Why Does 'As Close To Us As Breathing' Have Mixed Reviews?

2026-03-08 04:11:06
225
Share
ABO Personality Quiz
Take a quick quiz to find out whether you‘re Alpha, Beta, or Omega.
Scent
Personality
Ideal Love Pattern
Secret Desire
Your Dark Side
Start Test

3 Answers

Peter
Peter
Story Interpreter Student
I lent my copy of 'as close to us as breathing' to three friends, and all three had wildly different reactions. One couldn’t put it down, calling it 'a masterpiece of quiet grief.' Another said it dragged, and the third just shrugged, saying it was 'fine, I guess.' That sums up the mixed reviews perfectly! The book’s strength—its intimate, slice-of-life approach—is also its weakness for readers craving more action or a tighter plot. The author digs deep into everyday tragedies, the kind that simmer under the surface, and that’s not everyone’s cup of tea.

Another thing: the setting, a 1940s Jewish family at a beach house, feels vivid and nostalgic, but some critics argue it leans too hard on nostalgia without enough forward momentum. And the themes—guilt, sibling rivalry, the weight of expectations—are universal, but the way they’re explored can feel heavy-handed or too subtle, depending on who you ask. Personally, I appreciated how it made me think about my own family’s unspoken tensions, but I’d never recommend it to someone looking for a light read.
2026-03-11 23:39:39
11
Luke
Luke
Reviewer Cashier
Reading 'as close to us as breathing' was such a rollercoaster—I totally get why opinions are split. Some folks adore the way it weaves family drama with historical context, especially how it captures the quiet, aching moments between characters. The prose is lyrical, almost poetic, which I personally loved, but I’ve seen reviews where people found it too slow or meandering. It’s one of those books where the pacing feels intentional, like you’re meant to linger in the emotions, but not everyone vibes with that style.

Then there’s the structure—the nonlinear timeline adds depth, jumping between past and present to unravel secrets. For some, it’s a brilliant way to build tension; for others, it’s confusing or disjointed. And the characters! They’re flawed, messy, and painfully human, which makes them relatable to some and frustrating to others. I cried over certain scenes, but I’ve also chatted with readers who couldn’t connect with anyone in the cast. It’s a book that demands patience and emotional investment, and I think that’s where the divide happens.
2026-03-13 12:13:33
13
Harper
Harper
Bibliophile Librarian
The polarized reactions to 'as close to us as breathing' remind me of how subjective storytelling can be. What hooked me was the authenticity—the way small moments, like a shared meal or a sideways glance, carry so much emotional weight. But I’ve seen reviews complaining that 'nothing happens,' which baffles me because so much happens internally. It’s a character study, not a plot-driven thriller, and that distinction seems to be the core of the divide.

Also, the book’s handling of trauma and memory resonates deeply with some (like me) but feels repetitive or unresolved to others. The ending, especially, splits readers—some call it poignant, others anticlimactic. It’s the kind of story that stays with you, for better or worse, and that lingering effect probably fuels the debate. Maybe it’s just a love-it-or-hate-it kind of book.
2026-03-14 19:21:55
9
View All Answers
Scan code to download App

Related Books

Related Questions

Is 'as close to us as breathing' worth reading?

3 Answers2026-03-08 06:04:12
I stumbled upon 'as close to us as breathing' during a weekend bookstore crawl, and it completely blindsided me with its emotional depth. At first glance, the premise seemed quiet—family dynamics, historical undertones—but the way Miko Kingsolver weaves generational trauma with moments of tenderness is masterful. The prose feels like listening to an old relative tell stories by a fireplace; you catch yourself holding your breath during pivotal scenes. What hooked me wasn't just the plot (though the 1950s Connecticut setting adds such rich texture), but how the characters' flaws make them achingly real. Ada’s rebelliousness, Julie’s quiet desperation—they linger in your mind like people you’ve actually known. If you enjoy novels that treat family like a mosaic—broken pieces forming something unexpectedly beautiful—this one’s a treasure.

Why does The Air You Breathe have mixed reviews?

3 Answers2026-03-18 14:13:37
I recently finished 'The Air You Breathe,' and I can totally see why it's polarizing. On one hand, the prose is gorgeous—lyrical and immersive, like you're right there in 1930s Brazil. The friendship between the two main characters, Graça and Dores, feels raw and real, full of passion and betrayal. But I think some readers bounce off the pacing. It’s a slow burn, and if you’re not invested in the emotional dynamics, the middle section can drag. Also, the ending divides people; some call it poetic, others anticlimactic. Personally, I loved the bittersweetness, but I get why it’s not for everyone. Another thing is the historical backdrop. The book dives deep into samba culture and the music scene, which is fascinating if you’re into that era. But if you’re expecting a tight plot or clear-cut resolutions, it might frustrate you. The ambiguity around Graça and Dores’ relationship—whether it’s love, obsession, or something else—also leaves room for interpretation, which some folks adore and others find unsatisfying. It’s one of those books that lingers in your mind, for better or worse.

What books are similar to 'as close to us as breathing'?

6 Answers2026-03-08 10:07:20
If you loved the emotional depth and family dynamics in 'As Close to Us as Breathing', you might find 'The Weight of Ink' by Rachel Kadish equally gripping. Both books weave historical contexts with intimate personal stories, though Kadish’s work delves into 17th-century Jewish history alongside a modern academic mystery. The prose feels just as lush, and the way it explores legacy and identity resonates similarly. Another great pick is 'The Dovekeepers' by Alice Hoffman. It’s more mythic in tone but shares that same tender, almost painful exploration of women’s lives bound by tradition and crisis. Hoffman’s magic realism adds a layer of wonder, but the heartache and resilience feel familiar to Ferris’s novel. For something quieter, 'The Giant’s House' by Elizabeth McCracken has that bittersweet, small-town intimacy and quirky characters who linger in your mind long after the last page.

Why does 'The State of Us' have mixed reviews?

3 Answers2026-03-23 12:39:28
Reading 'The State of Us' felt like riding an emotional rollercoaster, and I can totally see why it’s polarizing. On one hand, the romance between the two main characters is achingly sweet—their chemistry leaps off the page, and the way they navigate political differences feels refreshingly real. But then there’s the pacing. Some chapters drag with overly detailed political subplots that, while interesting, don’t always mesh well with the personal story. I’ve seen readers who adore the slow burn call it 'thoughtful,' while others dismiss it as 'meandering.' And let’s talk about the ending! Without spoilers, it’s either a heartfelt conclusion or frustratingly open-ended, depending on who you ask. The book’s ambition is admirable, but it’s also its Achilles’ heel—it tries to balance too many themes at once, and not everyone vibes with that. Personally, I landed somewhere in the middle. The dialogue crackles with authenticity, especially in the quieter moments, but I wished some side characters had more depth. The protagonist’s dad, for instance, could’ve been more than just a political caricature. That said, the book’s exploration of activism and privilege is nuanced, even if it occasionally feels like it’s preaching to the choir. Maybe that’s the core issue: it’s a book with a clear message, and if you don’t connect with that message, the flaws stand out more. Still, the fanart I’ve seen online proves it resonates deeply with some—just not universally.

What happens at the end of 'as close to us as breathing'?

3 Answers2026-03-08 18:36:16
The ending of 'As Close to Us as Breathing' is a poignant blend of tragedy and quiet redemption. The novel, which revolves around a Jewish family in 1940s Connecticut, culminates in the aftermath of a devastating accident—the death of young Davy, the beloved son of Ada and Howard. This event fractures the family, especially the sisters Ada, Vivie, and Bec, who each cope with guilt and grief in starkly different ways. Ada withdraws into herself, Vivie seeks solace in religion, and Bec escapes into academic pursuits. The final chapters show how this loss lingers over decades, shaping their relationships and unspoken regrets. What struck me most was the author’s delicate handling of time. The narrative jumps between past and present, revealing how Davy’s death becomes a shadow that never fully lifts. The ending doesn’t offer neat resolutions but instead leaves you with a sense of how grief becomes woven into the fabric of family life. There’s a heartbreaking scene where Ada, now elderly, finally visits Davy’s grave after decades of avoidance—it’s a moment of raw, quiet closure that stayed with me long after I finished the book.

Why does 'Under the Earth Over the Sky' have mixed reviews?

4 Answers2026-03-10 16:02:59
I picked up 'Under the Earth Over the Sky' after hearing so much buzz, and wow, it’s a divisive one! Some readers adore its lyrical prose and dreamlike world-building—it’s like wandering through a myth painted in watercolors. Others, though, find the pacing glacial, with plot threads that unravel without clear resolution. Personally, I vibed with its melancholy beauty, but I totally get why folks craving tight storytelling might bounce off. It’s the kind of book that either cradles you or leaves you cold, depending on what you seek from fiction. What’s fascinating is how its themes of grief and memory resonate differently, too. Some call it profound; others say it’s pretentious. The ambiguity is intentional, but that’s a double-edged sword. If you love atmospheric reads that prioritize mood over momentum, this’ll haunt you in the best way. Otherwise, it might just feel like a pretty slog.

Who are the main characters in 'as close to us as breathing'?

9 Answers2026-03-08 22:53:05
The heart of 'As Close to Us as Breathing' revolves around the intertwined lives of the Leibritsky family, particularly three sisters—Ada, Vivie, and Bec—who navigate love, loss, and identity in a 1940s Jewish community. Ada, the eldest, carries the weight of tradition while hiding her own desires; Vivie, the middle sister, is pragmatic yet quietly rebellious; and Bec, the youngest, is a dreamer whose innocence is shattered by tragedy. Their brother Howard, though less central, adds another layer of familial tension. The novel’s emotional core lies in how their choices ripple across generations, especially through Ada’s daughter, Molly, who grapples with the family’s unresolved grief decades later. What struck me most was how the author, Liz Poliner, paints each character with such specificity—Ada’s stoicism, Vivie’s sharp wit, Bec’s artistic soul. Even secondary figures like Uncle Abner or the sisters’ mother, Celia, feel vivid. The book isn’t just about individual arcs but how these lives collide, like threads in a tightly woven tapestry. It’s one of those stories where the 'main' characters blur because everyone contributes to the collective memory. Molly’s retrospective narration adds a poignant layer, making you wonder whose story it truly is—hers or the sisters’.

Why does 'Things We Don't Talk About' have mixed reviews?

5 Answers2026-03-13 05:26:09
I picked up 'Things We Don't Talk About' after hearing so many conflicting opinions, and wow, it’s easy to see why reactions are all over the place. The book dives into really heavy themes—trauma, family secrets, mental health—but the way it’s written feels almost disjointed at times. Some chapters are lyrical and haunting, while others drag with overly vague metaphors. Honestly, I adored the raw honesty in parts, especially the protagonist’s inner monologues, but the pacing lost me halfway through. It’s one of those works where your enjoyment hinges entirely on whether you connect with the author’s style. What’s fascinating, though, is how the ambiguity becomes its strength or weakness depending on the reader. Some folks crave that open-ended, interpretive quality (I’ve seen fans dissecting symbols for hours online), while others just find it frustratingly incomplete. Plus, the lack of trigger warnings might’ve caught some off guard—the graphic scenes aren’t for everyone. Still, I respect how it refuses to sugarcoat life’s messiness, even if it stumbles in execution.

Why does The Fiction Between Us have mixed reviews?

4 Answers2026-03-20 12:23:44
I picked up 'The Fiction Between Us' after hearing so much buzz about it, and honestly, my feelings are all over the place. On one hand, the premise is intriguing—a love story woven into a meta-narrative about storytelling itself. The way it plays with reality and fiction could've been brilliant, but the execution felt uneven. Some chapters dragged with overly dense introspection, while others rushed through pivotal moments. The characters, especially the protagonist, had flashes of depth but often got lost in the book's own cleverness. It's like the author was trying to juggle too many ideas at once. That said, I totally get why some readers adore it. The meta aspects are daring, and when the emotional beats land, they hit hard. But the pacing and tonal shifts make it a divisive read—it demands patience, and not everyone vibes with that. If you love experimental storytelling, it might be your jam. If you prefer tight, linear plots, this could frustrate you. Personally, I admire its ambition more than I enjoy it.

Why does 'The Night Will Find Us' have mixed reviews?

4 Answers2026-03-21 20:49:09
I recently finished 'The Night Will Find Us' and totally get why opinions are split. On one hand, the atmospheric horror is phenomenal—the way the woods feel alive and menacing gave me serious 'Blair Witch' vibes. The tension builds so slowly that you almost forget to breathe. But I think where it stumbles is the character development. Some folks felt disconnected from the protagonists, like they were just vehicles for scares rather than people you root for. That said, the ending is divisive. Without spoilers, it leans hard into ambiguity, which some readers adore (me included—I love chewing over interpretations) while others wanted clearer resolutions. Also, the pacing’s uneven; the middle drags a bit before the wild final act. If you’re into mood over plot, it’s a gem. But if you crave tight storytelling? Might frustrate you.
Explore and read good novels for free
Free access to a vast number of good novels on GoodNovel app. Download the books you like and read anywhere & anytime.
Read books for free on the app
SCAN CODE TO READ ON APP
DMCA.com Protection Status