Why Is 'A Very Long Engagement' Rated R?

2025-06-15 23:00:29 62

3 answers

Yolanda
Yolanda
2025-06-17 13:48:49
I just finished 'A Very Long Engagement' last night, and the R rating makes perfect sense. The film doesn't shy away from brutal war scenes—graphic trench warfare with limbs blown off, soldiers drowning in mud, and close-up shots of rotting corpses. There's also a particularly disturbing execution scene where a character is tied to a post and slowly dies from multiple gunshots. The sexual content isn't gratuitous but definitely earns the rating; one extended love scene shows full nudity and passionate intimacy between the main couple. Some intense moments might haunt sensitive viewers, like when Mathilde fantasizes about her lover's possible mutilation. The emotional weight combined with visceral visuals creates an experience meant for mature audiences.
Jordan
Jordan
2025-06-20 12:18:08
As someone who studies war cinema, 'A Very Long Engagement' earns its R rating through a deliberate collision of poetic storytelling and unflinching realism. The opening battle sequence alone would secure the rating—bayonets piercing flesh in slow motion, a soldier's face melting from flamethrower fire, and rats gnawing at decaying bodies in no man's land. Director Jean-Pierre Jeunet contrasts these horrors with dreamlike visuals, making the violence more jarring.

The sexual content isn't frequent but is explicit when it appears. The protagonist's flashbacks to pre-war intimacy include prolonged nudity and tactile details that feel almost invasive. A subplot involving a brothel shows transactional sex without romanticization, including a scene where a sex worker cleans blood from her sheets after servicing a client. The film's central mystery involves wartime rape, though it's implied rather than shown. What truly solidifies the R rating is the psychological brutality—protagonist Mathilde's obsessive investigations lead her to confront grotesque truths about human cruelty that linger longer than any bloodshed.
Faith
Faith
2025-06-21 04:15:07
Having watched 'A Very Long Engagement' three times, I notice new R-rated elements each viewing. Beyond obvious factors like gore—a character's intestines spill out during a torture scene—the film explores mature themes that demand emotional resilience. Mathilde's journey reveals wartime atrocities: prisoners buried alive, self-mutilation to escape combat, and a haunting sequence where soldiers inhale poison gas. The romance isn't sanitized; their love scenes show raw passion with audible moans and strategic nudity.

What surprised me was the language. French profanity doesn't always translate directly, but subtitles include equivalents of 'f***' during battle chaos. The most disturbing aspect isn't visual—it's conceptual. The film forces you to contemplate how war erodes humanity, like when a general casually orders executions while eating gourmet food. Younger viewers might miss these nuances, but adults recognize why the rating exists. For similar intense wartime romance, try 'The English Patient'—another R-rated masterpiece that balances love and brutality.

Related Books

A Long Way to Find A Love
A Long Way to Find A Love
Cerita tentang Rania untuk menyadari bahwa kebahagiaan masih ada dalam hidupnya walau dengan liku yang panjang. Orang tua dan kedua adiknya meninggal bersama, pada hari dan waktu yang sama. Dia diangkat anak oleh adik dari ibunya yang seorang petinggi militer saat berusia 18 tahun. Keluarga kandung dari ayahnya menuduh Rania tak lagi ingat mereka karena sudah ada dalam keluarga ‘berada’. Orang-orang di sekitarnya tak pernah menghargai kerja kerasnya untuk meraih cita-cita karena di anggap menumpang nama dari Mama angkat yang berasal dari keluarga produser film. Keinginan untuk menikahi teman masa kecilnya harus pupus saat ia gugur dalam tugasnya sebagai abdi negara. Inilah kisah Rania Aprilia saat mencari alasan mengapa ia tetap dihidupkan saat semua alasannya untuk hidup diambil darinya. Bergembiralah, Orang yang meninggal tidak ingin mereka yang ditinggal menderita terlalu lama.” (Lim Ju-Kyung – True Beauty 2020)
10
14 Chapters
Long Way Home (Indonesia)
Long Way Home (Indonesia)
Bagi Brittany, Harry adalah pria pertama di kehidupan keduanya. Bagi Harry, Brittany adalah satu-satunya wanita di hidupnya. Namun apa yang akan terjadi jika perjalanan panjang Brittany untuk menemukan rumah tidak seperti pengharapannya? Dia terlanjur jatuh cinta pada Harry di waktu yang salah. Mungkinkah dia tetap bertahan dengan Harry? Ataukah memilih kembali pada kehidupan masa lalunya?
10
18 Chapters
B A R C O D E
B A R C O D E
Barcode atau kode batang sudah sering dijumpai di barang jualan. Kali ini, kode batang juga bisa ditemukan di tubuh manusia. Memang aneh, tetapi inilah yang terjadi. Jarang sekali manusia memiliki kode lahir di tubuh. Apalagi, kode batang tersebut adalah tanda di mana mereka memiliki kekuatan hebat untuk melindungi Bumi. Kode batang tersebut akan menyala sesuai dengan warna kekuatan mereka. Mereka ini adalah lima orang yang sudah berani merelakan nyawa demi Bumi. Danny, Ello, Alvina, Emily, dan Amanda akan melindungi planet yang mereka tinggali dari penyihir jahat di luar Bumi selamanya.
Belum ada penilaian
7 Chapters
Long Distance Marriage (Ketika Istri Kesepian)
Long Distance Marriage (Ketika Istri Kesepian)
Uang yang banyak tak cukup membuat Fani setia pada Bima. Bahkan, dia malah membeli laki-laki lain dengan uang pemberian suaminya itu. Fani mengira cinta yang baru akan membawanya lebih bahagia. Hingga dia nekat mendua dari Bima. Namun ternyata bagi Dika, istrinya lah pemenangnya. Bagaimanakah nasib Fani selanjutnya, saat Dika tak mau bertanggung jawab. Yuuuk simak cerita lengkapnya.
Belum ada penilaian
12 Chapters
R.E.D Red Everlasting Dragon
R.E.D Red Everlasting Dragon
Ketika sebuah rumah meledak, semua orang berpikir bahwa itu hanyalah kelalaian belaka. Tapi saat kepolisian mengetahui bahwa ada pasangan suami istri di dalamnya yang tewas, secara tak sadar itu membuat komisaris polisi panik. Di tambah dengan gadis kecil yang tidak diketahui keberadaannya menghilang, seluruh jajaran kepolisian dan ketentaraan mulai gemetar ketakutan. Karena akhirnya dia kembali! Orang yang bisa membuat pejabat besar gemetar dan suatu negara siaga darurat telah kembali. Dia kembali untuk membalas dendam! Membalas dendam pada pelaku yang telah membunuh orang tua, serta menculik adiknya. "Aku tidak peduli siapa dan apa, karena kalian berani membunuh orang tua dan menculik adikku, akan kupastikan bahwa dunia ini tidak akan aman lagi bagi kalian." "Sekalipun nama Red Everlasting Dragon kembali mengguncang dunia, aku bersumpah akan menemukan dan menghancurkanmu!" Bagaikan binatang buas, ketika dia sudah mengeluarkan amarahnya, tak ada seorangpun yang bisa menghentikan atau menghalanginya. Datang dari timur ke barat, semua orang mengenalnya sebagai R.E.D. Seorang pemuda berusia 27 tahun yang dapat membuat suatu negara ketakutan. Itulah dia, Raja Dunia Bawah dengan Tato Naga di tubuhnya. Red Everlasting Dragon.
10
70 Chapters
A.M.O.R.E.G.A
A.M.O.R.E.G.A
Kau takkan pernah tau kemana waktu membawamu. Kau takkan pernah mengerti mengapa kita dipertemukan.Kau takkan mengerti kenapa harus ada perpisahan. Tapi menurutku perlu adanya kehilangan agar kita tahu seberapa berartinya sesuatu yang hilang untuk hatimu.Agar kau tahu bahwa yang sakit masih bisa diobati namun yang luka tetap membekas apalagi yang patah sudah pasti takkan sama lagi.
10
41 Chapters

Related Questions

What Is The Ending Of 'A Very Long Engagement'?

3 answers2025-06-15 08:38:11
The ending of 'A Very Long Engagement' hits hard with its bittersweet resolution. Mathilde spends years searching for her fiancé Manech, who was supposedly executed for self-mutilation during WWI. Her relentless investigation uncovers layers of military corruption and cover-ups. The twist comes when she discovers Manech survived but lost his memory due to trauma. They reunite, but he doesn’t remember her. The beauty lies in Mathilde’s acceptance—she chooses to rebuild their love from scratch rather than dwell on the past. It’s a poignant commentary on war’s scars and the resilience of human connection. The final scenes show them walking together, symbolizing hope despite irreversible loss.

Where Was 'A Very Long Engagement' Filmed?

3 answers2025-06-15 05:19:01
I remember being absolutely mesmerized by the landscapes in 'A Very Long Engagement'. The film was shot in some stunning locations across France. Most of the wartime scenes were filmed in the hauntingly beautiful countryside of Picardy, particularly around the Somme River, where the actual battles took place. The production team also used the historic Fort de Douaumont near Verdun for some intense trench warfare sequences. Paris makes several appearances too, with iconic spots like the Pont des Arts and the Luxembourg Gardens doubling as post-war settings. What really stuck with me was how they transformed these real places into a cinematic time machine.

How Does 'A Very Long Engagement' Depict WWI?

3 answers2025-06-15 10:41:35
The depiction of WWI in 'A Very Long Engagement' is raw and unflinching. The trenches are shown as hellscapes—mud, blood, and decaying bodies blending into one grotesque reality. The film doesn’t glorify war; it exposes its absurd cruelty. Soldiers aren’t heroic icons but terrified men clinging to sanity. The protagonist’s quest to find her fiancé highlights war’s bureaucratic chaos—how records vanish, how lives become numbers. The battlefield scenes are chaotic, with explosions tearing through logic. The French countryside, once beautiful, is now a graveyard. The film’s genius lies in contrasting this horror with tender love letters, making the war’s waste even more gut-wrenching.

Who Plays Mathilde In 'A Very Long Engagement'?

3 answers2025-06-15 16:39:31
Audrey Tautou brings Mathilde to life in 'A Very Long Engagement', and she’s absolutely mesmerizing in the role. Her performance captures Mathilde’s quiet determination and deep love for her fiancé, making every scene she’s in feel intensely personal. Tautou’s expressive eyes and subtle gestures convey so much without needing dialogue, which is perfect for a character who refuses to believe her lover is dead. The way she balances vulnerability with steely resolve is masterful. If you enjoyed her in 'Amélie', you’ll love this darker, more complex role. The film’s poetic visuals and her performance make it unforgettable.

Is 'A Very Long Engagement' Based On A True Story?

3 answers2025-06-15 11:15:10
As someone who's obsessed with historical fiction, I can confirm 'A Very Long Engagement' isn't a documentary, but it's rooted in brutal truths. The novel (and subsequent film) takes the real horrors of World War I trench warfare as its foundation—the mutilated soldiers, the senseless court martials, the 'forlorn hope' suicide missions are all historically accurate. Author Sébastien Japrisot wove these elements into a fictional love story about a woman searching for her missing fiancé. The specific characters aren't real, but the military injustices they face mirror actual cases. The French army really did execute soldiers for cowardice, often without fair trials. The muddy hellscape of the trenches is described with such visceral detail because Japrisot researched actual soldier diaries. If you want to dive deeper into this era, check out 'The Price of Glory' by Alistair Horne for the military context or 'Testament of Youth' for the civilian perspective.

Who Is The Antagonist In 'Reborn To My Engagement Night'?

3 answers2025-06-13 04:50:54
The main antagonist in 'Reborn to My Engagement Night' is Lord Adrian Blackthorn, a ruthless noble who orchestrates the protagonist's downfall. He's not just a typical villain—his cunning makes him terrifying. Blackthorn manipulates political alliances, poisons rivals, and even frames the protagonist for treason. What makes him stand out is his lack of remorse; he sees people as pawns. His obsession with power drives him to commit atrocities, like wiping out entire families to secure his position. The protagonist's rebirth gives her a chance to expose his schemes, but Blackthorn adapts quickly, proving he's not just a brute but a strategic mastermind.

How Many Chapters Does 'Reborn To My Engagement Night' Have?

3 answers2025-06-13 18:57:34
I recently binge-read 'Reborn to My Engagement Night' and was surprised by how packed it is. The novel has 347 chapters in total, which might seem daunting, but the pacing keeps you hooked. The first 100 chapters focus on the protagonist's revenge arc, while the middle 200 delve into political intrigue and romance. The final stretch wraps up loose ends with some unexpected twists. If you enjoy rebirth stories with a mix of drama and action, this one's worth the commitment. The chapter count might intimidate new readers, but the story flows so well that you barely notice the length.

Does 'Reborn To My Engagement Night' Have A Happy Ending?

3 answers2025-06-13 22:53:29
I just finished 'Reborn to My Engagement Night' and wow, does it deliver a satisfying ending! The protagonist gets her ultimate revenge but in the most unexpected way—not through violence, but by outsmarting everyone who wronged her in her past life. The final chapters show her rebuilding her life with the people who truly care about her, and the romantic subplot wraps up beautifully with a heartfelt confession scene. What I love is how the author balances justice with personal growth—it’s not just about payback but about her becoming someone better. The last page left me grinning like crazy.
Jelajahi dan baca novel bagus secara gratis
Akses gratis ke berbagai novel bagus di aplikasi GoodNovel. Unduh buku yang kamu suka dan baca di mana saja & kapan saja.
Baca buku gratis di Aplikasi
Pindai kode untuk membaca di Aplikasi
DMCA.com Protection Status