Why Do Fans Prefer Good Fiction Novels Over Original Anime Scripts?

Fans often gravitate towards good fiction novels because they offer a deeper dive into the characters' inner worlds. In novels, you get to explore thoughts, emotions, and backstories in a way that anime scripts, constrained by runtime and visual storytelling, can't always deliver. For instance, in 'The Name of the Wind', Kvothe’s internal monologue adds layers to his actions that a visual medium might miss. Novels also allow readers to imagine the world and characters in their own unique way, creating a personal connection that’s hard to replicate in anime. Plus, the pacing in novels feels more controlled, letting you savor every detail without the rush of a 20-minute episode.

I think the appeal of fiction novels lies in their ability to immerse readers completely. Anime scripts, while engaging, often have to condense complex plots into a limited timeframe, which can leave out nuances. Take 'The Lord of the Rings'—Tolkien’s rich descriptions of Middle-earth and its lore are unparalleled. In a novel, you can spend pages exploring a single moment, like the tension in a conversation or the beauty of a landscape. Anime, on the other hand, has to balance visuals, dialogue, and pacing, which sometimes sacrifices depth.

Another reason is the flexibility of imagination. When reading a novel, you’re not bound by an animator’s interpretation. You can picture characters, settings, and events in a way that feels personal. This creative freedom makes the experience more intimate. Plus, novels often tackle themes and ideas that anime might shy away from due to audience or production constraints. For example, '1984' delves into political and psychological complexities that are harder to convey in a visual medium.

Lastly, novels often have a timeless quality. While anime can feel tied to its era due to animation styles or cultural references, a well-written novel transcends time. It’s why classics like 'Pride and Prejudice' still resonate today. Fans appreciate this enduring quality, knowing they can revisit a novel years later and find new layers of meaning.

From my perspective, fans prefer fiction novels because they offer a more introspective and detailed experience. Anime scripts, while visually stunning, often rely on action and dialogue to drive the story. Novels, on the other hand, can delve into the subtleties of human emotion and relationships. For example, in 'Norwegian Wood', Murakami’s exploration of love and loss feels more profound because of the narrative’s depth. Anime might capture the surface emotions, but novels let you live inside the characters’ minds.

Another factor is the pacing. Novels allow for slower, more deliberate storytelling. You can linger on a scene, absorbing every detail, without the pressure of moving the plot forward quickly. This is especially true for genres like mystery or psychological thrillers, where the buildup is crucial. Anime, with its episodic format, often has to keep things moving, which can dilute the impact of key moments.

Lastly, novels often feel more personal. The act of reading is solitary, allowing you to connect with the story on a deeper level. Anime, while enjoyable, is a shared experience, and sometimes the communal aspect can detract from the intimacy of the narrative. Fans who crave a more personal connection often turn to novels for that reason.