Why Does 'As Close To Us As Breathing' Have Mixed Reviews?

2026-03-08 04:11:06 185

3 Answers

Peter
Peter
2026-03-11 23:39:39
I lent my copy of 'as close to us as breathing' to three friends, and all three had wildly different reactions. One couldn’t put it down, calling it 'a masterpiece of quiet grief.' Another said it dragged, and the third just shrugged, saying it was 'fine, I guess.' That sums up the mixed reviews perfectly! The book’s strength—its intimate, slice-of-life approach—is also its weakness for readers craving more action or a tighter plot. The author digs deep into everyday tragedies, the kind that simmer under the surface, and that’s not everyone’s cup of tea.

Another thing: the setting, a 1940s Jewish family at a beach house, feels vivid and nostalgic, but some critics argue it leans too hard on nostalgia without enough forward momentum. And the themes—guilt, sibling rivalry, the weight of expectations—are universal, but the way they’re explored can feel heavy-handed or too subtle, depending on who you ask. Personally, I appreciated how it made me think about my own family’s unspoken tensions, but I’d never recommend it to someone looking for a light read.
Luke
Luke
2026-03-13 12:13:33
Reading 'as close to us as breathing' was such a rollercoaster—I totally get why opinions are split. Some folks adore the way it weaves family drama with historical context, especially how it captures the quiet, aching moments between characters. The prose is lyrical, almost poetic, which I personally loved, but I’ve seen reviews where people found it too slow or meandering. It’s one of those books where the pacing feels intentional, like you’re meant to linger in the emotions, but not everyone vibes with that style.

Then there’s the structure—the nonlinear timeline adds depth, jumping between past and present to unravel secrets. For some, it’s a brilliant way to build tension; for others, it’s confusing or disjointed. And the characters! They’re flawed, messy, and painfully human, which makes them relatable to some and frustrating to others. I cried over certain scenes, but I’ve also chatted with readers who couldn’t connect with anyone in the cast. It’s a book that demands patience and emotional investment, and I think that’s where the divide happens.
Harper
Harper
2026-03-14 19:21:55
The polarized reactions to 'as close to us as breathing' remind me of how subjective storytelling can be. What hooked me was the authenticity—the way small moments, like a shared meal or a sideways glance, carry so much emotional weight. But I’ve seen reviews complaining that 'nothing happens,' which baffles me because so much happens internally. It’s a character study, not a plot-driven thriller, and that distinction seems to be the core of the divide.

Also, the book’s handling of trauma and memory resonates deeply with some (like me) but feels repetitive or unresolved to others. The ending, especially, splits readers—some call it poignant, others anticlimactic. It’s the kind of story that stays with you, for better or worse, and that lingering effect probably fuels the debate. Maybe it’s just a love-it-or-hate-it kind of book.
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

AS LONG AS I'M BREATHING
AS LONG AS I'M BREATHING
Lorenzo and Selena secretly love each other, even though it should be forbidden by agents. Especially since Lorenzo was a captain and Selena was a member of his team. No romantic relationship should occur between agents. But Lorenzo was desperate to love Selena and marry her. During their five years of marriage, all was well and they had a son who was hidden from the public. But a new mission gets Selena killed and all the secrets they've been tightly hiding for so long are revealed to the surface. The FBI's elite board was furious and suspended Lorenzo for his misdeeds. Everyone shunned Lorenzo when he was in the most difficult phase of his life because Selena's death brought a threat to his son. Lorenzo was always blaming himself after all the weeks since Selena's death. He secretly investigates Selena's bizarre death case in order to viciously punish Selena's murderer. But when he gets close to the mastermind behind Selena's murder, he meets a woman who looks like Selena who works for his enemy. Lorenzo thought that the woman might be Selena. And as long as he was breathing, he would continue to pursue that woman to prove that she might be his dead wife.
Not enough ratings
|
63 Chapters
Mixed signals
Mixed signals
Lydia, 22 year old, beautiful and brave woman who was taken by her Aunt after her parents sudden death. Life hasn't being going on smoothly for her, a cheating boyfriend and her insecurities. One day, Lydia found out all her life has been a life as she found out the reason behind her parents death. On her way to report to the police station, she was taken by unknown and upon all struggle, she was thrown down the sea only to wake up finding a stranger as her savior
Not enough ratings
|
15 Chapters
Hot Chapters
More
Mixed Feelings
Mixed Feelings
"You are mine, No one has a right to touch you, hold you, or love you...You're all mine get that in your thick skull...I'll kill every single one who desires to have you or even think of having you, You belong to me only me your soul, your body everything belongs to me, only me...Do you get that" He said while gripping my chin with pressure, making me look into his eyes. "Please... You're hurting me" I said, trying to free myself from his iron-like grip. "Say it" he shouted on my face, gripping my chin even more tightly. "Yes( sobbing ) yes... I'm yours" I said, sobbing and struggling to be freed from his grip. Vanessa foster 18 years old cute, naive, and kind-hearted person. she was living a normal life with good grades until she meets a devil living in a greek god-like body. Lorenzo Francisco, 26 years old ruthless, cold, unforgiving, manipulative, and merciless businessman. As C.E.O of Francisco group's, he has billions on his name. The wind carries the way he kills and manipulates people in Los Angeles making everyone tremble in fear. He was envied by men and wanted by women. What happens when this dark and aloof billionaire meets the naive Vanessa? Will love win the game? Heartbreak, betrayal, manipulation, suspense, and Romance.
9.5
|
110 Chapters
Mixed Signals
Mixed Signals
Richard Rossi, co-owner of Petals Cosmetics and Pharmaceuticals gets a sexual experience that shakes his whole being from a young woman who turns out to be the youngest daughter of his partner, Peter Torres. He hides away after the incident miles away from the Torres family. His presence is not required until the sudden passing away of his partner and best friend. Jacqueline Torres is a wild child, the black sheep of the Torres family and the youngest child. On the night of her parents' annual summer party, she meets a man who evokes the female side of her which she had strived to keep buried within her. When she finds out who he is, she vows to make him pay for running out on her. When the runaway co-owner returns to take over after her father's death, Jacqueline begins to question her emotions as memories of that night plague her still. Richard is called upon to take up the responsibility of his company, putting an end to his nomadic lifestyle. He tries to play a distant, fatherly role when he meets with the lady from five years ago but when they encounter dire situations and death targets from all sides, he has a reason to stay, to protect and to love her.
Not enough ratings
|
17 Chapters
Hot Chapters
More
Mixed Signals
Mixed Signals
Sarah HAYES has worked too hard to let a single mistake derail her career. She’s finally secured her dream job as an executive assistant at Vance Holdings, a world ruled by spreadsheets, silence, and the ruthless, ice-cold CEO, ALEXANDER VANCE. ​Alexander is gorgeous, untouchable, and utterly terrifying. Their worlds collide when Elara literally crashes into him, earning a verbal lashing that should have ended her career before it even began. But instead of being fired, Elara is given the impossible: she's reassigned as Alexander Vance’s personal, 24/7 assistant. ​Now, she is trapped. ​One moment, he treats her like an annoying distraction—a clumsy obstacle beneath his notice. The next, his eyes hold an unsettling intensity, his voice lowers, and the air crackles with an electric current that screams forbidden desire.
Not enough ratings
|
13 Chapters
Hot Chapters
More
My Boyfriend Loves Me... As Does His Mistress
My Boyfriend Loves Me... As Does His Mistress
Nolan Shaw is the big shot on campus that everyone is intimidated by. He's also the guy I've been in love with for a while now. Out of nowhere, a new admirer of his pops out. She bears a striking resemblance to me. When I bring him his water, she beats me to it. When I write him a love letter, she tears it up. Finally, I muster up the courage to be honest with Nolan about my feelings—only for her to rush over and kick over the candles I prepared for the confession. That's when I finally lose my patience. "Just what on earth are you doing?" She ignores me and grabs Nolan's arm before saying, "I'll be frank with you. I'm actually here on a mission. You and Nolan will end up in a bitter marriage, hurting each other. So the system wants me to stop you two from being together." I don't believe a word she says, thinking that she's just lying to separate us. But at the very next second, I hear her thoughts. [Just what on earth did this scumbag do to make the 22-year-old Teresa fall so hopelessly in love with him? I bet she'll be heartbroken if she finds out that in the future, he'll find her boring and end up keeping 18 mistresses on the side. And after the divorce, he'll even make it hard for her to earn a living. She ends up dying of exhaustion, too!]
|
10 Chapters

Related Questions

What Are The Major Plot Twists In 'It Ends With Us' By Colleen Hoover?

3 Answers2025-10-24 16:45:08
There are definitely some jaw-dropping moments in 'It Ends With Us' that had me on the edge of my seat! One of the most significant twists for me was when Lily’s relationship with Ryle takes a dark turn. At first, he's this charming and charismatic neurosurgeon who sweeps her off her feet, but as their relationship progresses, his darker side emerges. The revelation that he can be abusive was such a gut-wrenching moment, and to see Lily struggle with the complexities of love versus self-preservation hit hard. It made me reflect on how love can sometimes blind us to warning signs. Another impactful twist is the introduction of Atlas, Lily's first love. His reappearance triggers a whirlwind of emotions. Suddenly, we see how undiscovered love can linger in the shadows, complicating Lily’s already tumultuous relationship with Ryle. When she discovers the depths of Atlas's struggles after being apart for so long, it’s a stark contrast to Ryle's character. This twist made me appreciate the nuanced layers of relationships and how they shape us over time. Lastly, the ending itself is a rollercoaster! I won’t spoil too much, but it leaves readers with a heavy heart while also offering a glimmer of hope. This twist pushes Lily towards making a powerful decision that reaffirms her self-worth. Overall, the way Colleen Hoover weaves these plot twists into the narrative makes it not just a love story, but an exploration of resilience and personal growth!

When Will Season 8 Of Outlander Be Released In The US?

3 Answers2025-10-27 09:03:52
Good news for fellow time-travelers: season eight of 'Outlander' already arrived in the US. It premiered on STARZ on March 10, 2024, and the episodes rolled out on a weekly schedule, so fans got to savor each chunk of Jamie and Claire's story rather than being hit with everything at once. I watched a handful of episodes the night they dropped on the Starz app — if you have a Starz subscription (through a streaming bundle, your cable provider, or the standalone app), that's the most direct way to catch it. New episodes aired live on the network and then showed up on the app for on-demand viewing. I've noticed that the streaming playback and picture quality on the app have been solid; it's the same place I binge-revisit earlier seasons when I'm prepping for new twists. Beyond logistics, I'm honestly torn between wanting to marathon the whole final season and wanting to savor it slowly. The show has always been equal parts sweeping romance, historical grit, and occasional pure chaos, and season eight keeps that mix. If you haven't caught up, I'd start with the end of season seven — it sets the stakes. Either way, seeing Claire and Jamie back on screen felt like visiting old friends, and I’m still smiling about a few moments that landed perfectly for me.

Does Outlander How To Watch List US Streaming Platforms?

5 Answers2025-10-27 05:11:06
Totally worth digging into — here’s the practical scoop for US viewers. 'Outlander' is a Starz original, so the primary place to stream current seasons in the United States is the Starz app or starz.com. If you subscribe directly to Starz you get the full library, new episodes as they premiere, and the ability to download episodes for offline viewing on the mobile apps. If you don’t want to subscribe straight to Starz, there are convenient ways to get it through other services: Starz is available as a channel add-on inside Amazon Prime Video Channels, Apple TV Channels, Roku Channel Premium, and Hulu (as a premium add-on). That means you can keep using the interface you like while paying Starz through that platform. For folks who prefer ownership, individual episodes and seasons can be bought on Amazon Video, iTunes, Google Play, and Vudu. Physical copies — DVDs and Blu-rays — are also sold with extras if you love behind-the-scenes material. Personally, I usually grab a season on sale and then binge with snacks; it feels like a proper ritual.

What Nearby Attractions Are Close To Jordan Pines Campground?

3 Answers2025-11-05 18:46:22
Sunrise light hitting the pines here always makes me want to lace up my boots and go explore, and around Jordan Pines Campground there’s plenty to keep a curious person busy. Within a short drive I usually find a handful of great trailheads for everything from mellow family hikes to steeper ridge scrambles — perfect for day trips and for chasing viewpoints at golden hour. There’s often a river or reservoir nearby that’s great for fishing, tossing a canoe in, or just sitting on the bank with a sandwich and a good book; I’ve caught more than one lazy afternoon slipping away while watching waterfowl and trout rise. Beyond the obvious outdoor stuff, I like seeking out small local museums and historical markers near campgrounds like this. They give a neat context to the landscape — old mining cabins, early settler homesteads, or interpretive signs about the indigenous plants and wildlife. Local towns nearby usually have a handful of charming cafes, hardware stores with last-minute camping supplies, and a seasonal farmers’ market that’s worth a morning stroll. In colder months, some of the higher roads turn into quiet cross-country ski loops or snowshoe routes, so I pack a different set of gear and enjoy the hush of snowy pines. If you’re into stargazing, the night sky here can be spectacular when the campground is quiet: bring a blanket, download a star chart app, and get lost identifying constellations. Personally, I love mixing a long day hike with a slow evening around the fire — simple, satisfying, and a great way to disconnect for a couple of days.

Are There Popular Novels Banned In The US Book Ban?

1 Answers2025-11-09 14:18:50
The topic of banned novels in the U.S. is pretty fascinating and often a bit distressing, especially for book lovers like me. It raises so many critical questions about freedom of expression and the importance of diverse voices in literature. You'll find that many well-loved novels have faced bans, sometimes for reasons ranging from their themes to explicit content, or simply because they challenge the status quo. One of the most notable examples is 'The Catcher in the Rye' by J.D. Salinger. This classic coming-of-age novel often finds itself on banned lists across schools and libraries due to its portrayal of teenage angst and rebellion. I mean, who can forget Holden Caulfield's cynical view of the adult world? It really resonates with anyone who has felt misunderstood or out of place. Yet, it’s precisely that raw honesty that makes the book such an essential read for many young adults. It's like a rite of passage! Then there’s 'To Kill a Mockingbird' by Harper Lee. Its powerful take on racism and moral integrity reflects themes that remain painfully relevant today. However, it often gets challenged due to its language and the uncomfortable truths it portrays about society. For me, the book is a critical piece that encourages dialogue about justice and morality. It’s a shame that some institutions choose to shy away from books that explore such vital issues, rather than embracing the lessons they offer. Another novel that comes to mind is 'The Bluest Eye' by Toni Morrison. This book dives deep into themes of race, identity, and beauty standards in America, and has also faced challenges, primarily for its explicit content and distressing themes. Morrison’s work has had a profound influence on literary discussions and the Black experience in America. It seems ironic that books like this, which provide important perspectives, are often silenced instead of celebrated. There's so much more to gain from reading these novels than from pushing them aside. It’s disheartening to see how certain works are deemed controversial, especially when they can ignite discussion and promote understanding. Every time I stumble upon a banned book list, I feel a sense of urgency to read those titles not just for enjoyment, but to understand the nuances of why they are challenged. It's like uncovering hidden gems that spark conversations that need to be had. So many perspectives, histories, and stories are lost when we allow fear to dictate what we can read. Let's keep exploring literature passionately, supporting the freedom to read, and appreciating the diverse voices that enrich our lives!

What Are The Reasons Behind The US Book Ban Controversy?

1 Answers2025-11-09 12:13:00
Navigating the book ban controversy in the US is like wandering through a tangled forest of opinions and emotions. It often sparks intense discussions, and honestly, it’s troubling to see how literature and education can become battlegrounds. One major reason this controversy has arisen is the question of what content is deemed appropriate for various age groups. Parents, educators, and lawmakers feel strongly about the influence of books on young minds, leading to calls for censorship when materials touch on sensitive themes such as sexuality, race, mental health, or violence. It's fascinating yet disheartening to think how powerful stories—capable of fostering understanding and empathy—are sometimes viewed as threats instead of opportunities for learning. Another significant factor fueling this debate is the rise of social media and our interconnectedness. When a controversial book surfaces, its detractors can rally quickly online, amplifying voices that seek to protect children from perceived harm. This reaction often comes from a place of genuine concern, but it can escalate to banning entire libraries of literature just because a single passage doesn't sit right with a few. It’s like throwing the baby out with the bathwater—so many important narratives get lost or silenced because they touch on uncomfortable topics. Moreover, political agendas play a massive role; books are sometimes sidelined or targeted based on broader ideological divides. For instance, what you might find offensive or unworthy of a child's education often varies dramatically between communities. Those on one end of the spectrum might advocate for full access to literature that presents diverse perspectives, arguing that exposure to a wide range of ideas better prepares kids for the realities of life. On the flip side, others might feel justified in their attempts to shield kids from what they perceive as inappropriate content and might push for bans to enforce their worldview. It’s a familiar scenario—where personal beliefs clash with others' rights to read and learn. The thing that truly stands out is that stories hold power; they teach us about history, human experiences, and different cultures. Banning books can stifle that learning process, leaving glaring gaps in understanding. I can’t help but feel every time a book gets banned, a part of our cultural fabric unravels. This whole situation makes me reflect deeply on why freedom of expression is so vital and why literature should remain a safe haven for exploring complex themes and ideas. In a nutshell, the book ban debate is not just about words on a page; it’s a mirror reflecting our society's values, fears, and aspirations. Quite the heady topic, isn’t it?

What Merchandise Exists For Close Body King Of Soldiers Collectors?

6 Answers2025-10-29 19:34:43
If you’re hunting for gear tied to 'Close Body: King of Soldiers', you’re in luck — it’s a surprisingly rich scene. I have shelves full of figurines and merch, and honestly, the variety is what kept me hooked. There are the obvious statue lines: scale figures in 1/6, 1/7, and 1/8 sizes that capture the armor details and facial expressions; they’re often released as regular and limited color variants. For people who like posability, look for articulated figures—think Figma-style and S.H.-type releases—that let you recreate those combat stances. On the smaller end you’ve got blind-box chibi micro-figures and gachapon runs that are perfect for desk displays or diorama work. Beyond figures, the art and print world around 'Close Body: King of Soldiers' is vibrant. Official artbooks and character design compilations give gorgeous full-color spreads of costumes and weapon schematics; limited-edition prints and lithographs sometimes come signed at conventions. There are also soundtrack CDs and vinyl pressings for the score — if you care about atmosphere, a soundtrack can make late-night replays feel cinematic. Apparel runs from tasteful enamel pins and embroidered patches to full hoodies, tees, and tactical-style jackets modeled after in-universe uniforms. Don’t forget the practical stuff: dakimakura (body pillows), mousepads featuring key art, phone cases, posters, enamel badges, and replica props like straps, holsters, or mini weapon replicas. For serious collectors, garage kits and resin cast models offer customization and repainting fun. I always recommend checking for official seals and trusted sellers to avoid bootlegs — a little extra on authenticity saves you future regret. Personally, I’ve made a micro-shrine of select pieces and it still puts a smile on my face every time I pass it.

Who Survives In The End Of Us Finale?

6 Answers2025-10-22 15:53:17
That finale of 'Us' keeps replaying in my head like a haunting song. The core takeaway: the Wilson family — Adelaide, Gabe, Zora, and Jason — walk away alive at the very end. We watch Adelaide triumph over Red in the final showdown at the funhouse, and then she returns to her family; the military and police arrive and the immediate threat subsides, with the film closing on the family driving away together. That's the surface-level survival list: the Wilsons make it out physically intact. Where it gets deliciously messy is the moral and identity angle. The Adelaide we follow through the whole movie is actually the child who, years before, was switched with her Tethered counterpart. The woman who led the underground rebellion, Red, is revealed to be the original Adelaide who had been trapped below. So the person who survives is the impostor — a Tethered who adopted the life of the original — and she kills Red, the original. That flip reframes victory into something uncomfortable: survival doesn't mean moral clarity. Also, many of the Tethered are either killed or dispersed by the military response, but Peele purposely leaves the larger fate of the dug-up doubles ambiguous. I love that the film gives you a tidy “they live” ending and then immediately peels it back with the twist, so you leave wondering whether survival is a victory or a complicated compromise. It’s the kind of ending that lingers with me whenever I think about identity and consequence.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status