Home / Romance / WHICH MAN STAYS? / Chapter 5— THE CLAIM

Share

Chapter 5— THE CLAIM

Author: Rach's pen
last update Last Updated: 2025-12-16 13:21:55

MAYA'S POV

“You look terrible, Maya. Are they not letting you use the shower?”

The voice, smooth and invasive as syrup, slides into the room. I look up from wiping Leo’s brow. Clara stands in the doorway, holding a ludicrously oversized bouquet of white lilies. She’s dressed for a board meeting, not a pediatric ICU.

Liam, who’d been dozing in the corner chair, is instantly on his feet, a silent, solid wall between her and the bed.

“What are you doing here?” My voice is flat. All my emotion is reserved for the beep of the monitor.

“I came to see the child, of course. And to see you.” She places the flowers on the windowsill, an act of conquest. “We need to talk. Man to man, as it were.”

“There’s nothing to talk about.”

“Oh, I disagree.” She smiles, glancing around the room with a pitying look. “I think we need to understand each other. For Daniel’s sake. He’s… stretched very thin.”

A cold laugh escapes me. “Is that what we’re calling it?”

She ignores me, stepping closer. Liam shifts, blocking her path completely. She finally acknowledges him with a flick of her eyes. “Liam. Still playing the faithful dog, I see.”

“Still trespassing where you’re not wanted, I see,” he replies, his tone deceptively calm.

Clara’s smile sharpens. She focuses back on me. “I’ll be brief. You need to accept the way things are. That man you’re so angry with? The provider in that lovely house? The career he has? That’s me, Maya. Every brick, every paycheck, every ounce of respect he’s earned in the last five years flows from my family. My father’s company. My favor.”

The words are meant to be bullets. They hit, but they find armor I didn’t know I’d grown. “You’re here to tell me my husband is a paid-for accessory?”

“I’m here to tell you he’s mine.” The veneer cracks, showing the steel beneath. “In every way that matters. He has been for years. You were the temporary caretaker of a life I built for him. It’s time to step aside with some grace. Sign the papers he’ll give you. Take your son. And go.”

The sheer audacity steals my breath. I stand up slowly, my body humming with a new, clean fury. “You have a child with him. I know that. Do you think that’s a winning argument? That you’re the winner of some contest? You’re the other woman who needed to trap a man with a baby to feel secure.”

Her composure wavers for a second. “You know nothing.”

“I know he forgot his son’s birthday for yours. I know which child he chose to celebrate. I know whose hospital bed he’s been too busy to sit at. You can have the prize, Clara. He’s a coward and a liar. But you don’t get to come into my son’s room and issue decrees.”

Liam speaks then, his voice cutting through the tension like a knife. “I think you’re forgetting something, Clara. Last I checked, you’re married. Or did your husband finally see the light? Why are you so obsessed with another woman’s man?”

Clara turns her glacial gaze on him. “My marital status is not her business. Or yours. This is between me and Daniel. And by extension, her. She’s the obstacle.”

“No,” I say, the word final. “I’m not an obstacle. I’m the ex-wife you’re going to have to deal with. Now get out.”

She doesn’t move. Instead, she reaches into her sleek leather portfolio. “I thought you might be emotional. Daniel always said you were… sentimental.” She pulls out a single, thick envelope. “This isn’t for you. It’s for him.” She holds it out toward Liam.

He doesn’t take it. “What is it?”

“A reality you’ve been avoiding.” She drops the envelope on the empty chair. It lands with a soft, heavy thud. The window on the front faces up. I see Liam’s full name printed in sharp, official letters. Below it, a line of text makes my heart stop.

SUBPOENA: PATERNITY TEST ORDER & INITIAL CUSTODY HEARING.

The world tilts.

Liam stares at it, all the color draining from his face. It’s not confusion I see. It’s recognition, followed by sheer, unadulterated horror.

“What is this?” My question is a whisper, directed at Liam, not Clara.

Clara’s smile is back, victorious and cruel. “It seems you’re not the only one who’s been in the dark, Maya. Your loyal knight here has a few secrets of his own. A child, from what I understand. A little boy, about five. The mother is seeking formal recognition and support. She’s quite determined.”

She lets that hang in the toxic air. The parallel is too precise, too devastating. A secret child. Age five. The exact weapon that destroyed me.

“It’s not true,” Liam says, but his voice is hollow, stripped of its usual certainty. He’s looking at the envelope like it’s a venomous snake.

“The courts will decide that,” Clara says sweetly. “I just happened to hear about it through my father’s legal team. Thought you should be served properly. Wouldn’t want you to miss your court date while you’re busy here… playing house.”

She turns to leave, pausing at the door. “Think about what I said, Maya. You have no allies here. Just different versions of the same betrayal. Daniel is mine. And your consolation prize?” She nods toward Liam, who is still staring, pale and shattered, at the legal papers. “He comes with baggage even bigger than yours.”

She’s gone.

The silence she leaves behind is screaming. The only sound is Leo’s steady monitor and the ragged sound of my own breathing. I look from the envelope—the official, terrifying envelope—to Liam’s face.

The man who has been my fortress for days looks utterly broken. He finally meets my eyes, and the pain in them is a physical blow.

“Maya,” he rasps.

It’s one word. A plea. A confession. A ruin.

And I have no idea what it means. The only man I trusted has just been served a paternity suit in my son’s hospital room. Clara’s last words echo. Different versions of the same betrayal.

The ground is gone again. But this time, Liam is falling with me.

Continue to read this book for free
Scan code to download App

Latest chapter

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 28 — THE SEAT TAKEN

    ELLIE'S POVMy hands were still shaking when I picked up the phone again. The TV was off now, but Giselle’s face and words kept playing in my head like a bad song on repeat. I scrolled through my contacts until I found Daniel’s name. My thumb hovered over the call button for a second before I pressed it. I needed answers. I needed something— anything— to make sense of this mess.The line rang twice before he picked up.“Ellie,” he said, his voice flat and tired.“Daniel, we need to talk.”There was a long pause. Then he sighed. “I remember warning you— and begging you— to buy my share in Silhouette when I offered it. You ignored me. Now you’re calling?”I closed my eyes and leaned against the wall. Leo was still on the couch, watching me with worried eyes. I tried to keep my voice steady. “Daniel, let me admit it. That day, I was acting based on my emotions. I was angry. Hurt. I just want to understand now— why is Giselle on my TV screen saying the opposite of what you told me? You sa

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 98— THE SEED

    The third spring in Seabrook arrived not with a gentle thaw, but with a week of defiant, icy rain that finally gave way to a sun so bright it made the wet world glitter. In the mud of my resurrected garden, I found the first brave spear of a crocus pushing through. It was purple, a tiny, triumphant flag. I showed Leo, his small hands caked in mud, his laughter echoing in the crisp air.Life had settled into a rhythm that felt less like a recovery and more like a life. A simple one. The kind with grocery lists and parent-teacher conferences and debates about whether to get a dog. (Leo was pro-dog. Liam was pro-"let's finish the storage shed first." I was secretly pro-dog, but loved the debate.)Liam's work with the coastal board had led to a part-time consultant role with the state parks service. He used his old, ruthless analytical skills to untangle budgeting knots and permit logjams. He came home smelling of pine and bureaucracy, a combination that made him grin. He was using the ma

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 97: THE BLUFF

    The cottage on the bluff was less a wreck and more a skeleton. Wind and salt had scoured the cedar shingles to a silver-grey. Two windows were boarded up. The porch sagged like a tired smile. But the view—the view stole the breath from your lungs and the fear from your heart. It was an endless expanse of moody Pacific, broken by the dark, jagged teeth of sea stacks. It was violent and beautiful and utterly, magnificently indifferent.Leo stood between us, one small hand in each of ours, and stared. "The ocean is big," he declared, his voice full of awe."It is," Liam said, squeezing his hand. "And this is ours. To fix."We named it Driftwood House for the grey, weathered look it already had. The purchase, funded by the swift, anonymous sale of a certain cliffside property thousands of miles away, was quiet. James's architect friend, Ben, drew up simple, sturdy plans. The town, a place called Seabrook, asked no questions. They saw a family looking for a fresh start, and that was a stor

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 96— THE AFTER

    MAYA'S POVThe federal safe house was not a home. It was a beige, carpeted limbo. It smelled of stale air and industrial cleaner, a bland anonymity that was both a relief and a kind of mourning. There were no windows that could be seen through from the outside. The doors had three locks. It was the safest place we had ever been, and it felt like the inside of a sealed vault.Leo, after days of clingy silence, began to tentatively play with the toys a kindly marshal had brought. He built towers with blocks, his movements careful, as if loud noises might summon the monsters back. He didn’t ask about Clara. He didn’t ask about the cliff house. The silence around those subjects was a wall we all gratefully maintained.Liam spent hours on the phone with Aronson and a new battery of lawyers—federal lawyers, financial lawyers, lawyers who used words like "restraining order," "asset forfeiture," and "criminal conspiracy." Clara was not in jail. She was under house arrest at the Finch mansion,

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 95— THE BREACH

    LIAM'S POVTime seemed to fracture. The sterile, controlled space of the cliff house dissolved into a tableau of raw, exposed power. Clara, for the first time since I’d known her, looked not calculating, but cornered. The invisible walls of her influence had been rendered visible, and they were closing in, broadcast on a live stream.The two men in tactical gear who had brought us here appeared at the doorway to the deck, their hands raised. Behind them, silhouetted against the stormy sky, were figures in flak jackets emblazoned with “U.S. MARSHALS.” The drone’s eye view had been replaced by the very real, very armed eyes of the state.Clara’s gaze swept over them, then back to James, to Rachel, her mind working with a visible, almost physical intensity. She wasn't defeated. She was recalculating with catastrophic variables.“You think this ends with me in handcuffs?” Her voice was a low, venomous scrape. “You’ve documented a private conversation under extreme duress. You’ve trespasse

  • WHICH MAN STAYS?   Chapter 94— THE CLIFFSIDE

    MAYA'S POVThe house was a museum of silence. Floor-to-ceiling windows showcased a violent, beautiful seascape—grey waves slamming against black rocks far below. The wind howled around the glass box, but inside, the air was still and cool. It smelled of new money and emptiness.Clara stood in the center of the vast, open living area, a solitary figure in all that space. She didn't gesture for us to sit. This wasn't a social call."The flight was a predictable move," she said, her voice cutting through the roar of the distant surf. "Melodramatic. Inefficient."Leo clung to my leg, hiding his face in my jeans. I kept my hand on his head, a grounding touch for us both. "What do you want, Clara?" My voice was scraped raw from fear and the cold wind.She ignored me, her gaze on Liam. "You were liquidating assets. Preparing to disappear. You thought you could simply vanish from the world I helped you inhabit." A faint, icy smile. "There is no 'outside' for people like us, Liam. Only places

More Chapters
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status