Which New York Times Best Books Of 2023 Are Ideal For Book Clubs?
Our club's looking for this year's standout fiction with layered characters and discussion-worthy moral conflicts. Which 2023 NYT picks sparked the best debates for your group?
2026-08-05 15:06:35
60
Follow6
Share
AmeliaBud
Novel Scout
Worker
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test
13 Answers
TomHill
Bibliophile
Mechanic
Our club had a split vote on 'Yellowface.' Half thought it was a razor-sharp satire of publishing and cultural appropriation, the other half found the protagonist so insufferable it was a chore to read. That division actually made for a fantastic meeting! We debated unlikeable narrators, the ethics of the story, and how much the plot mirrored real publishing drama. If your group enjoys moral ambiguity and industry inside baseball, it’s a top contender.
2026-08-06 01:25:52
5
RexBowen
Helpful Reader
Pharmacist
Length is a practical hurdle. 'The Covenant of Water' is a masterpiece, but if half your club are parents with full-time jobs, they might not finish it. Nothing kills a discussion faster than half the room being on chapter 3. 'Tom Lake' or 'The Rachel Incident' are shorter, equally rich options that respect people’s time. Completion rate is the first rule of book club engagement.
2026-08-06 11:09:29
2
ChaseDay
Longtime Reader
Data Analyst
I'm just sitting here taking notes. My club picks books by throwing darts at a board, literally. This thread is giving me way too much credit.
2026-08-06 20:37:03
3
FinnStone
Active Reader
Nurse
Our moderator always prepares a few 'cheat sheet' questions beyond the publisher’s guide. For 'The Fraud,' we looked up the real-life Tichborne case. For 'The Wager,' we found diagrams of the ship. Having that extra context ready can kickstart a stalled conversation or add depth for those who want it. A little preparation goes a long way in elevating the discussion from 'I liked/didn’t like it.'
2026-08-07 02:51:11
2
SimonBell
Book Guide
Teacher
The pacing of a book matters for discussion. A propulsive thriller like 'The Last Devil to Die' (the new Thursday Murder Club) might get read fast, but there’s often less to discuss beyond 'whodunit.' The NYT list's literary fiction tends to be slower, with more texture and ambiguity—that’s the stuff that generates real conversation. Plot-driven books can be fun, but theme-driven books make for better meetings.
2026-08-07 13:01:58
2
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
The Wife He Never Meant to Love
Luna Hart
9.6
22.2K
She married him knowing one thing clearly:
love was never part of the agreement.
Their marriage was built on terms, not promises.
A shared home. A shared bed. A public image to maintain.
Nothing more.
He was distant, controlled, and never cruel — but never warm either.
To him, she was a wife in name, a solution to a problem, a role that needed to be filled.
What neither of them expected was how silence could become dangerous.
How intimacy without love could still leave marks.
How wanting someone could come long before admitting it.
As the line between obligation and desire begins to blur, she must decide how long she can stay where she isn’t truly chosen — and he must face the truth he never planned for.
Because sometimes, the most dangerous thing isn’t loving someone too much…
It’s realizing you never meant to love them at all.
The Price of Peace: Book 3 In The No More Regrets Series
Shay Robinson
10
1.8K
The Price of Peace is the final showdown and book three for the No Regrets crew, where the masks come off and the bills finally come due. Shane O’Brien is done playing house. He’s been living his life like a "glorified roommate" with his wife, Isla, ever since she broke their vows with her best friend's husband, but now the cold war is turning hot. While Shane finds a temporary sanctuary with Maya Cruz, Isla is weaponizing their children trying to save a marriage that might already be lost, but will she realize this too late, or burn the whole house down. Speaking of Maya, she has a few secrets of her own, one that involves Mayor Rogers and a scandal that could level the city.
In the courtroom, Crandon Morgan is fighting to keep his name clean after a very public mental meltdown. He’s looking for a comeback, but he finds a distraction in Tempest Summers, a new law junior associate with a haunted past and a hunger for a kind of justice the law books don’t cover.
Meanwhile, Kole Michaels is trapped in a different kind of nightmare. A past mistake named Akeisha is using a legal loophole to pin a child named Urmagisty on him. With his relationship with a different Keisha on the line and his daughter Mabel watching, Kole has to prove he’s being set up before the lie becomes his life.
In this game, peace isn't free, you have to pay for it in blood, truth, or with everything you own.
My Billionaire Husband's Betrayal: A Hidden Heiress Rises
WRITELORDESS
0
990
Kate Taylor spent seven years being the perfect wife. She gave up her dreams of becoming a celebrated chef, abandoned her culinary career, and molded herself into exactly what her husband David wanted—quiet, obedient, and invisible.
When she finally decided to get her life together, he refused. She got tired of the humiliation after he refused her from taking an offer as a chef.
Kate files for divorce and returns to the only thing that ever made her feel alive—cooking. She takes the job at Morrison's, the most prestigious restaurant in New York, under Chef Henri Laurent and his son Alex. Her talent explodes back to life. Critics rave about her dishes and her name starts trending. She's finally remembering who she was before David made her forget.
But David won't let her go without a fight. He weaponizes their children against her, turns their son Theo against her, threatens her career, and parades Sarah around like she's already his wife. He wants to destroy everything Kate is building.
Then she finds out a secret David had been hiding for six years, Sarah was more than his secretary.
As custody battles turn vicious, family secrets surface, and old enemies join forces, Kate must decide: will she let the past control her future, or will she finally claim the empire she deserves?
Some women fall apart after betrayal but Kate Taylor will build an empire.
She thought she had it all—a peaceful life, a loving relationship, and a future she could finally count on. But everything shattered the moment she discovered the truth.
He never planned to stay. He never planned to love her.
He only wanted the child.
Forced to make an impossible choice, she vanished, determined to protect the life growing inside her. For years, she lived in silence, hiding the truth, raising a secret no one could ever know.
But fate has a cruel way of circling back.
When the past resurfaces in the most unexpected way, everything she fought to protect hangs in the balance.
The lies. The love. The billion-dollar secret.
Some stories aren’t meant to stay buried.
And some truths refuse to stay hidden.
The Billionaire Married Me, Then Forgot How to Love Me
Anney GW
10
21.2K
Serena Hale was never meant to belong in a world of diamonds, monogrammed robes, and dinner parties soaked in judgment.
Once a humble bakery girl, she eloped into a whirlwind marriage with billionaire James Hale, trading flour-dusted dreams for gilded heartbreak.
Now, Savannah’s back. James’s sophisticated, pregnant ex-fiancée has returned like a ghost wearing pearls, slipping seamlessly into his life, his home, and maybe… his heart.
As Savannah moves into their world like she never left, Serena is forced to smile through whispers and cold stares. James’s mother, ice-blooded and brutal, now she’s made her message clear: Serena was the wrong choice. The second choice. And she better not get pregnant again.
But it’s already too late. Serena is carrying James’s child again, a fragile, impossible hope tucked beneath her still flat stomach.
He says he loves her. He swears he chose her. But he didn’t come home last night. And Serena is no longer sure if James is lying to her… or to himself.
As secrets build and the tide turns against her, Serena must decide if love is enough to hold onto a marriage that may have never truly been hers before the truth rips everything apart again.
Because this time, it’s not just her heart at stake. She has a baby to think of.
Contracts of Desire: The Billionaire Romance Collection
Holi T. Watson
10
388
Six dangerous billionaires. Six women caught in the ruthless games of wealth, power, revenge, and desire.
A Lottery Marriage with My CEO Boss: Nova Pierce is forced into an elite lottery marriage system by the parents who should have protected her—only to be chosen by Nicolai Moreau, her cold, calculating, and fearsome CEO boss.
The Arrangement: Dyanna Croft, a girl from the slums, is offered a contract engagement by Dante Westmore, a wealthy heir desperate to secure his inheritance and control of the family business.
Marrying My Billionaire Best friend: Leah agrees to be her billionaire best friend Corey’s fake fiancée to stop his arranged marriage—but their pretend romance quickly turns real. As pressure from his powerful family grows, they must choose between protecting their friendship… or risking everything for love.
The Assistant and the Beast: Abigail Price works under billionaire tech mogul Andre Crawford, the boss from hell—until late-night work sessions reveal the wounded, forbidden man beneath the monster.
The Investment: struggling fashion designer Carla Hill is given a chance by Quinton Truce, the ruthless beast of high couture, and discovers that one investment can change far more than her career.
Reborn—This Time I’m Choosing the Brute: Willamina Perez awakens on the day that once sealed her tragic fate. Betrayed and murdered by the husband she loved and the sister who envied her, she refuses to repeat the same mistake. This time, she chooses Isaiah Vearnen, the corporate beast everyone fears—never knowing he has loved her all along.
Dark, sensual, and addictive, this anthology follows women who refuse to remain pawns and billionaires who will risk everything for the one woman they cannot possess without losing control.
I'm just sitting here taking notes. My book club is stuck in a rut of picking the same kind of domestic thrillers, and this thread is giving me so many better ideas to suggest. Thanks, all!
For a book club, I often suggest starting with a compelling question the book poses. 'The Measure' by Nikki Erlick presents a doozy: what if everyone on Earth received a box with a string inside, revealing the length of their life? It’s a thought experiment in novel form. The discussion practically runs itself: Would you look? How would society change? The book explores different characters' choices, touching on love, ambition, and fate. It’s not the most literary prose, but the premise is so engaging and discussable that it led to one of our most participatory meetings ever.
Sometimes you need a book that's purely about complex relationships, and 'Commonwealth' is Ann Patchett at her best. It chronicles the blended, messy Keating and Cousins families over five decades, starting with an illicit kiss that rearranges everyone's lives. The discussion is all about character dynamics: parental failures, sibling rivalry, the stories families tell themselves, and the accidental nature of tragedy. Patchett doesn't judge her characters, which allows the club to debate their actions freely.
It’s a masterful study of how a single event ripples through generations, providing endless material for analyzing motivations and consequences.
Huh, I haven't read most of these. My club just picks whatever's cheapest at the used bookstore that month. It's led to some wild cards, but it's never boring! Maybe the 'ideal' is just a sense of adventure and no pressure to be profound.
'The Secret Chord' by Geraldine Brooks (King David's story) is a masterclass in historical fiction. Brooks brings such depth and humanity to biblical figures. Our discussion dove into the nature of power, faith, art, and violence. It's a profound character study of a deeply flawed leader. Some members were hesitant because of the religious subject, but it's told from such a humanist perspective that it resonated with everyone. The writing is, as always with Brooks, impeccable. It sparked one of our most nuanced debates.