Is 'A Different Kryptonian [Invincible/Brightburn] SI' A Dark Superhero Story?

I just finished reading 'A Different Kryptonian [Invincible/Brightburn] SI', and yes, it absolutely qualifies as a dark superhero story. The protagonist starts with Kryptonian powers but lacks the moral compass of Superman. Instead of saving people, they manipulate events for personal gain, often with brutal consequences. The story doesn’t shy away from graphic violence or psychological manipulation. Unlike traditional superhero tales where the hero upholds justice, this one explores what happens when someone with godlike abilities leans into their darker impulses. The setting feels oppressive, with the protagonist’s actions casting a long shadow over everyone around them. It’s a fresh take on the 'evil Superman' trope, but with even fewer redeeming qualities.

Having followed this story from its early chapters, I can confidently say it’s one of the darkest superhero narratives I’ve encountered. The protagonist isn’t just morally gray—they’re outright terrifying. Their Kryptonian abilities make them nearly unstoppable, and they use that power to dominate rather than protect. The story delves into themes of control, fear, and the corruption of absolute power. Unlike 'Invincible' or 'Brightburn', which still have moments of humanity, this protagonist feels like a force of nature with no empathy.

What makes it stand out is how it subverts the typical SI (self-insert) trope. Most SI stories have the protagonist trying to 'fix' the world or align with heroes. Here, the SI embraces their darker side, manipulating events to their advantage. The violence isn’t just physical; it’s psychological, with the protagonist breaking people mentally before finishing them off. The world reacts realistically, with governments scrambling to contain them and other heroes failing miserably. It’s a relentless descent into darkness, with no clear hope for redemption.

If you’re into stories that challenge the superhero genre’s norms, this one’s a must-read. It’s not for the faint of heart, though. The author doesn’t pull punches, and the narrative feels like a slow-motion train wreck you can’t look away from. Compared to 'The Boys' or 'Irredeemable', this story feels even more personal because of the SI perspective. You’re inside the head of someone who could be a hero but chooses not to, and that’s what makes it so chilling.

Dark? Oh, it’s pitch-black. 'A Different Kryptonian [Invincible/Brightburn] SI' takes the idea of a superpowered being and flips it into a horror show. The protagonist isn’t just powerful—they’re cruel, calculating, and completely self-serving. The story explores how absolute power corrupts absolutely, with the protagonist’s actions escalating from questionable to outright monstrous. Unlike 'Brightburn', where the descent feels somewhat accidental, here it’s deliberate. The protagonist knows what they’re doing and enjoys it.

What sets it apart is the lack of a moral anchor. Most dark superhero stories have someone trying to resist or oppose the villain. Here, the protagonist is so far ahead in power that resistance is futile. The world feels hopeless, with ordinary people and even other superhumans powerless to stop them. The narrative doesn’t offer a way out or a hero to root for. It’s just a brutal exploration of what happens when someone with no limits decides to embrace their worst instincts.

If you’re into grimdark stories, this one’s a gem. It’s not your typical superhero fare, and that’s what makes it so compelling. The writing is sharp, the tension is relentless, and the protagonist is a nightmare come to life. It’s like watching a disaster unfold in slow motion, and you can’t look away.