LOGINLibrary
Search
Why Were The Giver Books Challenged Or Banned In Schools?
2025-08-29 09:55:55
269
4 Answers
Zane
2025-08-30 20:34:52
I’m a teenager who first read 'The Giver' for a class and then got curious why it shows up on banned book lists. Short version: it’s not because of swearing or sex, but because it makes adults nervous. The idea of 'release' (which equals killing) and the society’s strict control over life and death freaks some people out. Others worry it teaches kids to question family or faith.
What annoyed me at school meetings was how quickly people assumed it would 'corrupt' young readers. In reality, the book invites questions — about history, memory, and who gets power — and those are the exact conversations teens need. If anything, the controversy made me want to reread it and talk about the scenes with friends, which turned out way more interesting than the ban drama.
What annoyed me at school meetings was how quickly people assumed it would 'corrupt' young readers. In reality, the book invites questions — about history, memory, and who gets power — and those are the exact conversations teens need. If anything, the controversy made me want to reread it and talk about the scenes with friends, which turned out way more interesting than the ban drama.
Selena
2025-08-30 22:34:49
I've worked in a small-town library for years, and one thing you see is that bans and challenges are rarely about a single page — they're about social anxieties. People challenged 'The Giver' for multiple reasons: perceived promotion of euthanasia through 'release,' claims that it fosters distrust of parental or religious authority, objections to its portrayal of a society without a divine moral compass, and worries that middle-grade readers aren't ready for those ideas. The ALA catalogs many of these complaints under 'unsuited to age group' or 'offensive content.'
From my perspective, requests to remove the book often escalate when communities lack a shared idea of what kids should encounter in school. Some districts respond by offering opt-outs or alternative texts, which feels like a practical compromise. I also see how sequels like 'Gathering Blue' and 'Messenger' complicate matters by deepening moral ambiguity, so challengers sometimes target the series rather than just the standalone novel. For me, censorship decisions should weigh pedagogical value: 'The Giver' encourages critical thinking and discussion about memory, agency, and societal design — valuable topics if teachers provide proper framing and support.
From my perspective, requests to remove the book often escalate when communities lack a shared idea of what kids should encounter in school. Some districts respond by offering opt-outs or alternative texts, which feels like a practical compromise. I also see how sequels like 'Gathering Blue' and 'Messenger' complicate matters by deepening moral ambiguity, so challengers sometimes target the series rather than just the standalone novel. For me, censorship decisions should weigh pedagogical value: 'The Giver' encourages critical thinking and discussion about memory, agency, and societal design — valuable topics if teachers provide proper framing and support.
Declan
2025-08-31 06:33:27
I get why people get rattled about books like 'The Giver' — I teach literature on the side and watch these conversations play out all the time in staff rooms and parent meetings.
At the heart of most challenges are themes that some adults find uncomfortable: the book treats 'release' (which is essentially euthanasia) in a way that forces readers to think about death, choice, and who gets to decide. Parents sometimes argue that kids shouldn't be exposed to talk of killing, infant swapping, or the idea that a supposedly perfect society could be so morally empty. A lot of objections also come from people who read the book as promoting disrespect for elders or authority, or as containing values they feel clash with their religious beliefs. The American Library Association has repeatedly listed 'The Giver' among frequently challenged titles, often with complaints filed for being 'unsuited to age group' or 'anti-family.'
Even though it's not explicit or graphic, those themes still make some school boards nervous, especially when communities differ over what's age-appropriate. I usually tell my students that wrestling with hard questions is the point of the book — it opens up conversations about ethics, memory, and freedom — but I also get why some parents want alternatives for younger readers.
At the heart of most challenges are themes that some adults find uncomfortable: the book treats 'release' (which is essentially euthanasia) in a way that forces readers to think about death, choice, and who gets to decide. Parents sometimes argue that kids shouldn't be exposed to talk of killing, infant swapping, or the idea that a supposedly perfect society could be so morally empty. A lot of objections also come from people who read the book as promoting disrespect for elders or authority, or as containing values they feel clash with their religious beliefs. The American Library Association has repeatedly listed 'The Giver' among frequently challenged titles, often with complaints filed for being 'unsuited to age group' or 'anti-family.'
Even though it's not explicit or graphic, those themes still make some school boards nervous, especially when communities differ over what's age-appropriate. I usually tell my students that wrestling with hard questions is the point of the book — it opens up conversations about ethics, memory, and freedom — but I also get why some parents want alternatives for younger readers.
Zoe
2025-09-04 10:16:45
I’m a parent who sat through a curriculum meeting and heard the exact reasons people wanted 'The Giver' pulled from shelves. In plain terms: the book talks about 'releasing' people (which reads like assisted death), it questions authority, and it paints a society that’s sterile and emotionally numb. For some families that’s too heavy for middle-schoolers; for others it clashes with religious or moral beliefs.
Another common complaint I heard was that the book introduces kids to uncomfortable concepts — death, control over reproduction, and moral ambiguity — without enough 'positive' framing. What surprised me was how often the challenge wasn't about offensive language or pictures, but about big ideas. Personally, I ended up reading it with my kid and using it as a springboard to talk about empathy and history. If schools handle it with context, the book becomes less frightening and more useful.
Another common complaint I heard was that the book introduces kids to uncomfortable concepts — death, control over reproduction, and moral ambiguity — without enough 'positive' framing. What surprised me was how often the challenge wasn't about offensive language or pictures, but about big ideas. Personally, I ended up reading it with my kid and using it as a springboard to talk about empathy and history. If schools handle it with context, the book becomes less frightening and more useful.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Savage Sons MC Books 1-5
Savage Sons Mc books 1-5 is a collection of MC romance stories which revolve around five key characters and the women they fall for.
Havoc -
A sweet like honey accent and a pair of hips I couldn’t keep my eyes off.That’s how it started.Darcie Summers was playing the part of my old lady to keep herself safe but we both know it’s more than that.There’s something real between us.Something passionate and primal.Something my half brother’s stupidity will rip apart unless I can get to her in time.
Cyber - Everyone has that ONE person that got away, right?
The one who you wished you had treated differently.
For me, that girl has always been Iris.So when she turns up on Savage Sons territory needing help, I am the man for the job.
Every time I look at her I see the beautiful girl I left behind but Iris is no longer that girl.
What I put into motion years ago has shattered her into a million hard little pieces.
And if I’m not careful they will cut my heart out.
Fang-The first time I saw her, she was sat on the side of the road drinking whiskey straight from the bottle.
The second time was when I hit her dog.
I had promised myself never to get involved with another woman after the death of my wife.
But Gypsy was different.
Sweeter, kinder and with a mouth that could make a sailor blush.
She was also too good for me.
I am Fang, President of the Savage Sons. I am not a good man, I’ve taken more lives than I care to admit even to myself.
But I’m going to keep her anyway.
146 Chapters
Club Voyeur Series (4 Books in 1)
Explicit scenes. Mature Audience Only. Read at your own risk.
A young girl walks in to an exclusive club looking for her mother. The owner brings her inside on his arm and decides he's never going to let her go.
The book includes four books. The Club, 24/7, Bratty Behavior and Dominate Me - all in one.
305 Chapters
Dirty Wild Sultan (Alluring Rulers of Azmia 4 Books)
He is my only chance at freedom. She is the daughter of my enemy. Will their love survive?
Zain
As the Sultan of one of the most powerful countries in the Middle-East, I need to find my Sultana.
But I don’t intend to have heirs or even get married. Until I stumbled into Nasrin Elbaz.
I cannot resist her.
So I will claim her as mine. My Sultana. My Wife. My Lover.
I, Sultan Zain Al Latif, will propose to Princess Nasrin for a marriage. If she rejects me…
Well, I have been told I can be quite persuasive and demanding when I want to be.
Nasrin
He is a Sultan and I am the Princess of the country he is nemesis with. I don’t belong in his wealthy country that bleeds gold and his Palace.
I am trying to hold on to what little freedom I have.
No way can I fall for some dirty talking or his obsidian eyes curling with hunger whenever he sees me. Even if my body craves his tender touch and his sinful mouth.
I have to get my freedom and find a way to escape the proposals of marriage. Without his help, thank you very much.
“I am asking you to marry me.”
“Are you asking or ordering, Sultan?”
“I am asking, Princess.” I smiled at her. “For now.”
141 Chapters
Dionysus Rising ( A Rockstar Romance) books 1-3
Dionysus Rising - The biggest rock band in the world right now cordially invite you to take a sneaky look at their lives both off and on the stage.
The highs and the lows, the heart break and the mind blowing passion… it’s all within these pages as Jax , Dion and Louis tell you their stories ️
90 Chapters
Don't Date Your Best Friend (The Unfolding Duet 2 Books)
He shouldn’t have imagined her lying naked on his bed. She shouldn’t have imagined his devilishly handsome face between her legs.
But it was too late.
Kiara began noticing Ethan's washboard abs when he hopped out of the pool, dripping wet after swim practice. Ethan began gazing at Kiara’s golden skin in a bikini as a grown woman instead of the girl next door he grew up with.
That kiss should have never happened.
It was just one moment in a lifetime of moments, but they both felt its power. They knew the thrumming in their veins and desperation in their bodies might give them all they ever wanted or ruin everything if they followed it.
Kiara and Ethan knew they should have never kissed. But it's too late to take that choice back, so they have a new one to make.
Fall for each other and risk their friendship or try to forget one little kiss that might change everything.
PREVIEW:
“If you don’t want to kiss me then... let’s swim.”
“Yeah, sure.”
“Naked.”
“What?”
“I always wanted to try skinny dipping. And I really want to get out of these clothes.”
“What if someone catches you... me, both?”
“We will be in the pool, Ethan. And no one can see us from the living room.” I smirked when I said, “Unless you want to watch me while I swim, you can stay here.”
His eyes darkened, and he looked away, probably thinking the same when I noticed red blush creeping up his neck and making his ears and cheeks flush. Cute.
“Come on, Ethan. Don’t be a chicken...”
“Fine.”
His voice was rough when he said, “Remove that sweater first.”
76 Chapters
The Family Books 1 -3 (A collection of Dark Mafia Romance)
Book 1 Saints and Sinners
She was the light to my dark.
The saint to my sinner. with her innocent eyes and devilish curves.
A Madonna that was meant to be admired but never touched.
Until someone took that innocence from her.
She left.
The darkness in my heart was finally complete.
I avenged her, I killed for her, but she never came back.
Until I saw her again. An angel dancing around a pole for money.
She didn’t know I owned that club. She didn’t know I was watching.
This time I won’t let her escape.
I will make her back into the girl I knew.
Whether she likes it or not.
Book 2 Judge and Jury
I can’t stop watching her.
I’m not even sure I want to.
Taylor Lawson, blonde, beautiful, and totally oblivious to how much dangers she’s in.
She’s also the one juror in my upcoming murder trial that hasn’t been bought.
The one who can put me behind bars for a very long time.
I know I should execute her.
After all that’s what I do.
I am the Judge.
I eliminate threats to The Family.
And Taylor is a threat.
But I don’t want to kill her.
Possessing her, making her love me seems like a much better plan for this particular Juror.
61 Chapters
Related Questions
How Does 'The Giver' End?
3 Answers2025-06-29 07:25:17
The ending of 'The Giver' leaves us with a powerful but ambiguous moment. Jonas, after escaping the community with baby Gabriel, reaches what seems to be a new place. He sleds down a hill towards lights and music, suggesting he's found a village where people experience emotions and memories freely. The book cuts off there, making us wonder if it's real or a final hallucination from starvation and cold. Some readers think Jonas and Gabriel die, their sacrifice symbolizing hope. Others believe they survive, bringing change to the new society. The open-ended nature makes it haunting—we’re left debating whether it’s a tragedy or a triumph of human spirit.
What Happens In The Giver
3 Answers2025-08-01 14:33:53
I remember reading 'The Giver' and being completely captivated by its dystopian world. The story follows Jonas, a boy living in a seemingly perfect society where everything is controlled—no pain, no war, no suffering. But when he's chosen as the Receiver of Memory, he discovers the dark truth behind this 'utopia.' Through the Giver, he learns about emotions, colors, and the messy beauty of life that's been erased from his community. The climax is heart-wrenching as Jonas realizes the cost of this 'perfection' and makes a daring escape with a baby named Gabriel, hoping to find a place where life is truly lived. The book's exploration of freedom and humanity stuck with me long after I finished it.
How Does The Giver End
4 Answers2025-08-01 03:14:18
I was completely captivated by 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry, especially its ambiguous ending that leaves so much room for interpretation. After Jonas escapes the community with baby Gabriel, they embark on a perilous journey toward Elsewhere, a place of freedom and color. The final scene shows them sledding down a hill toward a warmly lit house, hearing music—symbolizing hope and a new beginning. Some readers believe they survive and find a better life, while others interpret it as a bittersweet, possibly tragic, culmination of their struggle.
The beauty of 'The Giver' lies in its open-ended finale, allowing readers to ponder whether Jonas and Gabriel truly reach safety or if their journey ends in sacrifice. Lowry deliberately avoids spelling it out, making the ending a powerful conversation starter about choice, humanity, and the cost of utopia. Personally, I love endings that trust the reader to decide, and this one does it masterfully.
What Is The Climax Of The Giver
3 Answers2025-08-01 14:33:35
The climax of 'The Giver' is the moment Jonas decides to flee the community with Gabriel, the baby he’s grown attached to, to escape the controlled and emotionless society they live in. This decision comes after Jonas learns the dark truth about 'release,' which is actually euthanasia, and realizes the community’s so-called perfection is built on lies and suppression. The tension peaks as Jonas steals his father’s bicycle and some food, then sets off toward Elsewhere, a place he hopes offers freedom and real emotions. The weather turns harsh, and Jonas faces starvation and exhaustion, but he pushes forward, driven by his love for Gabriel and his desire for a better life. The climax is both thrilling and heartbreaking, as Jonas risks everything for a chance at true humanity.
What Is Sameness In The Giver
5 Answers2025-08-02 21:33:44
In 'The Giver', sameness is the foundational principle of the community, a meticulously engineered society where differences are erased to maintain order and predictability. The concept eliminates pain, suffering, and even extreme joy to create a uniform existence. Everything from weather to personal choices is controlled—no colors, no real emotions, no memories of the past. People wear the same clothes, live in identical dwellings, and follow rigid routines. It’s a world where individuality is sacrificed for the illusion of harmony.
At first glance, sameness seems idyllic—no poverty, no war, no conflict. But as the story unfolds, we see the cost. Without pain, there’s no true happiness; without choice, there’s no freedom. The absence of color and music strips life of its vibrancy. The community’s elders enforce sameness through strict rules and the suppression of memories, leaving people numb and hollow. Jonas’s journey exposes the dark side of this utopia, revealing how sameness robs life of meaning and humanity.
Why Is The Giver Banned
4 Answers2025-08-01 05:48:50
As someone who's spent years discussing controversial books in online forums, 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry is often banned because it challenges traditional societal norms. The novel's depiction of a dystopian world where emotions are suppressed and euthanasia is normalized makes some parents and educators uncomfortable. Schools frequently remove it due to themes of infanticide and the questioning of authority, which they believe are too mature for younger readers.
Another reason is its exploration of complex moral dilemmas, like the ethics of sameness and the cost of a pain-free society. Some argue that children aren't ready to grapple with these heavy topics. Yet, this is exactly why the book is so valuable—it sparks critical thinking and discussions about freedom, choice, and humanity. The bans often stem from fear, but banning it only highlights how necessary these conversations are.
Who Is Fiona In The Giver
3 Answers2025-08-01 17:40:38
Fiona in 'The Giver' is one of those characters who seems gentle on the surface but carries a quiet strength. She works as a Caretaker of the Old, which means she’s responsible for tending to the elderly in the community before they’re 'released.' What’s fascinating about Fiona is how she embodies the society’s values—kind, obedient, and seemingly content—but there’s a hint of something more beneath. She’s assigned to release the elderly, yet she doesn’t question it, which makes her a perfect contrast to Jonas, who starts doubting everything. Her role highlights the chilling efficiency of their world, where even compassion is systematized and stripped of real emotion.
What Is The Correct Reading Order For The Giver Books?
3 Answers2025-08-30 23:58:23
Sunset reading session vibes hit me the first time I tried to figure out the best order for these books — and honestly, the easiest route is the publication order. Start with 'The Giver' (1993), which introduces Jonas and the chilling, tightly controlled society. It establishes the world and emotional tone that threads through the rest of the quartet. Next pick up 'Gathering Blue' (2000); Kira’s story feels thematically connected but different in setting, so reading it second broadens your view of Lois Lowry’s world without spoiling later reveals.
After that, read 'Messenger' (2004), which brings characters from 'Gathering Blue' into a meeting place that intersects with the moral questions from 'The Giver'. 'Messenger' deepens character relationships and sets up the final book’s payoffs. Finish with 'Son' (2012) — it reconstructs timelines and reveals connections that hit much harder if you’ve already met the other characters. 'Son' acts like a capstone, tying threads together and recontextualizing scenes from earlier books.
I once re-read the quartet in this sequence on a rainy weekend and finishing 'Son' felt like closing a long, strange loop. If you want suspense and emotional layering, go publication order; if you insist on strictly chronological events you might tinker, but you’ll lose a lot of the reveals. Personally, I’d save 'Son' for last and let it land.
Popular Question
Popular Searches More
Complexity: The Emerging Science At The Edge Of Order And Chaos
Danny Phantom Fanfiction
Last Man Nietzsche
Winn-dixie Novel
Book Off
I Became The Novel's Biggest Antagonist
The Demigod Diaries Pdf
Potential Man (megumi Si Jjk Wc Fic)
Fried Green Tomatoes At The Whistle Stop Cafe
Finding Alice
Horror Novel Books
Farewell To Manzanar Pdf
Regina Spektor The Call Narnia
100 Recommended Books
Earth Diet Book
As Simple As Snow
The Strongest Senior Brother In History
Killing Me Now
Online Read Books For Free No Download
Indexing Of Books
Gorre Puranam
Romance Jdramas
Richard Bach Messiah's Handbook
Unquiet Mind Book
My Immortal Fanfic
Beach Read Epub
Wolf Bait
The Originals AU: Hybrid’s Daughter
R18 Light Novel
Yerba Buena
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
