CHAPTER 2 The Long Road North

❄ · ❄ · ❄

Elodie Marchetti added one page to the contract, and it very nearly ended the deal before it began.

She had read the first six pages three times at her kitchen island at two in the morning, with tea going cold beside her and the city asleep in the window. They were, annoyingly, very good. Clear, fair, a little cold at the edges, like the man. Section four covered public affection with the dry precision of a tax code. Section nine, titled Exit, made the end of the whole thing sound like a train schedule.

She wrote her own page and called it Section Twelve. It said: Neither party will lie to the other about anything that is not in this contract.

Julian's lawyer, a calm woman named Ms. Adeyemi, read it across a glass conference table at nine the next morning and raised one eyebrow so slightly it was almost an act of kindness. "Mr. Hale will want to discuss this."

He came in four minutes later, in a charcoal coat with snow still melting on the shoulders, and read the page standing up. She watched his eyes move. They went down once, and then, strangely, back up to the top.

"We are lying to everyone," he said at last. "That's the entire arrangement."

"To everyone else," said Elodie. "Not to each other. If we are going to stand in a house full of people and perjure ourselves at a dinner table, I want one person in the building I can trust to tell me the truth when I ask."

"That is a very sentimental request for a woman who just negotiated my cover story down to the lighting."

"I'm a Marchetti. We cry at bread." She did not smile. "Sign it, or I take the other fiancé offer."

The corner of his mouth moved. She was beginning to learn that every expression Julian Hale had was very small, and that she would, against all sense, start to hunt for them. He uncapped the pen and signed. The line under his name was straight and firm, and the handwriting was less careful than the rest of him.

"Section Twelve," he said. "Fine."

They left for Vermont on the nineteenth, the first week of snow.

Julian drove himself, in a dark, old station wagon that had belonged to his grandfather, with a heater that whistled and a back seat full of paper folders. No chauffeur, no jet. A man alone with the road.

"You own forty-four ships," said Elodie, as they crossed the Wisconsin line, "and this is your car."

"It starts every time. Nothing in it is trying to impress anyone. I find that restful."

Outside, the land lay flat and white under a hammered pewter sky. Behind them, her father had received a short, formal email: Elodie was engaged. To a Hale. He had called her eleven times. She had let the phone ring against her knee each time, feeling every ring like a hand on her sleeve.

"You can answer him," said Julian, not looking over.

"I can't," she said. "If I answer, I'll apologize. And I'm not sorry. I want to be sure that I'm not sorry for at least one more day."

They stopped for the night at a diner outside Rochester, a long chrome car of a place with red booths and a waitress named Marjorie who called everyone honey. Elodie ordered pie. Julian ordered tea, black, and sat staring at her slice as though it were a legal exhibit.

"You can have a bite," she said.

"I don't..."

"You ate my truffle."

"I analyzed it."

"Take a bite, Hale."

He did. He chewed very seriously, like a man hearing testimony, and she watched a curious thing happen to his face. Something unclenched. His shoulders came down half an inch.

"That's apple," he said.

"It's apple."

"It tastes like October." He said it so quietly she almost missed it, and then, because he seemed embarrassed to have said anything at all, he went back to his tea. But he took a second bite when she pushed the plate over, and neither of them mentioned it.

This was the trouble, she was beginning to realize. Not that he was cold. She had arrived with a whole coat of armor for cold. The trouble was the small moments: that he learned the waitress's name by the second sentence and used it exactly once, at the right moment; that he put coins in the jukebox and then stood there as though he had forgotten what a person did next.

"Tell me about her. Before we get there."

He was quiet for so long that she thought he might not answer. Then he folded his hands on the Formica and spoke like a man reading directions to a place he dreaded.

"Odalys Hale is eighty-one. She came to this country at nineteen with one suitcase and a ship's berth she had to work for. She built half of what my grandfather is given credit for." His thumb moved on the table. "She sees through lies the way other people see through glass. She raised me after my parents... after. She loves me completely and has never once told me."

Elodie did not touch his hand. It was not in the contract. But she let the silence stay open, soft, without trying to fill it, which she had learned from her mother, and after a while he exhaled.

"She will ask you how we met," he said. "And she will know if we're lying."

"Then we won't lie about the important parts."

He looked at her.

"We met at a gala," said Elodie. "You corrected my arithmetic. I found you insufferable. You were standing on a terrace, eating one of my truffles and looking at it like it owed you money. Which is true." She picked up her fork. "We'll only change the part where I said yes."

Julian looked at her across the pie and the cooling tea and the neon sign blinking Open through the fogged window. Then, very slowly, he did something she had not seen him do. He laughed. Not much. A low, rusted-hinge sound, as if it had been a long time since the door had been opened.

"That," he said, "may actually work."

They reached the Vermont line at noon the next day, and the world turned white. Snow lay in drifts against stone walls. The road narrowed into a lane, and at the end of the lane, through a break in the trees, a house rose out of the snow like the memory of a house: gray stone, tall windows, a hundred chimneys breathing smoke.

Hollin Hall.

"It's very big," Elodie said faintly.

"It's very cold. It's big because my great-grandfather wanted a ballroom to be sad in." He turned off the engine. "Last chance. There's a lawyer in Burlington who could have you home by morning."

She watched the front door. It was a tall, dark door, and it had begun, very slowly, to open.

"Section Twelve," said Elodie. "Tell me the truth. Are you afraid?"

He did not answer at once. Then, with his eyes on the door, in a voice she would remember for a long time afterward, he said: "More than I have ever been in my life."

And before she could answer, he reached over and, for the first time, took her hand. Not for an audience. Not yet. There was no one on the steps. Just a cold palm over hers, steady as a stone, and a small tremor in his fingers that he could not hide.

"Then let's go be terrified together," she said, and opened the car door.