Where Did The Phrase 'Pie In The Sky' Originate From?

2025-09-01 07:12:26 357

5 Answers

Parker
Parker
2025-09-03 09:43:16
The phrase 'pie in the sky' has quite an interesting origin story! It was popularized by the American labor activist Joe Hill in the early 20th century. He wrote a song titled 'The Preacher and the Slave' around 1911, where he satirically critiqued the promises of an afterlife paradise that could distract workers from their struggles in the present. Hill's lyrics included the line about the ‘pie in the sky’ that he claimed was a false promise, implying that waiting for something better in the afterlife wouldn't help you when you’re struggling to make ends meet.

This imagery of a delicious pie, always out of reach, resonated with many and painted a vivid picture of hope mixed with disillusionment. It’s fascinating how such a simple phrase can encapsulate complex social issues! Since then, it has evolved in usage, now often referring to unrealistic dreams or plans that are appealing but ultimately unattainable. It's one of those phrases that can pop up in any context, from politics to personal conversations, and it always makes me think about how we set our expectations. How do we balance hope with reality in our own lives? That's the real question!

You know, with everything going on in the world today, I think there's something to be said about our collective desire for 'pies'—whether it's in our careers, relationships, or even just daily life. It's kind of a reminder to keep our feet on the ground while dreaming big!
Ryder
Ryder
2025-09-04 16:16:53
It's hilarious to think how something so simple can have such a complicated backstory. 'Pie in the sky' reminds me of those unrealistic expectations my friends and I used to have during college. We were convinced that we’d graduate, land our dream jobs, and live in the perfect apartments right away! But reality hit hard. Turns out, navigating adult life is all about those small, attainable goals rather than waiting for that grand ‘pie’ to drop in our laps. So, when I hear the phrase, I can’t help but chuckle at the irony!
Oliver
Oliver
2025-09-05 18:47:10
Isn't it amusing how certain phrases stick with us through the ages? 'Pie in the sky' hints at unfulfilled dreams and bravado with a rather cheeky twist, thanks to Joe Hill and his catchy tune from the early 20th century. It almost makes me want to write a story about modern-day dreamers chasing their elusive ambitions! It’s all about that balance—like trying to juggle life’s responsibilities while still wanting to reach for something great, something almost out of reach. Just like dreaming of the perfect slice of pie on a bad day, it serves as a gentle reminder to recognize when we're getting tangled up in our aspirations. It makes you wonder, what are our modern-day 'pies in the sky'?
Gabriel
Gabriel
2025-09-06 01:59:57
In the grand tapestry of language, the phrase 'pie in the sky' is a delightful piece woven with hope, dreams, and a hint of sarcasm! I’ve thrown it around in conversations on countless occasions, usually when talking about unrealistic business plans or overly ambitious goals people have. The humor in it usually lightens the mood! From Joe Hill’s satirical tune to its modern-day usage, it’s like a friend’s nudge reminding us to keep it real. Pie is delicious, but sometimes I think we need to focus on the cake we can actually bake! What can we cultivate today instead of waiting for that far-off pie?
Rowan
Rowan
2025-09-07 07:46:19
Digging into the phrase 'pie in the sky' is like exploring a treasure chest of history. It relates back to that old folk song, which has given this phrase a life of its own. I first came across it in a casual chat with a friend who used it jokingly while brainstorming ideas for a fantasy novel. Our conversation shifted from wild, unrealistic plots to more grounded ones, and I had a good laugh thinking how 'pie in the sky' was so perfectly fitting for some of our initial ideas! It's such a clever expression that makes you reevaluate what you're actually reaching for.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Falling From Your Sky
Falling From Your Sky
Cerise is a daughter of a famous businessman, moved to the city to pursue her dreams and follow her father's footsteps. What she doesn't expect however is becoming a supernatural Queen and getting involved with two men who want two different things. The world changes and now everything is in her hands.
Not enough ratings
27 Chapters
STARS IN THE NIGHT SKY
STARS IN THE NIGHT SKY
ADEDEJI TOLUWALASHE POPULARLY KNOWN AS LASHE IS ONE OF NIGERIAN MOST POPULAR TEENAGER SINGER AND MODEL. WITH A HUGE FAN BASE AND AMAZING SKILLS, ONE COULD SAY LASHE WAS ON TOP OF THE WORLD OR WAS HE? COMES IN OLA-AMUDA IBUKUNOLUWA WHO IS AN ARDENT FAN OF LASHE. SHE HAS EVERY SONG LASHE HAS SANG AND ALWAYS CLAIMS SHE IS HIS BIGGEST FAN, WHEN FATE BRINGS THEM TOGETHER AND THEY BECOME FRIENDS. AND EVEN AS THEY GET CLOSER AND THEY REALIZE THEY ARE CATCHING FEELINGS FOR EACH OTHER, BOTH OF THEM REFUSE TO STOP SEEING EACH OTHER. CHECK OUT THIS THRILLING STORY WHICH TALKS ABOUT LOVE, FRIENDSHIP, SISTERHOOD AND FAMILY!
9.7
80 Chapters
Euphoria in the Melancholic Sky
Euphoria in the Melancholic Sky
Hikari Raine Davis is a college student studying Architecture. She always plans everything but something she didn't plan, happened. She fell in love. She met a guy named Raui. He's mysterious, he never told her his surname and it seems like he's hiding something from her. But she didn't care, she loves him. He shows up only when it rains. He never called nor show up when the rain isn't pouring. She didn't know why and she didn't want to intrude. But when she found out everything accidentally, her heart teared into pieces. Everything became a mess, Raui's secret ended their relationship. After years of moving on, she's finally back and she didn't expect what happened while she was gone. Will there be a second chance for their love? Or everything they've been through will just stay in their memories forever?
Not enough ratings
7 Chapters
The Childless Sky
The Childless Sky
For the ninth time, my wife chose to have an abortion for the sake of her ailing first love. This time, I did not stop her. Even when my grandfather flew into a fit of rage, his heart faltering as he called me a disgrace to the family, I stayed silent. The truth was that I had already decided to divorce her. In three days, I'd be leaving for Westmarch to begin my research. Until then, I have decided to grant her every wish. If she wanted me to hand over a promotion so her first love could take the credit, I gave it up without hesitation. If she wanted to bring him home to rest, I vacated the master bedroom on the spot. She beamed with satisfaction, praising me for finally learning to be "sensible." She promised that once he recovered, she would give me a child of my own. However, what she did not know was that there would be no next time.
10 Chapters
CRIMSON SKY
CRIMSON SKY
When 16 years old TOKE inadvertently saves her favorite teacher from death with her powers, she is confronted by a group of spirit children and yanked from the world she knows into the witching world where she finds she is a white WITCHLORD and one of the five tasked to protect Nigeria from magical threats. Toke soon finds herself in the thick of the war between the Witches and the Cursed Ones (Vampires) who have suddenly appeared all over Africa, and she must choose between love, duty, and betrayal, even as she discovers her boyfriend is one of the enemy, and the battle is brought closer to her homestead and her loved ones in peril.
10
49 Chapters
Where the Flowers Go
Where the Flowers Go
I had poured my heart into planning the perfect wedding—for my female client. Then I turned a corner and saw her kissing my boyfriend at the stairwell. He chuckled softly. "No wonder you're my wife. You're stunning." She let out a soft laugh. "Your little secret girlfriend still does not know you're marrying me. She actually wished me happiness—can you believe it? So… when are you planning to tell her?" He tilted her chin and said, "Didn't we agree? Once we're married, we each live our own lives. Teresa is the love of my life. I hope you'll keep your mouth shut." She gave a snort of laughter and yanked playfully on his tie. "Relax, babe. As long as you keep treating me right, I won't stir up trouble." I felt like I had plunged into an ice bath. Face pale, hands trembling, I picked up my phone and texted my mentor: [I'm ready to take the transfer to Luminous City.] The reply came not long after: [Three days from now. We'll go together.]
9 Chapters

Related Questions

Who Is The Author Of Buried In The Sky?

6 Answers2025-10-22 14:22:57
If you bring up 'Buried in the Sky', the names behind it that I always mention first are Peter Zuckerman and Amanda Padoan. I picked this book up because the subtitle hooked me — it's about Sherpa climbers on K2's deadliest day — and I was curious who had the nerve and care to tell such a difficult, human story. Zuckerman and Padoan teamed up to blend investigative reporting with on-the-ground interviews, and you can feel both the journalist's curiosity and the storyteller's empathy on every page. What grabbed me most, beyond the facts, was how the authors treated the Sherpas not as background figures but as the central characters. The pacing is part biography, part mountaineering disaster narrative, and part cultural exploration. Zuckerman brings a sharp, clear prose that pushes you through the timeline, while Padoan's contributions give texture and warmth to the portraits of climbers and their families. If you like 'Into Thin Air' for its tension and self-reflection, 'Buried in the Sky' complements it by widening the lens to the local communities and the often-unseen sacrifices on big mountains. I also appreciate how the book makes you think about risk, responsibility, and storytelling itself. The research felt thorough, and the interviews stick with you; even weeks later I was replaying lines about loyalty, weather, and choices on the ridge. It isn't a light read, but it's honest and reverent in a way that made me respect both the subject matter and the authors. For anyone curious about high-altitude climbing or human stories behind headlines, Peter Zuckerman and Amanda Padoan did something I respect — they listened and then wrote with care, and that left a real impression on me.

What Songs Use The Lyric Falling From The Sky In Pop Music?

9 Answers2025-10-28 12:14:23
There’s a neat little cluster of pop songs and indie tracks that lean on the exact phrase or very close imagery of ‘falling from the sky’, and I like to think of them as the soundtrack to cinematic moments where everything crashes in — or lightens up. If you want straightforward hits that use sky/rain/falling imagery, start with the obvious rain songs: 'Here Comes the Rain Again' (Eurythmics) and 'Set Fire to the Rain' (Adele) — they don’t always say the exact phrase but they live in the same lyrical neighborhood. Train’s 'Drops of Jupiter' uses celestial fall imagery with lines like ‘did you fall from a star?’, and that feels emotionally equivalent. For tracks that literally use the line or very close variants, you’ll find it more in indie pop, electronic, and some modern singer-songwriter cuts. There are a handful of songs actually titled 'Falling From the Sky' across artists and EPs — those are easy to spot on streaming services if you search the phrase in quotes. Also check out reinterpretations and covers: live versions often tinker with wording and might slip in that exact line. I love how the phrase can be used both romantically and apocalyptically depending on production — a synth pad will make ‘falling from the sky’ feel cosmic, whereas a lone piano will make it fragile. Personally, I end up compiling these into a moody playlist for late-night walks; the imagery always hits differently depending on the tempo and key, which is part of the fun.

Are There English Translations Of Buried In The Sky?

6 Answers2025-10-22 01:16:57
If you're talking about the non-fiction book 'Buried in the Sky', then yes — the book itself is originally written in English and widely available in English editions. I picked up a copy a few years back because I was fascinated by mountain stories, and what struck me most was how the authors center the Sherpa perspective on K2's 2008 catastrophe. It reads like investigative journalism mixed with intimate portraiture, and you can find it in paperback, e-book formats, and often as an audiobook through major retailers and libraries. The publisher's listing and ISBN are the fastest ways to confirm a specific edition if you want the exact printing. If, however, you meant a different work that shares the title 'Buried in the Sky' — maybe a manga, short story, or foreign novel — the situation can be more mixed. There are a surprising number of works that reuse poetic titles, and some are translated officially while others only exist in fan translations. My go-to approach is to check WorldCat or my local library's catalog and then cross-check on sites like Goodreads or the publisher's site. That usually tells me whether an authorized English translation exists, who did the translation, and which country released it. For manga or serialized web novels, I sometimes dig through scanlation archives or Reddit threads to see if a fan translation exists, but I prefer official releases when possible. Bottom line for the non-fiction K2 book: you don't need a translation — it's already in English — and it's worth reading if you care about climbing history and human stories on extreme mountains. If you had a different 'Buried in the Sky' in mind, try searching by original language title or the author's name; that usually clears up which edition is which. Personally, the English edition gripped me for days afterward — such a haunting, human story.

Where Can I Read Pie Novel Online For Free?

3 Answers2025-11-10 03:23:56
So, you're looking to dive into 'Pie' without spending a dime, huh? I totally get that—budgets can be tight, and the love for stories shouldn’t have a paywall. From my own scavenger hunts for free reads, I’ve stumbled across a few spots. Webnovel platforms like Wattpad or Royal Road sometimes host lesser-known gems, and 'Pie' might pop up there if you dig deep. Scribd occasionally offers free trials, which could be a sneaky way to access it temporarily. Just remember, though, that supporting authors when you can is super important—they pour their hearts into these worlds! Another angle: check out forums like Reddit’s r/FreeEBOOKS or Goodreads groups dedicated to sharing free finds. Sometimes users drop links to legal free copies, especially for indie titles. Libraries are also unsung heroes—apps like Libby or Hoopla might have 'Pie' available if you link your library card. It’s like a treasure hunt, but for books!

Can I Find Pie Novel In Audiobook Format?

4 Answers2025-11-10 14:57:12
Man, I totally get the hunt for audiobooks—it's like digging for treasure sometimes! I went through a phase where I needed everything in audio format because of my commute, and let me tell you, tracking down niche titles can be a challenge. 'Pie' isn't one of the super mainstream novels, so it might not be on every platform. I'd start with Audible or Scribd since they have a massive catalog, but if it's not there, check smaller audiobook retailers like Libro.fm or even Google Play Books. Sometimes, indie authors or lesser-known works pop up in unexpected places. Another trick is to look for fan readings or podcasts—I once found a whole serialized version of an obscure book read by a passionate fan on YouTube. It wasn't professional, but it had heart! If 'Pie' is a newer release, maybe keep an eye out; audiobooks often lag behind print editions. And hey, if all else fails, shoot the author or publisher a message—they might just consider recording it if there's enough interest.

When Did Studio Ghibli'S Castle In The Sky Come Out?

4 Answers2025-08-28 04:55:56
I still get a little thrill saying it out loud: 'Castle in the Sky' first flew into theaters in Japan on August 2, 1986. That date always feels like a little festival in my head because it marked the official debut of Studio Ghibli as a theatrical studio with Hayao Miyazaki steering the ship—the lush clouds, the floating island, Joe Hisaishi’s unforgettable score, everything felt brand new. I saw it on VHS later as a kid and that memory of the airships and Sheeta’s pendant stuck with me for years. Beyond the Japanese premiere, the film trickled out internationally over the next several years through festivals, subtitled tapes, and later dubbed releases, so many of us outside Japan discovered it somewhat gradually. If you ever want to trace the different home video and theatrical windows, there are fun little timelines online showing when the English dubs, restorations, and Blu-rays arrived in various countries.

Which Constellation Contains The Brightest Star In The Sky?

3 Answers2025-08-29 04:05:38
I still get a little thrill when I look up on a clear winter night and spot that ridiculously bright point near Orion — it's hard not to, because Sirius practically steals the show. Sirius is the brightest star in our night sky and it lives in the constellation 'Canis Major', the Greater Dog. Its common nickname is the Dog Star, and once you know where to look (a quick line down from Orion's Belt), it jumps right out at you with a white-blue wink. What fascinates me most is that Sirius is only bright partly because it's luminous and partly because it's close: about 8.6 light-years away. Its apparent magnitude is around −1.46, which is why even city-sky viewers can often pick it out. There's also a neat twist — Sirius is a binary system. The main star, Sirius A, is a hot A-type star, and it has a much fainter companion, Sirius B, which is a white dwarf. If you ever have access to a decent amateur telescope and steady skies, spotting Sirius B is a rewarding challenge — it's a lovely peek into stellar evolution. Watching Sirius rise with Orion has become a small seasonal ritual for me: it marks the cooler months and the best constellation-hopping nights. If you're starting out, look for Orion's Belt and slide your gaze down-right (in the Northern Hemisphere) to find the Dog Star — simple, instantly satisfying, and a tiny spark of cosmic perspective that never gets old.

Does Light Pollution Hide The Brightest Star In The Sky?

3 Answers2025-08-29 18:10:40
Under the sodium-orange glow of my neighborhood streetlamps, I used to swear the sky was a flat, dull ceiling — but then I learned the truth: yes, light pollution can hide even some of the brightest stars, though usually not the very brightest under typical conditions. Sirius, the brightest star in our night sky at about magnitude -1.46, is astonishingly luminous, so in many cities you can still spot it if it’s high enough above the horizon and the air is reasonably clear. The problem isn’t that the star itself dims; it’s that the sky’s background gets so bright from scattered artificial light that contrast vanishes. Skyglow, especially from unshielded streetlights and billboards, raises the “black level” of the sky. When the background brightness approaches the star’s apparent intensity, your eyes can no longer pick it out. Add low clouds, humidity, or haze, and even Sirius can disappear. What helped me most was learning limits: urban skies often limit visible stars to around magnitude 3 or 4, whereas a rural sky will reveal magnitude 6 or fainter. Practical fixes? Walk to a darker spot, wait until later at night when businesses shut off lights, use binoculars, or check light pollution maps. I still get a small thrill when I escape the city and the Milky Way floods the sky — nothing beats that contrast for showing off what’s truly hidden back home.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status