LOGINLibrary
Search
How Do Old Habits Affect Redemption Arcs In Manga?
2025-10-27 23:02:03
40
6 Answers
Xander
2025-10-29 12:37:40
Redemption arcs in manga fascinate me because old habits act like stubborn ghosts — they don’t vanish just because a character decides to change. I love how mangaka make the clash between intention and habit feel lived-in: the protagonist may declare a new path, but panels show the hand twitching toward a blade, the same grim expression slipping back in, or the repetition of a childhood ritual that never quite leaves. For example, in 'Vinland Saga' Thorfinn’s attempts to embrace nonviolence are haunted by the muscle memory and trauma of a life spent fighting; the story forces you to sit with relapse and shame rather than hand the character a tidy moral victory.
What excites me is the craft — pacing, visual callbacks, and secondary characters all amplify those lingering habits. A close-up on an old scar, a repeated sound effect when a temptation appears, or a mentor who refuses to trust immediately turns redemption into a process. This makes the eventual shift feel earned: we celebrate small victories first, like a week without a violent outburst, then bigger transformations. It’s not just about personal willpower; it’s about social proof and new rituals that replace the old ones.
On a personal level, seeing characters wrestle with their past behaviors reminds me that real change is messy and slow. That honesty is why I keep reading: I want the tension of relapse and the relief of real growth, even if it takes a hundred chapters to get there.
What excites me is the craft — pacing, visual callbacks, and secondary characters all amplify those lingering habits. A close-up on an old scar, a repeated sound effect when a temptation appears, or a mentor who refuses to trust immediately turns redemption into a process. This makes the eventual shift feel earned: we celebrate small victories first, like a week without a violent outburst, then bigger transformations. It’s not just about personal willpower; it’s about social proof and new rituals that replace the old ones.
On a personal level, seeing characters wrestle with their past behaviors reminds me that real change is messy and slow. That honesty is why I keep reading: I want the tension of relapse and the relief of real growth, even if it takes a hundred chapters to get there.
Parker
2025-11-01 16:37:13
I notice old habits in redemption arcs like recurring motifs on a page: the same body language, a favorite insult, or a repeated moral shortcut. Those patterns shape how believable a character’s return to decency feels. If a story glosses over habit and only swaps external goals, the redemption rings hollow. But when a manga acknowledges relapse—shows the character returning to old ways under stress and then actively choosing differently—that’s where things get nuanced and satisfying.
Narratively, habits serve as both obstacle and evidence. A villain with a habit of betrayal needs time and credible incentives to change; seeing them rebuild trust incrementally, perhaps through reparative acts that cost them, is more powerful than a sudden moral epiphany. Creators often use visual repetition—panels that echo earlier scenes—to track this evolution, and series like 'Monster' emphasize how a single ingrained worldview resists quick reform. I’m particularly drawn to stories that let community reactions matter: redemption that includes forgiveness, restitution, and boundaries feels truer than simple absolution. In short, old habits complicate redemption in the best way, and I appreciate authors who treat change as work rather than a plot checkbox—it's the messy, human stuff that keeps me reading.
Narratively, habits serve as both obstacle and evidence. A villain with a habit of betrayal needs time and credible incentives to change; seeing them rebuild trust incrementally, perhaps through reparative acts that cost them, is more powerful than a sudden moral epiphany. Creators often use visual repetition—panels that echo earlier scenes—to track this evolution, and series like 'Monster' emphasize how a single ingrained worldview resists quick reform. I’m particularly drawn to stories that let community reactions matter: redemption that includes forgiveness, restitution, and boundaries feels truer than simple absolution. In short, old habits complicate redemption in the best way, and I appreciate authors who treat change as work rather than a plot checkbox—it's the messy, human stuff that keeps me reading.
Piper
2025-11-01 20:44:29
Habitual tics—an eye twitch, the involuntary clench of a fist, always taking the high ground with violence—act like anchors on a character, and breaking them is the hard, believable part of any redemption. In a single scene a repeated habit can betray how much of the character’s old life is still living inside them, and that’s where empathy grows: we see the struggle in small, ordinary failures.
I think the strongest manga portrayals make redemption incremental. Instead of dramatic one-off confessions, they show a series of small choices that add up: a rescued animal kept rather than abandoned, a lie corrected, a familiar phrase replaced by a new habit over many panels. That slow accumulation makes the final change feel earned. When I read these arcs, I tend to linger on the little moments—gestures, unease, the way other characters respond—because they’re the honest proof of transformation, and they stick with me longer than any dramatic climax.
I think the strongest manga portrayals make redemption incremental. Instead of dramatic one-off confessions, they show a series of small choices that add up: a rescued animal kept rather than abandoned, a lie corrected, a familiar phrase replaced by a new habit over many panels. That slow accumulation makes the final change feel earned. When I read these arcs, I tend to linger on the little moments—gestures, unease, the way other characters respond—because they’re the honest proof of transformation, and they stick with me longer than any dramatic climax.
Zane
2025-11-02 01:10:50
Old habits in manga often operate like narrative gravity — they pull characters back even as the plot pushes them forward, and I find that interplay really compelling. In quieter series like 'Monster', the past choices keep orbiting the protagonist, coloring other characters’ perceptions and making redemption feel complicated rather than purely heroic. The writer uses consequence and reputation as a stickier form of habit: people remember, and that memory shapes how easy or hard it is to start anew.
From a more structural angle, authors use relapse as a device to test sincerity. A character who repeatedly lapses into old behavior exposes whether their change was performative or deep. Visual storytelling helps here: recurring motifs, panels that mirror earlier scenes, or shifts in linework and shading can signal that an old pattern is resurfacing. Conversely, new small rituals — tending a garden, answering a child’s questions, taking responsibility for an injury — are shown in mundane detail to demonstrate habit formation in the positive direction.
I also appreciate how some manga explore systemic factors that reinforce bad habits: poverty, trauma, or living conditions can make harmful patterns the rational choice. Redemption becomes communal, not just individual — acceptance by others, restitution, and new social roles are part of the cure. That realism is what keeps me hooked; I love watching whether the world around the character adapts as much as the character does.
From a more structural angle, authors use relapse as a device to test sincerity. A character who repeatedly lapses into old behavior exposes whether their change was performative or deep. Visual storytelling helps here: recurring motifs, panels that mirror earlier scenes, or shifts in linework and shading can signal that an old pattern is resurfacing. Conversely, new small rituals — tending a garden, answering a child’s questions, taking responsibility for an injury — are shown in mundane detail to demonstrate habit formation in the positive direction.
I also appreciate how some manga explore systemic factors that reinforce bad habits: poverty, trauma, or living conditions can make harmful patterns the rational choice. Redemption becomes communal, not just individual — acceptance by others, restitution, and new social roles are part of the cure. That realism is what keeps me hooked; I love watching whether the world around the character adapts as much as the character does.
Xanthe
2025-11-02 04:43:54
Redemption arcs that lean on old habits are some of my favorite narrative engines, because habits are stubborn little ghosts that keep dragging characters back toward their worst selves. I get pulled in by the idea that change isn’t a light switch—it's a slow, uneven reprogramming. In many manga, the repeated behaviors (a character flinching at touch, snapping at friends, or resorting to violence first) are shorthand for a whole backstory of fear, trauma, and learned survival. When an author shows those reflexes persisting even as the character professes growth, the arc gains emotional weight: you can feel the tension between intention and impulse.
I love when creators use small, mundane details to dramatize relapse and progress. A time-skip where a former bully still straightens his collar before apologizing, or a montage of awkward therapy-like conversations, tells me more than a single contrite speech. Works like 'Violet Evergarden' handle this by having gestures and letters stand in for internal change, while darker stories such as 'Tokyo Ghoul' play with recurring violent habit as both threat and a marker of what must be overcome. The best redemptions don’t erase habits; they rewire them, often through relationships, consequences, and repetitive practice. That slow, sometimes painful repatterning is what makes me root for characters—I want to see them fail, try again, and slowly stitch new habits into their lives. It feels honest and, honestly, pretty inspiring to watch, like watching someone learn to walk again after a fall.
I love when creators use small, mundane details to dramatize relapse and progress. A time-skip where a former bully still straightens his collar before apologizing, or a montage of awkward therapy-like conversations, tells me more than a single contrite speech. Works like 'Violet Evergarden' handle this by having gestures and letters stand in for internal change, while darker stories such as 'Tokyo Ghoul' play with recurring violent habit as both threat and a marker of what must be overcome. The best redemptions don’t erase habits; they rewire them, often through relationships, consequences, and repetitive practice. That slow, sometimes painful repatterning is what makes me root for characters—I want to see them fail, try again, and slowly stitch new habits into their lives. It feels honest and, honestly, pretty inspiring to watch, like watching someone learn to walk again after a fall.
Wyatt
2025-11-02 12:57:42
Old habits are the secret engine behind believable redemption arcs in manga — they create tension, make change feel earned, and give authors material to dramatize inner conflict. I’m especially drawn to stories where the old behavior isn’t a single villainous act but a set of reflexes: survival strategies, compulsions, or defensive cruelty. Those are harder to write off. Often the best arcs show small, mundane replacements for bad habits — learning a craft, forming daily routines, or a new relationship that interrupts the trigger-response cycle. Visual language helps a lot: repeated panel layouts, flashback inserts, and symbolic objects remind you that the old habit is still there, just quieter. Relapse scenes aren’t failures so much as realistic beats; they reveal weakness and also create moments for other characters to either punish or forgive, which in turn shapes how full the redemption can be. I keep returning to these stories because they mirror real life: change usually happens in fits and starts, not in a single epiphany, and that slow churn feels honest and satisfying to watch.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App
Related Books
Mr. Old Bully
She was a receptionist in one of her friend's luxurious hotels when he walked there to destroy the complete hotel. She remembers him as she knows him well since high school but he doesn't remember her because she is no more the fatty girl which she was back in her high school time.
To save her friend's hotel she stood before him and he abduct her from the place. He manipulates her to become his girlfriend. Few months after he forced her into contract marriage. Several exposures exposed in her life and love blooms between them.
71 Chapters
Rekindling Old Flames
“I need to teach you a lesson for defying me,” Beau says, and in an instant, my leg drops down. He puts his other hand on my waist and lifts me off my chair. Landing perfectly on him, my eyes widen once I feel him against me. “Yes, darlin’, you are the reason for it. And tonight, you are going to satisfy it.” He holds me down, hunger in his eyes.
“I’ll do no such thing,” I say, resisting the urge to grind my hips against him. My already is pressed against his hard length, and I find myself wanting to pull it out so he can fill me up to the hilt and make all my dreams a reality.
“Oh, you will, and you are going to enjoy it.”
****
Delilah Stephen is a young architect trying to make a name for herself without Daddy’s help. She is so close to achieving her goal when something unexpected happens. The investor meant to make her dreams a reality turns out to be someone Delilah wishes never to see again, Beau Williams. He is a handsome billionaire with a dangerous family. He broke Delilah’s heart seven years ago and is now back to win her. Delilah passionately hates Beau, so he has his work cut out for him. She refuses to forget the past, but Beau doesn’t give up. He will stop at nothing to make Delilah feel something for him after so many years. But for how long can he keep trying, and will he ever succeed?
67 Chapters
Redemption
***Mature content***
Alexander Hamilton was born into a ruthless weapons business family in Spain, His family own a lot of companies in Europe, New York and Australia, life was always been an easy thing for him. He doesn't know what are difficulties, he doesn't know what is rejection, he doesn't feel any emotions.
He is well known for his intelligence, arrogance, attitude, cleverness, instincts and no need to say for his hot handsome looks with a figure of 6feet 2 inches height.
•
•
Alisha Heathway was born into a well renowned teachers family in the rural area of England. After she completed her school, she came to London to do masters in English literature. She is intelligent, kind, soft hearted, extrovert with a good sense of humor and always been an open minded.
•
•
When it comes to business there is only one thing DEAL or NO DEAL...., what happens when Alisha makes a deal with Alexander cause that's the only choice she had.. !
44 Chapters
Redemption
Anna is in desperate need of a savior to rescue her from the dangerous world her father left her in. Dante Williams seems like the perfect candidate with his wealth, power, and undeniable attractiveness. But as Anna quickly discovers, Dante is not just a man to be reckoned with, he's a force of nature. And with each step she takes deeper into his world, she realizes that she may need protection from him just as much as she needs his help. Will Anna survive the dangerous game she's playing with Dante? Or will she be consumed by the very man she thought could save her? Find out in this thrilling tale of power, passion, and danger.
84 Chapters
Beloved Old Lover
On the day Emily returned to the country, she received a request from her father, which was to flirt with her ex-lover to achieve the goal of marrying him, saving Wine company, which was on the verge of bankruptcy.
In the flickering light of candles and melodious melodies surrounding, Kevin used force to hug Emily's small waist, pulling her close to his face and whispering:
“Emily, your face is also really thick. Do you think you can still seduce me after you've abandoned me?”
“Aren't you hugging me? You chose me to be your dance partner, not the other girls, right?” Emily curled her lips and asked.
“Don't be too confident about yourself. I'm just worried that you'll seduce my little brother.” Kevin smiled scornfully.
“Then try to hug me tight. If you let go of me, I will seduce your brother.”
125 Chapters
Redemption
Lily Williams and Rose Williams, the twins who are never afraid to speak their minds, always seeking something adventurous. Their wish finally comes true when an old enemy of their father returns but so does the dangers and threats of being born in a mafia family.
They have always been prepared for situations like such and are ready to enjoy this rollercoaster ride, but what they were not ready for, were the two handsome men who have taken a sudden interest in them. Not to forget they just happen to bear the names that sends shivers and fear down everyone's body.
Vincenzo De Connor and Dante De Connor.
One is a gang leader and the other is an assassin . Together they are the best partners in crime ever known to the world.
So what happens when the two unite again? What happens when both have set their goals on getting something they want? More like someone.
Bullets are fired, secrets are unraveled, fear is established, pain is felt, but most importantly..... Love is discovered.
41 Chapters
Related Questions
What Other Songs Are Similar To Westlife'S 'I Wanna Grow Old With You'?
3 Answers2025-10-18 12:18:53
The moment I stumbled upon Westlife's 'I Wanna Grow Old With You,' it struck a chord deep within me, making my heart flutter with nostalgia. The song encapsulates this beautiful sense of love and commitment that many of us dream of. If you’re looking for similar tracks that evoke those warm, fuzzy feelings, let’s talk about a few gems I’ve collected over the years.
First off, 'Thinking Out Loud' by Ed Sheeran is an absolute must. This song has so much depth and sincerity that just melts my heart every time I hear it. Ed captures the essence of growing with your partner beautifully, painting a vivid picture of lasting love that resonates with anyone who dreams of a future with someone special. And how about 'All of Me' by John Legend? This is another emotional powerhouse. The lyrics convey unconditional love and acceptance, making it a wedding favorite. I swear, every time I hear it, I can feel the love in the room!
You can’t forget classics like 'Can’t Help Falling in Love' by Elvis Presley either. It has this timeless quality that speaks volumes about love's eternal nature. These songs, like 'I Wanna Grow Old With You,' share that universal theme of love that transcends time, and I think it’s incredible how music can connect our hearts across generations.
What Novels Explore Themes Of Wanting To Grow Old Together?
4 Answers2025-10-18 14:24:32
'The Notebook' by Nicholas Sparks is an absolute classic that instantly springs to mind when I think about growing old together. The story revolves around Noah and Allie, whose love endures the test of time, despite life's twists and turns. Their journey reminds me of how relationships can evolve, facing challenges like family expectations and personal growth. The lovely way their bond deepens as they age resonates on so many levels, not just romantically but also through shared memories and experiences. The imagery of them sitting together, reminiscing about their life, captures the essence of wanting to grow old together so well.
Another great read is 'The Time Traveler’s Wife' by Audrey Niffenegger. It dives into love that defies time but ultimately underscores those mundane moments that define relationships. Henry and Clare's years together aren't filled with extraordinary events all the time, but it's the simple act of sharing a life despite adversity that really gets to me. Their story highlights how love grows deeper over the years, illustrating that growing old together means cherishing every fleeting moment.
I can’t help but admire how both novels portray love as a journey, showing that with the passage of time, relationships can transform in beauty and complexity, just like vintage wine!
What Songs Reflect The Feeling Of Wanting To Grow Old With A Partner?
5 Answers2025-10-18 12:25:25
An instant classic that springs to mind is 'Perfect' by Ed Sheeran. The lyrics are so heartfelt and paint a beautiful picture of a long-lasting relationship. When I listen to it, I can almost visualize shared moments—laughter over breakfast, walks under the stars, and even the mundane routines that become special when you’re with someone you love. There's something so touching about the promise of growing old together; the idea that every wrinkle and gray hair is a testament to the journey shared. Plus, Ed's voice is like melted chocolate; it wraps around you and just feels right.
Another great track that captures this sentiment is 'Grow Old With You' by Adam Sandler from 'The Wedding Singer.' It’s simple, sweet, and sincere. The way he just wants to be by his partner’s side through thick and thin resonates with so many of us. It perfectly encapsulates that cozy feeling of companionship and the small, sweet moments that define a life shared. The overall vibe makes you smile, thinking about the future adventures that await in a lifetime together.
If you want something a bit more upbeat, 'Better Together' by Jack Johnson is a gem. The gentle guitar and his soothing voice create a relaxed atmosphere that’s perfect for dreaming about life with your significant other. The lyrics remind us that everything in life is better with that special person, like a cup of coffee or a rainy day. You can almost feel the warmth of a sunset while listening. Not to mention, it’s one of those songs you can easily see as a background for a cozy evening on the couch, wrapped in a blanket sharing popcorn.
Lastly, I can’t leave out 'I Choose You' by Sara Bareilles. This one’s all about making a conscious choice to be with someone no matter what. It’s fun, it’s lively, and it carries that sweet promise of commitment. The imagery of building a life and growing old together resonates deeply. The message is transformative—reminding listeners that love isn’t just some fairytale; it’s a beautiful journey filled with choices and moments that shape your life together. Can’t help but feel all warm inside when I think about it!
How Old Is The Actor Who Plays Young Sheldon Bruder?
3 Answers2025-10-14 07:37:23
Here's a neat bit of trivia I keep telling friends: the actor who plays Sheldon's brother Georgie in 'Young Sheldon' is Montana Jordan. He was born on March 8, 2003, in Longview, Texas, which makes him 22 years old as of October 20, 2025. He stepped into the role when the show started airing in 2017 and has grown up on screen right alongside the series, which is part of why so many fans feel connected to the Cooper family.
Watching him over the seasons is wild — you can actually see the kid become an adult in real time. Montana gives Georgie a mix of charm, frustration, and earnestness that sells the whole family dynamic; he’s not just “Sheldon’s brother,” he’s his own person with dreams and occasional dumb decisions. If you follow the show, you’ll notice little moments where the writing and his facial expressions make Georgie feel like a real, complicated kid from Texas.
Beyond the age fact, what I find fun is comparing him to the rest of the cast. People sometimes confuse him with Iain Armitage, who plays young Sheldon, but their ages are different and that contrast shows in the performances. Honestly, I enjoy watching Montana’s career trajectory — he’s got that easygoing, authentic presence on screen that makes me curious what roles he’ll pick next.
Who Are The Key Characters In No Country For Old Men Novel?
5 Answers2025-10-18 21:42:08
The key players in 'No Country for Old Men' are simply unforgettable. You've got Llewellyn Moss, a rugged Vietnam War veteran whose life takes a dark turn when he stumbles upon a drug deal gone wrong and snags a briefcase full of cash. His actions set off a chaotic chain of events that draw in other pivotal characters.
Then there's Anton Chigurh, the chilling hitman with an almost philosophical approach to his work. He’s that unique blend of a sociopath and a ghost, wielding a cattle gun and a coin toss as instruments of fate. His relentless pursuit of Moss makes for an incredibly tense narrative, showcasing the moral decay in the landscape of modern America.
Lastly, Sheriff Bell is the weary lawman who attempts to make sense of this violent world. His reflections on aging and the changes in society add depth to the story and remind us of the moral complexities that intertwine with the chaos. Through Bell, McCarthy emphasizes themes of loss, regret, and the relentless passage of time. These characters not only drive the plot but also weave a rich tapestry of existential questions about fate and morality in a brutal world.
Each character is so nuanced that they invoke a spectrum of emotions, from admiration to profound fear, making it a memorable read that lingers in the mind long after the last page is turned.
What Makes Atomic Habits By James Clear A Bestseller?
4 Answers2025-09-13 12:55:51
From what I've gathered, 'Atomic Habits' by James Clear resonates deeply with many readers because it offers a practical approach to self-improvement. The book isn’t just about grand goals but focuses on the small, seemingly insignificant habits that build up to monumental change. What I truly appreciate is Clear's knack for storytelling—he uses relatable anecdotes to illustrate his points. It’s like he’s chatting with us over coffee, making complex ideas feel digestible and engaging. Plus, the actionable strategies are a game-changer. I've tried applying his concept of the 1% improvement in my daily routines, and it’s astonishing how small tweaks can lead to monumental outcomes over time.
Another engaging aspect is the science behind habit formation; Clear backs everything with research, giving it a credible foundation. This blend of personal experience, scientific evidence, and practical advice creates a compelling narrative that many find both motivating and accessible. From professionals to students, the diverse appeal makes it a perfect choice for anyone looking to cultivate better habits for lasting success. You can't help but feel that this book is more than just a read; it feels like a toolkit to success.
The community around 'Atomic Habits' is equally vibrant. I've stumbled into various book clubs discussing it, and the shared experiences of transformation are invigorating. It fosters this sense of camaraderie, where we're all striving for improvement and celebrating our little wins together. I think that collective journey amplifies its status as a bestseller.
What Music Video Accompanies Westlife'S 'I Wanna Grow Old With You'?
3 Answers2025-09-14 12:41:52
The music video for Westlife's 'I Wanna Grow Old With You' is a delightful experience that encapsulates the warmth of love and companionship. Set in various romantic locations, it features the band against picturesque backdrops while embodying sweet, heartfelt moments. These visuals transport you into a world of youthful love, where couples are seen sharing gentle glances and tender embraces. You can't help but feel the nostalgia pull at your heartstrings as the forlorn settings and beautiful melodies blend together.
In particular, the video features a gorgeous, sunlit park where lovers picnic, dance under the clouds, and even share precious whispers beneath the trees. It’s like a glimpse into a dreamy relationship where everyday moments feel extraordinary. The cinematography is stunning, filled with soft, warm tones that evoke feelings of intimacy and hope. It’s simple yet powerful, illustrating the song's message that true love only deepens with age.
What makes this video truly stand out for me is how it reflects not just romantic love but the profound companionship that grows over the years. Watching this video always reminds me of those quiet moments with someone special, whether it’s a close friend or a significant other. I find that it leaves a warm feeling in my heart!
How Do Manga Series Illustrate The Concept Of Wanting To Grow Old?
4 Answers2025-09-14 04:37:05
In various manga series, the theme of wanting to grow old is often portrayed through character development that reflects the passage of time and the inevitability of life changes. Take 'Your Lie in April,' for example. The protagonist, Kōsei Arima, grapples with his past and the realization that life is both fleeting and precious. You see him transform as he learns to embrace music and love, which symbolizes the growth that comes with age and experience. Every character in this series has their journey, mirroring how each of us grows through our own challenges and triumphs.
Additionally, in 'March Comes in Like a Lion,' we delve into the complexities of growing up. The main character, Rei Kiriyama, faces the pressures and loneliness that often accompany adolescence. His interactions with an endearing family highlight the emotional support that can ease the burden of growing older. There’s a poignant moment when Rei reflects on his maturity, realizing that with age comes understanding and resilience, capturing the bittersweet essence of aging. Each character's journey in these series is a beautiful reminder that wanting to grow old often intertwines with the desire to be understood and to find one’s place in the world.
Ultimately, manga often intertwines this desire for aging with personal growth and connections, showing us that it’s not just about the years but the experiences that shape us along the way.
Popular Question
Popular Searches More
Nineteen Eighty Four
Recreator
And The Mountains Echoed
Only Say Good Things
What Is Fanfiction
Halal Romance Books
MetroNovel
Second Lead Syndrome
My Repentant Brothers
The Silence Of The Girls
Icy Blue Eyes
Quotes About Being Strong
Pdf Into Epub
Google Books
Dark Stalker Romance Books
Online Free Books Romance
The Most Fun We Ever Had
Books To Get Back Into Reading
The Dark Tower: Song Of Susannah
Tower Of God Chaos Bringer
Circ By Sonder
Sluts
Anne Rice Novel
Title Of The Book
Pdf Readers Online
Pocket Reference Book
Mayluna
Vow Of Thieves
Where The Hell Am I And Is That A Kaiju!
NovelShort
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
