All Chapters of A Love That Shouldn't Be: Chapter 121 - Chapter 130

Behind her, Danni grinned as a sudden idea struck her. Leaning over and brushing Beth's hair back, she leaned in close to whisper something in her ear. Beth grinned immediately and glanced at Mike, winking and pulling up a chair.Not having a clue what his two sisters were up to, Mike shrugged and finished serving their other guests. As they fell into their chairs and began chewing on the succulent rib meat, Beth seemed to make sure that all three men could see her plainly. Groaning, Mike had a feeling that she was about to do something to spur the difficult conversation on.As if on cue, Beth lifted one of her ribs up to her mouth, biting into it as the juices flowed into her mouth. She began to make a show of eating it, really getting into letting the juices flow down her chin and chewing the meat off, incredibly sexy, but also incredibly 'Beth-like'. She seemed to be unaware of what she was doing and Mike glanced over at Matt and Paul, both of them glued to his sister.Mike glanced

The entire group was laughing, most of them at least. Mike sat quiet, smiling and even further embarrassed."How'd she catch you?" Danni asked.Shaking his head, Mike refused to answer, not wanting to open that particular can of worms again."He yelled out someone's name," Emma said, unable to resist the temptation."Ooooo," came the reply from several people."Who?" Ashley said, secretly wishing it was her. Alright, maybe not so secretively, the poor girl was bouncing with anticipation.Mike was shaking his head though, adamantly not going to answer.Desperately trying to change the topic, he glanced over at Missy. "Truth or dare?"Seeing the desperation on his face, Missy stopped laughing long enough to cough out, "Dare."Desperate for some revenge, Mike decided to get even. "Go down on Emma, or you have to make out with your brother."The laughter stopped briefly as they all looked at Mike, and then turned to Missy who didn't look excited about either prospect."Aww, come on you gu

"That's...different," he said. "I didn't start this intentionally. I was dreaming and thought you were Emma!""Then why are you so hard?" she asked, her fingers encircling his thick rod. "Tell me this doesn't turn you on," she said, slowly beginning to pump him up and down."Ash," he began to protest, but faltered."Paul," she said, moving to lay on top of him, his cock sticking upwards between her legs and resting against her pussy. "Tell me to stop and I'll stop," she said.Paul had his eyes closed and was desperately trying to find some courage to get her off of him, but he had to admit it to himself. He wanted her. He wanted her badly.He wrapped his arms around her and gently pressed her to him, feeling her red hair draping around down his face and neck."I've always had a thing for my big brother," she said, leaning her face close to his and giving him a kiss.He groaned in pleasure and moved his hands lower, cupping both butt cheeks as she began to gyrate, rubbing her sopping p

They came down as Mike and Paul both finished their plates and headed out back to clean up the bottles and trash. Emma stopped him and whispered in Mike's ear for a few seconds, giving him an abridged version of what Ashley had told her.Mike glanced at her and then Ashley, but then shrugged as he realized that it would actually make his conversation easier.Nodding, he leaned over and gave Emma a peck on the cheek and headed out back with Paul.Moving around the pool, he picked up stray clothes and bottles of beer that had been dropped or casually tossed."So I heard you know our little secret," Mike said finally, catching Paul off guard.Paul glanced over and for a moment, looking like he didn't know what to say."I'm not judging," he said eventually."To be honest with you," Mike confessed, "the whole date with Emma and I was to somehow get you and Ashley to hook up."Paul cocked his head, looking confused."Ashley found out about our secret a few days ago and my sisters came up wi

Mike shuffled beside the warm form laying next to him and turned, squinting at the sunlight pouring through the window. Groaning, he rolled over and wrapped his free arm around soft snoozing, feminine form, that then snuggled closer to him. Pushing his nose deeply into her hair, he inhaled deeply and smiled.'Danni,' he thought, smiling.Danni,' he thought, smiling. Of course it was her. He'd been sleeping next to her, and with her, for that matter, for weeks now. She twitched slightly next to him, causing him to smile. Whenever she was sleeping, Danni had this adorable quality. She would jump, ever-so-slightly, like her body was resisting trying to go to sleep, or waking up.She inhaled deeply and moved again, slowly turning over, nuzzling her head forwards. Pushing his chin up, she brought her nose and lips to rest against his bare chest."Mmmm," she said, slowly awakening.He reached his hand up and brushed her hair away from her beautiful face, her eyes slowly opening as she raise