Chapter 1

Winona Lambert looked at me, tears still in her eyes. Her lips trembled. "Mr. Fuller, you're really going to hire me?"

Dave Kingston, the vice principal, was even more excited than she was. He put his pen down as he spoke in a hoarse voice, "Of course! You're someone who has endured so much pain and still wants to come back to school to protect students. Someone with a heart like yours is so rare these days."

Caden Wagner nodded. "That's right. Her mother went through so much back then, and she still chooses to become a teacher. If that's not true compassion, then what is?"

My stomach turned when I heard the word "compassion".

38 years ago, they said the same thing about Lena Lambert. She cried that her life had been ruined. They all believed her.

My father, Brendan Fuller, said he was innocent. They said he was lying. My mother, Lucy Murphy, begged them to wait for the investigation. They said she was covering for him.

I was so young back then that all I remember was Dad standing in the middle of the crowd, his face white as he kept saying he was innocent.

But everyone ignored him.

I glanced at Winona's résumé. Lena's name was listed under family members.

I'd spent the last 38 years seeing that name. It was in old newspapers, in the court records, and even on the newspaper clipping Mom had crumpled in her hand before she died.

I thought I'd go crazy if I ever saw that name again. But now, I simply closed the résumé and slid it back to her. "Report in at the Language Arts Department next Monday. I hope you remember what you said today. Be a good teacher."

Winona immediately stood and thanked me. Her voice trembled, and her eyes were sincere. "Thank you, Mr. Fuller! I won't let you down."

If I hadn't seen that slight smile when she lowered her head, I might have believed her.

Winona didn't leave right away. Standing outside the gates of Westbrook High, she found a good angle and opened her phone. Her eyes were red on camera, the school's name in gold letters behind her.

"Guys, I did it. I finally walked into the place where my mom was hurt all these years ago. I don't want revenge. I just want to make this place better for my mom and for more kids." Winona's voice broke at the end.

I watched the comments roll in.

"You're so brave."

"The victim's daughter becomes a teacher. This is the best revenge."

"Now that's what we call a true heroine."

Winona was good at crying on camera too, and she looked so much like Lena sitting in front of the cameras back then.

I went to the desk and opened the bottom drawer. There were only three things inside.

An old teacher ID card, a yellowed newspaper, and an old envelope with a worn-out cover, containing the evidence I'd collected over 38 years. Evidence that Lena had faked the whole thing back then.

Dad was wearing a white shirt, smiling innocently in the teacher ID photo, but the brutal headline read, "Monster Teacher Exposed by Poor Girl."