Hmm, I'm only about halfway through. Trying to avoid spoilers here, but the vibe is incredibly unsettling. The way the main character's thoughts keep intruding... it's like listening to someone's anxiety in real time. I don't have a full interpretation yet, but I'm hooked and deeply uncomfortable, which I guess is the point?
Man, reading these comments is making me want to pick it up again. I think I liked it, but I also remember feeling really unsettled and sad for days. Not sure I'm ready for that rollercoaster again just yet.
The dialogue. Reid's dialogue in the book is stilted and awkward, meant to feel off. Kaufman's dialogue is hyper-articulate, referential, and performative. Characters quote poetry and critique film seamlessly. It creates a different kind of unreal atmosphere. In the book, people are bad at communicating. In the film, people communicate in dense, rehearsed-seeming monologues, highlighting the artificiality of the entire scenario. Both are unsettling, but in opposite directions.
I think people overcomplicate it. The change is from a mysterious date story to a confirmed unreliable narrator story. We learn Jake the janitor is imagining everything. The young woman is a composite. The ending confirms the speculation. The power is in the execution—the creeping dread, the way Iain Reid uses spare prose to make the unreal feel terrifyingly immediate. The plot 'changes' by revealing its own central lie.