How Do Elmore Leonard Book Fans On Reddit Rank His Crime Series?

Leonard readers on r/books, what's your personal tier list for his crime fiction? I'm deep into his world, but craving some consensus beyond glowing reviews.

2026-08-01 03:24:44

105

Suivre8

SilasWade

Novel Fan

Chef

5 Réponses

OwenKelly

Book Guide

Receptionist

I appreciate the rankings that acknowledge his short story collections, like 'When the Women Come Out to Dance'. The story 'Fire in the Hole' is obviously crucial, but others like 'Karen Makes Out' are pure Leonard gems. Some fans rank these stories above some of his full novels. It's a reminder that his genius worked perfectly in condensed form, and a ranking of just his novels misses a key part of his output.

2026-08-03 12:00:45

OscarCook

Responder

Editor

The audiobook experience completely changes the ranking, as I hinted before. Frank Muller narrating 'Get Shorty' is a performance for the ages. But other narrators, like Peter Francis James, bring a different energy. I've seen people say they didn't care for 'Riding the Rap' in print, but the audiobook made it click. So any Reddit thread about 'best Elmore Leonard' should specify format. The ranking for 'best to read' and 'best to listen to' could have different winners.

2026-08-05 20:19:27

EasyVibe

Sharp Observer

Editor

I wonder how much the physical book itself matters. The old Harper Perennial editions with the bold colors and simple designs feel like Leonard. Reading a cheap, mass-market paperback with tiny print might make the experience of a great book slightly worse. I know it's superficial, but the artifact contributes to the memory. I ranked 'The Moonshine War' higher after finding a pristine vintage copy with a great cover. Totally irrational, but part of the fun of being a book fan.

2026-08-06 03:38:20

MaryBoone

Sharp Observer

Doctor

A practical tip from Reddit: check the publication date. The general consensus in ranking threads is that his peak period was roughly 1974 to 1992. Books from this era are almost always ranked in the top half. '52 Pick-Up' (1974) through 'Rum Punch' (1992). After that, the rankings become more divisive, with some brilliant stuff but also some that feel like he's repeating himself. So if you see a list that puts a late-90s or 2000s book at the very top, it's a deeply personal and probably controversial take.

2026-08-07 01:43:22

RenGreen

Book Guide

Chef

My ranking is based on which books I can hear in my head most clearly. Leonard's prose has a specific rhythm. When I read 'Rum Punch', I hear Pam Grier's voice from the movie, but also Leonard's own cadence. 'Freaky Deaky' has this staccato, back-and-forth dialogue that plays like a movie. The books that achieve that perfect auditory illusion—where you're not reading words, you're hearing voices—are the ones I rank highest. It's the highest compliment to his 'just the tips' writing style.

2026-08-07 05:23:13

Toutes les réponses

Livres associés

UNDER LEO'S COMMAND (The De Castello Family #1)

Condemned The Mafia Book Three Cruel Intentions Series

Mafia Kingpin: A Dark Organized Crime Romance

Black Aces MC (The Complete series)

Emma Mountford

41.1K

Delve into the world of the Black Aces MC and fall in love with the men who ride hard for their club and the women they would do anything for. You are in for the ride of your life with these four scorching hot couples. 1- Ruined 2- Truth Forever 2.5- Aces Wild 3- Wicked Games 4- Gentleman Wanted

Lire maintenant

The Heaven Hill Series

Laramie Briscoe

21.4K

Fall in love with these bad-boy bikers — with steamy stories ranging from second-chance romances to secret hookups.The Heaven Hill Series is created by Laramie Briscoe, an eGlobal Creative Publishing Signed Author.

Lire maintenant

UNDER LEO'S COMMAND (The De Castello Family #1)

STAREX

8.8

17.2K

“I'm so sorry, Leo,” I rasped, my voice barely a whisper. Tears of guilt and self-blame streamed down my cheeks as I stood before him, eyes cast downward. Despite the fact that I was his prisoner and he was my warden, I couldn't bear the thought of anything bad happening to him. I told him, “It's my fault. I shouldn't have let you go-” “Damn it, Alessandra. I don't want your apology,” Leonardo snapped, lifting my chin with a firm finger, forcing me to meet his gaze. His voice was hard as steel as he continued, “I want you to write a fucking essay about how much you think about me. How you crave my touch. I want to hear you say you love me, because I swear it in this life, mia principessa, there won't be anyone else but me.” ----------------------------------------------------- When Alessandra Scavelli is forced into marrying Leonardo De Castello, her childhood sweetheart turned feared mafia kingpin, her world is thrown into chaos. Leonardo, still madly in love with her, sees this as a chance to reclaim their lost romance. Alessandra, however, is torn by a secret mission handed to her by her family: infiltrate Leonardo's syndicate and bring it down from within. As she delves into Leonardo's dangerous world, Alessandra finds herself conflicted between her family’s demands and the undeniable pull of her own heart. The once clear lines between loyalty and love blur, and she must navigate a treacherous path where betrayal lurks at every corner. Will Alessandra follow through with her family's plan, or will she surrender to the passion that threatens to consume her?

Lire maintenant

Condemned The Mafia Book Three Cruel Intentions Series

Peyton Iuga

28.8K

Elliot O’More is Killian’s (Betrayed the Mafia) left hand in the New York Irish Mob. He is known for his ruthless killings and way around the dark web. Elliot might look like the guy next door, but he is not as lovely as it seems. He is a player that has given up on love. And we all know how dangerous that can be. Hazel walks into Elliot’s life, turning his head upside down, and the only way he can get her out of his system is by forging a contract marriage. He will protect her, and she will be his. His obsession with her soon becomes love, and Elliot struggles to stay sane and protect her when everyone around them wants them apart. Hazel is a pawn in the hands of the Russian Mafia. They use her to their benefit, and what happens when they decide to use her against the Irish, to use her against her husband?

Lire maintenant

The Moonshine Task Force Series

Laramie Briscoe

28.5K

A one-night stand results in a big surprise, a car accident offers a second chance at love, and a marriage of convenience leads to real romance! Meet the men of the Moonshine Task Force in this delicious series.18+, sex scenesThe Moonshine Task Force is created by Laramie Briscoe, aneGlobal Creative Publishing Signed Author.

Lire maintenant

Mafia Kingpin: A Dark Organized Crime Romance

A. Hayat

1.7K

A cold and ruthless Mafia Kingpin, "kill or be killed" is what Louis lives by... Until he meets Sarina: a sexy, mysterious woman who turns his life upside down. Follow Louis's journey as he transitions from a young, teenage boy into a mob boss, as he is influenced by his crime lord stepfather Steve Sawyers. Watch Louis as he is thrown into a dark and dangerous world of drug smuggling, gun trafficking, money laundering, fraud, sex, psychopaths and murderers... There aren't any friends on these streets.

Lire maintenant

Tags du livre

Autres questions liées

Which Elmore Leonard books focus most on crime and heists?

7 Réponses2026-08-01 09:22:58

His collaboration with Walter Mirisch on the screenplay for 'The Moonshine War' (adapted from his own novel) is a deep dive into Prohibition-era bootlegging crime. The book itself is a tighter, meaner version of that story. It's a war between revenuers and moonshiners, so the 'crime' is the entire economic foundation of the community. This isn't a heist; it's a siege. It focuses on the logistics, the loyalties, and the brutal pragmatism of illegal enterprise. The setting itself becomes a character, a landscape defined by its criminal industry, which is a theme Leonard would return to often.

Where should I start with Elmore Leonard if I love crime novels?

5 Réponses2026-08-01 01:21:03

Crime lovers diving into Leonard need to begin with 'Get Shorty'. It’s the perfect gateway—lean, hilarious, and dripping with that signature dialogue where every character thinks they're the smartest one in the room. The plot about a loan shark trying to produce a movie is just the right mix of criminal machinations and Hollywood satire. You get a complete sense of his style without the heavier baggage of some of his earlier, more straightforward genre work. It sets the tone for everything else he’d do.

Which Elmore Leonard books highlight his humor in crime storytelling?

4 Réponses2026-08-01 21:23:55

He's great at the 'competent woman vs. incompetent men' dynamic for humor. Think of Karen Sisco, or Jackie Burke in 'Rum Punch,' or even the female marshal in 'Riding the Rap.' They're surrounded by men who are posturing, scheming, and often failing. The women's humor is drier, more observant. They roll their eyes, they make a quiet comment that cuts through the nonsense, they get the job done while the men are still talking about it. It's not a militant feminist humor; it's a practical, realistic one that points out the folly of male ego without ever needing to shout. It's effective and consistently funny across his work.

What is the best Elmore Leonard crime novel to start with?

3 Réponses2026-08-01 07:48:59

Maybe the question is backwards. Instead of the 'best' to start with, consider which one not to start with. I'd avoid 'The Bounty Hunters' or 'The Law at Randado'—his very early Westerns. While they're good, they're not fully formed Leonard. His voice wasn't quite there yet. Also, maybe skip 'Djibouti' or 'Raylan' (his last novels) as first choices, as they can feel a bit thinner compared to his peak work. Start in the sweet spot, from the late 70s through the 90s. That's where you'll find the untouchable run of classics that define his legacy.

What Elmore Leonard books were adapted into major crime movies?

4 Réponses2026-08-01 22:25:54

I think the absolute essentials are 'Get Shorty', 'Out of Sight', and 'Jackie Brown'. That's the holy trinity. They're all from within a few years of each other and represent the peak of translating his prose to the screen. '3:10 to Yuma' (2007) is the essential Western adaptation. 'Justified' is the essential TV adaptation. Everything else is for completists or curiosity seekers. Those four (or five, counting the show) are the major pillars of Leonard's film and TV legacy.

Where should I start reading Elmore Leonard novels in order?

5 Réponses2026-08-01 19:01:30

I got given 'Get Shorty' as a gift and hated the first chapter. Put it down for a year. Picked it up again, pushed through, and it clicked. My advice? Give any book at least 50 pages. His style is an acquired taste, but once you get it, it's addictive.

Where should I start reading Elmore Leonard books in order?

7 Réponses2026-08-01 01:14:15

Forget order, just grab 'Rum Punch.' It’s tight, the characters are incredibly vivid, and it’s the basis for 'Jackie Brown.' The dialogue crackles on every page. It’s a masterclass in how to write a thriller with minimal filler. After that, you’ll understand what people mean by the 'Leonard vibe,' and you can explore his other work based on which elements you liked most—be it the Hollywood satire, the Miami vibe, or the criminal banter.