Is The Arkenstone A Silmaril

Thorin and Bilbo’s conflict over the Arkenstone is a goldmine for fanfiction writers, and I’ve seen so many creative spins on it. Some fics focus on Bilbo’s guilt, imagining him confessing his theft earlier, leading to a tense but heartfelt conversation where Thorin’s pride clashes with his growing trust. Others take a darker route, with Thorin’s dragon-sickness spiraling out of control, forcing Bilbo to make even harder choices. I’ve read a few where Bilbo uses the Arkenstone as a bargaining chip not just for peace but to save Thorin from himself, blending political intrigue with emotional depth. There’s also a recurring theme of Bilbo’s loyalty being tested—does he prioritize Thorin’s well-being or the greater good? One standout story had Bilbo hiding the Arkenstone not out of fear but to protect Thorin’s legacy, showing how deeply he understands Thorin’s heart. These fics often explore the aftermath too, with Thorin grappling with betrayal and forgiveness, and Bilbo learning to navigate the complexities of dwarven honor.