LOGINCandy’s POV
Father Julian wasn’t ready, or at least, he still thought he wasn’t. I left him after that electrifying kiss we shared, even though every inch of my body was screaming for him to keep touching me. He didn’t know it yet, but he was playing a losing game. There were a lot of things he didn’t know; things he would never know. I liked the fact that he thought he was in control. I liked that he believed our meeting was by chance. I took off my coat and stepped into the rain, clad in nothing but my lingerie. I attracted curious glances; a few people yelled at me to get out of the downpour. It was a heavy rain, but I didn’t move. This was my last ace. I had always known Father Julian. I had sat through more of his masses than I could count. At first, I went for the fun of it, It was a joke, listening to him talk about hell and my soul being trashed, especially when the men in the front pews were the same ones paying to touch me on Tuesday nights. But I digress. I had seen him at one of those masses: a bright-eyed boy who loved what he was doing. Then it turned into a silly attraction, and then it became an itch I needed to scratch so bad. I knew I wanted him, whatever it took. I knew he struggled with the sin of lust. I’d seen him drive by the club and slow down just to see the girls trooping in and out. I knew every move he made before he made it. Just like I knew that tonight, if I showed up drenched in nothing but lace, he wouldn’t turn me away. He couldn't. I stood in the downpour until the silk of my lingerie clung to me like a second skin. When I burst through the side door of the chapel, gasping and shivering, he was there. "Candy?" His voice faltered as he turned, those eyes drinking me in unashamedly. I wrapped my arms around myself, letting my coat slip just enough so he could see what was underneath. “I was d-drunk and I…” He didn't hesitate. He grabbed my arm, his fingers digging into my wet skin, and hauled me through the shadows toward the heavy oak door of the Sacristy. He slammed it shut, the sound echoing through the silent church. "You're insane," he hissed, his eyes wild as they raked over me. The dim light caught the curve of my breasts through the soaked fabric. "If the other priests find you here, if anyone sees you—" "But they won't," I whispered, stepping into his space. "Because you're going to hide me, Julian." He backed me against the heavy vestment wardrobe, the scent of incense surrounding us. His breathing was labored, a frantic, uneven sound that told me he was already losing. Behind him, the gold vials of Holy Oil glinted, and a large, silver crucifix watched us from the wall with stony, silent eyes. "You're freezing," he muttered, his hands trembling as he reached for a white linen cloth, an altar cloth, something far too important for the church to be used on me. He started to wipe the rain from my shoulders. But then his hand stopped. His thumb brushed the swell of my breast, and the air in the room vanished. He looked at me, his face a mask of agony and desire. "Do it," I breathed, my hand finding the front of his robes. "Stop pretending, Julian. Your body wants this, I can feel it…" He let out a low, guttural groan, the sound of a man finally breaking. He reached into his pocket and pulled out his rosary, the wooden beads clicking loudly. I thought he was going to pray, but instead, he wrapped the cord around his knuckles, his eyes dark with a terrifying intensity. "You want the truth?" he rasped, pinning my wrists above my head against the wardrobe. "You want to know what I think of when I see you? All the things I want to do to you?” He didn't wait for an answer. He crashed his lips onto mine. He bit down on my lower lip, tugging at it. His hands buried deep into my hair, leaving me wondering where a priest could have learned to kiss like that. He pushed the coat off my shoulders until it pooled on the floor. I wrapped my arms around his neck, pulling him impossibly closer. His hands wandered down my bare back and over my ass. He caressed me as if unsure, but when I deepened the kiss, pushing my body into his, he found his resolve. He gripped me hard, his fingers and the rosary beads digging into my skin. When we finally broke the kiss, we were both gasping. He pulled away to check the lock on the door. When he turned back, his eyes were pools of melted chocolate, dark with a hunger that looked like it could eat me alive. “Take off your clothes,” he whispered in a strained voice. I looked at him sultrily as I reached behind me to untie my lingerie. Slowly. This was a strip show for his eyes alone. I swayed my hips, licking my lips as my hands caressed my own body. I held his gaze as I undid my bra, letting my breasts spring free. I watched in delight as his gaze darkened, his throat bobbing as he swallowed hard. I licked my lips, my eyes darting to the bulge in his pants. I wanted to tease him, but he was done waiting. He charged toward me, spun me around, and forced my hands above my head. Then, in one swift motion, he tied my wrists together with the rosary. The heat between my legs flared instantly. “Father Julian,” I whimpered. He ripped the rest of the lingerie away until I was stark naked. He pressed his body into my back, letting me feel the full weight of his hardness against my skin. He leaned into my ear, his hot breath making me shudder. “Look what you’ve done to me, Candy…” He had me pinned against the wall at first, his body pressed into mine. When I stole a glance at him, he looked like a man who had finally stopped fighting a drowning current and just let the water take him. He lifted me, my feet leaving the floor as he slammed me onto the heavy oak table where the vestments were usually laid out. The white linen cloth he’d used to dry me was bunched beneath my hips. He was trembling, his fingers fumbling with the buttons of his robes, his eyes fixed on mine with a terrifying, singular focus. He looked like he was about to devour me right there under the judging gaze of the silver crucifix. Then, the world outside our bubble shattered. Thump. Thump. Thump. Three heavy, rhythmic knocks echoed against the thick oak door of the Sacristy. Julian froze. His entire body turned to stone, his hands stopping mid-motion on his belt. The color drained from his face, leaving him ghostly pale in the dim light. "Father Julian?" A deep, gravelly voice called out from the other side. "Are you in there? The side door was left open... I saw the light." Julian’s gaze darted to the door, then back to me, naked, my wrists bound by his own rosary, sprawled across the table. If that door opened, everything was over. I didn't stay quiet. I leaned in, my lips brushing his ear, and whispered: "What are you going to tell him, Daddy?" The handle of the door rattled loudly. "Julian? I'm coming in."Carter’s POVMy hand was still on the metal locker door, pinning him. The silence that followed was deafening; it was like the world around us had gone quiet. I could feel the rapid thump of his heart beating against his ribs, mirroring the heavy pounding in my own chest.My eyes drifted down to his lips. They were still slightly swollen, parted just enough for his shallow breaths to hit my neck. I wanted to lean in. I wanted to finish what we started earlier.Liam didn’t blink. He stared at me for ten agonizing, endless seconds. The defiance in his eyes slowly crumbled, leaving behind something raw and completely exhausted.“I’m gay, Carter,” he whispered.My breath caught in my throat. I didn’t even have time to process it before the heavy metal door of the locker room swung open.“Yo! Liam, did you see that pass?” Bryce’s loud, obnoxious voice boomed down the hallway. The spell broke instantly.Liam didn't hesitate. He used my moment of shock to duck right under my arm. He p
Carter’s POVIt took me a solid five minutes just to get off the concrete. The throbbing ache in my groin made my stomach turn, but the fire burning in my chest was worse. I dragged myself up, leaning heavily against the brick wall, my breath coming in ragged gasps as I forced myself to walk back to the locker room.When I pulled the heavy metal door open, the loud sound hit me. The team was already inside, there was the rushing noise of running showers, boys yelling at each other over the music, and the sound of wet towels being strung over the locker doors. It was the exact background noise we’d lived in for years.My eyes instantly cut through the crowd, tracking down the one person I needed to see.Liam was at his locker at the very end of the row. He was already bare-chested, his broad shoulders glistening with a mix of sweat and water from where he’d tried to wash his face at the sink. His skin was still flushed a violent pink from our fight, his chest
“Carter! Carter!” Coach yelled, but I ignored him. Training was over for me and Liam today.“Hey! What the hell—” Liam stumbled, trying to yank his arm back, but I didn't let go.The boys behind us were hollering and cheering, thinking it was just a typical captain fight, but I kept walking until I dragged him all the way back into the locker room hallway, a quiet corner away from prying eyes.The second we were inside and alone, I shoved him back, my palm slamming hard against the brick wall right next to his head. The impact echoed loudly.“Are you okay?!” I breathed, my chest heaving against my shoulder pads, my face inches from his.“What the fuck do you think, Carter?” Liam spat, his voice trembling with a mixture of rage and shock. He ripped his wrist out of my grip. “I just got dragged off my own field like a piece of trash in front of the entire team!”“Don’t say that,” I interjected, my voice dropping. “Don’t say that.”“Then what am I sup
Carter’s POVI was drowning, and the worst part was that I’d jumped into the water myself.One week. One week of total radio silence from the only person who actually knew me. I’d called Liam a dozen times. Every single call went straight to voicemail. When I finally swallowed my pride and texted a massive paragraph trying to apologize, all I got back was a single word: Okay.I sat at our usual lunch table, staring blankly at my plastic tray while the rest of the guys argued about some college game. My head was a violent, chaotic mess. I wasn't in denial anymore. I couldn't be. You don't lunge at your best friend, pin him to a wall, and kiss him until your knees go weak if you're completely straight. I had gotten rock hard just holding him. I liked the taste of his mouth. I was bi, or gay, or whatever the hell label fit—I didn't care. I just knew I was crashing out because the thought of losing Liam was physically making me sick.He can’t be gay, I kept tel
Liam’s POVThe sky didn't just open up; it completely dumped on us the second Carter’s truck engine stopped in the driveway.“Go, go, go!” I yelled, playfully shoving Carter’s shoulder as we bolted out of the car, sprinting toward the porch.“Move your fat ass, Liam!” Carter bellowed back, bursting into a loud laugh echoing over the thunder. He gave me a hard shove back to get ahead of me, but the wet grass gave way. My foot slipped on the wet turf, and I violently lost my balance, my arms flailing as I stumbled backward.Instinct took over Carter. The second he saw me slip, his laugh cut short. He lunged forward, his face instantly twisting into pure worry as he rushed toward me, his hands grabbing my forearms to steady me before I could hit the ground.“Whoa, you good? You alright?” he yelled over the downpour, his voice frantic as he held onto me, his thumbs digging into my skin. He didn't pull away once I was stable. Instead, he stayed right there, scann
Carter’s POV“Oh my god, Carter, stop being so absentminded and pass the bowl already!” Stacy yelled, flicking her fingers in my face. I didn’t realize she had been trying to catch my attention the whole time.I blinked, pulling myself out of my head, and reached for the popcorn on the coffee table. “My bad.”“Like, seriously. You’ve been a zombie all day.” She snatched the bowl from my hands, tossing her head so her blonde ponytail whipped across my face. She didn’t even look at me as she turned her perfectly wide smile toward the other side of the couch. “Anyway, Mira! You have got to tell Liam about that thing you did with your hair for the pep rally. It was literally so cute, right, Liam?”Liam sat on the opposite end of the couch, looking massive and entirely out of place in the cramped space. “Yeah,” he answered, clearing his throat. “It looked great, Mira.”He didn't look at Mira, though. He looked at the TV screen. And then, for a split second, h
Father Julian’s POVI bolted out of the confession booth and didn’t see Candy again. It was hard, but I had fixed my rosary. I went to confession, and though I withheld the specific details of my sins, I confessed them. I said my prayers more often than I ever had before. I also avoided the booth;
Father Julian’s POVI woke up on Friday morning with a skip in my step. I went through my routine humming hymns, a delightful smile on my face. I had taken great care in preparing my robe that day for confession. I sat in the booth, only half-listening to the others ramble about the sins they had c
Father Julian’s POVSaturday night. It was embarrassing to admit how hard it was to find Candy’s workplace. I should have quit then; I should have quit after driving to the seventh club and asking patrons if they knew a "Candy." I shouldn’t have gotten out at the eighth spot, fueled by the fear tha
Father Julian’s POV“Father, forgive me, for I have sinned…”I furrowed my brows in confusion, glancing at the wooden divider, even though the small holes in the screen were too narrow to offer a clear view of who sat on the other side.“Is that how they usually begin?” the voice asked. It was hi







