Is There A Historical Basis For The 'Silent Sisters' In Real Life?

2025-06-25 09:53:36 53

4 answers

Tessa
Tessa
2025-06-30 09:40:36
The 'Silent Sisters' from 'Game of Thrones' feel like a dark twist on real-world religious orders that handled the dead. Medieval Europe had groups like the Beguines or certain monastic sisters who tended to the sick and prepared bodies for burial—quiet, solemn work that kept them separate from society. The Sisters take it further with their vow of silence and macabre rituals, but the seed is there.

What’s fascinating is how they mirror historical fears around women and death. Midwives and washerwomen often got accused of witchcraft for handling corpses, and the Sisters’ eerie reputation plays into that. Their mute devotion feels like a nod to anchorites, religious women who lived in seclusion. The show exaggerates their role, but the bones of truth are buried in there—just like the bodies they tend.
Blake
Blake
2025-06-30 09:36:31
I’ve always been intrigued by how 'Silent Sisters' blend fact and fantasy. Real-life counterparts exist in cloistered nuns, like the Poor Clares or Carmelites, who took vows of silence and lived apart from the world. The Sisters’ focus on deathwork echoes the medieval 'Anchoresses,' who prayed for the dead in tiny cells. But GRRM amps up the gothic horror—no real order removed tongues or embalmed kings. It’s like he took the quiet piety of historical sisters and dipped it in nightmare fuel.
Yasmin
Yasmin
2025-06-28 08:46:17
The 'Silent Sisters' remind me of the 'Miko' in Shinto traditions—women who performed purification rites for the dead. They weren’t silent, but their role as intermediaries between life and death feels similar. Europe had the 'Sisters of Charity,' who cared for corpses during plagues. GRRM probably mashed up these ideas, adding a dash of drama. Real sisters didn’t mutilate themselves, but the vibe of sacred, shadowy labor is spot-on.
Penelope
Penelope
2025-06-27 01:45:03
Think of them as medieval morticians with a fantasy upgrade. Real convents did handle burials, but the Sisters’ muteness and mystery are pure fiction. The closest might be the 'Penitent Sisters,' a lesser-known order that tended battlefields—gruesome, but no vow of silence. GRRM loves historical echoes, then cranks them to eleven. The Sisters are more atmosphere than accuracy, but they nail that medieval dread of death and women who wield it.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Vengeful Sisters
Vengeful Sisters
Being born as twins Phidelia and Phidel were separated at young age due to one or two reasons. Phidelia’s lived with her aunty in Netherlands while Phidel lived with their parents in Australia but they had always kept in touch. On one way or the other Phidelia mysteriously got missen, making her parents return back to Netherlands with Phidel with he bid to find her. They tried to find out more from the school authorities but no nobody seemed to give them any good answers. Phidel then thought there was only one way to find out the whereabout of her sister and that was to get enrolled in the school which she did in her sister's disguise. She from her research found out that her sister lost her life to bullies. She felt bitter, seeking revenge for her sister as her spirit hoovers around her and she is the only one who sees her. What really happened to Phidelia’s? What is the reason behind their separation? And how is Phidel going to get back at her sisters murderers. Will Phidelia’s spirit ever leave her sister? Join me on this journey to find out more.
10
54 Chapters
Sworn sisters
Sworn sisters
This story centers around two blood sisters who turned from loving each other to hating each other. Kalthum the calm and loving sister found herself in a situation she never expected, her sister who she loves so much turned into her worse nightmare. Life hasn't been so good at all to her since then. She was blamed for things she didn't do all planned by her sister Basma. Things became worse when their boss realized he was in love with kalthum, Basma made sure to do everything possible to separate this two which she successfully did not until this particular day......
Not enough ratings
45 Chapters
Real Deal
Real Deal
Real Deal Ares Collin He's an architect who live his life the fullest. Money, fame, women.. everything he wants he always gets it. You can consider him as a lucky guy who always have everything in life but not true love. He tries to find true love but he gave that up since he's tired of finding the one. Roseanne West Romance novelist but never have any relationship and zero beliefs in love. She always shut herself from men and she always believe that she will die as a virgin. She even published all her novels not under her name because she never want people to recognize her.
10
48 Chapters
The Romanov Sisters
The Romanov Sisters
The whole world has changed. In the year 2054, the human race is no longer the largest population on earth. The global invasion of a new yet not quite new species has forced the remaining people to hide in fear. Just like the other war survivors, Avery Pierce tries to escape death by hiding from them. But when she reaches seventeen, her life is doomed. She is sold as a slave to an old powerful family. Living in a beautiful mansion, she has to serve her owner, the mistress of the house. Will she be treated as a mere slave or maybe something more?
10
49 Chapters
Sisters Before Misters
Sisters Before Misters
Before my engagement, a fire broke out in my dressing room. The explosion sent shards of glass deep into my body. My best friend, Monica Addams, shielded me as we escaped the flames.  At the hospital, she stayed by my side as I clung to life.  She called my fiancé, James Miller. However, his response was dismissive. “Veronica isn’t feeling well, and I’m accompanying her to get an IV drip. If it’s no big deal, just drop it.” Furious, Monica unleashed a string of curses and called her own boyfriend, Lucas Smith, asking him to help find a specialist.  He brushed her off, too. “Stop overreacting. Veronica’s sick, so I’m getting her some medicine.” When I narrowly escaped death and met Monica’s gaze, I said in a low voice, “I want to call off the engagement.” Without hesitation, she responded, “If you end yours, I’ll end mine.” That was when both men panicked. 
9 Chapters
Real Identities
Real Identities
"No, that's where I want to go" she yelled. ** Camila, a shy and gentle young adult is excited to join a prestigious institution owned by the renown Governor. She crosses path with Chloe, the Governor's niece who's hell bent on making schooling horrible for her. And, she meets the school darling, the Governor's son, Henry, who only attends school for fun. Her relationship with him deepened and through him, her identity starts surfacing. Will she be able to accept her real Identity? What happens when her identity clashes with that of Henry? Will the love between them blossom after their identities are surfaced? How will Chloe take the news?
1
96 Chapters

Related Questions

Why Are The 'Silent Sisters' Forbidden To Speak In The Books?

4 answers2025-06-25 21:43:49
In 'A Song of Ice and Fire', the Silent Sisters are a religious order dedicated to preparing the dead for burial. Their vow of silence is deeply symbolic, reflecting their role as intermediaries between the living and the dead. Silence signifies respect for the deceased, ensuring their passage to the afterlife remains undisturbed. It also distances them from worldly distractions, allowing them to focus solely on their sacred duties. Their muteness isn’t just a rule—it’s a spiritual discipline, a way to honor death’s solemnity without the clutter of words. The practice might also stem from the Faith of the Seven’s teachings, where silence can represent purity and detachment. By forsaking speech, the Sisters embody humility, becoming blank slates for mourning families to project their grief upon. Their silence isn’t oppressive; it’s a form of service, a way to comfort without imposing. The taboo around their voices adds an eerie mystique, reinforcing their otherworldly role in Westerosi society.

Who Are The 'Silent Sisters' In 'A Song Of Ice And Fire'?

4 answers2025-06-25 10:14:07
The 'Silent Sisters' in 'A Song of Ice and Fire' are a somber and enigmatic order of women devoted to the Stranger, the god of death in the Faith of the Seven. They handle the deceased, preparing bodies for burial with eerie precision—washing, embalming, and shrouding them in silence, as they’ve taken vows of perpetual muteness. Their ghastly pallor and hooded robes make them figures of both reverence and dread. Unlike the maesters or septas, their role is purely funerary, yet steeped in sacred duty. They navigate the horrors of war, tending to corpses with unsettling detachment, their silence amplifying their mystique. Some whisper they possess forbidden knowledge of necromancy, though they never confirm it. Their presence lingers like a shadow, a reminder of mortality in a world where death is ever-present.

How Do The 'Silent Sisters' Prepare The Dead In 'Game Of Thrones'?

4 answers2025-06-25 20:25:07
The Silent Sisters in 'Game of Thrones' are shrouded in reverence and mystery, their rituals as precise as they are solemn. They cleanse the dead with meticulous care, stripping the body of clothing and washing it with oils and herbs to purify the flesh. The organs are removed and preserved in jars, a practice both practical and symbolic, ensuring the body doesn’t bloat or decay too quickly. The corpse is then wrapped in linen, its face covered to shield the living from the hollow gaze of death. Candles are lit, prayers whispered—though the sisters themselves are voiceless, their devotion speaks volumes. Their work isn’t just about preparing the dead; it’s about honoring the transition from life to whatever lies beyond. They stitch wounds closed, dress the body in simple shrouds, and sometimes even bleach the bones if the family requests it. The sisters handle nobles and smallfolk alike, their impartiality a quiet rebuke to the realm’s divisions. There’s a haunting beauty in their silence, a reminder that death is the great equalizer, and their hands are its gentle attendants.

What Role Do The 'Silent Sisters' Play In Westerosi Funerals?

4 answers2025-06-25 15:26:14
The 'Silent Sisters' are a haunting yet essential part of Westerosi funerals, serving as the keepers of the dead with a solemnity that chills the spine. Cloaked in grey and sworn to silence, they prepare corpses for burial with eerie precision—washing, embalming, and shrouding bodies to honor the deceased. Their vow of silence isn’t just tradition; it’s a shield against the horrors they handle daily, distancing themselves from the living world. They’re often seen as omens, their presence a grim reminder of mortality, yet their work ensures the dead are treated with dignity, even in war’s aftermath. Beyond practicality, they embody the Faith’s teachings on humility and service, operating in the shadows to spare families the gruesome tasks. In a land where death is frequent and brutal, their role is both a mercy and a macabre art—silent, steadfast, and utterly indispensable.

Do The 'Silent Sisters' Appear In The 'Game Of Thrones' TV Show?

4 answers2025-06-25 10:04:06
The 'Silent Sisters' do indeed appear in the 'Game of Thrones' TV show, though their role is more subtle compared to the books. These mysterious women, clad in grey robes with faces hidden by hoods, are responsible for preparing the dead for burial—a sacred duty in Westeros. Their silence isn’t just a vow; it’s a defining trait, adding an eerie gravitas to their presence. While they don’t get much screen time, their appearances are memorable, like when they tend to Catelyn Stark’s prayers for her father’s bones or handle the aftermath of battles. The show captures their otherworldly aura perfectly, making them feel like relics of an older, grimmer time. Their inclusion, though minor, enriches the world’s texture, reminding viewers of the unseen forces that keep the realm’s traditions alive. Unlike the books, where their rituals and history are fleshed out, the series treats them more as atmospheric backdrop. But that’s enough to leave an impression. Their quiet, shuffling movements and the way other characters react to them—often with a mix of respect and unease—speaks volumes. It’s a testament to the show’s attention to detail that even these fringe elements feel integral to the world’s dark, medieval realism.

Who Are The Three Sisters In 'Blue Sisters'?

5 answers2025-06-23 15:54:44
The 'Blue Sisters' focuses on three siblings whose bond is as deep as the ocean and as turbulent as a storm. The eldest sister, Eleanor, is the pragmatic anchor of the family, a former lawyer who left her career to care for their estranged mother. Middle sister Bonnie is the wildcard—a free-spirited musician chasing highs and lows, both in her art and her addiction struggles. The youngest, Isla, is the quiet observer, a medical student haunted by their shared past. Their dynamic is a messy, beautiful collision of responsibility, rebellion, and redemption. The novel explores how their individual traumas—especially the loss of their fourth sister—shape their identities. Eleanor’s stoicism masks guilt, Bonnie’s chaos hides vulnerability, and Isla’s precision struggles to control the uncontrollable. Each sister’s journey reflects different ways grief can fracture and rebuild a family. What makes them unforgettable is how their flaws mirror their strengths. Eleanor’s control freak tendencies saved them from homelessness, Bonnie’s recklessness brings spontaneity to their lives, and Isla’s emotional distance lets her see truths the others avoid. The ‘blue’ in their name isn’t just sadness—it’s the depth of their connection, the coldness of their conflicts, and the rare moments when they harmonize like notes in a bittersweet song.

Why Does Alicia Remain Silent In 'The Silent Patient'?

4 answers2025-06-26 23:41:36
Alicia's silence in 'The Silent Patient' is a fortress built from trauma and defiance. After shooting her husband five times, she retreats into muteness as both a shield and a scream—a refusal to perform for a world that reduced her pain to spectacle. Her childhood wounds, buried beneath layers of artistic expression, resurface violently. The novel suggests her silence mirrors the voicelessness of abuse survivors, echoing how society often dismisses women's rage as madness. Her therapist Theo uncovers a chilling truth: Alicia's muteness isn’t just psychological armor but a calculated act of revenge. By denying explanations, she forces others to confront their own complicity in her suffering. The twist reveals her silence as the ultimate power play—a way to control the narrative, just as her husband once controlled her. It’s a haunting critique of how we demand victims speak on our terms.

Who Are The Seven Sisters In 'My Seven Sisters Are Unparalleled'?

3 answers2025-06-09 03:59:45
The seven sisters in 'My Seven Sisters Are Unparalleled' are a powerhouse of distinct personalities and abilities that make them legendary. Violet is the eldest, a strategic genius who manipulates politics like a chessboard. Indigo, the second, is a merciless assassin with blades faster than light. Blue is the tech whiz, hacking into anything with a circuit. Green controls nature, making plants grow or wither at her will. Yellow is the brute force, crushing mountains with her fists. Orange is the illusionist, bending perceptions to her whims. Red, the youngest, is pure chaos, her powers unpredictable even to her siblings. Together, they're an unstoppable force, each complementing the others' weaknesses with their strengths. Their bond isn't just blood; it's a symphony of destruction and loyalty, making them feared and revered in their world.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status