gets stabbed by his mother, are necessary to understand abuse dynamics. But schools argue these passages could retraumatize students who've experienced similar situations.

Another concern is the book's perceived lack of redemption. Unlike other banned books that get challenged for political reasons, this one faces opposition because some believe its unrelenting darkness offers no constructive lesson. Critics say it doesn't sufficiently address recovery or healing, focusing overwhelmingly on suffering. Supporters counter that the raw honesty helps readers recognize abuse symptoms in real life.

What fascinates me is how the bans vary by region. Conservative districts often cite 'inappropriate material,' while liberal areas sometimes ban it for potentially retraumatizing marginalized students. The debate showcases how censorship isn't always black and white - even well-intentioned protections can silence important voices.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Winning His Ex-Wife Back
Winning His Ex-Wife Back
Treated like a piece of trash by her husband whom she was forced into an arranged marriage with, Aliya tried to make her marriage work, despite her husband's cruel attitude toward her. She thought she could eventually change his mind from hating her, however, she realized along the line that some things are better left the way they are, to avoid destruction. Since she couldn't keep up with her husband promiscuous lifestyle and hurting her emotionally, Aliya decided to escape from this hell of a marriage when she was pregnant, but things changed with her husband as soon as she left, as the young man realized he couldn't do without her. Will she come back to the man that treated her like a piece of trash before? Will she find happiness and peace in her marriage even if she decided to come back?
8.8
148 Chapters
Irresistible Boss: Succumbing to Your Touch
Irresistible Boss: Succumbing to Your Touch
Catherine Vergara accepts her friend's invitation to a party to avoid attending her cousin's wedding, who had betrayed her with her ex-boyfriend. She has a fleeting encounter with a stranger at the party and becomes pregnant by a man whose identity she doesn't know and could never find. She keeps the memory of this stranger until she meets Alexander Miller when she starts working as an executive assistant to this stressed, impatient, and incredibly handsome CEO at a major company. But Alexander didn't want to get involved with her. He was searching for a woman who simply vanished.
9.7
1483 Chapters
The Alpha Claimed Me Deeply
The Alpha Claimed Me Deeply
She's trying to escape. He's looking for revenge. She stumbles. He catches. She holds a secret. He wants to unravel it. It's impossible for them to be mates. But destiny had other plans. Xavier Knight thinks having a mate makes one weak. But can he really resist the bond that has entwined the two so deeply? Especially when he needs to have a taste of her to calm his raging beast? Her taste alone has become an addiction he craves severely, so how long can he hold off from marking her as his? Warning! MATURE CONTENT!
9.8
81 Chapters
Mr CEO's Triplets Mom
Mr CEO's Triplets Mom
This Book is Classified into Two Books under the same title. Book One has 60 Chapters. Whiles Book Two is the continuation and the love story of the Book One main characters' children. A one-night stand with a stranger brought Ashley to her downfall. Being betrayed by her step-sister and her boyfriend on her birthday, Ashley took on an impulsive action to sleep with a stranger. Which unfortunately got her pregnant. To add to her sorrow, her step-sister and her 5 years boyfriend were getting engaged. Thrown out from her home by her father and stepmother, Ashley thought she would struggle to carter for her baby. Until she met a man who took her under his wings and protected her. But the man always wears a mask in other for Ashley not to recognize who he is. Not having anywhere to go. Families and friends turned their back on her. Life was hard for Ashley. But she was still determined to move forward with the unknown man. Ashley was overwhelmed by the unknown person's care toward her. Without having any idea, the unknown person is no other person than David Westwood. The CEO of DWC, the multi-billionaire, and the same person who got her pregnant. What will Ashley do with her triplets? What will Ashley do when she finds the man who got her pregnant? Will Ashley forgive him and forget her past? Will there ever be love between them? Read more to find out!!
9.7
99 Chapters
The Alpha's Unwanted Luna
The Alpha's Unwanted Luna
This is Currently an Omnibus! Featuring: Book 1: The Unwanted Luna - Kennedy and Ryker's Story Book 2: The Warrior's Mate - Finn and Greta's Story Book 3: Taming the Alpha's Heir - Ben and Elara's Story Kennedy is a human thrown into the unbelievable world of the supernatural when her parents die in a freak car accident and her mother’s best friend steps in to become her guardian. Her mother’s best friend, Beth, is the Luna of the Silver Crescent Pack. Kennedy has known Beth and her husband James and their son Jeremiah her whole life, but thought pack life would be something she would only hear about. The Alpha and Luna keep no secrets about the dangers of their world for a human like Kennedy. Jeremiah takes an interest in keeping Kennedy safe and helps her through the trauma of moving on from the accident. Kennedy is taught pack ways and for the most part is loved by all the pack members, learning the values of the pack bond, the ways of the warriors and respect for the hierarchy of the wolf culture. She becomes a very proficient warrior even with only human strength and senses. Follow Kennedy on her journey of mates, love, friendship and fighting a mate bond she doesn’t want holding her back from her own goals and dreams. __ Ryker is a young, well-known, and feared Alpha of Dark Moon pack. He cares for his pack members through tough love and an iron fist. He's seen what happens when Alphas take their mate. It makes them weak and lose focus. Many have been corrupted by terrible mates. He would rather stay alone than be controlled.
9.5
434 Chapters
The Way of the Dragon
The Way of the Dragon
Zephyr Khan, the King of Alchemy, was reborn in his youth. He took the Ancient Draconic Way to refine his body and cultivate supreme sword skills! In this life, he was destined to ascend to the top of martial arts, Even the most gifted one was inferior to him!
9.7
4240 Chapters

Related Questions

How Does Carrying A Child That'S Not Mine Portray Motherhood?

4 Answers2025-10-20 15:26:38
The way 'Carrying a Child That's Not Mine' treats motherhood hits me in the chest and in the head at once. It doesn't worship the idea of a mother as an untouchable saint nor does it reduce caregiving to a checklist; instead, it lays bare how messy, contradictory, and fiercely humane the role can be. The protagonist’s actions—small routines, exhausted tenderness, bursts of anger—show that motherhood in this story is more of a verb than a label. It’s about choices made over and over, not a single defining moment. I love how the narrative refuses neat moralizing. There are scenes where being a mother looks like sacrifice, and then others where it’s a source of identity and joy. The social pressure building around the characters—whispers, assumptions, policies—makes the emotional stakes feel real. Visually and tonally the piece balances tenderness with grit: close-ups on tiny hands, quiet domestic strains, and loud confrontations with judgment. For me, that blend made it feel honest rather than manipulative, and I walked away thinking about how motherhood can be claimed, negotiated, and reshaped by the people who live it. It left me quietly impressed and oddly reassured.

Can Carrying A Child That'S Not Mine Be Adapted For TV Or Film?

4 Answers2025-10-20 13:32:15
There are so many layers to 'Carrying a Child That's Not Mine' that I get excited imagining it on screen. The emotional core — guilt, unexpected attachment, and moral ambiguity — is the kind of thing a limited series can stretch out beautifully. I’d want at least six episodes to breathe: early setup, the reveal, societal fallout, the backstory of the biological parents, courtroom or custody tension, and a quieter resolution. Visually, I picture naturalistic lighting, tight close-ups for the emotional beats, and a gentle soundtrack that swells only when it needs to. Casting is crucial: you need actors who can carry silence as much as shouting, and a kid who feels like a real person rather than a plot device. If it were a film, it should pick a focused arc — maybe the day-to-day adjustments of raising someone else’s child and a single major crisis that forces a choice. That would keep things taut and cinematic. Either format should avoid melodrama and lean into subtle gestures, micro-expressions, and quiet scenes that reveal more than dialogue. Personally, I’d binge the series in one sitting and still crave a rewatch the next week.

Who Are The Characters In Harry Potter Cursed Child?

2 Answers2025-09-13 10:09:02
The characters in 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' are a vibrant mix of familiar faces and fresh new characters that add layers to the beloved world. This play continues the saga of Harry Potter, now grown up and a Ministry employee, navigating the complexities of parenthood and his past. We see a more mature Harry, who is faced with the challenges of raising his son, Albus Potter, who struggles with his own identity. Albus, along with his friend Scorpius Malfoy—yes, the son of Draco Malfoy!—brings a new dynamic, grappling with family legacies and the weight of expectations. Their friendship is heartwarming and challenging, reminiscent of the trials faced by Harry and his friends in their youth, yet it’s laced with unique trials that modern young adults face today. Then there’s Ginny, now a professional Quidditch player and a strong, supportive figure for Harry, embodying resilience and love. Hermione, too, has evolved; she is now the brilliant Minister for Magic! Her presence in the story serves as a reminder of her indisputable strength and intelligence. Ron, the ever-enthusiastic and loyal friend, brings lightness and humor, keeping the group's spirit high as they deal with darker themes that the story touches upon, such as regret and the consequences of our choices. While on one hand, the old team offers a nostalgic return to the series, the subplot with Albus and Scorpius genuinely makes you think about how generational conflicts resonate. It's like watching the new generation navigate the world their parents grew up in. Moreover, the presence of villains from the past, particularly Voldemort's legacy, adds thrilling stakes that raise questions about fate and free will. Characters like Delphini, a new antagonist, weave in unsettling motivations that challenge the protagonists in unique ways, showing that new threats can emerge despite past victories. The combination of old and new characters creates an enthralling tapestry of emotions, growth, and choices that echo throughout the narrative, showcasing how far everyone has come since those Hogwarts days! I couldn’t help but feel nostalgic yet excited, seeing how the storyline twists and turns through time, emphasizing the consequences of our actions while exploring themes of friendship, family, and forgiveness. It makes for an engaging experience that I couldn’t recommend enough if you’re a fan of the franchise or just love a good story about growth and legacy!

Where Can I Watch Harry Potter Cursed Child Performances?

3 Answers2025-09-13 09:53:47
Catching 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' in live performance is like stepping into the magical world of Hogwarts itself. This thrilling stage adaptation continues to mesmerize audiences around the globe, and there are several fantastic venues where you can experience the show firsthand. Currently, the West End in London is a prominent location. The beautiful Palace Theatre hosts the production and it's simply enchanting to see it unfold where it all began in the heart of the UK. You can book your tickets directly from the theatre's website or through platforms like Ticketmaster. Watching it live is an experience unlike any other; the special effects and the energy of a live audience truly bring the story to life! If traveling to London isn’t feasible, look for local theatres or national touring productions in your area. Many major cities often host 'Cursed Child' for a limited time, with the same breathtaking magic that occurs in London. Check websites like Broadway.com or local listings where they often announce upcoming shows. Stay vigilant on social media too; communities and fan groups often share updates about show dates and ticket sales! Another great way to relive the magic is through recorded performances that sometimes become available via streaming services or on television during special events. Stay tuned for those too! No matter how you choose to experience it, those magical moments between characters will grab you and make you feel like you're back in the magical realm of J.K. Rowling's creation.

How Has Harry Potter Cursed Child Been Received By Fans?

3 Answers2025-09-13 19:30:00
The reception of 'Harry Potter and the Cursed Child' has been quite a mixed bag among fans, and that’s putting it mildly! When it first debuted, there was this colossal wave of excitement, a sort of jubilation that swept through the Potterhead community. After all, for many of us who grew up with the series, the thought of returning to that world was like being given a new chapter in a beloved novel. It felt like magic, literally! The ambitious nature of staging a play, combined with the familiar characters and new challenges they faced, had fans buzzing with curiosity. However, as the curtain was drawn back and audiences settled in, a sea of differing opinions surfaced. While some reveled in the enchanting visuals and the nostalgia of seeing old characters come to life again, others had gripes about the storyline itself. Many felt that certain character arcs, particularly regarding Albus Potter and his complex relationship with Harry, seemed forced or uncharacteristic. Some even voiced their discontent on memes and forums, jokingly asking if this was really the legacy of J.K. Rowling. The time travel element also garnered mixed reviews; fans debated its execution and how it fitted within the established timeline of the original series. Ultimately, whether people loved or disapproved, 'Cursed Child' spurred endless discussions, fan theories, and debates. It’s kind of heartening, though—this backlash and fervor show just how passionate the fanbase is. We adore these characters and want them to be treated with respect; it’s like discussing family! So, while I might have wished for a slightly different plot twist here and there, the fandom energy around 'Cursed Child' has undeniably kept the magic alive, providing space for new conversations and lively debates.

Do Kenshin And Kaoru Have A Child In Rurouni Kenshin?

5 Answers2025-09-11 02:40:42
Wandering through the pages of 'Rurouni Kenshin', I always found Kenshin and Kaoru's relationship to be one of the most heartwarming aspects of the series. Their bond evolves from mutual respect to deep love, especially in the 'Jinchu' arc where Kenshin finally confronts his past. While the original manga doesn't explicitly show them having a child, the sequel 'Rurouni Kenshin: Hokkaido Arc' introduces their son, Kenji. It's such a satisfying payoff for fans who followed their journey. Kenji inherits Kenshin's sense of justice but has Kaoru's fiery spirit, making him a fascinating blend of both parents. The way Watsuki-sensei subtly hints at their family life in the sequel feels like a love letter to long-time readers.

What Is The Main Conflict In 'Kamaria The Water'S Child (Book 1)'?

2 Answers2025-06-11 12:57:49
The heart of 'Kamaria the Water's Child (Book 1)' revolves around Kamaria's struggle to reconcile her dual identity as both human and water spirit. Born with the rare ability to manipulate water, she faces persecution from her village, which fears her powers as unnatural. The tension escalates when drought strikes, and the villagers blame her for disrupting the natural order. Meanwhile, ancient water spirits demand she embrace her heritage fully, leaving her human life behind. This internal and external conflict creates a gripping narrative about belonging, sacrifice, and the price of power. What makes it compelling is how the story layers political intrigue with personal drama. The village elders see Kamaria as a tool to control the weather, while rogue spirits want to use her as a weapon in their war against humans. Her childhood friend, now a skeptical guard captain, adds another layer by torn between duty and loyalty. The author brilliantly shows how environmental crises amplify human greed and superstition, making Kamaria’s choices feel monumental. The climax isn’t just about survival—it’s a poignant decision about whether to bridge two worlds or let one drown.

Where Can I Buy 'Kamaria The Water'S Child (Book 1 The Price Of Love)'?

3 Answers2025-06-11 06:00:46
I found 'Kamaria the Water's Child (Book 1 The Price of Love)' available on Amazon in both paperback and Kindle versions. The paperback's decently priced, and the cover art looks stunning in person. If you prefer physical copies, Barnes & Noble stocks it too—sometimes even with signed editions if you check their special collections. For international buyers, Book Depository offers free shipping worldwide, which is a steal. Local indie bookshops might carry it if you ask; mine ordered it within two days. The audiobook’s on Audible, narrated by someone with this rich, melodic voice that fits the watery theme perfectly.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status