Does 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution' Follow The Original 'One Piece' Timeline?

2025-06-18 08:14:11 171

3 answers

Bryce
Bryce
2025-06-23 03:17:50
I've been following 'One Piece' for years, and this spin-off 'One Piece Signing in as a Pirate Begins with Roger's Execution' definitely plays fast and loose with the timeline. While it starts at the iconic execution scene, it quickly diverges by introducing an original protagonist who interacts with key figures like Garp and Rayleigh decades before Luffy sets sail. The author cleverly uses Roger's era as a sandbox, expanding on brief manga mentions like the God Valley incident while inventing new conflicts. Some purists might grumble about timeline tweaks, but seeing Shanks as a rookie or watching Whitebeard's crew rise feels fresh. The tech level and marine hierarchy match Oda's established world-building, making the alternate path believable.
Yasmine
Yasmine
2025-06-20 12:32:35
As someone who analyzes pirate lore across mediums, this fanfic's timeline approach fascinates me. It doesn't just follow the original 'One Piece' chronology—it interrogates it. The story treats Roger's execution as a branching point where history could've unfolded differently. We see marines developing advanced seastone weapons earlier, which logically should've changed the power balance in the main timeline. The fic compensates by showing Vegapunk sabotaging these projects to maintain Oda's tech consistency.

The protagonist's presence creates ripple effects that feel organic. When he allies with a young Doflamingo during the latter's escape from Mariejois, it reshapes the Donquixote family's future without contradicting Dressrosa's canon events. What impresses me is how the writer preserves key milestones—the Ohara incident still occurs, but we now see it through the eyes of a marine defector who joined the protagonist's crew. These parallel narratives make the world feel expansive rather than contradictory.

Where it truly shines is character aging. The fic meticulously tracks how decades should affect characters like Crocus or Sengoku, giving them appropriate power progression. A standout detail is Mihawk's cameo as a teenage swordsman fleeing Marine recruitment, which aligns perfectly with his later reputation as the world's strongest swordsman. The attention to temporal cause-and-effect makes this an enriching companion piece rather than a replacement timeline.
Piper
Piper
2025-06-22 21:39:32
For casual fans wondering about timeline fidelity, here's the scoop: this story is more 'what if' than strict prequel. It nails the emotional beats of Roger's era—the ambition, the betrayal, the birth of the Great Pirate Age—but takes liberties with character intersections. Imagine young Buggy actually showing competence during his early days with Shanks, or Rayleigh mentoring someone besides Luffy. The fic's strength is exploring blank spaces in the timeline, like the lost years between Roger's surrender and his death.

Physical continuity is spot-on. Buildings in Loguetown match their 'One Piece' chapter 1 appearances, and the Going Merry's design reflects its later inspiration from Roger's ship. Even minor details like the absence of transponder snails in early chapters get addressed by showing their experimental phase. The writer clearly studied Oda's timeline bible but wasn't afraid to plant new seeds. My favorite touch is how the protagonist's actions indirectly cause events we know—like his raid on a marine base inspiring the stricter bounty poster system Luffy encounters.
ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด
สแกนรหัสเพื่อดาวน์โหลดแอป

Related Books

One Night One Love ❤️ดวงใจรามสูร
One Night One Love ❤️ดวงใจรามสูร
รามสูร พิสิฐกุลวัตรดิลก ลูกชายคนโตของแก้มใสคุณแม่สายเฟียร์ส ผู้ชายเจ้าเล่ห์และแสนเย็นชาที่วันหนึ่งต้องเปลี่ยนจากถือปืนมาถือขวดนม เพราะความเฟียร์สที่ถูกถ่ายทอดมาจากมารดาทำให้รามสูรเกลียดการท้าทายเป็นที่สุด ดื่มเหล้าอะงานถนัดแต่ดื่มจนเมาและเผลอไปมี One Night กับคู่อรินี่น่ะสิ ที่ทำให้ชีวิตของรามสูรต้องเปลี่ยนไปตลอดกาล จากมาเฟียหน้าโหดเข้าสู่โหมดผัวขี้อ้อน "ใครกล้าแตะเมียกู......มึงตาย" เขา ร้ายกับคนทั้งโลกยกเว้นกับเธอแค่เพียงคนเดียวเท่านั้น เขา เย็นชากับผู้หญิงทั้งโลกยกเว้นเมียเด็กอย่างเธอเท่านั้น ม่อนไหม วิจิตรเดชากุลณรงค์ ปี 2 คณะวิศวกรรมศาสตร์สาขาเครื่องกล สาวสวยแสนแสบแสนซนที่ต้องเปลี่ยนจากไล่ตีคนมาเป็นคุณแม่ยังสาว ดื่มเหล้าอะเรื่องจิ๊บๆแต่ดื่มจนเมาแล้วเผลอไปมี One Night กับคู่อรินี่น่ะสิ ที่ทำให้ชีวิตในรั้วมหาวิทยาลัยต้องจบลงอย่างงงๆ จากสาวสวยหน้าโหดเข้าสู่โหมดแมวน้อยขี้อ้อน "ใครกล้าแตะผัวกู...มึงเจอตีน" สวยสะกดตัวแม่คือฉายาของเธอในมหาวิทยาลัย สวยห้าวตีนคือฉายาของเธอที่คู่อริตั้งให้
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
96 Chapters
คืน one night
คืน one night
เมื่อเธอและเขา one night stand กันโดยไม่ตั้งใจ "คุณภูมิ" "คุณจูนจะทำอะไรครับ" "จูนร้อนคะ" "เดี๋ยวผมไปเร่งแอร์ให้" "ไม่คะ จูนอยาก ช่วยจูนด้วย" "จะให้ผมช่วยยังไงครับ" "จูนต้องการคุณ "
10
42 Chapters
one secret ดีลแลกรัก
one secret ดีลแลกรัก
ทิชาสาวน้อยผู้หวาดกลัวผู้ชายเป็นทุนเดิม เกิดพลาดไปมีสัมพันธ์กับหนุ่มแปลกหน้า แล้วก็ต้องพบว่าชายคนนั้นคือลูกค้าคนสำคัญของบริษัท เขาสามารถจำเธอทันที และแล้วข้อตกลงลับระหว่างทั้งคู่จึงเริ่มต้นขึ้น
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
59 Chapters
One night ป้ายรัก
One night ป้ายรัก
เขารักเธอ แต่เธอไม่รัก ดันกลับไปรักน้องชายของเขา..ก็คนมันเสียเซลฟ์เพราะว่าสาวไม่มอง..ทั้งที่พี่ก็ออกจะหล่อ แต่โดนน้องฟันแล้วทิ้งได้ไง
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
43 Chapters
One night stand!!
One night stand!!
One night stand เรื่องราวความฮอต ความแซบของ 'อัปสร' กับ 'ตรัย' ที่ระดับความฮอตนั้นทะลุจุดเดือดได้ไม่ยาก (ชุดรวมเรื่องรักฉบับติดเรท 1)
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
20 Chapters
ประธานบริษัทนี้ฉันเคย One Night
ประธานบริษัทนี้ฉันเคย One Night
นิยายโรมานซ์มีเรท NC20+ ฟิลกู้ด และ ฟิน เพราะปาร์ตี้สละโสด หรือเพราะอะไรก็ตามที่ดลใจให้เธอ ซินเดีย ทรงโอสถ ยินยอมเสียความสาวในคืนวันไนท์สแตนด์ให้กับหนุ่มหล่อดีกรีนักเรียนทุนปริญญาโท ทิ้งเงินไว้ให้เล็กน้อยเป็นค่ารถกลับเป็นค่าขึ้นครู คิดเพียงว่าคงไม่ได้เจอกันอีก แต่โลกมันกลมอย่างไม่น่าเชื่อ เมื่อสี่ปีต่อมา ผู้ชายคนนั้นโผล่เข้ามาในชีวิตอีกครั้ง พร้อมตำแหน่งประธานบริษัทคนใหม่ อีธาน สมิท หนุ่มไทยบุตรบุญธรรมเจ้าของบริษัทสายการบินชั้นนำ เข้ารับตำแหน่งประธานบริษัทที่เมืองไทย การมาในครั้งนี้ทำให้เขาพบกับเธออีกครั้ง สาวสวยที่ยอมให้เขาได้เปิดซิง แล้วทิ้งเงินค่าครูไว้ให้สิบดอลลาร์ข้างหัวเตียง แล้วหายเข้ากลีบเมฆไปตลอดกาล คงเป็นโชคชะตาหรือจังหวะชีวิตที่ทำให้เขาออกล่าเหยื่อตัวแสบคนนี้อีกครั้ง อย่างเสือหิวที่ไม่ได้เจอเหยื่อมานาน แต่เหยื่อสุดแสบก็ใช่ว่าจะยอมด้วยง่าย ๆ เหมือนคราวที่แล้ว ทำให้เขาต้องออกแรงเสียเหงื่อสักหน่อยจึงได้ขย้ำสมใจ
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
26 Chapters

Related Questions

How Does 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution' Start?

3 answers2025-06-18 01:18:46
The story kicks off with a bang, showing Gol D. Roger's execution at Loguetown, which becomes the catalyst for the Great Pirate Era. The protagonist wakes up in this chaotic world right as the execution happens, realizing he's somehow signed a mysterious contract that binds him to the pirate's life. Unlike typical isekai tropes, there's no slow build-up—he's immediately thrust into the action, scrambling to survive as marines and pirates clash around him. The scene vividly captures the frenzy of Roger's final moments, his famous last words echoing through the crowd, and our MC's panic as he grasps his new reality. It's a clever twist on the original 'One Piece' timeline, blending nostalgia with fresh stakes.

Why Is Roger'S Execution Pivotal In 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution'?

3 answers2025-06-18 08:18:33
Roger's execution in 'One Piece: Signing in as a Pirate Begins with Roger's Execution' isn't just a plot point; it's the spark that ignites the entire pirate era. His final words about the 'One Piece' treasure created a global frenzy, turning ordinary men into dreamers willing to risk everything for glory. The scene shows how one man's death can reshape the world—his defiance in dying with a smile made him a legend, while his revelation about the treasure set the stage for decades of chaos. Pirates, marines, and revolutionaries all trace their motivations back to that moment. The execution isn't just about Roger; it's about the power of legacy and how ideas outlive flesh.

Where Does 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution' Take Place?

3 answers2025-06-16 11:51:27
The story 'One Piece Signing in as a Pirate Begins with Roger's Execution' kicks off in the iconic location of Logue Town, the same place where Gol D. Roger met his end. This town is famous for being the Gateway to the Grand Line, where pirates gather before setting sail into the most dangerous waters in the world. The execution platform where Roger spoke his last words becomes a pivotal spot, symbolizing the start of a new era of piracy. The protagonist arrives here, drawn by the legacy of the Pirate King, and the town's chaotic energy fuels his journey. Logue Town's mix of naval presence, pirate activity, and black market deals makes it the perfect starting point for any pirate tale. The atmosphere is thick with ambition and danger, capturing the essence of the 'One Piece' world.

Who Dies At The Beginning Of 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution'?

3 answers2025-06-18 08:29:05
The very first death in 'One Piece Signing in as a Pirate Begins with Roger's Execution' hits hard—it's Gol D. Roger himself. The Pirate King's execution sets off the entire story, showing his calm defiance even at death's door. His final words about the One Piece ignite the Great Pirate Era, making his death more than just a plot point; it's the spark that changes the world. Roger's execution is brutal but dignified, with his smirk unsettling the Marines. This scene establishes the series' tone: even death can't crush true freedom. The execution platform becomes iconic, reappearing throughout the series as a symbol of inherited will. If you're hooked by this premise, try 'Vinland Saga'—its prologue also uses a major death to propel the protagonist's journey, though with more historical grit.

What Is Roger'S Role In 'One Piece Signing In As A Pirate Begins With Roger'S Execution'?

3 answers2025-06-16 14:57:16
In 'One Piece: Signing in as a Pirate Begins with Roger's Execution', Roger is the legendary Pirate King whose execution sparks the Great Pirate Era. His role is pivotal—his final words about the One Piece treasure ignite global chaos, pushing countless dreamers to sea. Though dead, his legacy dominates the narrative. Flashbacks reveal his unmatched strength, charisma, and the void he leaves. The protagonist often mirrors Roger's ideals, grappling with his shadow. Roger\s influence isn’t just historical; it\'s a living force shaping every pirate's ambition. His death wasn’t an end but a catalyst, making him the unseen architect of the story\'s world.

Where Can I Buy 'One Piece: The Pirate Survival Guide'?

5 answers2025-06-08 18:06:54
I've been hunting for 'One Piece: The Pirate Survival Guide' myself, and here's what I found. The book is available on major online retailers like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Book Depository. Amazon usually has both new and used copies, sometimes at a discount, especially if you opt for the Kindle version. For physical copies, checking local comic book stores or specialty manga shops might yield results, as they often carry niche 'One Piece' merchandise. If you prefer supporting smaller businesses, websites like RightStufAnime or Crunchyroll’s store occasionally stock it, though availability varies. eBay is another option, but watch out for inflated prices from resellers. Some international buyers might need to look at Kinokuniya or other global retailers if local stock is limited. Pre-owned copies sometimes pop up on platforms like Mercari or Facebook Marketplace, but condition and authenticity can be hit or miss.

How Does 'One Piece' Portray Female Pirate Crews?

5 answers2025-06-16 06:56:01
In 'One Piece', female pirate crews are depicted with a mix of ferocity, charisma, and emotional depth. Characters like Boa Hancock and Big Mom showcase the spectrum of female leadership—Hancock blends beauty and power, ruling her crew with an iron fist yet revealing vulnerability when it comes to Luffy. Big Mom, on the other hand, is a force of nature, using her raw strength and cunning to maintain her empire, proving that women in this world can be just as ruthless and ambitious as men. The series avoids one-dimensional portrayals. Nico Robin’s intellect and resilience make her indispensable, while Nami’s navigational genius and street-smart tactics highlight how women contribute uniquely to their crews. Even minor characters like Alvida reinvent themselves post-Devil Fruit, symbolizing transformation and agency. Oda balances combat prowess with emotional arcs, showing female pirates as complex individuals—not just fighters but strategists, survivors, and sometimes even nurturers, like Bellemere’s sacrificial love for her daughters.

Why Are Female Pirate Crews Rare In 'One Piece'?

1 answers2025-06-16 12:23:12
I’ve always found the world of 'One Piece' fascinating, especially how it mirrors and twists real-world pirate lore. Female pirate crews are rare in the story, and there’s a lot to unpack about why that might be. The pirate world in 'One Piece' is brutal, dominated by power struggles, territorial wars, and a general culture of machismo. Most established crews are led by men, and the few female pirates we see often operate solo or in smaller groups, like Big Mom’s crew, which is an exception due to her overwhelming strength and influence. The series doesn’t shy away from showing how harsh the seas can be, and societal norms in this universe seem to discourage women from leading large crews. Another angle is the narrative focus. 'One Piece' is, at its core, a story about Luffy’s journey, and the world-building reflects the tropes of classic pirate tales, where male captains are the norm. Female characters like Boa Hancock or Nico Robin are incredibly powerful, but they’re often integrated into male-led crews or function as allies rather than captains. Even the Yonko, the emperors of the sea, had only one woman among them until recently. It’s not that women lack strength—characters like Big Mom prove otherwise—but the systemic barriers in the 'One Piece' world make it harder for them to rise to prominence. The story does challenge these norms occasionally, but the scarcity of female pirate crews feels intentional, highlighting the inequalities within its universe. Then there’s the thematic side. Oda, the creator, often uses female characters to explore resilience in a male-dominated world. Take Nami—she’s a navigator first, but her backstory is about surviving exploitation and reclaiming agency. Female pirates in 'One Piece' tend to carve their paths differently, whether through cunning, like Alvida, or sheer force, like Big Mom. Their rarity isn’t about weakness; it’s about the narrative emphasizing the uphill battle they face. The series could definitely use more female-led crews, but their scarcity also makes the ones we get, like the Kuja Pirates, stand out even more. Their stories are often about defying expectations, which adds depth to the world-building.
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
DMCA.com Protection Status