Does Naruto'S Eternal Mangekyou Surpass Sasuke'S?

I've been deep into 'Naruto' lore for years, and the idea of Naruto unlocking the Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan at eight is a fascinating what-if scenario. Canonically, Naruto never awakens the Sharingan, let alone its advanced forms, since he isn't an Uchiha. But if we imagine an alternate universe where he somehow gains Uchiha genetics or transplants, the process would be brutal. The Mangekyou typically requires traumatic loss—like witnessing a loved one's death. For an eight-year-old, this would mean experiencing something horrifying, possibly the death of someone like Iruka or Hinata early in his life. The emotional toll would shape him into a completely different character, darker and more isolated. Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan requires transplanting another Mangekyou, usually from a sibling. Naruto lacks Uchiha siblings, so this twist would need creative rewriting—perhaps a bond with Sasuke where one sacrifices their eyes. The power scaling at eight would be absurdly OP, but it could mirror themes of destiny and sacrifice the series loves. The visual prowess—Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, or even Kamui—would redefine his battles, making him less about Rasengan spam and more about strategic, ocular dominance. The story implications would be massive, altering everything from the Chunin Exams to Pain's invasion.

I've been deep into 'Naruto' lore for years, and 'Naruto: Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan at Eight' definitely isn't part of the official canon. The main series, both the manga and anime, never mention this title, and Kishimoto's works are the only sources considered canon. Fan-made stories like this often pop up because the Sharingan's evolution is such a fascinating topic. The Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan is a huge deal in the series, requiring intense emotional trauma and a sibling's eyes—something an eight-year-old achieving it breaks every established rule. The idea of a kid mastering it so early contradicts everything we know about the Uchiha clan's power progression. That said, the fanfic community loves exploring 'what if' scenarios, and this one taps into the appeal of overpowered protagonists. The concept might be fun for alternate universe stories, but it doesn't fit the carefully structured power system of the original. Canonically, even Itachi, a prodigy, didn't awaken his Mangekyou until much later after witnessing Shisui's death. The title itself feels like clickbait, playing on the popularity of early-age power fantasies without grounding in the series' actual mechanics. If you're after authentic Naruto content, stick to the manga, anime, or Boruto's official materials.

In 'Naruto', it's Sasuke who unlocks the Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan, not Naruto. Naruto doesn't have the Sharingan—that's an Uchiha clan trait. Sasuke achieves it by transplanting Itachi's eyes after their emotional final battle. The process isn't about training but a brutal exchange of power between brothers. The Eternal Mangekyou stops the blindness curse of overusing the regular Mangekyou, giving Sasuke permanent access to abilities like Amaterasu and Susanoo. While Naruto grows through Sage Mode and Kurama's power, Sasuke's path is darker, relying on Uchiha legacy and sacrifice. Their rivalry shows how different their power systems are—one born of friendship, the other of bloodline.

The Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan in 'Naruto' is one of the most visually stunning and overpowered abilities in the series, and Naruto’s journey to mastering it is nothing short of epic. Unlike the standard Mangekyou, which degrades with use, the Eternal version eliminates the blindness drawback, making it a permanent upgrade. Naruto’s variant amps up his already ridiculous chakra reserves, letting him spam Susano’o like it’s nothing—this massive, armored warrior form becomes his signature move, capable of tanking mountain-level attacks and dishing out destruction with energy blades. His control over Amaterasu also sharpens; he can now extinguish the black flames at will, something even Sasuke struggled with early on. But the real game-changer is the Perfect Susano’o. When Naruto taps into this, he’s practically a demigod—the full-bodied Susano’o towers over landscapes, swings swords that slice through entire battlefields, and even flies. Combined with his Kurama chakra, the synergy is insane; he once coated the Susano’o in Nine-Tails energy, creating a hybrid form that could level nations. The Eternal Mangekyou also refines his genjutsu resistance, letting him break high-level illusions that would cripple others. What’s fascinating is how the power reflects his growth—no longer just raw strength, but precision and tactical mastery, making him a nightmare in one-on-one battles.

There’s a cool, brutal logic to how the Eternal Mangekyō Sharingan works in-canon, and the short, concrete list of folks who actually obtained it keeps the power feeling rare and meaningful. From the pages and panels of 'Naruto', the Eternal Mangekyō Sharingan (EMS) is only achieved when someone with a Mangekyō Sharingan transplants the Mangekyō eyes of a close blood relative into themselves. That transplant cancels out the progressive blindness caused by using the Mangekyō and fuses the ocular abilities into a stronger, more stable form. In canon, the two explicit, confirmed cases are Madara Uchiha — who took his brother Izuna’s eyes — and Sasuke Uchiha — who received Itachi’s eyes. Those two moments are framed as pivotal: Madara’s gaining EMS cemented his legendary power, and Sasuke’s transplant after Itachi’s death was a major turning point for his battles in 'Naruto Shippuden'. I still get chills reading those scenes; the artwork and the weight of Uchiha tragedy make the mechanics feel tragic and intimate. It’s also why characters who had lots of Sharingan, like Danzo, or outsiders who borrowed eyes, like Kakashi, never ended up with EMS — the transplant has to be from a compatible Uchiha bloodline, not just a random eye swap or a hoard of stolen eyeballs. So, canonically, if you’re asking who can obtain EMS: only Uchiha with Mangekyō Sharingan who transplant a Mangekyō from a close blood relative can — and we’ve only seen Madara and Sasuke actually get there in the official story. That rarity is part of what makes the EMS so memorable in 'Naruto'.

Some nights I’ll stay up rewatching the fight scenes in 'Naruto' and get hung up on how much power comes with real consequences — the 'Eternal Mangekyō Sharingan' is a perfect example. On the surface it looks like a cheat-code: it cancels the progressive blindness that Mangekyō users suffer and gives a person far more stable access to powerful techniques. But that doesn’t mean it’s free of cost. First, there’s the physical toll: even with the eternal upgrade, using high-end ocular jutsu — think Susanoo, Amaterasu, heavy genjutsu — chews through chakra and stamina like nothing else. Full-body Susanoo, for instance, can drain someone to the point of near-collapse or shorten their lifespan if used recklessly. Second, getting the Eternal Mangekyō requires transplanting another Uchiha’s eyes; that’s an invasive, permanent procedure with huge ethical and emotional costs. Families are torn apart, donors are often incapacitated or killed, and the recipient carries the weight of that sacrifice. There’s also the compatibility issue — eye transplants only work reliably within the Uchiha line, and you’re stuck with whatever visual abilities merge into your new pattern. Finally, don’t underestimate the mental strain. The visions, trauma, and temptation to rely on overwhelming ocular power can warp tactics and personality. You gain an immense advantage, but it rewires how you fight, how you relate to others, and how much you can realistically push your body without paying a severe price. It’s not a free upgrade — it’s trading one set of limits for a different, often darker, set of consequences.

There’s something almost poetic about how two eyes can mean entirely different destinies in 'Naruto'. For me, the Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan feels like a perfected family heirloom — it keeps everything that made the Mangekyou powerful (the sharper perception, the monstrous genjutsu, the Susanoo upgrades) but strips away the tragic price: the progressive blindness. Mechanically, it’s still a Sharingan-based dojutsu. You get amplified visual genjutsu, faster reflexes, more precise chakra control tied to the eye, and Susanoo that’s more stable and less taxing. The key lore point is how it’s obtained: transplanting another Uchiha’s Mangekyou eyes into someone who already has Mangekyou unlocks a permanent, non-degenerative form. That’s why Madara and later others could keep using their ocular powers without going blind. The Rinnegan sits on a different throne. It’s not just an upgrade of visual acuity; it’s a fundamentally different toolset. Rinnegan grants access to the Six Paths techniques, planetary-level abilities (think gravity or soul manipulation in certain hands), chakra receivers, and command over life-and-death when tied to the Outer Path. In-story, it’s often connected to a broader, almost divine inheritance — Hagoromo’s chakra, combining Uchiha and Senju elements, or long-term jutsu and implants. Where Eternal Mangekyou refines and removes the downside of a very Uchiha-centric power, the Rinnegan opens a whole new array of abilities that change how a fight is fought — from eye duels to cosmic-scale techniques. In practical terms I like to think of it like tools in my gaming inventory: Eternal Mangekyou = upgraded legendary weapon optimized for the same playstyle; Rinnegan = unlocking a whole new class with unique skills. Both are ridiculously powerful, but they come from different trees and tell different stories about lineage and sacrifice. Personally, I prefer watching the interplay between them — it’s where strategy and tragedy collide in the best way.

I get nerd-chills talking about this one — the Eternal Mangekyō Sharingan is basically the Uchiha's 'stopgap turned upgrade'. In practical terms, the regular Mangekyō Sharingan slowly robs its user of sight the more you use its techniques. When someone with that degeneration receives another Uchiha's Mangekyō eyes (usually via transplant), the result is the Eternal Mangekyō Sharingan and the most obvious immediate effect is that your vision is restored and the progressive blindness stops. In other words, the blurring and eventual loss of eyesight caused by continual Mangekyō usage is cured. Beyond just preventing blindness, I've always loved how the Eternal form feels like a qualitative upgrade in battles: eyesight becomes sharper, reactions get crisper, and you can use Mangekyō techniques more freely without fearing the ticking clock of blindness. It also tends to merge or augment the ocular abilities of both donors, so you can access a broader set of techniques or stronger variants. Canon examples like Madara and Sasuke show that patterns can change and power spikes significantly after the transplant. There's also an intangible edge — improved perception of chakra flow, faster target tracking, and stronger resistance to genjutsu. That said, it's not a magic get-out-of-everything card. Techniques still cost chakra and strain the body, and the transplant itself is grim and risky in-universe. I usually end up picturing the scene from 'Naruto' where characters make that terrible choice — it fixes the eyes, but it leaves a complicated legacy, which always gets me thinking about the cost of power.