Does 'A Stark New Robb SI' Follow Book Or Show Canon?

2025-06-16 12:00:38 151

3 คำตอบ

Parker
Parker
2025-06-19 15:51:59
As someone who's read both the books and watched 'Game of Thrones', I can tell you 'A Stark New Robb SI' plays fast and loose with canon in the best way. The fic blends elements from George R.R. Martin's 'A Song of Ice and Fire' novels and the HBO adaptation, but leans heavier on book lore. You'll spot deep-cut references like Robb's warging abilities that the show ignored, plus nuanced political dynamics from the books. The author clearly studied the source material - Northern mountain clans get more screen time, and minor characters like Dacey Mormont appear with book-accurate personalities. The SI's knowledge seems drawn from both versions though, mixing show visuals with book plotlines creatively.
Quincy
Quincy
2025-06-21 00:45:21
Diving into this fanfiction was like uncovering a treasure trove of alternate universe possibilities. The story follows an intriguing middle path between book and show canon, making smart choices about when to deviate from both. Early chapters stick closer to 'A Storm of Swords' events, including the proper chain of command at the Whispering Wood battle that the show simplified. Later arcs incorporate show-only elements like Talisa Maegyr's character, but reinvent her backstory to fit book lore better.

What fascinates me is how the SI's presence creates ripple effects that make both canons irrelevant. The Red Wedding gets completely derailed by Robb making strategic decisions neither book nor show version considered. The fic introduces original twists like Robb negotiating with the Iron Bank early, something neither medium explored. The author's clearly done their homework - they use book-accurate geography for troop movements but keep the show's pacing during battles. It's a masterclass in blended canon storytelling.
Kyle
Kyle
2025-06-22 02:08:15
Having analyzed dozens of ASOIAF fics, this one stands out for its canon agility. The SI's knowledge base appears primarily show-driven initially - he recalls visual details like the Hound's burnt face clearly. But his actions unlock book-exclusive content immediately, preventing Theon's betrayal through tactics only a book reader would know. The fic treats canon like a buffet, picking the juiciest elements from both versions.

Northern politics follow book rules meticulously - Glover and Mormont banners appear correctly at war councils. Yet the dialogue crackles with the show's modernized wit during small council scenes. The author even fixes continuity errors between mediums - Robb's marriage pact with the Freys gets the proper book terms rather than the show's vague promises. When the story needs tension, it'll suddenly diverge from both canons spectacularly, like having Stannis arrive at Winterfell before the Boltons. This isn't just following canon - it's improving upon it.
ดูคำตอบทั้งหมด
สแกนรหัสเพื่อดาวน์โหลดแอป

หนังสือที่เกี่ยวข้อง

Follow Through
Follow Through
The fascinating,chaotic story of a food obsessed girl who discovers startling new abilities within herself and is transported to the mystical land of Opa where she must save the land,control her hormones and try to not fall in love with her best friend.
10
38 บท
Follow Your Dreams
Follow Your Dreams
Liam Patrick Owen, a 17 year old gay young man, who has been homeless for the last two years of his life; living on the streets and doing what he has to do to survive in life from day to day; moment to moment and second to second. Riley Aegon Grayson, a 23 year old bisexual man who is the president of the motorcycle club, The Gray Rebel's since he was 18 years old. Most people view these clubs and the members as bad but that isn't true for all. Once of Riley's Patch holders finds Liam and brings the young man to his brother to figure out what should be done with Liam. Liam is usually terrified of everyone especially men but he has an instant connect with Black Jack and one of the women in the club. What will Riley do with Liam and will Black Jack allow it.
10
27 บท
The New Age King // Book 2
The New Age King // Book 2
The war between Werewolves and Fairies is beginning. Lives are being lost on both sides, and King Octavius Bishop is up to his neck in blood. When it seems as if all hope for Octavius's humanity is lost, his mother sends him a gift. A gift in the form of his long-awaited mate. But will Octavius see his mate as a gift or as a burden? Will her unwavering love be enough to keep him from turning into the evil he is fighting? Or will Octavius reject and crush his only hope for redemption?
9.8
65 บท
SHOW ME LOVE
SHOW ME LOVE
Lorenzo De Angelis is an Italian tycoon who runs his empire with an iron fist. He is gorgeous, powerful, young, and very wealthy. His enemies are several and quite ferocious, so Lorenzo trusts no one. This is why when he discovers a woman hiding in his office, listening to some important and extremely confidential information, his first instinct is to keep her ‘prisoner’ for a few days while trying to discover who is this beautiful ‘spy’. She is Phoebe Stone and she is just doing her job cleaning offices, without knowing she is ‘in the wrong place at the wrong time’. So, in a matter of minutes, against her wishes, she will start a thrilling adventure, next to a stunning but frightening man. This adventure will change both their lives forever. (Excerpt) The reality hit her hard. She was standing in a dimly lit room, half naked in front of the man who kidnapped her… who threatened her... The most beautiful man in the world. He lifted her hands and put them on him as if it was the most natural thing in the world that she should touch him. She caressed him again, just to make sure he was really there. He covered her small hands with his and stood perfectly still. “If you want me to stop, I will. If you want me to leave this room, I will. ‘Piccola’ (Ita. Baby), the decision is yours.” “Don’t stop, please… I just want to be yours tonight… and always…”
10
32 บท
Where Stars Don't Follow
Where Stars Don't Follow
When my husband once again chooses to abandon me to celebrate his true love's birthday, I finally let go. He takes his true love stargazing; I don't cause a fuss. He buys her an expensive scarf, but all I do is smile. I even tell him to buy another hat—it's pretty cold. He thinks I've finally learned to be obedient. However, he has no idea I've secretly renounced my citizenship to join Doctors Without Borders. By the time he comes to his senses, I've vanished without a trace.
9 บท
Midnight Horror Show
Midnight Horror Show
It’s end of October 1985 and the crumbling river town of Dubois, Iowa is shocked by the gruesome murder of one of the pillars of the community. Detective David Carlson has no motive, no evidence, and only one lead: the macabre local legend of “Boris Orlof,” a late night horror movie host who burned to death during a stage performance at the drive-in on Halloween night twenty years ago and the teenage loner obsessed with keeping his memory alive. The body count is rising and the darkness that hangs over the town grows by the hour. Time is running out as Carlson desperately chases shadows into a nightmare world of living horrors. On Halloween the drive-in re-opens at midnight for a show no one will ever forget. ©️ Crystal Lake Publishing
10
17 บท

คำถามที่เกี่ยวข้อง

Who Does Robb Stark Become In 'A Stark New Robb SI'?

3 คำตอบ2025-06-16 06:59:38
In 'A Stark New Robb SI', Robb Stark undergoes a radical transformation that flips his original fate on its head. Instead of the tragic end in 'Game of Thrones', he becomes a strategic powerhouse with modern knowledge, thanks to the self-insert twist. This Robb merges his medieval leadership with 21st-century tactics, turning the North into an industrial and military force. He introduces gunpowder, reforms agriculture, and negotiates alliances using psychological warfare. His enemies don’t stand a chance because he anticipates their moves like a chess grandmaster. The story explores how one man’s advanced mindset can rewrite history, making Robb the architect of a new Westerosi empire.

Are There Romance Subplots In 'A Stark New Robb SI'?

3 คำตอบ2025-06-16 12:30:38
I binged 'A Stark New Robb SI' recently, and yes, romance sneaks in between all the political maneuvering and battles. Robb's relationship with Jeyne Westerling gets more depth here—it’s not just a youthful fling. The SI’s modern perspective adds layers to their dynamic, showing Jeyne as a strategic partner rather than just a love interest. There’s also subtle tension with Margaery Tyrell, though it’s more about alliances than passion. The fic handles romance realistically; no instant soulmates, just messy feelings tangled with duty. If you enjoy slow burns where love plays second fiddle to survival, this delivers.

Where Can I Read 'A Stark New Robb SI' Online?

3 คำตอบ2025-06-16 08:06:52
I stumbled upon 'A Stark New Robb SI' while browsing fanfiction sites last month. The story pops up frequently on Archive of Our Own (AO3), which hosts tons of Game of Thrones SI fics. SpaceBattles Forum also has an active thread where the author posts updates regularly. Some readers mirror chapters on FanFiction.net, but AO3 tends to have the most polished version. The writing quality surprised me—it’s not just wish fulfillment. The SI’s political maneuvers feel authentic to Westeros, and the author nails Robb’s voice. If you enjoy SI stories with heavy world-building, this one’s worth tracking down across multiple platforms.

How Does 'A Stark New Robb SI' Change Westeros' Timeline?

3 คำตอบ2025-06-16 03:25:55
As someone who’s obsessed with 'A Stark New Robb SI', I can tell you the timeline shifts dramatically from the moment Robb gains self-awareness. The biggest change is Robb avoiding the Red Wedding entirely by exposing the Freys’ treachery early. He allies with Stannis instead of declaring himself King in the North, which keeps Tywin distracted longer. The SI’s modern knowledge lets Robb innovate—better crop rotations prevent famine, and primitive gunpowder weapons give the North an edge in battles. Bran’s training starts earlier, making him a more skilled warg by the time the White Walkers attack. The SI’s biggest impact is preventing the Stark family’s disintegration; Sansa never marries Tyrion, Arya returns home faster, and Jon learns his parentage before the Long Night.

Is 'A Stark New Robb SI' A Game Of Thrones Fanfiction?

3 คำตอบ2025-06-16 22:23:41
I've read 'A Stark New Robb SI' and it's absolutely a 'Game of Thrones' fanfiction, but with a fresh twist. The story follows Robb Stark getting a self-insert (SI) character—basically, someone from our world wakes up in his body. The SI aspect changes everything: Robb makes decisions no original character would, like negotiating with the Lannisters early or using modern tactics in battles. The writing nails the political intrigue of Westeros while blending in the SI’s outsider perspective. It feels like 'Game of Thrones' but with a strategic overhaul. If you love AU fics where characters break canon, this delivers. Try 'The Dragon’s Roar' for another SI take on Jon Snow.

When Does Robb Stark Die

4 คำตอบ2025-01-17 07:11:46
Gosh, that was a tough moment for any 'Game of Thrones' fan. Robb Stark, the Young Wolf, met his tragic end in Season 3, during the shocking ninth episode, appropriately titled 'The Rains of Castamere'. This episode, also known as the infamous Red Wedding, was where Robb, his mother, and many of his soldiers and bannermen were brutally slain. Caution, it's still a nail-biter, even if you know what's coming.

Who Killed Robb Stark

2 คำตอบ2025-02-24 13:28:58
In that horrific occurrence, Walder Frey, Roose Bolton, and Tywin Lannister all had a part.Vengeance must be heavy in your heart to break a marriage agreement, as it did to Walder Frey.It was actually Roose Bolton who wielded the blade that killed Robb. This close associate of Frey's was the one to finally put an end into Mr Stark after everyone else had gotten out of range...What a cruel man!

What Episode Does Robb Stark Die

4 คำตอบ2025-01-17 17:47:36
I am grievously sorry, it is with great sorrow to admit that Robb Stark, one of the best-loved characters in 'Game of Thrones' was killed off in Season 3 Episode 9. People call that episode 'The Rains of Castamere' for short. The event was shocking and harsh, a major blow to fans around the world. The episode itself is a brilliant example of 'bad' storytelling, with that cruel twist being a tribute to the remorseless world of 'Game of Thrones'.
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
DMCA.com Protection Status