Home / Romance / DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER / Two Truths and a Lie

Share

Two Truths and a Lie

Author: Lemon
last update publish date: 2026-11-02 10:22:22

"Hello again?" Richard looked between us, delighted. "You two know each other?"

"No," Colt said.

"Yes," I said, at the exact same moment.

My mother's fork stopped halfway to her mouth. Julian's gaze traveled from Colt to me and back, the way he reads a contract with a hidden clause.

"Which is it?" Julian asked evenly.

I have talked clients out of lawsuits. I once convinced a fire marshal that a flaming centerpiece was an intentional design choice. I opened my mouth and trusted my training.

"He's my dentist," I said.

"We met at a motorcycle rally," Colt said.

Silence. Colleen blinked. "A dentist at a motorcycle rally?"

"Biker dentist," Colt said smoothly, kicking my ankle under the table. "Very niche."

"You own a motorcycle shop," Julian said. "You've never touched a tooth."

"Then clearly I'm not her dentist," Colt said, "which is what I was about to say."

I gulped my wine. This was going badly, and my head was spinning from the whiplash.

"What I meant," I said, "is that he looks like someone's dentist. Straight teeth. Very trustworthy."

"Thank you," Colt said. "I floss."

Richard was grinning like this was dinner theater. "Let's try again, children. Slowly."

Colt leaned back. "She was my accountant."

"He fixed my bike," I said.

We had done it again.

Julian set down his fork. "Harper doesn't have a bike."

"A bicycle," I said quickly. "Vintage. The chain slipped on the Brooklyn Bridge, and a stranger stopped to help."

"Stranger being me," Colt said, catching on with the speed of a man who had improvised his entire life. "Chain was a mess. Took twenty minutes. She bought me a coffee."

"A very small coffee," I said.

"A tragically small coffee. Which is why I said hello again. I never forget a coffee."

It was a terrible story. It was also, I realized, almost believable, if you ignored everything.

Julian wasn't ignoring anything. "Harper takes the subway. I've signed her commute reimbursements for two years."

"It was Amy's bicycle," I said. "I borrowed it. Once. To get something."

Colleen clasped her hands. "Oh, that's so romantic."

"It's not romantic," Julian and I said together, and Colt just smiled.

Richard laughed hard enough to wipe his eyes. "Well, I believe it. Colt has always rescued strays."

"Dad," Colt said, with a flicker of something raw that vanished quickly.

I noticed. Of course I noticed. That's my curse.

Dinner dragged on. Roast lamb, then Richard's story of Vegas: Colleen, a slot machine, and an Elvis impersonator who cried at the vows. Julian stayed politely silent, rubbing his jaw.

Beneath the table, Colt's boot tapped mine, once, twice, like Morse code for *you owe me*. I moved my foot. He moved his. I'm not proud.

By dessert, I had a plan: leave before I said something worse.

"This was lovely," I said, standing, "but I should go home."

"Home?" Colleen's face fell. "Sweetheart, stay. We have six bedrooms."

"Six," Richard confirmed. "You're family now, Harper. Stay the night. Have breakfast. Let us spoil you."

Family. The word landed somewhere between warm and terrifying.

"I would love to," I said, "but I have things to take care of. Laundry. A spreadsheet. A plant that's technically dead but deserves a chance."

"We can send a driver," Richard offered.

"Don't bother." Colt rose, shrugging into his leather jacket and jingling his keys. "I'm heading that way anyway. Brooklyn's on my route. I'll take her."

"On the motorcycle," Julian said flatly.

"Is there another kind of transportation?" Colt asked.

Julian's eyes found mine. "I can drive you, Harper."

A month ago, I'd have sold a kidney for that sentence. Tonight, I could feel Colt watching me, and I could feel my mother watching Julian, and I suspected every possible answer was a trap.

"Julian, stay," Richard said, laying a hand on his son's shoulder. "I'd like a word with you."

Julian hesitated, jaw working. "Text me when you're home," he told me.

"Of course," I said. "I'll send a calendar invite."

He almost smiled.

Colleen hugged me at the door and whispered, "Aren't both of them gorgeous? Your stepbrothers, I mean. Lucky you."

"Mom," I hissed. "Please stop talking."

Outside, the night air smelled like rain and expensive hydrangeas. A black motorcycle waited at the curb, gleaming under the streetlight like it knew exactly what it had done to me.

"You can stop glaring at it," Colt said, holding out a helmet.

"I'm not glaring. I'm assessing risk."

"Dentist, accountant, now risk assessor. You have many talents."

"We are not discussing this," I said. "Not tonight. Not on a motorcycle. Not ever."

"Fine." His grin softened into something I couldn't file under any category. "For the record, you lied beautifully in there."

"You lied worse," I said.

"I've had more practice."

I should have walked to the subway. I should have ordered a car, or hired a priest. Instead I looked back at the townhouse, where my mother waved from the doorway like I was shipping off to war, and then at Colt, helmet outstretched, waiting without pushing.

Behind the front window, a silhouette in a charcoal suit stood very still, watching.

"It's one ride," Colt said quietly. "Twenty-five minutes. I'll even obey the speed limit."

"You've never obeyed anything in your life."

"Then consider this my first."

Against all my better judgment, and every spreadsheet in my head, I took the helmet.

His fingers brushed mine, and my entire body remembered last night.

"Hold on tight," he said.

"Don't push it," I said, climbing on.

The engine roared awake beneath me, and I realized, far too late, that I had just agreed to the single worst idea of my week. Which, considering my week, was saying something.

As we pulled away from the curb, I caught my reflection in the side mirror: windblown, flushed, grinning. Grinning! I wiped it off my face immediately. It came right back.

Some crises you handle. Some, apparently, you ride.

And we hadn't even reached the bridge.

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER    Strikes and Spares

    Marcus Webb came home broader, tanner, and with a haircut so short that Amy couldn't stop rubbing it like a lucky charm."Stop that," he said, grinning, and did not move her hand.I watched them from the doorway of a retro bowling alley in Gowanus and felt something loosen in my chest for the first time all week. Six months of glitchy video calls, and here he was, solid and real, lifting me off the floor in a hug that smelled like laundry soap and airports."Quinn," he said. "You got promoted and I had to hear it from Amy at four in the morning.""I was going to send a card.""She was going to send a card," he told Amy, deeply wounded.We took lane nine. Amy had already ordered nachos, a pitcher, and something called bowling wings. Some friendships are built on shared trauma. Ours was built on shared fries.I picked a pink ball. Marcus picked the heaviest one in the building, because he is an idiot. Amy typed our team name into the screen: Three Idiots and a Gutter.My first throw cur

  • DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER    Tiny Houses and Large Mistakes

    The ride to Brooklyn took twenty-six minutes, and I spent every one of them pretending my arms around Colt's waist were a safety measure.He didn't speed. He crossed the Manhattan Bridge like a man carrying a wedding cake, and somewhere over the East River I stopped being terrified and started being annoyed at how much I liked it.My building is a four-story walk-up in Park Slope with a buzzer that works when it feels like it. Colt parked, cut the engine, and followed me inside before I could object."You don't need to walk me up," I said on the second landing."Gentleman," he said, pointing at himself."Liability," I said, pointing at him.I unlocked my door on the third floor. He leaned against the frame and peered inside, where four hundred square feet held a couch that doubled as my bed, a kitchenette, and a dead plant named Gerald."This is it?" Colt asked. "I've seen bigger bike helmets.""It's called cozy.""It's called tiny. If you sneeze, your neighbor says bless you.""She d

  • DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER    Two Truths and a Lie

    "Hello again?" Richard looked between us, delighted. "You two know each other?""No," Colt said."Yes," I said, at the exact same moment.My mother's fork stopped halfway to her mouth. Julian's gaze traveled from Colt to me and back, the way he reads a contract with a hidden clause."Which is it?" Julian asked evenly.I have talked clients out of lawsuits. I once convinced a fire marshal that a flaming centerpiece was an intentional design choice. I opened my mouth and trusted my training."He's my dentist," I said."We met at a motorcycle rally," Colt said.Silence. Colleen blinked. "A dentist at a motorcycle rally?""Biker dentist," Colt said smoothly, kicking my ankle under the table. "Very niche.""You own a motorcycle shop," Julian said. "You've never touched a tooth.""Then clearly I'm not her dentist," Colt said, "which is what I was about to say."I gulped my wine. This was going badly, and my head was spinning from the whiplash."What I meant," I said, "is that he looks like

  • DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER    Family Plans

    The train swallowed my mother's answer whole. All I caught was "...surprise, sweetheart, I'll text you the address!" before the call dropped.I made it to the office at 9:04, which for me is practically a felony. I changed into the emergency blazer I keep in my desk drawer, fixed my face in the bathroom mirror, and decided to treat the morning like any other disaster: calmly, and with a spreadsheet.It almost worked. Then Amy texted: Did you survive?? I need details. Also I'm sorry. Also you're welcome.I put my phone face down and did not answer. Some crises you handle; some you bury.Julian arrived at ten, and the whole floor straightened without being asked. He wore a charcoal suit, and he looked like a man who had slept eight hours and never once made a decision he regretted. Meanwhile I had a stranger's cologne in my hair.Around two, he stopped at my desk. He rubbed his jaw. That is never good."Harper, clear my four o'clock. Actually, clear everything after three-thirty."I loo

  • DRUNK ON THE WRONG BROTHER    A Very Good Save

    Julian Hale drinks his coffee black with a splash of oat milk, and he waits exactly ninety seconds before the first sip. I know this the way other people know their own birthdays.I also know that he rubs his jaw when a meeting is going badly, that he hates being called before nine, and that every March, on the anniversary of his mother's death, he needs one quiet afternoon. Nobody ever asked me to clear his calendar. That's the thing about being an executive assistant. The job is mostly paying attention.I'm good at it. Ridiculously good. I can read a room in three seconds, memorize a forty-page contract over lunch, and rebuild a collapsing schedule while smiling at a furious client. Once, when a caterer cancelled an hour before a board dinner, I turned a Brooklyn taco truck into the most talked-about event of the quarter. Julian looked at me across the room, nodded once, and said, "Good save, Harper."I replayed those three words for a week.That's the other thing I know about Julia

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status