What Are The Best His Forsaken Luna Fan Theories?

Sometimes I map out possibilities on sticky notes and 'His Forsaken Luna' turned my wall into a conspiracy board. One neat theory I keep returning to is that Luna’s ‘forsakenness’ is actually a ritual exile—an ordered, compassionate removal meant to protect a deeper truth. The flashback sequences peppered throughout the narrative feel selective, like someone curated what the characters remember. That suggests memory-wiping or protective erasure, which would make Luna a sacrificial shield for something catastrophic. If so, the moral tension becomes whether to restore memory and risk disaster or keep the peace built on lies.

Another angle I chase is language and naming. A few NPC names are anagrams or share roots with lunar deities—simple crossword-level sleuthing, but it hints at a mythic overlay that the protagonists are only beginning to decipher. Combine that with recurring astronomical imagery and you get a world where myth influences physics: belief shapes reality. That unlocks a theory where rituals, songs, and art literally hold back calamity, and Luna’s absence slowly erodes those cultural anchors.

I like the poetic cruelty of these ideas: they make every small scene carry the weight of history and choice. It feels less like a puzzle to solve and more like a tapestry you’re unweaving, thread by thread.

One twist I keep circling back to is that 'His Forsaken Luna' isn't about abandonment at all but about a deliberate exile—Luna chose to be cast out to hide something bigger. I like this theory because it reframes her quiet moments and coded dialogue as calculated self-preservation rather than victimhood. There are recurring images of locked windows, eclipses, and silver thread that, to me, read like a map of someone sealing a secret away. If Luna deliberately walked away, it explains the contrast between her soft voice and the really strategic moves she makes behind the scenes.

Another favorite theory is that Luna is a reincarnation—or partial vessel—of an ancient lunar deity. That would justify the supernatural pull around her, the way certain characters shift tone when the moon is mentioned, and why rituals seem to go wrong in her presence. It ties into the idea of memory echoes: odd déjà vu sequences in the text could be flash fragments from a past life bleeding through. I also toy with Luna secretly being related to the supposed antagonist: a hidden twin or child swapped at birth. That familial twist would add layers to the betrayal theme and give weight to the title 'Forsaken.'

Finally, I adore theories that lean meta: the narrator is unreliable, and what we see as Luna’s isolation is actually a narrative device showing how communities mythologize trauma. If the storyteller embellishes or edits, then all the clues—like those stray lunar sigils and half-erased letters—are purposeful breadcrumbs. Personally, the duality of gentle imagery and cold strategy is what hooked me, and I keep replaying scenes, looking for the one line that flips everything for me. Feels like treasure hunting, and I love it.

Okay, here’s a tight take I keep telling friends: Luna might be a living contract, not a person. In several scenes of 'His Forsaken Luna' she binds herself—or is bound—through language, sigils, and promises that appear in the margins of tomes and murals. If Luna is the embodiment of a covenant, then her being ‘forsaken’ means the contract was broken, freeing consequences that now roam the world. That frames the antagonists not as evil for evil’s sake but as parties trying to cash in on a void left by that broken pact.

I also like the micro-evidence game: repeated use of a particular constellation, the same three-note motif in music, and a certain phrase cropping up in dream-visions. Those are the breadcrumbs fans use to argue Luna’s role is metaphysical. Imagining a finale where restoring the contract requires personal sacrifice rather than grand battles feels right to me—a quieter, mournful victory that sticks with you.

I find the mechanics in 'His Forsaken Luna' to be fertile ground for conspiracy-level headcanon. One detailed theory posits a time loop: Luna's apparent foreshadowing and knowledge of old songs aren't mystical awareness so much as memory of lived cycles. There are subtle temporal mismatches—characters referencing events that supposedly haven't happened yet, or dialogue that repeats verbatim across different timelines. If Luna is both the cause and the effect of a loop, her being 'forsaken' becomes tragic necessity rather than moral failing. This explains why certain factions treat her like a myth to be contained.

Another angle I dig into is institutional betrayal. The ecclesiastical order in the story has more faces than it admits, and their rituals around the moon are almost colonial in tone. My reading sees Luna as a scapegoat used to consolidate power: mark the inconvenient person as cursed, then justify purges and land grabs. That frames the personal drama as political theater, aligning with broader motifs about propaganda and memory control. It’s a darker take, but it makes the world feel systemic rather than accidental.

Lastly, I indulge a symbolic reading: Luna as mirror and cipher. The moon has always reflected light rather than produce it, so maybe Luna's role is to reflect truths the society refuses to face. This makes her both fragile and indispensable. I keep returning to that image of the moon’s face cracked—beautiful, haunted, and necessary—and it makes me respect the narrative craft here. I like how each theory adds a different emotional weight to the same scenes.

One quick, messy brain dump that I can’t help but believe: Luna might be two people in one—either a secret twin sharing memories or a host with a sealed persona. The text sprinkles repeated dreams and mirrored scars that scream split-identity to me, and I love how that would explain sudden shifts in skills and temperament.

Another compact theory is the prophecy-as-misinterpretation: people misread lunar omens, basically weaponizing superstition. That turns the real villain into the culture that punishes nuance. Finally, there’s the heartbreaking possibility that Luna is a living archive—someone keyed to absorb memories so the society can forget its crimes. If true, that would make her sacrifice quietly heroic, and I end up oddly moved whenever she smiles through pain.

Wild theory list incoming: my favorite one is that Luna herself is a fractured timeline—literally split into two beings. In 'His Forsaken Luna' the visual motifs of mirrors and moons cropping up in different color palettes always felt like more than atmosphere to me. I like to imagine that every time the world resets or someone meddles with fate, a piece of Luna gets cast off into another reality. That explains the ghostly copies, the duplicates of memories, and why some characters recognize her while others don’t. The emotional payoff here is huge: if true, reunification would be bittersweet, because reassembling Luna might erase the friends she made as fragments.

Another theory I cling to is that the Forsaken are actually guardians who were betrayed, not monsters. Contextual clues—faded sigils on ruined altars, the sad expressions on stone statues—hint to me that the city’s collapse was an act of political fear, not simple corruption. That flips the narrative: instead of heroes purging evil, the protagonists might be undoing a centuries-long injustice. I love how this makes moral choices heavier; every fight could be the wrong fight if you don’t dig into history.

My sentimental favorite ties the OST leitmotifs to character fate. The lullaby that plays whenever Luna appears is reworked into a harsher rhythm before major betrayals; to me that’s composer-level foreshadowing. If the lullaby is a memory-thread, restoring it could be the key to healing both the world and Luna. It’s messy, it’s tragic, and it’s exactly the kind of emotional wrecking ball I want from this story—so yeah, I’m rooting for a reunion that’s earned and painful.