Home / MM Romance / PLAYING PRETEND / CHAPTER 3 ~ FINN'S POV

Share

CHAPTER 3 ~ FINN'S POV

Author: Cyra McKenzie
last update publish date: 2026-02-05 19:45:33

By the time I made it back to campus later that evening, my mother’s voice was still ringing in my ears like tinnitus. “Your type is fictional.” It was unfair, mostly because it was true.

I parked my beat-up sedan in the student lot, grabbed my duffel bag, and trudged toward the dorms. The campus was alive in a way that always made my skin prickle. It was Sunday night, which meant everyone was either frantically finishing assignments or loudly recounting their weekend mistakes. Groups of students clustered on the quad, laughing, smoking, and practically vibrating with social energy.

I kept my head down, pulling the hood of my sweatshirt up. It was a reflex. If I couldn't see them, maybe they wouldn't see me.

"Finn! Hey, Finn!"

I winced. The strategy had failed.

I turned to see Sarah jogging toward me, her curls bouncing with every step. Sarah was one of the few people on this campus I could tolerate for extended periods. She was loud, opinionated, and had absolutely no filter, but she was loyal. David was trailing behind her, looking typically exhausted.

"Hey," I said, shifting my bag on my shoulder. "What’s up?"

"We were just betting on whether you’d actually come back or if your mom finally held you hostage," Sarah said, hooking her arm through mine. "You look traumatized. Did she bring up the wedding?"

"She brought up the wedding," I confirmed grimly. "And she asked if I was on Grindr."

David choked on his coffee. "Your mom said 'Grindr'?"

"She pronounced it 'Grinder,' like a spice mill, but yes. The intent was there."

We reached the entrance to the dorms, and the warm, stale air of the lobby hit us. I scanned the room instinctively. It was a habit I hated—checking corners, watching faces. Over by the vending machines, a group of guys from the soccer team were loud and taking up too much space. A couple was making out aggressively near the elevators.

As we walked past the front desk, I felt it. A gaze. A whisper.

Two girls from my Art History class were sitting on the worn-out leather sofas. As I passed, their conversation dipped into that hushed frequency that screams “we are talking about you.”

I stiffened.

"Did you hear that?" I muttered to Sarah once we were in the elevator.

"Hear what?"

"Them. The whispering."

Sarah sighed, leaning her head back against the metal wall. "Finn, you have got to stop being so paranoid. Not everyone is talking about you."

"They were looking right at me," I insisted. "I heard one of them say 'monk.' I swear to God, Sarah. 'The Monk.' That’s what they call me."

David winced. "Okay, to be fair, Tyler in psych 101 did call you that last week. But he’s an idiot."

"See?" I threw my hands up. "It’s a thing. I have a reputation. And not even a cool reputation like 'mysterious bad boy.' I have the reputation of a asexual hermit crab who hates fun."

"You don't hate fun," Sarah argued. "You just... prefer fun that involves zero risk and heavy blankets."

The elevator dinged at the fourth floor. We stepped out into the hallway, which smelled faintly of burnt popcorn and cheap body spray.

"It’s just frustrating," I admitted, my voice dropping lower as we walked toward my room. "My mom thinks I’m wasting my youth. The campus thinks I’m a weirdo. And the worst part is, I don’t even want to date anyone. I just want people to stop speculating about why I’m not dating anyone."

I unlocked my door and pushed it open. My room was exactly how I left it: tidy, quiet, and safe. My desk was organized, my books were color-coded, and my bed was made. It was a sanctuary, but for the first time in a long time, it felt a little bit like a cell.

Sarah lingered in the doorway while David headed to his own room down the hall.

"Look," she said, her voice softer now. "If it bothers you that much, just put yourself out there. Come to the mixer on Friday. Talk to someone who isn't me or David."

"I can't just 'talk' to people, Sarah. I freeze up. I say stupid things about the weather or medieval architecture."

"You are cute, Finn," she said firmly. "You have that whole 'tragic poetic' vibe going on. Guys like that. You just need to... I don't know. Break the seal. Rip the band-aid."

"I'll think about it," I lied again.

"No, you won't. You're going to put on pajamas and read until 2 AM." She rolled her eyes, but she was smiling. "Night, Finn."

"Night."

I closed the door and locked it. The silence rushed in, instant and heavy. I dropped my bag on the floor and flopped face-first onto my bed.

My phone buzzed in my pocket. I groaned and pulled it out.

Mom: Just sent you a link to a blog about how to flirt. Read it! Love you!

I let the phone drop from my hand onto the mattress. I stared up at the ceiling, tracing the water stain that looked vaguely like a map of Florida.

The pressure was coming from both sides now. My family wanted a show pony for the wedding. The campus wanted a spectacle to dissect. And all I wanted was to be left alone to get my degree in peace.

I rolled over and looked at the pile of romance novels on my nightstand. The cover of the top one featured a brooding billionaire in a suit, looking confident and untouched by the world.

Must be nice, I thought bitterly. To have all the answers. To have the money to make problems disappear.

I didn't have money. I didn't have confidence. But as I lay there, listening to the muffled bass of music thumping from the room next door, I realized I did have one thing: desperation. And desperation, as the books always said, was a dangerous motivator.

I didn't know it yet, but my quiet, invisible life was about to end. And it wasn't going to be because of a blog post about flirting. It was going to be because of a deal with the devil.

Or, at least, the closest thing our campus had to one.

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 13 ~ FINN'S POV

    Knowing the peace wouldn't last, my anxiety spiked at 7:00 PM while sitting at my desk to memorize the cranial nerves for the third time just as my phone started vibrating against the wood.There was no need to look at the screen to know who was calling because the aggressive, sustained, and demanding vibration pattern made it obvious that it was the Queen Mother.Staring at the phone felt like looking at a bomb that had just ticked down to zero since ignoring the call meant she would immediately ring Sarah. If Sarah didn't answer, she would dial the campus police, and if they ignored her, she would probably drive down here herself armed with a casserole and a battering ram.Taking a deep breath and muttering a prayer to the god of patience was the only preparation before swiping to answer."Hi, Mo.....""Finnian James Parker!"Her voice was so incredibly loud that the phone had to be held at least six inches away from my ear."Why," she continued, without pausing for breath, "am I fi

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 12 ~ KYLE'S POV

    The metrics were beautiful.Sitting on a bench outside the Life Sciences building, scrolling through the analytics on my phone revealed that in the twelve hours since posting the photo of the soda cups, engagement was up 45%. The comments were 90% positive, 5% confused, and 5% trolls, which was a noticeably better ratio than the campaign for Student Body President.However, the most important statistic wasn't a number but rather a single view.Vanessa_L had viewed the story three minutes after it went live.She hadn’t liked it, commented, or texted to hurl accusations of lying. That silence was golden because it meant she was stewing and wondering if she had misjudged everything, perhaps realizing her assumption of a safe and predictable robot was entirely wrong.Mission accomplished, the thought crossed my mind while closing the app to signify Phase One was complete.Now it was time for Phase Two: Maintenance.A quick glance at the watch showed 10:50 AM, meaning Finn’s Anatomy lectur

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 11 ~ FINN'S POV

    Waking up brought the distinct feeling of having committed a felony, especially since the morning light was streaming aggressively through the gap in my curtains to hit me right in the eye. Groaning and rolling over allowed me to bury my face in my pillow with the desperate hope that staying there long enough would turn yesterday into a fever dream induced by too much caffeine and stress.Perhaps the trip to the library had never happened, and meeting Kyle Bennett was just an illusion rather than a reality, where he dragged me to a party and held me like a prized possession in front of his ex-girlfriend.Reaching for the phone on the nightstand to check the time caused the screen to light up, and it just kept lighting up with a barrage of notifications.Instagram: 99+ new followers.

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 10 ~ KYLE'S POV

    Finn obeyed instantly by burying his face in my shoulder to hide from the world, and it looked incredibly intimate because to anyone watching, he appeared shy while I acted as his safe harbor.Vanessa pushed off the wall and started walking toward us with Travis trailing behind her looking completely bored."Showtime," I whispered before stopping in my tracks and planting my feet firmly. Pulling Finn around meant he was standing directly in front of me with my chest pressed against his back and my arms loosely circling him to create a possessive stance that clearly claimed him.Vanessa stopped three feet away and immediately crossed her arms."Well," she said, her voice dripping with ice. "You weren't kidding.""I don't kid about my dating life, Van," I said coolly.

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 9 ~ KYLE'S POV

    The moment we stepped through the double doors, the noise hit us like a physical wave because the bass rattled my ribcage while the air grew thick with body heat and the strobe lights sliced through the darkness in dizzying intervals.Usually, this was my element since I thrived on the chaos and knew exactly how to navigate a room like this. It was just a matter of knowing who to nod at, who to ignore, and where the best lighting was.But tonight, everything felt different because an anchor was attached to my left hand.Finn’s hand was sweating so much that the dampness was clear against my palm, and his rigid fingers gripped mine with a desperation bordering on painful. He was trembling with a full-body vibration that traveled up his arm and into mine rather than just a cute flutter of nerves.He was going to bolt and panic, leaving me looking like an idiot holding onto thin air, but that simply couldn't happen.Instead of letting go of his hand, I pulled him closer without asking an

  • PLAYING PRETEND   CHAPTER 8 ~ FINN'S POV

    Regret set in immediately because the moment Kyle’s fingers closed around mine to seal the deal with a firm and confident shake, my stomach did a backflip that felt less like excitement and more like impending food poisoning.Pulling my hand back as if it had been burned, a wave of panic hit me. "Okay," I said, my voice rising an octave. "Okay. Deal made. Now I’m going to go home, hyperventilate into a paper bag, and we can start this... charade... tomorrow."Kyle was already standing up and dusting off his expensive jeans. "No can do, Parker. The clock is ticking. Vanessa is at the mixer now. If I don't walk in there with you in the next fifteen minutes, the moment is gone."He reached down to grab my arm and effortlessly hauled me up from the floor, causing me to stumble while clutching my textbook and phone tightly against my chest."Wait," I protested, digging my heels into the carpet. "I can't go to a mixer. Look at me!"Gesturing wildly at myself, the reality of my outfit set in

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status