Is The Arkenstone A Silmaril

2025-02-06 08:03:03 94

3 Answers

Adam
Adam
2025-02-07 21:56:16
They were as tough as plain gravel but gold seemed soft to them, indeed their hard handhold was good only for a little while. The Arkenstone being found in rock and hewn just like any other gem. Also, it should be noted that they say in "The Silmarillion" two of the three brilliant Silmarils ended up settled in places out of reach–in sky or else deep inside planet Earth. And the third one was cast into middle ocean where it vanished forevermore.

So, the result of finding one gem that lay between them in the halls of Erabor is surely questionable. The Arkenstone might have been a different jewel entirely, quite different in beauty and elegance but equally captivating for dwarfs as were the fabled Silmarils.
Omar
Omar
2025-02-09 20:21:11
The Arkenstone of 'The Hobbit' and the Silmarils in 'The Silmarillion,' are keys of difference. The Silmarils, made by waylorn smith Feanor, catch the light from the Two Trees of Valinor, cannot be broken by no power on plain earth. But the Arkenstone was found in earth, can be cut and has no literal glow of divinity. Good legend, too!
Yolanda
Yolanda
2025-02-11 00:10:12
Discussing Tolkien's gems, aren't they fascinating?! Tempting to imagine that the Arkenstone, the heart of the mountain in 'The Hobbit', could be one of the lost Silmarils from 'The Silmarillion'. That'd be an epic crossover, right? But, I think not, mate. Remember, the three Silmarils were unique, unbreakable jewels crafted by Feanor, containing the divine light of the Two Trees of Valinor. On the contrary, the Arkenstone was unearthed in the Lonely Mountain and was able to be cut, polished, and shaped - which wouldn't be possible if it were a Silmaril. Moreover, according to lore, the Silmarils are meant to be gone from the world, hidden in the sky, the earth's fiery core, and the ocean until the end of days.

So in my opinion, it's unlikely the Arkenstone is a Silmaril, but it's undoubtedly a thematic echo, a kind of homage to the allure and drama of the Silmarils!
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

I Paid A Billionaire For A Hook Up
I Paid A Billionaire For A Hook Up
BOOK #5 Wright-Petrov Series Nursing her broken heart and crushed pride, Abigail Marie Fuentebella Sandoval boldly gatecrashed her ex-fiance's engagement party. As she stood in the corner of the massive hall, she gritted her teeth in pure contempt while witnessing his betrayal. Worst, they looked so happy together. To assuage the searing pain drilling her chest, she drowned her sorrows in several glasses of champagne. Her boyfriend of eight years fathers her scheming stepsister's unborn child. Seeking retribution, she impulsively hooked up with a striking man from the crowd, convinced he was someone of importance. However, she was cruelly ridiculed after discovering he was a pauper, not the prince she had hoped for. She faced immense mockery for presumably "downgrading" from her wealthy ex-fiance, Justin Del Castillo, the President of F&D Group of Companies, to a struggling man who couldn't even afford to take her on a date at her family-owned luxurious hotel. Unbeknownst to everyone, especially to Abigail, she was not mistaken that night. The man she chose was not a mere millionaire, but a BILLIONAIRE. The shrewd business tycoon, CEO Lucas Alexander Montes Wright, the cherished firstborn of the world's richest family and the eldest heir of the Petrov Mafia.
10
280 Chapters
The Amazing Doctor
The Amazing Doctor
Before the divorce, she thinks he's absolutely worthless. After the divorce, he's transformed into the most amazing doctor of the millennium with boundless power and wealth. Unbeknownst to her, he's the one who's given her everything she owns now, and everything she could ever want would be served to him with a snap of his fingers. Since being average was a crime, he would show her who was the unworthy one!
9.3
2550 Chapters
My fiance's Brother
My fiance's Brother
As the youngest daughter of Yoke family, Evangeline can only marry to Bishop family. Her father deeply loved his elder daughter Rose, who is born to his late wife. Evangeline's mother is just a convenience to her father, even her mother thinks highly of her elder sister Rose more than her. Never got the love of both of her parents, Evangeline was promised to Jake Bishop, who is nothing but a womanizer and lives off of the money earned by his stepbrother, the type she least wants to be involved with. Damien is the elder son of the most powerful family in the werewolf world. As the next in line to take over the Bishop empire, he is 29 and already promised to marry Rose. But one night changed their lives forever. Evangeline unexpectedly slept with Damien and gave him her virginity. Slowly Damien begins to be attracted to Evangeline more than he should.  What will happen if Evangeline finds out that Damien is none other than her would-be brother-in-law? Will she bend down to her father's demands and marry Jake? Can Damien let her go? Can this forbidden couple have a happy ending?
9.4
200 Chapters
HE'S MY ALPHA
HE'S MY ALPHA
"Arise, my Luna." His voice rang in the air and sent shivers down my spine. I looked down at the ground, slowly rising to my feet while holding my breath.  "My name is Clair, Alpha Aeon." I answered respectfully, but I refused to look at him. Frustration rolled off of his aura before it changed into anger. I swallowed hard as bile threatened to rise from my throat.  "Have I done anything to despise you?" His hand snaked around my nape as he took one step closer. "My wolf is so close to marking you, Clair. I can assure you, it'll be painful. I'm the only one standing in the way. Submit, and we'll make it less painful." He moved his hand to my jaw, forcing me to look at him. "Look at me. You'll be mine! And I will make sure all others before me are forgotten." I closed my eyes, and the tears fell from my eyes. I was already losing this battle. I took a deep breath, ready to nod my head, when a ferocious growl marred the air, shaking the ground where I stood.  "I dare you to touch what's mine!" I snapped my eyes open, turning in the direction of the threat. He's here.  He came for me.  My Alpha came for me.  ¤¤¤¤¤ ALPHA JACOB GALHART of the Black Shadow Pack never wanted a mate. He has led his pack for years without a Luna and was content to remain that way. But it was time to produce an heir. Not wanting to find his mate, he set his eyes on this one female, Clair Montrell.  He thought he had everything planned out until she turned out to be the fated mate he never wanted. But would he be able to let her go?
9.8
95 Chapters
MY STEP UNCLE IS MY SUGAR DADDY
MY STEP UNCLE IS MY SUGAR DADDY
AHEM *CLEARS THROAT* THIS STORY CONTAINS MATURE CONTENTS THAT ARE VERY VIVID, IT'S NOT ALLOWED FOR ANYONE UNDER EIGHTEEN, YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. There were secrets I kept from everyone else because I would be sent for counselling or even therapy if I ever told anybody about it but there was no way that I could control the burning desire I felt when I saw my step uncle. "Forbidden!" the voice in my head would warn but it doesn't stop the throbbing between my legs. I see the way he looks at me and I'm certain that he wouldn't be able to hold himself much longer, soon, we both would have to keep dirty secrets from everyone else because there is no way I would tell after he has had me tied to his bed.
9.8
240 Chapters
The Dragon King's Seduction
The Dragon King's Seduction
In a world where the werewolf kingdom is on the brink of war, the Alpha King is forced to offer one of his daughters hands in marriage in exchange for peace. When Princess Xendaya finds out that her younger sister has agreed to wed the Dragon King - a beast who is known for his callous, ruthless and deadly nature - she decides to take her place, making the ultimate sacrifice and signing away her freedom. Far from home and her people, will the head-strong werewolf princess survive in the kingdom of beasts? A place that is far worse than she thought. Her new husband is not only dangerous but has the sexual appetite of a hundred men. How will Xendaya cope knowing that her king has a harem and has no shortage of women? Agnarr, the Ruthless, is a merciless leader who has his eyes on a throne that he feels is his birthright, thrusting his people into the claws of full-out war and carnage. Will he continue to bottle his pain, rage, and hatred within him or allow his new queen to help guide him? How will Xendaya cope when her so-called husband turns his gaze upon her, his newest possession? How will Agnarr react when he realises he wants a taste of his new wife? And how will she remain strong and not succumb to her Dragon King's seduction? In a clash of wills, passion and desire, will the threat that hangs above them allow them to give in? Or will it simply drive them apart? ~~~ The sequel to The Alpha King's Possession Follow me on IG Author.Muse and FB Author Muse for updates, aesthetics and more!
9.8
96 Chapters

Related Questions

How Do Thorin X Bilbo(The Hobbit)Fanfiction Stories Reimagine Their Conflict Over The Arkenstone?

3 Answers2025-05-08 22:33:50
Thorin and Bilbo’s conflict over the Arkenstone is a goldmine for fanfiction writers, and I’ve seen so many creative spins on it. Some fics focus on Bilbo’s guilt, imagining him confessing his theft earlier, leading to a tense but heartfelt conversation where Thorin’s pride clashes with his growing trust. Others take a darker route, with Thorin’s dragon-sickness spiraling out of control, forcing Bilbo to make even harder choices. I’ve read a few where Bilbo uses the Arkenstone as a bargaining chip not just for peace but to save Thorin from himself, blending political intrigue with emotional depth. There’s also a recurring theme of Bilbo’s loyalty being tested—does he prioritize Thorin’s well-being or the greater good? One standout story had Bilbo hiding the Arkenstone not out of fear but to protect Thorin’s legacy, showing how deeply he understands Thorin’s heart. These fics often explore the aftermath too, with Thorin grappling with betrayal and forgiveness, and Bilbo learning to navigate the complexities of dwarven honor.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status