Why not just read them in random order and then try to piece together the timeline of his writing style afterwards? That could be a fun analytical challenge. Like a puzzle. Probably not what you're asking for, but it's an unconventional idea!
I have a soft spot for 'Prince Caspian' as a starting point. It's about returning to a Narnia that has moved on, where the legends of the Pevensies have faded. As a new reader, you get to learn about this forgotten golden age alongside the characters. Then, when you go back to 'The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe,' you're reading about the mythic past everyone was talking about. It's a cool, reverse-engineering way to experience the history.
Google Sheets is your friend. I found a template shared by a book club that had columns for title, genre, publication year, and whether it was part of a series. I copied it and have been ticking them off slowly. A search for 'book tracking spreadsheet' will yield many results you can adapt. It's more flexible than any static webpage.
My aunt reads these exclusively out of order, based on which title speaks to her at the bookstore. She says it's like visiting a town where you already know the residents, but you're hearing a new story about their past each time. She never feels lost, just continually enriched.
She has a point. Each book is designed to welcome new readers while rewarding returning ones. The author is smart about recapping just enough. So maybe my aunt's chaotic method is the most pure cozy method of all: choose by whim, not by list.
The library or audiobook app you use might dictate your order. If you're borrowing, you take what's available when it's available. That's how I did it. It was chaotic, but fun. I'd get 'The Sundered Sea' from Libby, then two weeks later, 'Whisper of the Crown' from Hoopla. It felt like receiving random dispatches from a fantasy world.
Constraints can lead to creative consumption. Go with the flow of availability.
her books are like comfort food for the soul. If you're looking for a complete list in order, the best place to start is her official website or dedicated fan sites like Fantastic Fiction. They usually keep meticulous records of publication dates and series order.
For her most popular series, like 'The Heritage of Lancaster County,' the order is 'The Shunning,' 'The Confession,' and 'The Reckoning.' Her standalone novels like 'The Postcard' and 'The Photograph' are also worth checking out. Libraries and bookstores often have sections dedicated to Amish fiction where her works are prominently displayed.